Easily one of our favorite Indian restaurants in New York. From the moment you walk in, you're…read moregreeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere, beautiful decor, and genuinely welcoming service. It's a cozy, family-friendly spot that's perfect for a relaxed meal. Even better, everything on the menu is vegetarian, with plenty of variety ranging from classic Delhi and Mumbai street food to Indo-Chinese to hearty North Indian main courses. Among our favorites: Appetizers: Papri Chaat, Raj Kachori, Masala Curly Fries, Paneer Tikka sizzler, Tandoori Soya Chaap sizzler Sandwiches: Chili Cheese Toast, Cheese Pav Bhaji, Bombay Grill sandwich Main Courses / Bread Combinations: Sarson ka Saag / Makki ki Roti, Paneer Makhani / Garlic Naan, Chole Bhatura, Paneer Paratha, Hakka Chowmein Noodles, Special Thali, Roomali Roti Veg Keema Drinks: Masala Chai, Cold Coffee with Ice Cream Go-to spot for vegetarian Indian food on LI!

Wow! This place checks all the boxes for the best Indian restaurant in town!…read more Atithi is a family-owned, pure vegetarian spot offering delicious dishes with a creative twist. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu and willing to offer recommendations when needed. The best part is that the menu has very detailed descriptions of each item so even if you're not super familiar with this cuisine, you'll know how to order. My husband and I started with samosas which were the best I've ever had! If you're a fan, please go and try this and let me know if I'm being hyperbolic, but they were insanely good! I had the Aloo Gobi Masala which was out of this world. The flavors were well balanced and tasty. My husband had the veg biryani. The portions were plenty and the ingredients super fresh! We're so excited to have found a great purely vegetarian Indian restaurant so close to home. We will absolutely be back!

Good quality and tasty. Chicken tikka masala was perfectly spiced. The naan was great and the…read moredessert was very good too.

I didn't get to post any pictures because every single dish that we ate was absolutely devoured! I…read moredon't think word justify the food at this place. Being an Indian, I always enjoyed Indian food only at home. But this place, the food is absolutely spectacular! Although it's a very small spot, it's very clean and they staff is very welcoming. The restaurant is run by husband and wife, whatever they make is made with amazing flavors.

This restaurant was recommended by a friend who grew up in India, and so we had to visit! He said…read morethis spot is as good as what you can get in India. One thing you need to get here is a rava dosa. We got the Cheese Onion Rava Masala Dosa, which was so so good. Super crispy and flavorful--it's the best feeling when you get hear the crunch after ripping a piece of dosa off to eat. Many of the components of the South Indian Thali were also very yummy too, and was also a good size portion. I'm usually not a fan of chickpeas, but this was great! Service was decent and filled up pretty quickly, even had a wait on a different day that we went, which says a lot about a restaurant in Hicksville (and how you know it's good too). What we ordered: - Cheese Onion Rava Masala Dosa - South Indian Thali - Mango Lassi

Bustling, attractive, with delicious, gorgeous dishes and friendly, attentive service.read more

Seriously the best Indian food I've ever had and I have been to so many places, everything is…read moreclean. the servers are so nice and hospitable. The owner talked to us and he is awesome thank you mac!!! I hope this place gets the attention it deserves because it is truly such an incredible restaurant I cant even begin to describe how good the food is. My sister and I came here years ago and just recently came back because she was visiting long island we would talk about this place thats how good it is and how much of an impact it made BEST INDIAN FOOD AND SERVICE EVER

AMAZING Indian food‼ They are cooking it up here. The…read morecultural taste of the food was the best I've had thus far

The mango mojito was a good alternative to the mango lassi. If you're not in the mood for a yogurty…read moredrink. Their mango mojito was non alcoholic. Very light and refreshing. The server recommended the samosa chaat and sev dahi puri for appetizers. My friend and I loved the samosa chaat. The fresh veggies and pomegranates gave different textures and made the dish read less heavy. The sev dahi puri had so much yogurt that it was hard to taste the other ingredients. Goat biriyani came with plenty of meat and minimal amount of bones. Beautiful presentation as well. For the main dish, we got the chicken tikka masala and a side of garlic naan. I would've liked the chicken tikka masala to be more flavorful but it was still tasty. The chicken itself was super tender. Garlic naan was not too garlicky and was perfect for dipping into the tikka masala sauce.

The food, the food and the food!!!!! Best Indian food on…read moreLong Island and perhaps New York. The wait staff was efficient and friendly, and the decor was cheerful. We will most definitely return!

So happy we found out that the original owners are back as this was our favorite spot! Everything…read moreabout this restaurant is great. The food is amazing & it always feels like you're being welcomed into their home.

So happy the original owners are back! The food is just as incredible as I remember from years…read moreago...rich, flavorful, and truly authentic. Every dish brought back that same comfort and quality that made me fall in love with this place in the first place. If you've been missing real Indian and Indonesian flavors, this is it!

Really good food with decent portion sizes…read more Food: I didn't love the samosa chaat- it needed more chutney. The chicken seekh kaban was very flavorful. The biryani was good but could have used some more meat Receive: good service - fast Ang kind Ambience: a nice spot with decent seating

My friends took us to this South Indian spot in Hicksville and it did not disappoint. It's a small,…read morehomey place with really delicious food. Parking's a little tight, but you can also grab a spot along the sidewalk if the lot is full. The four of us shared the TOC Special Dosa (stuffed with mixed veggies and cheese, rolled up with their sauces), Aloo Gobi Masala, two curries, and mango lassis. Everything was delicious, but my favorite dish was the Aloo Gobi Masala - potatoes, cauliflower, and a mildly spiced tomato sauce. Service was great and we literally finished every bite. Definitely recommend checking it out!

I've tried several vegetarian dishes and all were fantastic, my favorite being the Paneer Corn…read moreMasala. Service is always polite, helpful and friendly. They have a great location too, near a very good bakery and a well stocked general store.

We wanted to try this place after reading the reviews on it - I must say on the whole it didn't…read moredisappoint. We started with the pani puri which was okay. We also tried the Maggie which was surprisingly good. The tandoori chicken came next - that was very good. We had the chicken vindaloo which was also very good. Service was quick and efficient. The restaurant is pretty small with about 5 or 6 tables.