Jersey Mike's in Arroyo Grande totally hit the spot! I went with a regular size Original Italian and wow--tons of flavor and spices. Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni all stacked up on super fresh bread... perfection. They definitely don't skimp on the meat or toppings here. The staff was great too--super quick making the sandwiches and really helpful when my daughter was picking out her turkey sub. Prices are reasonable, and honestly, it's way better than Subway. I'll definitely be back for another sub fix! read more

I've been to this Jersey mikes location about 3 times this week, this place is sooo delicious! The staff are amazing and so welcoming even when it's busy. Special kudos to Alyssa, she was so pleasant and she makes each sandwich to perfection, I should have taken a picture!! - from a NJ native! read more

What a a location! Has great people here, especially Gabe, who should be the Manager if he isn't already. I really enjoyed my subs and the nice service that I received here at this location. Fast and efficient with quality food as a result. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Inside! - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Great place to eat! The employees are friendly and happy to assist with questions, and the food was perfect! Will definitely be back!

Play the Mobil order at about 1130. We'll be ready at 12:08. Here. I am sitting at 12:25 and they haven't even started making it yet. This isn't the first time. This is happened to this location. read more

Came for the sub, stayed for Alyssa. First time she helped me and wow -- sweet, speedy, and pure sunshine. This place somehow only hires the nicest humans alive. Give whoever's in charge of hiring a raise ASAP. read more

Fast service, great food, and great environment. I didn't grab their names but the folks there were very helpful and polite!! Thank you guys!! read more

Great food and service - their subs are the best!! I usually call ahead, only because they are soooo busy!

Have been here a couple of times and every time, sandwiches have been very tasty. Service is excellent. Sandwiches are also hearty. I'm a fan. They also have a rewards program. Recommend. read more

Jack tended me and my family and we we're welcomed with great customer service to start off with and dealt a bomb one too Made my number 7 taste off the charts read more

The best crew working today ! They were so nice and friendly. The sandwiches are always sooo delicious!!

Fresh sandwiches that don't ever disappoint! Love the turkey on rosemary parmesan! Fast service and always friendly staff at this location.

My husband is a BOSS / FOREMAN of a work shop in 5 cities. He takes the whole crew ! To lunches , and EVERYTIME he goes to jersey Mike's- alllllll staff is AMAZING FROM THE COOKING, TO GRILL, TO SERVICE ! keep it up! Great job !!!!!! U all rock. read more

Great sandwiches also great service which is hard to find nowadays. Way better than subway and jersey mikes which used to be my favorite

Jersey Mike's Subs in Arroyo Grande is in this Yelper's opinion the BEST "chain" Sandwich Shop on the Central Coast. The selection of Sandwiches includes both "hot" and "cold" Subs on various types of bread w/a variety of accoutrements (veggies and such) that can be included in your personalized variation of the Sub you select from the sandwiches offered on the Menu Board. In general...I have found that Jerseys Mikes (Arroyo Grande location included) gives the customer a generous amount of "meat" (so that you don't feel the need to order "extra", unless you really want to), whereas other Sandwich "chain" Brand Shops do not. The Staff here in Arroyo Grande Jerseys Mikes is ALWAYS friendly and displays the effort to make the Customer feel that they are more than just "a sandwich order". Today's Customer Service KUDOS go out to Kayla, Lilly and of course Josh (on the Grill) for making my repeat visit to Jersey Mike's in AG a fabulous experience...yay guys, way to go...and again thank-you! Today's order was a Regular #56 and a Mini #13...both were DELICIOUS! Don't know what a #56 or a #13 are...WELL, I would encourage you to go and have a look at the delicious offerings on the Menu Board and find out for yourself (or just look at the pics). While you're doing that...might as well order something for yourself, you wouldn't be disappointed. Again on this occasion, in this Yelper's opinion...Jersey Mike's Subs in Arroyo Grande truly earned this "highly recommend" 5 Star review! read more

See all

Love love Jersey Mike's Sub! It's definitely sub above Subway. Our faves are their BLT, Tuna, and Italian but all other sandwiches are great. I especially like em Mike's Way with extra spices and juices! The subs are great when you crave something yummy and quicky! The whole gang works fast and they listen to how one likes his/her sandwich. Keep up the awesome job! read more

Great food, Good prices, even better service. I would recommend Jersey Mike's to anyone

I just had possibly the best tuna sandwich made for me by manager Jackie. It was a fully loaded regular size with the works and jersey mikes way plus avocado and bacon. I have been in the Food Service industry for 40 years Catering and Events and Route Food truck catering and yeah I could make it at home .. but sometimes you don't want too. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Two nice 60-something ladies came in to order @ counter and eat in store & before anyone even greeted us they said "...it'd be a 35-minute wait @ least". I explained we were going to order simple sandwich and drink and it was a medical reason. We were still turned away! They showed us about 8 "orders" that came in before we did; but there was not one customer in the store except us. There were approx 6-8 people working there; about 4 at counter and about 4-6 in kitchen? Crazy. And Rude. Why don't you just make it a robot store w/drive thru and no customers and no workers. I'm sure that's what things are heading toasts; but we're not there yet; or are we? read more

1st off I waited very patiently as the Young man asked the gentleman that walked in behind me what he'd like. I waited about 8-10 mins for couple in front of me. Then when it was my turn he asked me what I wanted then sat there shredding meat n cheese for guest behind me. About 10 more mins he asked what I wanted on my tuna sub. When I went to take a Bute it was the HARDEST PIECE OF WHITE ROLL ID EVER EXPERIENCED IN MY LIFE. ABSOLUTELY NOT OK. SO GROSS. LITERALLY ROCK HARD ON EVERY SIDE IF BREAD. 10 BUCKS IN TRASH. Called for refund no answer. I was s9 hungry now I'm hungry maybe chk bread b4 leaving....ugggrr read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Hardest bread ever. So so unexceptable - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Took a friend to JM for the first time. They all LOVED it. Ordered off the secret menu.

Walked in and we already knew what we wanted. We were craving a hot big kahuna sando. When we ordered, we were notified that all hot sandwiches would take 20 minutes since they were cooking bacon on the flat top. They were cooking bacon even though they had an overflowing container of bacon on the line. When we I quoted as to why, the girl was super rude and had no viable explanation why they were cooking bacon when they had a full pan of bacon. Very disappointing when you had your heart set on one thing and can't get it. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Full pan of bacon - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Not one employee wearing a mask. What are you thinking? Covid-19 is a disease spread primarily by droplets, ie. people speaking/breathing in close proximity. When your employees ask me if I want it Mikes Way, or what kind bread I want, they are talking directly over my sandwich.. guess what winds up on my sandwich? droplets! Every other food establishment I've been to over the last 2 weeks all wear masks. And.. they dont talk or ask me questions while standing over my food. After waiting in line for 10 minutes outside, once inside I saw what was going on.. I left! Another gal left too once she saw whats going on inside. Im sure your delivery is in full swing, but only because those people at home dont know whats going on over there. Get it together guys, mask up. If this is "Mikes Way".. you can keep it. droplets travel while talking, wake up: https://www.fox19.com/video/2020/04/17/experiment-shows-how-droplets-travel-while-talking/ read more

The sandwiches are great, but the service is awful. We ordered 9 sandwiches the day before for a 10:45 deadline for a staff pickup- all paid separately which is pretty normal. We were scolded by the manager because we didn't do one order paid by one person. That's not a thing when you don't have a corporate card, we are a public school, so there is no such thing. We called multiple times the night before, and no one answered the phone - to explain what was happening the next day. The day of pick up, the manager called nine people to explain that their sandwiches couldn't be ready by the times prescribed by the Jersey Mike's order app. Obviously plenty of time to work on the sandwiches. Instead, we still received our entire order late, and with one missing sandwich. No discounts offered, no apology from rude staff. The customer service at the store was so rude, a dad picking up lunch for the committee l, embarrassing. There are lots of local delis who will be filling our orders from now on. read more

Went in 30 min before they closed and the workers said he couldn't help us anymore because all their equipment was clean already and didn't want to dirty their stuff anymore. What a disappointment, should have closed the doors 30 min too if they didn't want to help customers ! read more

Ordered online through Uber Eats and waited for an hour and a half for two sandwiches. This is not the first time there have been issues. I love Jersey Mike's food, but this owner/manager needs to seriously look at their poor customer service Half of the time the cancel their order after it is supposed to be delivered. Overall, terrible read more

We have been ordering sandwiches here almost every week for the last year. and our experience is consistently the same. Delicious sandwiches and outstanding service. We order by phone and the order is always ready within minutes of their estimate. we always feel welcome and the staff really knows how to hustle. read more

The food is actually good. Unfortunately the management sucks. They abuse their employees so I will not order anything from them again. So sad because it used to be one of our favorite places. They hire young people and don't put any time into training them adequately. Not good business practices. read more

I've always loved jersey mikes and at other locations I usually get really good customer service. I've gone in and ordered online a few times and each time I'm amazed on how they have such bad customer service, besides the girl who works there. I'm blanking on her name but everyone else who works there should not be in customer service. Management needs to do a better job. This is a horrible location to go to. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - this is just an example, I waited on hold for 10 minutes then got hung up on. - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

In a stressful rush on an unnaturally hot November day, the crew was exceptional at getting orders out the door, the sandwich was great, the service accepable under the circumstances. Minus one star for following the tranical edicts of a failed govern, over the clear wishes of the people. Commonsense much reign supreme over insane government and news created pandemonium. The heat out there is much more threatening, than the risk of Covid19. I'm sorry, but this Covid19, over all over concerns NEEDS TO STOP IMMEDIATELY! Thanks to the hard work crew, I felt so bad for them having to deal with such a large cranky group of hot sweaty people. I would have joined in on making sandwiches, but there honestly wasn't any more work space to be found. Besides I'm not formally trained in food safety, would you really want a sandwich I made? TLDR: Service good, sandwich good, Covid19 rules suck. read more

Just stopped and picked up a Big Kahuna to go called back to find out it was made by Alex and I wanted to let them know that this was the first sandwich there I really enjoyed! Usually with this sandwich there are so many jalapeños that later my stomach is not liking me but Alex made this sandwich today exactly how I wanted it and it was amazing great job Alex thanks for making my day and sandwich. read more

Their Italian subs are really just like you'd get in Jersey including the oil, vinegar and herbs. Fresh sliced meat and cheese and generous with the lettuce and tomato. And the Rosemary roll is great. This is one of my very favorite fast foods. You can also get any sandwich as a salad too if you are avoiding bread. And it's a great salad too. read more

My buddy, Dan introduced me to JM's and I'm addicted! Great service but line can get long so use the app and order ahead.

Today was my first time trying Jersey Mike's all of my coworkers recommended them. I try the Philly everywhere I go and until today I had yet to find the best my mind is blown away they make the absolute best Philly I have ever tried. The customer service was great also. I will 100% recommend to everyone. read more

Ordered the tuna sandwich like I have at other locations & it's always been very good. This one, no. The celery was easily cubed in one inch chunks -on a sandwich- how are you supposed to eat that? Pickles all in a lump to one side & what felt like 6 cans of tuna piled onto the sandwich that just fell & squeezed out everywhere. Took the giant to share on a picnic & it was a nightmare. The dog was happy, he got to eat 4 cans of tuna left on the paper. All in all, it's not hard to make a sandwich, the employee didn't care & sadly, careless employees ruin businesses all the time. read more

i've had multiple orders messed up and when you try to call the store they answer and set the phone down on the counter and don't speak to you. don't order from here they'll mess it up and won't refund your money!!! or even answer the phone!!! 0/10 won't recommend read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - PAID FOR EXTRA BACON, GOT NONE! - Sandwiches Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Bread does not taste fresh, everything else is up to par with the J-mikes experience.

This location is full of patient employees that deal with an overwhelming number of guests, and online orders, simultaneously. Every staff member in the store is working diligently, and diplomatically handling frustrated patrons. Jersey Mike's is always a great sandwich, but it's nice knowing that the people making it are kind and making the best of a tough situation on a daily basis. If you're impatient or entitled, maybe find somewhere else to eat. Otherwise, enjoy the wait and the friendly staff. It's been worth it every time, and I'll continue to support this location. read more

There is a female that works here that runs circles around the staff .. she is a rare breed of employee.. I don't give reviews much but I truly think she deserves recognition. I don't know but a raise is definitely needed if not given already. Didn't get her name .. but seriously you would recognize it if you saw her work ethic .. good job jersey mikes read more

I used to like this place until the last time I ordered the classic sub. What a soggy mess, the wet wrapping should have been my clue. I got it home and deposited it in to the garbage. It was so wet, soggy and inedible. And for nine dollars and change, I shall never return.You have lost my family business and you're not the only game in town. You're people are untrained and incompetent. This was after I ordered on the app, gave more time than required and they hadn't even started my order until after I showed up in person. Terrible experience, I won't be back. read more