I really enjoyed this seafood place! My friend and I celebrated our birthdays a little late, and since we both love a good seafood boil, we decided to try this place out. We did the all-you-can-eat option for $48.99, and it was worth it! That may be a little pricey to some, but for a special occasion with unlimited seafood and appetizers, it was a great price for me personally. They gave us little paper menus to check off what we wanted, and you can fill out as many as you'd like. The staff was very kind and attentive, so everything came out quickly! The seafood was very clean and a good size, which means a lot to me as a seafood lover. I got crawfish, snow crab, black mussels, clams, shrimp, potatoes, corn, and boiled eggs. The sauce had great flavor as well. You can also ask for the sauce on the side if you'd like to control your sodium or calories. Next time I'll try some different things on the menu. It was a clean, cute place, and I'll definitely be back! read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - All you can eat seafood (snow crab,Black Mussels, Crawfish, shrimp , Eggs, Potatoes, Corn) - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I'm honestly surprised how underhyped this place is We did the AYCE and were NOT disappointed. Everything was so good, the price is great, and the value is absolutely there. Service was fast and super on point too Safe to say... we can't wait to go back. read more

They don't miss. They do not miss. It's been a while since I've been but I'll be needing my fix soon. The all you can eat is mandatory if you go. The flavors of the juicy sauce, fire, we all know the sides are there to fill you up, but so be it. They're just as good and I can't not get them! Come hungry leave happy. Good job juicy mayport. Numbers read more

I came here on my birthday and I was not disappointed. I ordered the AYCE and it was so good! I cannot wait to go back. The waitress was accommodating to me needing an outlet. Since I was sitting solo and had my sister on video, I needed to charge my phone. I cannot wait to go back! The food was so good! read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Got some crab legs delivered to my home after a major craving for them. I decided to go with Juicy Mayport due to reviews across delivery apps and Yelp being pretty consistent which I appreciate. I actually got the 1lb crab legs which when the order arrived I didn't realize that it also came with corn and potatoes, 2x Cajun and Mild. It was a late dinner so I went easy on the spicy so that I don't regret it later. The order came double-plastic bagged and in a brown paper bag which all held up pretty good. I really enjoyed the flavors. Would definitely order from them again. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - 1lb crab legs with corn and potatoes - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

The restaurant is located in a strip mall with a fun inside that makes you feel like you're at a proper seafood beach place. The food was good. We got hushpuppies, a crab seafood boil, and a shrimp seafood boil. It was just enough to make us full and tasty. The hushpuppies were a nice sweet treat that made it our favorite part of the meal. The service was quick and attentive to us. They checked in on us multiple times and did a good job being quick. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - The portion size of shrimp and crab and hushpuppies. - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

The food was great and the all-you-can-eat was amazing. We will be back We had the all you can eat snow crab and shrimp now you only have 1 1/2 hours to eat as much as you can. After an hour and a half we had to be rolled out . read more

This place is a lil pricey, however with the flavoring and the perfectly cooked food it's worth it, we all know making crab boils at home is very time consuming and requires large pots to make, getting the spices and flavor too come out perfect is difficult, unless you're a pro!! So if you're in the mood for delicious seafood, this is the place. The service is always fast and accurate! We will definitely repeat!! read more

See all

"Mayport shrimp" ..... Presumably what they advertise as Mayport shrimp are fresh shrimp procured from our local Mayport shrimpers as opposed to frozen shrimp. In any event without a doubt Juicy serves the best fried shrimp platter on the beach. For $16 you get eight large fried "Mayport" shrimp with two sides. Friendly accommodating food servers. Beverage prices are reasonable. Plenty of parking. Ambiance is ok. read more

All you can eat boiled seafood, sign me up. They have a good selection of seafood. The fried food was coming out hot and fresh. The sauce for boiled seafood were good. Plenty of garlic flavor. Service was great. read more

See all

The restaurant is located on a business strip. The sign is easy to see. The restaurant was very clean and spacious. We went on a Saturday during lunch time. The service was quick and professional. The food was delicious and hot. I love cheese sticks and these are some of the best I've taste. The shrimp fried was had eggs in it and the shrimp were a nice size. The fried shrimps were hot and tasty. Next time I will try the all you can eat Seafood, You select 4 items at a time and keep selecting until you get full. read more

See all

Excellent from start to finish , they have steak delicious potatoes food made with love

Great food and good service will be back for sure Nice and quiet place to eat the seafood boil for two was well worth it

This is literally one of my favorite restaurants ever. The service was amazing and the food was top-tier and if you are a seafood lover like me, I highly recommend this place. The seasons were very delicious. The food tasted fresh and the workers checked in with you frequently. read more

The food was, frankly, terrible. All three of us who ate ended up nauseated. The servers, while friendly enough, only came to the table twice during the meal. There were also very few people working the floor, meaning customers waiting for service. It was clean, but we spent $160 for three all-you-can-eat meals and didn't eat enough for one meal. Nothing made this even remotely worth it. read more

Solid for the price, good flavor and value. All you can eat snow crab is worth it alone.

Not the best atmosphere and location but good food and service, seasoning for boils very good, recommend " juicy " type seasoning. The crawfish were better than the crab, crab lacked flavor, not sure was fresh, would go again and only get crawfish read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - M12. King Crab Legs - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

I almost admittedly don't want to write this review because then everyone will know about this place lol but I can't hold in my secrets lol. Hands down best seafood spot in Jacksonville with such a great all you can eat option. The flavor of the sauce is insanely delicious and the food is super fresh. Such a great restaurant with even better food. Run don't walk! read more

See all

Like I previously mentioned. We had to come back again for lunch and they didn't disappoint us!! Their food is so darn good!! WE WILL BE COMING BACK!! read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - The A fried mayport shrimp(6) are banging!! Mixed Vegetables, Yes! I'm telling y'all that you will not be disappointeddisappointed. - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Don't get me wrong, the food is amazing however, the server we had was very passive aggressive and made inappropriate comments about her customers and my partner. Also, she would come over to our table to see if we were done yet to the point of practically standing over me waiting for me to give her my card to pay. If me and my partner ever come here again we will request a different server. read more

Food was terrible and service was awful. I am from Maryland and know what seafood should taste like and that wasn't it. Says all you can eat but they give you an hour and a half time limit and it takes 30 minutes just to get your first order. read more

Juicy Mayport has been a favorite of mine for awhile now. Great location, good drinks, good food and the service is good as well. I usually get the pound of snow crab with juicy special sauce medium and it's amazing!! But today I got the fried shrimp, Cajun shrimp, and coleslaw and everything was good!! The shrimp was fried to perfection and seasoned very well. The coleslaw was sweet like i like it, not too sweet but flavorful as well. The ambiance of the restaurant is very chill and seaside-ish!! They also have an all you can eat special!! Make sure to check them out! read more

See all

The food was great and prices are reasonable. The oysters and seafood was fresh. I only wondered why the served the appetizers and food nearly at the same time. Didn't give us time to finish before the main dish. Clean and nice inside - simple set up with lots of screens if you are into that. read more

See all

My family and I came here. We drove a good distance and the restaurant we were gong to was closed for maintenance. We were hungry so checked to see what was close by. First my sister, who Alessia going to ask questions and you should especially if it is somewhere you've never been. She asked if she didn't like something could she get something else. The lady basically told her once they bring it to the table that's it. My niece ordered their blue crabs, she told them they had a funny smell and didn't taste fresh. They would not let her return or order anything else. She gave her 1/2 off instead of refunding her in full for food she didn't eat. Beware is all I'll say. I've had so much better seafood boils. read more

My wife and I were vacationing at Jax Beach. I wanted to go to the Juicy Crab Mayport for my birthday. They have a huge selection of all you can eat food including seafood. Their crab legs were unbelievable. I am 62 years old and I've been eating crab legs all my life. I ate over 6 pounds of crab legs and I am only 130 pounds lol There was not a thing on the menu that my wife and I ate that was not delicious. Our server was Charlie. She was absolutely phenomenal. She brought me crab legs each time before I had even finished up the crab legs that I was eating so that I wasn't sitting there waiting for more crab legs. We then left the restaurant and I realized to my dismay that I left my Dentures on the table. I called the restaurant and told them what had happened. I told them that I was coming back. When I got there, it was around 10:15 PM and they closed at 10 PM. We all walked out to the dumpster and took out two bags of trash to start looking through them. I then saw five employees literally RUN from the restaurant to the dumpster to assist us in the search for the needle in the proverbial haystack. By the grace of God, they found my dentures within two minutes of the search. Every single one of the Employees, including the owner, bent over backwards in order to find my dentures. I would refer this restaurant to 100 out of 100 people. The food was awesome and the people were absolutely awesome as well! I give them a 10 star rating on a five star rating system. I will refer them to anybody I meet! I just wish they had one of those restaurants down the street from me where I live because I would go there practically every week. read more

One of the best crab places I've tried in Jax so far. The portions on my crab entree were perfect. I did a medium hot - also just the right amount of spice. My double Tito's and soda hit the spot (not pictured bc vodka soda is a boring photo‍) Our server was so sweet and hospitable. The decor was also cute in here. Very clean, and not loud at all on a Friday night. I loved my first experience here and I would go back. Wish they had an instagram page so I could have tagged them on the story while here, or made a post about it later advertising how good this spot is. For the Facebook users out here; I was told they do have fb read more

See all

Amazing tasting seafood. Many options to customize your seafood boil. I would definitely visit again.

Juicy Seafood is an absolute delight for seafood enthusiasts and food lovers alike. From the moment you step in, the inviting ambiance and the tantalizing aroma of freshly prepared seafood captivate your senses. The all-you-can-eat experience is nothing short of spectacular, offering an impressive array of dishes that cater to every palate. The seafood is incredibly fresh and flavorful, with a diverse selection that includes succulent shrimp, tender crab legs, and perfectly seasoned fish. The buffet also features an array of sides and accompaniments that complement the main dishes beautifully. Each item is prepared with care and precision, ensuring that every bite is a burst of deliciousness. The staff at Juicy Seafood are attentive and friendly, making sure your dining experience is smooth and enjoyable. They are always ready to assist and make recommendations, adding a personal touch that enhances the overall experience. What sets Juicy Seafood apart is its commitment to quality and variety. The restaurant continuously replenishes the buffet with freshly prepared items, ensuring that every dish is at its best. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or just looking to indulge in a hearty meal, Juicy Seafood delivers an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you craving for more. Please note (you'll get a card and the list is split down the middle so you can select up to 4 items on each side (Appetizer side and seafood boil side) for a total of eight items. Your server will bring out your bowls. It is strongly encouraged to only eat what you can as it helps for food not be wasted as you can be charged if you pick excessively but don't eat. read more

See all

The all-you-can-eat seafood special at this place is definitely worth the price! Price range from $45-$52 per/person . I've been here four times already, and it hasn't failed to impress me. The sauce is incredible, and the seafood boil selection is fantastic. You'll leave feeling stuffed and satisfied. Only downside drinks are okay, and the service was generally okay. read more

Stopped here for lunch after church. We had heard good things about Juicy Mayport but didn't realize it's primarily a "seafood boil" type restaurant. Fortunately for us, they do have other things on their menu if your not into seafood boil (church clothes!). The service was excellent and the restaurant was very clean! They were playing ok music (wasn't thrilled with a song that came on that had a bunch of profanity in it). We ordered blackened shrimp, seasonal veggies and coleslaw. The coleslaw was delicious and the shrimp were very good too. Our server recommended the crab wontons for an appetizer so we did order those too. They were served fresh from the fryer, really hot and tasty! We will probably go back for a boil sometime soon! read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Blackened Mayport Shrimp basket with coleslaw and seasonal veggies. - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

We went here as a backup plan for some all you can eat Snow Crab legs. Our original plan was Fushimi Buffet on Atlantic Blvd, but when we got there, we asked about them and they no longer were serving them. They blamed market prices. However, you can go to the Wynn Buffet in Vegas and get all you can eat Snow Crab, Lobster, and King Crab! So how are they affording it? Anyway, Juicy Mayport is NOT a buffet. You can get boil in bag seafood for various prices off the menu, or do the all you can eat for a time limit of 90 minutes. This method is where you pick items you want off a check sheet you give the waitstaff. The downside is that the clock is ticking while you wait for each of your orders to arrive. The flavor of the seasoning was good. I recommend the medium spice level. It had a good garlic flavor as well. There are boxes of gloves you can get, but you have to ask for them, or find them on a ledge when you walk in. The place was ok, ambiance-wise. It was fairly busy. We spent more than we would have at Fushimi, but it was the only other place we could find in the area offering all you can eat Snow Crab legs. read more

We originally saw this restaurant on a Instagram post and decided to try after I searched it on Yelp and TikTok to get more honest reviews. The location was in a nice large lot which had ample parking and the restaurant was extremely clean and large. Upon arrival we were greeted and sat almost immediately. We opted to try the AYCE menu as that seemed to be a popular option and who doesn't love AYCE seafood boil?! We started off with waters, calamari and my husband ordered a dirty martini. The waters and calamari came out fairly quickly and we proceeded to place our first round of orders. The seafood boil came out pretty quickly after ordering and that's about all that went well. we were still waiting on the martin when the food came out so my husband inquired and the waitress went to check on it. We started in on the seafood. The crab legs were extremely thin and we did not have a tool to crack them open, typically I don't need one but these were tough and the meat did not slide out like everyone else's experience claimed. Our shrimp were overcooked and the sausage were rubbery. The sauce was minimal and had virtually no flavor. The crab leg sliced my finger when I tried to crack it. We ordered a second round to give it another try thinking we got a bad batch but the outcome was the same. My husband's martini finally came out and it did not taste like a martini at all. He was very disappointed and yes he knows exactly what it's supposed to taste like. For dessert they brought us what looked like what we'd describe as prison ice cream lol extremely frost bitten in a styrofoam cup. The price point was great but unfortunately the food did not match the reviews we read. We may go back for another try as maybe it was a bad night in the kitchen but I'm not so sure. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Was quite surprised of the experience and the quality of food. The way they served is so that you don't waste the food and everyone in my party was well satisfied read more

First time coming and will definitely be back! They have two menu options of regular and all you can eat. Not everyone has to do all you can eat but you can't share which is normal for any ayce restaurant. You do have an hour and a half time limit and the time starts as soon as your first order goes in. There are a variety of options to choose from and come out pretty quickly. There are sheets on the table and it tells you how much comes per order that way you don't have left over food. If you do, they do charge!The crab legs and crawfish were really great and their boil sauce was great! It's pretty spacious inside and looked very clean as well. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Crab legs and Crawfish - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

After eating my way through Dover, DE, NYC's Chinatown, Lancaster, PA, DC, and the Philadelphia International Airport for the past nine days, it's good to be back home in Jax. After a long day, there was no way I was going to cook, so after unpacking and loving on our fur babies that we haven't seen for nine days, we headed out to Juicy Mayport for some good seafood boils. I got the Crawfish boil. It includes crawfish, shrimp, sausage, corn, and potatoes steamed and slathered in all the butters they had to offer. As you can see, I was more than ready to dig in. It was all delicious and a great dinner to come home to. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

We've been here a few times and it's definitely my favorite. I love the new ayce options as well and they have good selection of options. We tend to come right when they open on the weekend and never have an issue getting a table. With the new option of ayce you order on papers which is pretty quick. Timing was a bit odd that we got two rounds at the same time but we did notice an influx of tables at that time too. Flavor is good and seafood was cooked perfect. We haven't had a bad experience here yet. This is one of my favorite spots. read more

The only possible reason I could see to give less than 5 stars is that I might need to be rolled to my car. I've been looking for a good seafood restaurant with AYCE crab legs, I found a fantastic one. The staff at Juicy Mayport were attentive and never left us waiting for the next round of food. And the food... so good. Cooked perfectly there was not a single thing that I would have wanted to be different. We drove 45 minutes to come here and we will be back, without a doubt. read more

The Juicy Seafood Mayport - Crab legs and shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

This place is delicious, ate so much we did not have room for dessert, but I forced that keylime pie down. Had the all you can eat from a TikTok recommendation. I would eat here everyday if possible ***Warning*** You are charged for any leftovers!!! read more

See all

It's a must go. Everything was fresh and good. It's worth going . Very clean and the waitress were fantastic.

The food was amazing. The service was amazing and ambiance was perfect. It was nicely decorated and music was quietly playing in the background soft enough so you could carry on a conversation at your table. We will definitely be returning. read more