Kaptain Jimmys should fire whoever is in charge of there web site and Faceboook account. For years I have been trying to figure out who is playing there on the weekends but nothing is ever posted. I always check there website and Facebook with no results so I have to end up calling to find out like its 1991, maybe they don't need the business. read more

I went with my husband and my daughter on Saturday, about 3:30pm., they were still serving lunch menu. We were seated fast and our waiters came right away. Unfortunately she did not know nothing about lunch menu, she never served lunch before. She could not answer any of our questions. Food came in 20 min. (restaurant was not busy),and that was the worse food I ever had. I had chicken sandwich( McDonald sandwich taste even better then that) it was tasteless and cold. My husband had cod sandwich, was over cooked . My daughter had spaghetti with marinara sauce on the side, her pasta was heated up in the microwave no flavor at all. They used potato roll for our sandwiches,rolls were cold and hard. While I was eating my tasteless food I was observing waitstaff - too many of them , and they were going back on forth, had know idea what to do. They could stay busy by filling ketchup bottles, that were served empty. As a new restaurant you would expect to see manager around to talk to his customers- but you would not see any managers around at Kaptain Jimmy's. No wonder service and food were bad. Needless to say we will not go there again, and for all of you up there it is nothing to see or eat at KAPTAIN JIMMY'S!!!! read more

Bartenders don't know how to make drinks! Cosmopolitan & Vodka gimlet were horrible ! Shrimp cocktail & crab and spinach dip were both excellent ! Then dinner went down hill! $28.00 steak was thin , over cooked, and dry. DON"T get the ribs! They were tough as shoe leather! Couldn't even chew them. Very expensive for the poor quality of food. If you like beer, they have a lot on tap. read more

Just got back home after a terrific lunch with a friend. this was the first visit for both of us. The pirate who showed us to our table gave us a quick runthrough on how the place has been transformed from the circa 1970's establishment it once was. Our friendly server, Kim, was informative as well as humorous. She offered several suggestions from the menu, and discussed how the staff's various pirate outfits came to be. The manager on duty eventually came by to check on how things were going. Things were going great! This is about the only place around that still has cocktail onions, and the knowledgable bartender made good use of them in perfectly crafted Gibsons. The AAARR burger that my friend ordered was perfectly done and my "special," the soft shell crab BLT that Kim suggested, was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. The house fries and the onion rings (which I kept telling Kim were the largest calimari I'd ever seen) were delicious. The staff offered to take us around and show off the decor, but we declined as we were too comfortable sitting at our high top. My friend and I loved the place, the food and the waitstaff. I will definitely be back and I will bring many friends. Good luck to this new restaurant and Congratulations to the folks who put it all together! read more

Food was flavorful and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere was fun and upbeat. Waitstaff was great and entertaining. ( slow at times) we have been here numerous times and have always been extremely happy. Friends and relatives from out of town loved it also and had a great time. Highly recommend Kaptain Jimmy's if you want an enjoyable time whether it be lunch or dinner. Sunday brunch is also plentiful and tasty with lots to choose from. read more

Good and bad. The bad was the 5 mushroom dinner special: The mushroom stuffing was too dry, and the entire meal was just too many carbs. But at under $12, I guess I got what i paid for. The other bad was that we were not offered dessert or coffee/tea at the end of our meal. It didn't occur to me at the time, really, but now on yelp reading about some yummy dessert options, I feel like I missed out! The good: the waiter Jared was attentive and personable. The tomato bisque soup was yummy. The bread was also good, but the maple glaze made my fingers sticky. The selection of beers was good, and the sampler was a good way to try new ones. My companions got the cobb salad, prime rib and chicken/pasta/broccoli: and they were all happy with their choices. read more

Went Saturday night for my third visit there. Although my last two visits shortly after they opened were not stellar, I figured they had a month to work out some of the kinks(slow service being the biggie) and I'd give them a try again. We had a really great experience this time. Waitress was way on her game. Never waited for drinks, and the food was on time and great. Had the filet and mashed potatoes. Cooked perfect. Fondue appetizer is the bomb! Could do without the maple butter and bread. Looked like about 50 different beers on tap. Had the Adonis lager. Great recommendation from our waitress. Will definitely be back again! read more

My wife and I visited Kaptain Jimmy's last nite with another couple. We used our Groupon and the other couple did not. My wife and our friend ordered prime rib and my wife's was noticeably smaller that our friend's prime rib. I ordered sea scallops and for $21.00 I think I should have received more than 6. We have used a Groupon at Kaptain Jimmy's in the past and we noticed the same thing - The Groupon users got a smaller portion. The first time we thought this may have been a coincidence but last nite confirmed it. Next time we use a Groupon at Kaptain Jimmy's, we will present the Groupon AFTER dinner, not before. Our server, Jared, apologized every time he came to our table. First because it took so long to be acknowledged, then the time it took to get our drinks, etc, etc. Instead of apologies, I think the service could be much faster, then no need for apologies. read more

The server was not interested in telling us about any specials (yes there are specials and you should check) The diner that I ordered was terrible when I told the waiter he gladly took it away without asking what was wrong. He brought me a new dinner and it was ok but nothing spectacular they took a brown gravy/sauce and put it on the steak and figured that made it good. The potatoes were oily like they had been sitting around for a while. Not a good first impression. read more

Eight of us went to dinner on Tuesday night . We were sat at a table in the bar area and it took 57 minutes before the waitress to come to take our drink order!!! we even tried to flag down a waiter who completely ignored us!! so after we finally got our drink order in it took another 21 minutes! Then I asked to speak to a manager and that took another half hour!!! This place is a joke. I didn't even order food but the rest of the table did and it was nothing great. do yourself a favor and stay away from this place ! read more

I will never go back to this restaurant again. I ordered the Prime Rib and it was supposed to be medium and it was a very tough piece of meat.I ended up bringing it home to my dog. I felt the prices were very high for the quality of food . I was very disappointed. The potatoes were also very dry but didn't taste too badly. I won't be recommending this place to anyone. read more

Meh. Food is OK - not great but not terrible - but service was disappointing. We waited a while (maybe 30 minutes?) for our salads, and when the main meal came about 15 minutes later, one person in our party was given the wrong dish. When it was pointed out, the server was quite confused and took it back to the kitchen, then disappeared. No apology or explanation or update. The correct dish came about 20 minutes later, brought out by another server. Surprisingly, nothing was adjusted in the bill for the mistake. We didn't force the issue, but it would have been nice to have a little more acknowledgment of the inconvenience it caused. If you want to try their food, you may like it, but be prepared to wait a while to get served. read more

Don't believe the negative reviews on this place went there for dinner service was excellent our server hailey was making sure our dinner and drinks where perfect didn't wait long at all for our food and the food was good price wise average if you like beer they have ALOT....my wife and I would return here and I would recommend this place read more

No where can you eat a meal for five dollars that is so delicious. Portions are generous. Atmosphere is so cool. Buffet breakfast is awesome and for dinner I love the turkey pie. Some friends introduced us to this restaurant and I shall go there many more times. read more

"Kaptain Jimmy's" is one of the most disgusting seafood restaurants I personally have ever been to. By the end of my meal Im surprised that i even liked the water they had served me. Now for a cheap date, it would be perfect, spending little and getting your money's worth. Everything is frozen nothing at all is fresh, I will never step foot in the building ever again. read more

Family & friends love this place! Great food & service. I'm a big fan of the fish & chips!

I go here often, my family and I love it here, but today the service was unacceptable. We got here around 5:30 pm and we ordered our food. We got our appetizers around 6:30, and now it's about 7:10pm and we are just now getting our meals. It was busy when we got here, it's Father's Day so that was understandable, but around 6:20 they were informing people that they had run out of certain items, and the place almost cleared out completely. The service was STILL slow after a generous amount of people left. We have NEVER had service as slow as this. It was not the waiters fault, they were short staffed in the kitchen on such a busy day, which is inexcusable. The food we received was messed up, some orders were missing items, or given wrong items, cold food, and some food was either over or undercooked. And when we came in, we didn't even receive silver wear to eat with. I'm not even sure if this is some place I would even return to after such a terrible experience. I could have stayed home and had a dinner party in a shorter amount of time that this dinner out took. I work in food service and I know from 8 years of experience that 2 burgers, 3 steaks, and 1 order of chicken parmigiana does not take almost 2 hours to make. read more

Breakfast buffet on Sunday was absolutely the lowest quality food I have ever experienced in a restaurant. Complete disappointment. Everything in chaffing dishes. Watery eggs, burnt soggy French toast and pancakes. Nasty syrup of some kind stuck like glue. White bread toast only. No Danish or muffins only two choices of poor quality fruit. I have had better breakfast for FREE at hotels. Too many dirty dishes to count stacked up on condiment table. Only one server for a party of 60+. Would NOT recommend. In fact This place should abandon its breakfast endeavors until they can do a better job. read more

We were seated right away and were greeted by our waiter. He took our drink orders and came back about 5-7 minutes later minus a root beer. That was brought about 2-3 minutes later by someone else. It was 10-13 minutes for him to come back and take our order. My salad and the bread were brought out promptly as well as the food. The portions were huge but . . . the prime rib sub that was supposed to have garlic aioli had no taste and did not taste the aioli until the last bite, the fish and chips had been fried a little too long, the fries were soaked in grease and the coleslaw was dry and tasteless. As for the waiter, he was now too busy to wait on us now that his friend had arrived at the next table. He actually sat down to chat meanwhile he has not asked us how our food was. It was about 20 minutes before he came back to ask if we wanted anything. And then he was back to chatting with the friend. By now we were done and he still had not come back. About 10 minutes went by and he finally came back asked if we needed boxes and then he was off for another 10 minutes, meanwhile the boxes were diagonal from me. When he came back he asked if we wanted him to box our food as he is giving us the boxes (he had no intent of boxing and we weren't taking the chance of having to wait longer). When we were walking out there were 3 people standing at the podium including who I think was Kaptain Jimmy, only one quietly said "have a good night". The wait staff were very immature and not professional. read more

I decided to go to Kaptain Jimmys restaurant because it looked very nice from the outside.When I walk in they were nice I got seated but then all I could hear is someone in the kitchen blowing their nose not once but twice and foul language was heard from the kitchen I had to leave. I will never step foot on this restaurant ever again!!! read more

Went to dinner ordered the Thanksgiving pie it came cold they very nicely microwaved it. It was definitely not dark nest turkey it was made with beef. We ordered fried ice cream that was described as being served with a chocolate ganache it was chocolate syrup. They gave us serving spoons to eat with and one was bent into a ladle shape. The waitress was friendly. The Mac and cheese good but I would not rush back read more

I'm really not trying to bash a local bussiness but if I was looking up reviews I would want to know this information too. I've heard so many good things about this restaurant but only just got to try it tonight. There was nothing good about the food we ordered besides the mac n' cheese. I dont have any complaints there. My boyfriend got the prime rib special. I tried it myself. The cut was only about 1/4 in. thick. I've gotten prime rib much thicker than that at other places & thought it was always a thick cut? We also got the fried calamari.... no flavor & very rubbery. Worst I ever had :( & then there was the french onion soup. While it wasnt the worst, it tasted like it came out of a progresso can lol. The service was great. Our waitress was very attentive & polite. She was on top of everything. & did take the calamari off the bill. I apologized to her & explained that it wasnt her fault at all (she did everything right & never once complained or got angry). I also got whiskey on the rocks. It was $8 which for a restarant like this the drink price was reasonable. The food was 100% not worth the money but like I said I've heard other people say they like the place..... read more

The worst food ever, don't waste your money! We heard mixed reviews about the food, however, we decided to give it a try for ourselves. Yikes we should've listened! The burger was overcooked which I don't understand how when our server asked if I wanted pink or not to which I replied pink, it was two wafer thin frozen patties with Cajun spices poured over the top of them with barely any blue cheese. My husband's steak and cheese grinder had enough bread to fill two sandwiches and the steak was dry, burnt and the cheese looked liked processed cheese singles! We don't eat McDonald's but I would've preferred a BIG MAC! The best thing we had was the Pepsi! read more

I have been here about 8 times (not usually by choice) and finally feel the need to write a review as this oddly pirate themed place really is a mixed bag. Food is mediocre and high priced for the market they are in. If you don't order from the specials, expect your dinner to be over $20. If you do order off the specials expect to be unimpressed and probably still hungry when you leave. Portions are either kids meal size or way too large, depending on what you get. They tend to skimp on expensive ingredients and overload you with pasta or filler. (3 shrimp in a whole plate of shrimp alfredo and about 1lb of pasta with bland sauce that was $20 and an up charge for a salad that looked like it came out of a bag) Dinners don't even come with salad anymore. Quality of service is highly dependent on the server you get, they have a few that are really great ( and nice to look at too) and a few that are stuck up and quite rude. If it is a busy night or during peak hours expect to wait almost a half hour just for your drink, they give the servers too many tables/large parties to handle. Breakfast buffet on weekends is cheap but very bland food and powdered eggs. They have an impressive bar and beer list, but don't expect to be able to conversate at the bar on thurs/fri/sat without yelling as this place gets very loud and crowded. Overall I would avoid going here unless it's for a week night sample of the beer list. Your wallet and your taste buds will thank you. read more

Been here three times, this is the first review. The food is great, the beer selection is great. The first two times the service was bad, but they were relatively busy, and had already waited to get a table or room at the bar. Today, went and the brunch was busy but the rest of the place was kind of dead. Which is expected on a Sunday early lunch side. We sat at our booth for 15 minutes, and no one even came to acknowledge us or ask what we wanted for a drink. We walked out in disgust, annoyance, and were not surprised to find two people at the hostess stand complaining; one that she hasn't seen her waitress for at least 10 minutes after asking for crackers with her soup, and the other complaining about how long his waitress took. If they fix the service, this place will be THE place to go, until then, I may step in every once in a while for a drink at the bar and observing how the waitstaff does. read more

I'll be shocked if this place makes it through the summer. I'm still amazed this place opened while still under construction (heavy equipment is still all over the restaurant ). After ordering our entrees, I now know that I wouldn't let the kitchen staff prepare a meal for my dog...the salmonella lawsuits MUST be piling up by now. read more

The food was about the worst you can get from beginning to end! The bread was tasteless and the maple syrup they put on top was horrible. The shrimp scampi tasted like the noodles were cooked in dish water. The baked potato was rotten in the center. I for one will NEVER go back! read more

Really a 3.75. Went in with my 12 yo son late afternoon and asked for lunch menu. We were seated promptly, with the hostess telling us our server would be over soon. She came over, asked if we had been there before and proceeded to tell us about the restaurant and how it was becoming a distillery in a few months, one of only two in the US, how many different flavored vodkas they would be having, the sixty or so beers on tap that will have and how they love suggestions for new flavors. She did mention, after all that, to my son that it wasn't for him. Then asked for our drink orders...I think she might have expected me to get a drink? We placed our water and soft drink order. She came back a few minutes later; I asked if there were specials. She told me. We decided to order the 'pupu platter' and a bowl of chile con carne to share. The con carne was pretty good, nice big chunks of veggies and ground meat, covered generously with a sharp cheddar, we skipped the sour cream on top. The pupu was good. We liked the calamari the best, it had a white sauce drizzled over the top that we could not place but it did complement it. Second, were the hog wings? It was a country style, pork rib, with a portion of the bone cleaned like a lollipop. My son said it tasted like pulled pork on a stick. The blue, red and regular corn chips used in the nachos made it a little more exciting, they topped it with chile con carne, jalapeno's and what look like a mixture of white and yellow cheddars. Homemade potato chips, parrot wings, coleslaw (nicely placed in a romaine leave) and vegetable spring rolls finished the 18" inch (too big) round platter. The wings will get a 6.5 out of 10...good but something just not there. Coleslaw was ok, nice hint of horseradish. Veggie spring rolls...no. Just no, they weren't good. Tasted frozen, and were very greasy. Really didn't make sense with the other items either. Maybe because it's called a pupu? Substitute the veggie spring rolls for something fresh or plain carrot sticks and celery. Prices for lunch ranged from $5 for chile con carne to $7 burgers to $14 entrees. Over all we did like it...and will go back. read more

A friend recommended this place. We were NOT happy with the service. We were seated immediatly, ordered drinks, apps, and meals. We waited over an hour, without so much as our appetizers brought out. We watched another table be seated, get apps, and their meals! Finally, our meals came out, boardering being cold. We had to remind the waitress we still hadnt received soups/salads that come with meals. The appetizers came out last. We were embarrassed that we had suggested the place to our friends! read more

I feel the waitstaff is mostly young girls with no exp. Had a very loud waitress, not remembering her name just that it started with a K. Where do you find these people? Besides that, they ran out of Prime Rib, Oysters, Clams and Lobster! Which is all on their menu and so early on a Thursday! Settling for a sandwich the one I wanted was out also. Will not be returning. read more

Mediocre at best. The beer was the highlight of the meal, honestly. The beer was great - as we both enjoy Opa Opa. Everything else... not so much. Husband got chili, which he said was decent, but not great. Not much heat to it. After our salad, as the waitress cleared out plates, she stated dinner would be right out. 25 minutes later, our dinner was brought out. The waitress had told us when we ordered that the "vod" was corn on the cobb, but it ended up being carrots. She made no ackowledgement of the error, other than saying "no" when I said "no corn?". Husband ordered filet medium rare... it came beyond well done. He politely sent it back and she mumbled an apology. When he eventually got his filet, it was medium, which at that point, was good enough... but his original overcooked filet was topped with brown butter (as the menu described). The corrected filet was dry. Also had pretty much no seasoning from the bite I had. I had the steamed lobster, which was fine. My husband liked the corn fritters that came with the lobster (I gave them to him so he'd have something to eat while I ate my meal.) Side note that I found amusing... the "moist towelette" that came with the lobster was bone dry. I'm not sure how long that little packet had been around, but that thing was like paper. No moisture to it at all.... Overall, both service and food was below our expectations. Might go back for some drinks at the bar some time, but definitely not for a meal. read more

Read about Kaptin Jimmy's online and thought it'd be a new fun place to try. I don't ever write reviews on places, good or bad, but after dining there this week I needed to share my experience. The decor, outside appearance and overall look of the place was was intriguing. I was excited to try the food and find a new place for my friends and I to make our regular place. From the very second we walked in the door, strange looks from all of the waitstaff began. I could have sworn there was something on my face from the way the whole restaurant turned to stare. It took me a little longer than it took my two friends to realize, because I'm white- and they are black.. that the stares weren't due to writing on my face. I have never, ever experienced such blatant prejudice. The host sat us down without a word, just staring. Our first waitress came over with just a look of disgust on her face. I didn't jump to conclusions at first, also because I haven't dealt often with this kind of thing. It was odd to watch the same waitress, as well as all of the staff be kind to other customers, and so rude to us. The waitress soon there after had another waitress take over our table... not too sure why but I could take guesses.. And this waitress didn't say two words to us for the remainder of the evening. Brought us our food in silence. Now, my friends are very polite and respectful and I couldn't believe the way they were being treated.. and looked at! I couldn't tell you how the food was because honestly I lost my appetite about 10 minutes in. After we left, my friends didn't speak about the night other than saying that they will never, ever go back. Even though they were able to brush it off- I sure as hell can't. Waitstaff and customers alike couldn't stop staring, whispering and being down right disrespectful. That being said, if you aren't a minority, then maybe you'll be treated with respect and served your dinner without feeling like you aren't welcome. This is 2012!!!! So sad. read more

Went about 3pm Sunday afternoon. Quiet in the dining room. More people were coming in when we were leaving about 4:30pm. The bar was busy. The food was good. Had the scallops and my husband had the prime rib. He said that it was delicious and tender, cooked as ordered-medium well. We ordered a piece of Chocolate Rum cake for dessert. I think it was enough for at least 3 people!!! Had to take most of it home. Full from dinner. The portions were very adequate. Service was excellent. And the restrooms were very clean read more