Food was great but the service was extremely bad. I think the reason is that it's just way too busy and they have too many tables crammed in there. The dirty plates just kept piling up on us to the point where at one point I had to eat with one hand and hold a dirty plate in the other hand for several minutes because there was no room left on the table and nobody was checking on us. read more

Annoying that it's cash only but if you like thin crust bar pie and like the Idea of a kinda spicy fra diablo pizza. Love the crisp thin pizza. read more

Great pizza and other bar foods. The staff is friendly. The only downside is it's so popular that wait times can be long. But that's because the food is good. Warning: they accept cash only. read more

This is what you do... go to the frozen food section of your grocery store and get yourself a mama Celeste pizza. Save yourself 10.00! The pics speak for themselves. No flavor, needed salt, the edge of crust was crunchy, but the rest was soggy, chewy, and floppy. Also, don't get the calamari. That's a 1 star, some of the worst I've ever had If you don't take my advice and go anyway, make sure you bring cash or pay the 2.00 atm fee that they have outside. read more

See all

If you like thin crust, this is the place for you. I went with three other people & we cleared 5 pies! The pizza is crispy and tasted great! The waitress was super friendly & gladly answered all of our questions & even helped us with some helpful suggestions. The restaurant itself takes you back to an old school aesthetic, very simple and inviting. I can certainly see why people wait for hours to have their pizza. If you are going during peak hours, a reservation is key. I'm confused by some of the not so positive reviews of Kinchley's. What more can they want? I recommend this place wholeheartedly! read more

I got a medium pie. The pizza was okay. The sauce could be a bit better but it was decent. The service was good only thing is cash only. And the place was nice inside. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

I'd go here if it was late and the only place open in the area. It's got good flat bread pizza and offers me some nostalgic memories because my family used to get food from there many years ago...having lived in NYC I think I've been spoiled with too many great restaurants and therefore this is now meh for me. I know many people still enjoy it and have fun times so if you are looking for something casual and basic check it out. read more

Great pizza!! Stuffed mushrooms were good. Caesar salad needed more flavor. Overall great place for pizza. However, our waitress was missing action. We wanted a second drink but she never checked on us. No one checked on us after we got our pizza. Expect good pizza, subpar service. Otherwise worth a try or at least pick up a meal. read more

See all

I really hate to give this place three stars because the pizza really is delicious, but that doesn't make up for the terrible attitude from the staff there. We invited friends to meet us there for dinner. They live farther away and have never been there so we were excited to treat them. When I called a few days prior to see if they take reservations I was happily surprised to find out they did. (In the past we have always walked in and waited.) They were able to accommodate a group of 6 adults and 1 high chair and I was thrilled. They even called the night before to confirm the reservation which was nice, however when we got there we were immediately greeted with an attitude. We arrived right on time for our 6pm reservation and found the friends we were meeting already seated at a booth. When I asked for the highchair I was told they aren't able to add one to the corner booth and if we wanted one we would have to wait because there were other 6pm reservations. Throughout our experience being seated, ordering, eating, and paying the staff attitude was so bad that the guests we invited jokingly asked what we did to have the staff so angry with us. I was embarrassed to have suggested this place to get together but at least the food was good as always. read more

We had the Marco's Zesty Greek salad and an original thin pie. Both were extremely delicious. The server was professional as he kept checking in on us and was very attentive. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Large Original - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Oh man do these slices go right through me!! The plain cheese and pepperoni are my fave here. They are so thin I could probably eat a pie of the plain to myself. They are simple and so perfect!!! So so delicious. read more

See all

After seeing the one bite review of this place I had to give it a try. And I have to say WOW, solid bar pie. The pizza is thin with a nice crunch to it. We got a large pie which is more than enough for 2 people if you get a appetizer. We chose the Fra Diavolo sauce which is a spicer sauce (high recommend). For out toppings we did half sausage and half cherry peppers and green bell peppers. Dessert we got fried cannoli cream ravioli's with a scoop of vanilla ice cream which was delicious. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Delicious pizza -if you are in the mood or like thin crust this place is delicious and well known in the area I feel like it's been around forever!! Which is a good sign - I usually get their regular pizza and they make a fantastic BBQ Chicken Pizza!! Go there- It will not disappoint- If you read this and went there to give it a try after you read this and if you can make comments to reviews- (which idk it's my first time writing one) Please comment and let me know what you thought and if you liked it! I will start to actually add reviews to spots I go and have been to so check em out I've been to lots of great places - a lot of over rated and under rated places and usually the "nicer" restaurants and fun restaurants in and around the city so keep checkin my reviews I can promise I won't steer ya wrong!! So i would 100% reccomend you check this place out and you won't be disappointed- but again it's not like your normal pizza place with a huge menu - it is thin crust.. but damn good! Thanks for reading and thanks to Kinchlys, keep on doing what you do! read more

I work in nearby Rockland County, and I've been looking for a nearby dinner spot for when I work late. Kinchley's pizza is quite amazing, and I do feel that it deserves a higher ranking than what it received via Barstool Pizza reviews. I faced a medium pie alone, maybe could have started another. The slices are super thin, and crust is crispy like toast. The ambiance inside was super old school, with wooden tables and plaid tablecloths. Kinchley's has a pretty rockin bar too. Thanks Kinch! read more

Note: CASH ONLY I love me some thin crust pizza but.....this pizza is almost as thin as a tortilla wrap. Too thin to even hold up all the toppings they suggest on their menu. ESPECIALLY too thin for the one we ended up picking- "The Garbage Pie" with the FRA Diavolo sauce . I was really disappointed because my friend really hyped up this place. He said it deserves a Michelin star and everything. But...dang, my pie barely had any flavor! I barely tasted their famous "FRA Diavolo sauce." However, it tasted much better once I reheated it at home and doused it in hot sauce. Our party ordered so many other kinds too and I tried theirs (with less toppings) and it still didn't do it for me. I like thin crusts but crusts that still have a enough thickness to have a nice crunch and chew to it. Also, it was just too messy to eat, it kept falling apart. Their apps were really great though, I really liked their fried ravioli, and their meatballs were moist. Their calamari and mozzarella sticks were just ok. But their service was fantastic! read more

See all

Some of the best, if not the very best thin-crust pizza in northern NJ. Great for take-out as well, pizza stays hot and crispy!

I go to Kinchley's all the time with friends and family. We love the thin crust pizza. Our favorite is plain and onion pies. The ambiance is great and the service is fast which is perfect for families. read more

Was hiking about 10 minutes away and decided to come here after hiking. Ambiance of the place was cozy and nostalgic. we had large pizza, calamari, and draft beer. The pizza is super thin with a nice crispy cracker like crust. Calamari and beer was pretty average. Service is excellent. I would highly recommend their pizza, its better than most great pizza places. read more

See all

Kinchleys is a northern NJ staple. I LOVE their thin crust pizza, fried ravioli, salad, and they have a good beer and cocktail selection as well. Great place to go if you're looking for a cool old school vibe. read more

Kinchley's never disappoints. I grew up in NJ but have lived in VA for the last 20 years. We visit Kinchley's whenever we head North. BEST thin crust pizza. SO delicious. I believe they are still cash only. Don't let the full parking lot deter you - they move at Jersey speed! And you always have the option of takeout. We were recently traveling to VT and planned our route from VA just so we could swing into Kinchley's and grab a few pies. Ate them in the car.....fantastic. read more

Fact that I have been going here for over 40 years should tell you lots- Always good and consistent and worth the crowds. Cash only business,old school atmosphere, friendly staff with many of the staff has been there for years. Thin crust pizza is excellent as is everything we have tried off their menu.I have moved but still drive over a half hour to go there. Wish it was a much bigger place - Love the display of Lionel Trains- read more

Kinchley's is one of the best old school pizza parlors around. The food and service is always consistently excellent. The environment is very chill and you never feel rushed to finish your meal. The prices are also very reasonable. My personal favorite is the fra diavolo pizza with cherry peppers. The pizza is thin crust so you don't feel guilty indulging. We usually order a couple of pies because it will gets devoured quickly. During my last visit, I tried for the first time the meatball appetizer. It was one of the best meatballs I have had in my life. The 3 meatballs was served with ricotta cheese and touch of pesto sauce. I am looking forward to trying different items on the menu because Kinchley's has never disappointed! You must give Kinchley's a try because it is one of the best pizzerias in North Jersey. I would suggest to call for reservations so you don't have to wait! Enjoy! read more

See all

I don't think they've changed their sauces not tasty. Their pizza is very thin and crusty.

We love going to Kinchley's for the best thin curst pizza. The food is always consistent and full of flavor. The pepperoni pizza is my favorite. Great staff, friendly, attentive, efficient. Always a great experience. read more

Was here on 7/8/24. Service and food were great. Super cute decor! I left my black lululemon back either in the bathroom or maybe it fell under the table at the booth we were sitting at along the wall that had the train display. Management has been helpful with taking down my info and checking out. It hasn't been found. Fingers crossed it gets returned because it had my wallet and ID in it! read more

First time trying Kinchley's. The place was recommended by friends. Pizza was good. Definitely thought it was over hyped. Just a usual bar pizza, nothing special. Not saying it was bad. It was average at best. Would have gave this place 4 stars but the staff was very unfriendly from the moment I walked in. *review is based on the pizza and service* I will definitely return to try the other menu items. read more

Bar pizza at its finest. White pizza to die for. Middle of the day on a Saturday you can enjoy a nice cold one at the bar and a delicious thin, crusty pie. The standard pie with meatballs turns it up a not. NEVER been disappointed with the quality, price, or taste. The white pizza is a sleeper, garlicky goodness and great cheese. read more

Kinchley's is one of those spots I had heard about but never had the chance to go. I rarely go that far north in NJ but luckily a friend brought it to a party I was at. There is a lot of hype here and I thought it lived up to it. I tried all sorts of pizza here from the pepperoni, meatball, vodka, and plain. First off the pizza is thin and there is almost no crust. That isn't necessarily a bad thing. It kind of reminds me of Federici's in that you can crush a whole pie in one sitting and not even know it. It is one of those pizza's I can eat anytime anywhere. I even had it cold and it was still good. It is that tried and true new jersey thin crust bar pizza that never disappoints. Kinchleys has been here for a while and it isn't going anywhere. I would put it in my top 20 for best pizza places in the USA and I get the hype. Glad I tried it! Another big time pizza spot checked off the list. read more

See all

Best pizza EVER. I drive 40 minutes for this pizza. Fantastic fried raviolis, garlic bread, beer! And super amazing staff! Love love love Kinchleys read more

My wife and I finally had the opportunity to take our son to Kinchley's. It was a busy Christmas week afternoon and the place was packed but the staff was very attentive and our server, Cindy, was an absolute delight. We shared a famous thin crust pizza and ordered some entrees. My wife enjoyed her fried clam platter while my son ordered a chicken dish. I enjoyed the open roast beef platter. We had a wonderful time. Ample portions and a fair price. We will definitely be back. read more

I typically love mushroom, onions, and sausage pizza but not this one. It's good, but I don't think I will be a making a special trip. I suppose I am not a big fan of really thin pizza. This is a popular place but it's not for me. read more

It's a community staple and great family experience. Very thin crust pizza with its own taste. However, if you are vegetarian or vegan or just like to eat relatively healthy, you won't find anything worth eating. read more

Heard a lot about this place and it was better then expected. The thin crust pizza is the best Service was outstanding Will definitely be back read more

Time warp feeling of my childhood. Interior remains paneled just as it did from my childhood The trains no longer run above but are still there only encased in glass separating the bar from the dining room There is an ATM on site for ease as only accepts cash Thin crust pizza best around Wait staff quick and knows their stuff and the menu well Perfect for a rainy day meal read more

Great food at a reasonable price. Be sure to bring plenty of cash because they don't take credit cards. Friendly atmosphere and outstanding service! read more

Had the mushroom, onion, and sausage pizza which was a great combo of toppings on a perfectly sweet and tomatoey sauce or "gravy". The crust was similar to matzo, very thin and crunchy and a great crust for this nj bar pie type pizza. We also ordered the fried zucchini sticks which were great too. The zucchini itself was not flavored but the crunchy coating/exterior was perfect for the bland vegetable. This app came with a tomato dipping sauce which seemed different than the pizza sauce, but not sure. Very yummy place; will be going back. read more

Kinchley's Tavern - Zucchini fries - Pizza Near Me - Ramsey, New Jersey

See all

Is this fine dining? No. Is the plain cheese pizza excellent. No (I don't like the sauce) Is the Vodka pizza life changing? Yes. Never thought I'd be one of those people, putting sauces where they don't belong. But it's true, everyone CAN grow. It's cash only and it's cheap. And it's authentic in its own way. There is a reason it's been in business since 1492. read more

Good food service ambiance. I would say a must have is the pizza! We also go a few other things, honestly everything was great. I had the spicy pizza wasn't my favorite, I like plain! read more

Artie came home after a week at Valley Hospital...his son Kevin brought him immediately to KINCHLEYS for 2 pies...sausage, peppers and onions And a plain read more

Best thing to happen in the area in a while, only problem very looks so good and is that you always end up spending more then you want to, but well worth it read more