We were Out & About yesterday, stopped at Via Roma II for a couple of quick slices because we were…read moreboth starving. We felt my wife's Margherita slice was better than my pepperoni slice, I thought mine was only a slight upgrade from Gas station quality pizza. But pictures of whole pies posted from other Yelpers look decent, I imagine if we come back again, we'd order a pizza rather then having re-heated slices. So a 3 Star Rating for the present.

We stopped here for dinner on way back to Ohio from Statue of Liberty. Our meals were amazing…read more Portions were large and tasted like Nonna's home cooking. Home made garlic bread and huge fresh salad served with meal. Service was excellent. And Pasta Fagiol was amazing. We will go back for pizza based on recommend of people at next table!!

Sorella's Pizzeria is very generous with great tasting bread and lettuce on their cold subs. This…read moreis what $18 gets you, enjoy.

Great pizza. Love their margarita and nona's pie. Have really good salad as well. Great customer…read moreservice.

I wanted to write a review not just about the pizza, which is high quality and delicious , but also…read moreabout the team they have working there. I went in tonight to pick up two pies I had ordered online. They weren't quite ready yet, so I sat down to wait and was immediately greeted by the young man working the register. He then proceeded to do something that feels like a lost art these days: he actually talked to me. A few minutes later, the guy making the pizza joined the conversation too. In the span of a 10-minute wait, we talked about college, sports, music, and pizza. It was such a nice change from the usual "face in the phone" experience you get in so many places now, where customer interaction feels like an afterthought. Then, when one of the pies didn't look up to their standard, they made me a new one and gave me the original pie for free. So basically: go for the pizza, which is excellent, but stay for the great customer service. Solid spot.

True Italian fine dining with wood fired oven for their authentic artisan pizzas. We just had our…read morefavorite margherita pizza to go as our order. Waited a few minutes outside the patio and observed. Service is great and fast with their friendly, hospitable, helpful staffs. We observed that there's a lot of orders to go as people keeps coming in and out . Quite busy place. Clean and tidy pizzeria. Scuola Vecchia first timer but definitely will be coming back for dine in with friends. Margherita pizza is really good. We do recommend this place if you're looking for authentic artisan wood fired oven pizzas and fine Italian dining.

Amazing pizza, truly an institution. Call ahead to reserve your time otherwise you're SOL. Honestly…read moresimple is better here, the pizza is just a masterpiece based on the oven they have. They should never renovate this place. Also bring your own wine, it's BYOB!

Pizza reviews are 1,000% subjective, and I'll say up front that my take probably won't line up with…read morewhat most people are experiencing here. I waited for the hype to die down before coming in. This is what I found. Saturday at open, there were about ten groups ahead of me and the wait wasn't bad at all. I felt good about the experience early on. Street parking and was able to find a spot. One pet peeve: list your prices. I don't like guessing what I'm about to pay. It came out to around $19 for a large cheese, which is honestly not bad. The young lady who took my order was personable, and I was able to grab a seat inside -- they have outdoor tables as well. The pie came out and at first glance the crust is crispy with an orange glow to it. Unfortunately, I've had better tasting pizza. Someone nearby made a comment about the dough being like a cracker, and I have to agree -- it read more like cardboard to me. I ended up using the garlic salt, grated cheese and oregano from the table just to recover some flavor. The leftovers were even worse. A few odds and ends: the pizza makers all look pretty serious, maybe even miserable. That may just be the heat back there. They also sell individual frozen pies to take home, and they accept cash or card. It wasn't a total waste of time, but it's not going on my list of all-time greats. One and done for me -- I wouldn't travel an hour or more to come back. Sorry guys, I wanted this to be epic and it just wasn't.

Amazing pizza! We love the vodka pie and the meat and peppers combo…read more Friendly staff. Smaller dining area but always clean. Entrees, salad, sandwiches all solid.

$10.58- 1 plain, 1 Sicilian, 20oz coke $30.00- chicken parm…read morehero, 2 margarita slices, 20oz coke, 16oz water. Small inside dining area, took it to go. Friendly girl working the counter. Chicken Parm Hero 6.8/10 (not very big) Sicilian slice 8.8/10 Plain slice 8.1/10 Margarita Slice 8.9/10 Price justified by quality & speedy service.

We haven't been back in quite some time and boys. Some things have certainly changed especially the…read morenew bar so no longer BYOB. We came in just at opening realizing we didn't have a reservation and waiting at 4 o'clock on a Sunday so we got fortunate to have choice of seat seats. We opened up with the Gemelli and meatballs and complimented that with the tartufo di Gianni pie. With a glass of Montiepuliciano. Cody was extremely tentative, very friendly engaging. Give us a time we needed to make our final decisions for a meal. Platings were beautifully done. Ingredients were all super fresh. The pie was made just the way we like it just the right amount of crisp without being too soggy in the middle where each other restaurants haven't I guess figured that part out. Good meal good time parking up on the side. Did notice a credit card surcharge on the bill and it's not American Express that I carry. The reason I pointed out is we've been to other restaurants where they give you a choice of credit card or a discount for cash was not offered that choice here. See your food pics

We came to Osteria on a Wednesday night with the kids and had a fantastic meal. Inside had a warm…read moreand cozy feel, making a great spot to enjoy dinner. We ordered the garlic Parmesan wings, garlic knots, Pizza Dora, and a margarita pizza--everything was delicious! The standout dishes were definitely the garlic Parmesan wings and the margarita pizza, both packed with great flavor. The pizza crusts were thin and crunchy, along with the sauce made it a great bite. It was also a nice bonus that a couple of the items were on the happy hour menu, making them an even better deal. The quality of the food, combined with reasonable prices and a welcoming atmosphere, makes this a spot we'll definitely be returning to. Highly recommend!

Prince street pizza is a stop that should definitely be on your bucket list! While there is no…read moreseating here ( you're free to stand indoors/outdoors - or find seating near by) the service here is quick and professional. I have been here a numerous ammount of times and after my most recent visit I knew it was time to leave a review! What I love the most about Prince Street pizza is that despite all of the "hype" or "clout" they genuinely have good a$$ pizza ! It's that classic early 2000's pizza with the thick dough where you can tell they were working that dough and putting their fingers into it! With that pillowy crust that folds and flakes just how you want it too !! Make sure you save room for more because this is not your one slice only kind of pizza joint ! My personal favorite is four cheese slice !!

Vibe/ambiance: classic neighborhood pizza; minimal standing space…read more Service: standard Items ordered: - hot honey pep: 8.5/10

Ordered pizza and a sub for pick up. Super quick and friendly service. The pizza was great--the…read morecrust was exceptional crust had bubbles and char--absolutely perfect. (Might have it for breakfast) The sub was huge and grandpa really liked it. Half for dinner and half for lunch the next day. The guy behind the counter was very friendly and upbeat. Just let me with a great impression...we'll definitely go back often.

Ordered take out and they're huge portions. I probably got three meals from the chicken parm I…read moreordered. They're always friendly when you go in and answer any questions you may have. Never ate in but looks like your typical pizza place.

Pizza is very good. Had chef salad. It was very good and fresh. Lettuce, red onions, green and…read moreblack olives, ham, turkey, American cheese, grape tomatoes, and cucumbers. Large portion and delicious. Service is always quick and friendly. Relaxing eat in atmosphere with 8 booths and 5 tables.

The holy grail of pizza. The actual best pizza I've ever had in my lifetime. It smells so freaking…read moregood in there too, people at the counter are super nice and actually speak Italian as well which warms my Italian heart. The fries and garlic knots are also amazing. Squirrel approved as well they LOVE the garlic knots (probably not the MOST healthy for them but 'twas only a treat). Overall great place.

Back for a retry after a number of years. It's okay, nothing to write home about…read more I suppose a safe place to bring family. This time around our service was 5 . The pizza - dirty calm pie was good. The Italian chicken dish was a miss for us... tough chicken pieces and lacking flavor even though it had nice chucks of cut up vegetables. The lentil soup was adequate, it met base line flavor and presentation. I guess what locks and information is I noticed the population that's coming in. It's a much older crowd. Certainly the menu items are on the lower price side so it makes it affordable to go out. It's hard when you cook at home and you want to go out a couple nights a week at the weekend and for what we've been paying with inflation and the impact of tariffs we would expect a higher level of them when I'm putting out of my own kitchen. Again, a safe place a consistent place a busy place and if this is acceptable for you, then this is your go to.

Stopped in on our way home. My husband and I were greeted and seated immediately. There is plenty…read moreof seating and the place looked pretty clean. We ordered some water along with mussels in red sauce, medium pizza with half onions. The mussels were very meaty with a delicious chunky tomato sauce. The pizza had a thin crust with more sauce than cheese, more of a tomato pie taste. It was okay but not the best ratio of tomato sauce to cheese. This place probably has a great tomato pie. I would definitely return just for the mussels alone. But if I ordered a pizza, I'd be a little more specific about its preparation.