This was our final pizza stop in New York City -- sadness! A short walk from both Chinatown and Little Italy, Prince Street Pizza is a great option, especially if you don't want Chinese food or want a sit down Italian meal at a restaurant. The two people at the counter were by far the least friendly people we came across in all of New York City. I thought I might have been teleported to South Street Philadelphia with the level of rudeness!!! While customer service is definitely not a highlight of Prince Street Pizza, the pizza slices were delicious. The spicy pepperoni pizza lived up to the hype. Interior seating was very limited but the trash cans out front were covered with plastic to mimic little tables and were a perfect place to enjoy our slices. It sounds gross typing that out, but I promise it was a great solution to limited seating. If you are looking for a great slice of a classic pizza, this is your spot. If you want an amazing slice of unique pizza (like fig jam bacon), I would head to the recently opened L'Industrie in Little Italy. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Slices and squares. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

While on a mother-daughter trip to SoHo, we stumbled upon this iconic spot and decided to see what all the hype was about. After only a short wait in line, we were ordering within minutes--and from the very first bite, we understood why people rave about this place. We tried the Meat Lovers and the famous Naughty Pie, and both were absolutely incredible. The thick, crispy square slices were perfectly cooked, loaded with flavor, and had that ideal balance of crunchy edges and soft, airy dough. The pepperoni on the Naughty Pie was perfectly crisped, while the Meat Lovers was packed with savory goodness in every bite. What started as a spontaneous stop became one of the highlights of our day. Great pizza, great atmosphere, and even better memories made with my daughter. If you're wandering through SoHo, do yourself a favor and grab a slice--or two. Trust me, you'll be thinking about it long after the last bite. read more

For Sicilian slices, it is great. The line seemed long but it moved quickly. I had two meat lovers & spicy pepperoni. Both were delicious but the spicy pepperoni stands in its own. There are a few standing tables, but a few like me ate our pizza just outside because it was such a lovely day. read more

See all

Visited Prince Street Pizza while in Manhattan. The atmosphere was iconic, busy, and full of energy, and the service was surprisingly efficient given the constant lines. This place draws a crowd for a reason -- expect long lines, but they move at a decent pace. As you make your way up the line, the walls are covered with photos of famous people who've visited, which adds to the experience. Grabbed a few slices, and I have to say, so far one of the best pizzas I've had in New York. Overall, worth the wait and definitely a must-try if you're in the city. Saluti. read more

See all

I stopped by Prince Street Pizza late at night and was honestly surprised (in a good way) that they were still open--it's definitely a convenient spot if you're looking for food after hours. That said, the pizza itself just didn't fully land for me. I know they're especially known for their square slices, but I've realized I'm just not the biggest fan of that style to begin with, so part of this may come down to personal preference. The slice I had felt a bit too heavy on the toppings, and overall it leaned saltier than I would've liked. It kind of overpowered the balance I usually look for in a good slice. I can see why a lot of people love this place, especially if you're into thick, square, topping-loaded pizza. It's just not quite my style. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The third stop on our own NYC pizza crawl brought us to Prince Street Pizza. We had only done traditional NYC slices up to this point, so I was excited to switch it up and try a square slice. I didn't know if it would compare to everything we'd had before, but oh boy did it stand strong. The naughty pie was amazing, I couldn't get enough of it. The vodka sauce was perfection. We also got a slice of Prince Perfection, which was also good, but it was the naughty pie that stole the show for all of us. They have what looks like two different storefronts right next to each other, one is for ordering whole pies, and the other just a slice. The slice line was pretty long on a weekend afternoon, but it moved fairly quickly compared to some of the other places we went. No seating inside, but a small counter inside and a parklet outside to enjoy your pizza. read more

See all

Really really enjoyed the pizza here The wait wasn't bad when we went and even though there wasn't space to eat there there was a nice park nearby that we brought our pizza to. Definitely recommend! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Discount on pizza if you pay with cash - But do check their math! Our total was $36. I gave a $100 bill and the cashier only returned $44. After asking for the remaining change, the cashier raised her voice and insisted that she gave the right amount of change back. Customers behind us in line audibly questioned the cashier. She wouldn't budge and had so much attitude. We came back with a calculator on the phone to show her the math, and then she finally gave me the correct change. How unfortunate the service turned out to be this time. We were lucky to grab one of the few outdoor tables to eat our pizza fresh. Unfortunately, the pizza didn't taste as yummy as my first visit. Not sure if the Naughty Pie was missing hot honey, but it definitely didn't have any sweetness. I hope this day was just a hiccup! Better consistency in both service and food quality could be improved. I brought a group of friends here for our NY pizza crawl & the experience left them quite unimpressed. read more

When a place says they're "delivering happiness one slice at a time," you hope it's true and this spot absolutely lives up to it. We ordered a slice of the Naughty Pie (spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey), and let me just say... I went to heaven and came right back down just to grab another slice. The balance of spicy, creamy, and sweet was unreal. Every bite was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly crisp. It's the kind of pizza that makes you pause mid-bite because it's that good. This is definitely more of a grab-your-slice-and-go kind of place. They do have a few high-top tables, but it gets crowded quickly because it's so popular. That said, the line moves fast, so don't let it scare you away. Safe to say, this is officially on my must-go list. I'll absolutely be checking out their San Diego location and any others I can find because I already know I'll be dreaming about this pizza. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Naughty Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ironically, whenever I see a massive line for a food joint in NYC, I'm highly skeptical. Back in the day, it used to be a sign of objectively good eats, but now, in the age of TikTok and viral trends, it usually just means a desperate (or paid) influencer made a video for content. More often than not, those places never live up to the hype and the food can even be straight up trash. However, Prince Street Pizza is not that. In fact, it's a wonder their line wasn't longer. A friend wanted to try it, so I reluctantly agreed to wait with them, pressing on despite a bit of rain. The joint is tiny but has that authentic, old-school NYC pizza parlor feel, with all the accoutrements (like the owner posing with celebrities and posting them along the wall in cheap, flimsy frames). It took about 25 minutes to get to the front, but it was well worth the wait. I tried the Spicy Spring (their take on the pepperoni slice) and the four-cheese slice. Both were presented as a hearty slice and both tasted fantastic. Once I muster up enough patience to brave the line again, I'll definitely be back to try a few other slices. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm pretty sure I've Prince Street Pizza before, but probably not in a sober state. This time, we stopped by on a Friday night because we were still hungry after our dinner. The place was pretty packed but the line to order moved super fast. The walls were covered in photos of famous people who had come there for pizza. I ordered the Spicy Vodka slice and both my partner and sister got the Naughty Pie slice. I probably should've just eaten it on the spot but we were eager to get into an uber and out of the cold. I liked my slice, but honestly the crust was a little too doughy for me. I really just prefer thin-crust. The spicy vodka had good flavor though, and I ended up adding some hot honey to jazz it up. Would return to try more! read more

See all

This is the best pizza in New York. I've tried this place several times in addition to other places in New York when I visit every year and this is consistently great. To simply put it, the quality of the cheese, sauce, toppings, and crust are above of what you typically eat in pizza restaurants. Great pizza with a wall full of notable celebrities that have visited should that mean something to you. Try it and thank me later or let me know what's better than Prince Street, because it'll be hard to find. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious, albeit a bit pricy. Definitely get the square pie margherita or their peperoni.

Prince St is simply the best square you can get. The very first time I had it, was in 2018, and I flew out from LA. The service is always straight forward and good. The vibes inside is something you can only get from NY. I'm glad we have it in Cali now. read more

Not the biggest pizza person, but I can appreciate a good slice (or square). And wow, Prince Street Pizza did not disappoint. There was a line out the door, but it moved relatively quickly. It's a very small joint, with a small bench to eat inside and 2 standing tables outside. They have a decent selection, all served piping hot and fresh with high quality ingredients. We got their Spicy Spring and Naughty Pie. The Spicy Spring was essentially your classic spicy pepperoni grandma square, but with great execution--seasoned spicy marinara sauce on a thick crust, topped with thick cut pepperoni. Their Naughty Pie (Spicy Vodka Sauce, Pepperoni, Fresh Mozzarella, Whipped Ricotta, Zab's Hot Honey). It was definitely the favorite of the day. It was soooo good like I'm still thinking about it good. It was savory, saucy, spicy, with hints of sweetness. It paired perfectly with the thick cut pepperoni and was not overly greasy. The thicker bread served as the perfect vessel for all the sauce. Prince Street Pizza exceeded my expectations overall. I would definitely come back, especially for the Naughty Pie. I will say, it is not cheap though (like $7/square). But highly recommend! It is worth the money and wait! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Spicy Spring, Naughty Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I've had this pizza a few times just to be sure when I see this - overrated!! There's so many other pizza places in NY that are better, don't let that line fool you, it's purely hype. Not saying Joe's is the best but I definitely prefer their pizza to put things into perspective and 3/5 is me being nice You're welcome ! read more

I wanted to like this place sooooo bad!!! But unfortunately it wasn't giving what I wanted! I felt that the crust needed to be a little crispier. And for some reason, I wasn't feeling the sauce. I think for the amount of bread (they are thicker crusts)- there needs to be a little more sauce. Service and vibes were chill though. Just wasn't hitting the spot for me. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Prince Perfection and spicy pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered the vodka slice. I wish they had heated it longer because it was only a little warm. Aside from that, it was delicious. The line moves very fast. The place is small, but there is a standing area inside if you're looking to grab a quick bite. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Vodka Sauce - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Prince street pizza WILL ALWAYS BE THAT GIRL! Line outside the DOOR. Lines move quick and they have made a location next door that sells pies. I'm so happy they made a Not spicy vodka version it was delicious!!!! My fiancé had the crispy pepperoni and I could hear the crunch from it!!! Ahh! 10 stars! Nothing beats NEW YORK PIZZA read more

See all

I've been coming here for years and the pepperoni slices are just the best. I can't get over it. They're just so good. I don't know what's about it but it's just so addicting. It's not too spicy and the crisp is amazing and the pepperoni flavor is just great with everything. Sometimes there's no line sometimes there's a line but usually we order delivery so we don't have to wait in the line but when we are in person they're usually is a line. There's not much seating at all it's kind of a grab-and-go place If you're visiting New York you have to get it. Just come and try the pepperoni slice. It's bomb read more

See all

Prince Street Pizza 27 Prince St. New York, NY 10012 Naughty Slice Spicy Pepperoni with Vodka sauce is a good combination. I cannot understand why this is called a "naughty slice," but it doesn't matter because it was truly enjoyable. #naughtyslice #princestreetpizza read more

Prince Street Pizza - Naughty Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

You can never go wrong with Prince Street Pizza. That should be the full review. Period! It's so good here, if you're not from NYC and don't have a Prince Street location in your city, like me, I feel bad for you. I think of these slices often. The slices are so good, you'll be okay risking the roof of your mouth and the burns you'll get because you're so impatient to take another bite. This is the best pizza after a night out, but it's just good pizza in general. The line goes by quick and all of their slices look so delicious, but my go to is the spicy spring and the vodka slice. Makes me want to catch a train to New York often to just go here. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Vodka Sauce, Spicy Spring (square ) peperoni cups - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Prince street pizza really lives up to the hype. We got a pepperoni soho square, spicy vodka soho square (6/10 spiciness) and a fancy prince round slice. All were delicious! I've never had anything like the square slices before. The crust was flavorful and crunchy and the pepperoni was juicy and thick. The round slice is on par with Bleeker Street pizza. Lines were 10 people out the door on a Thursday night at 6pm, but it moved fast. They also do a cash discount. read more

See all

Love this place. Great location with fast service. Place is always busy and food it amazing. Sorry I forgot to snap a picture but the others you see placed by Yelp reviews is accurate read more

I'm saddened to report this spot is overhyped. After waiting in line for about 20m, I was disappointed to receive a room temp slice that was far from fresh. The best part of the Spicy Spring was the pepperoni and I found myself trying to finish my food simply because it's so popular. I love square pizza but would recommend others to try less popular joints for a higher quality taste and experience. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Not your traditional NY slice. Walk up ordering, standing room only to eat. Really fantastic pizza. In house made mozzarella & ricotta. Wasn't hungry when we stopped in - no regrets. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Sameo sameo!!! lol one of our favorites in NYC. I will say the service is lacking a bit but it's expected from a place that just slammed with tourists and people who have no idea what they're doing. Haha Anyways... great pizza, ambience same old school NYC feel. Always a stop for our household. read more

See all

I think there are enough pizza shops in NYC that there shouldn't be a line and wait like the one I encountered here. That said, pizza was pretty good. Wish the seating/eating situation was better than a counter on the street, but it's NY so space is limited. Pizza good. Long wait in line for 2 slices, bad. read more

See all

The Za here is extremely mediocre at best. Much better slices around the city that clear. Go explore pls read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Are you ever in Midtown Manhattan at work craving a New York slice of pizza? That was certainly the case for my friend and me. We both live in the Bay Area but happened to be in the NYC office at the same time. So we figured it would be the perfect time to take a little lunch adventure! My friend is an avid pizza lover from Jersey, so I knew she had high expectations. She had just gone to Joe's that weekend, so I knew Prince Street was the next thing she needed to try. A couple stops on the F train and a short walk later, we were there! It had been a while since my last visit, so we had accidentally walked into the dessert side on the left (woops) and was directed by the worker to the pizza portion next door. There were a handful of people within the shop, but nothing compared to the weekend rush. My friend decided to get the spicy vodka sauce and four cheese slices. I opted for the carnviorous meat lovers and spicy pepperoni slices. A major con is that there's not seating, and the standing portion inside is super tiny. The outside standing tables have no shade, so we opted to walk to a park nearby. We made the mistake of not grabbing napkins - so be sure to grab them. After finding a bench at the park, it was time to dig in! And dug we did. The Sicilian slices are quite thick, meaning they're very filling. It was super greasy especially without napkins, and our hands were smothered in grease - which we had to wash our hands off in the kids fountain afterward. We loved how the slices were crunchy and not that doughy. The sauces were flavorful, the meat was well cooked, perfect amount of spice, not too much sauce, and on top of that, great bonding. If you made it this far - I'm sure you're curious what's better: Joe's or Prince Street? We did our homework, and we have the answer for you...(drum roll please) PRINCE STREET!! Prince Street takes debit card and Apple Pay, which is a +1 for convenience. Additionally, as someone who loves Sicilian pizza, it has a natural competitive edge. You have to give credit where credit's due doe - Joe's has seating. Anyway, will definitely be back whenever I'm in NYC!!! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Mehhhhhh. Mid tier pizza. This was super hyped up by the best friend as the best pizza she has ever had, so I was super excited. However, I wasn't that impressed. We arrived here on a Tuesday around 3:30pm and there were a few folks waiting to order and pick up their orders. We ordered the Naughty Pie and the Meat Lovers. My husband wanted a slice of cheese, but they were out of cheese, so he got the Meat Lovers instead. The Naughty Pie was pretty good. Not like any pizza I have ever had before. It's a little sweet. My husband liked the Meat Lovers. It was a little on the spicy side. We both agreed that our slices weren't warmed up enough. Both slices were cold in the middle, which was disappointing. There isn't anywhere inside to stand and eat, but right out front is a pretty large covered counter area to stand and enjoy your slices. I'm glad we came here, but we had better pizza during our trip. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Meat Lovers in the front and the Naughty Pie in the back - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Naughty Pie - It was a meaty tasting slice with a creamy, slightly sweet but also very savory vodka sauce. The savory meatiness of the prosciutto comes through in the sauce. The dough was perfectly crispy and chewy. The pepperoni cups were plentiful and perfect. Being my very first slice from Prince Street, I enjoyed this slice a lot, even as leftovers. My friend told me to get a slice of the Spicy Spring with hot honey, but upon hearing that order the employees kept strongly pushing the Naughty Pie, insisting that's the one we should get if we wanted hot honey. Not wanting to argue, we gave in and got the Naughty Pie. My friend tasted it and was disappointed, saying that the Spicy Spring with hot honey is much better. The Naughty Pie is saltier and less 'fresh tomato' tasting than the Spicy Spring due to the difference in sauce. Just a note. Next time, just insist on the Spicy Spring with the addition of hot honey. read more

Prince Street Pizza - 8.14.2025 - Naughty Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My Brother and I were going to try out as many pizza places as we could on our drive through the city. Prince Street Pizza was our 7th stop. This one got messed up a little and it was my fault. There is no parking in most of NY, so I was dropping my Brother off at all these places and then circling the block, picking him up, and parking illegally somewhere to eat really fast lol. I forgot to tell my Brother to get the "Pepperoni Square Slice" so he came out with 2 regular slice of cheese. I was a bit disappointed, but again, it was my bad for not telling him what I wanted (I had a list, but we did not refer to it lol). Anyways.......the cheese slice. Eh...it was ok. A little bit thicker than all the other regular slices we had during the day. Wasn't bad, but wasn't memorable either. I'm sure the square slice was way better. Until next time, Prince Street............ read more

Prince Street Pizza - Plain cheese slice. Ok. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York