Delicious, very small, almost always a wait, no cash!…read more The best pizza in the greater area, easily. There's always a wait due to being very small inside, so don't come if you're in a hurry. But it's worth the wait. Note: they take CASH ONLY!! The staff is friendly. It is warm and cozy - a small town "place to be". It's old school - hand written tickets and cash register. Their pizza is the best, but also have amazing hoagies, pasta, and appetizers. Huge selection of local beer. You haven't truly been to Davis until you've eaten here!

Stop in here during a road trip thru WV. Had good write up on Yelp. Atmosphere is very rustic with…read moremultiple types of seating to choice. It was middle of week during off season so it was not very busy. Ordered waters to drink and our Red Lodge pie. I took a little bite to get pie but it came out very hot. There is parmesian cheese and red pepper on tables to spread on your food. My wife and I both thought the pie was lacking in flavor. We could hardly make out the individual vegie flavors and the chicken was bland. There seemed to be a good amount of ingredients on it and grust was medium thickness with good flavor. Service was good, several staff checked in with us during our meal.

Adorable Italian place in Elkins with some awesome lunch specials!…read more You get a salad and garlic bread with the pasta which is discounted at lunch. Egg on the salad was over cooked but everything else was wonderful. Menu isn't anything out of the ordinary but it is very good and well executed Americanized Italian food. Server was very attentive and I love that there is enough for leftovers! I'll have to check out their pizza!

This place is permanently closed. It was great but I've been by in the last couple of months and it…read moreis a new restaurant

The ambience of Mama Mia is a bit drab, somewhere between cafeteria and homely. The staff are all…read morequite pleasant. There's a pool table by the bar, and hit rock tunes playing over the speakers. It's approximately on par with what you would expect for small-town Italian with a bar. In contrast to the rest of the digs, the pizza was quite remarkable. The chef clearly puts great care into his pizza. Crunchy but airy crust with an appropriate thickness to it. The cheese blend was clearly chosen with care. And the tomato sauce beautifully wove the rest of the ingredients together. I'd highly recommend Mama Mia for a family wanting some pizza after a day out hiking or skiing. I'm certain it will be a lovely time.

Wildly inconsistent. Watery hot sauce. Delayed ordering and serving. Ain't no mamma to me :(…read moreServer was very nice though

Amazing pizza! Service was great and the space is large and combined with a bar. Lots of parking…read more They had an large pizza over, my mistake was taking it to go. After 30 minutes still tasted great but know it would have been better as soon as it came out. Highly recommend if in the area!

Drove 30 mins out of the way to try this place and would 100% do it again. Friendly, laid back…read moreatmosphere and staff. AMAZING food. Our only regret is not being able to try more things. Will definitely come again if ever in the area.

Love that they serve pizza by the slide and full pies. Very much NY style pizza. Other great…read morepasta options on the menu!

I had little to no expectations stopping here for a weekend getaway, but this was some of the…read morebetter NY style pizza I've had in some time. The woman working the counter was not the nicest upon originally checking in (I was too early for the pizza and she made that clear to me), but the food made up for the dry attitude. I don't normally go for white pizza as well, and thought their version was spectacular and full of flavor.

Food was very good, we came in right after what looked like a busy rush. All of the servers were…read morehustling and very attentive. It's not the most lavish place but it was close so we went for it despite some of the bad reviews. Overall I'm glad we went, the pizza was good and my wife's pasta was also good. No complaints.

There was one other table besides us. The place was under construction and it looked like it will…read morebe a lovely spot with beautiful views. There were 2 of us, ordered 2 teas and mozzarella sticks and then pasta with no chicken for me and a pizza with no meat for him. It was $75 before tip. Salad was good, ranch was delicious. Pasta wasn't good. Watery and not much flavor. His pizza came out 20 minutes AFTER I WAS DONE EATING MY PASTA. I got up from the table and interrupted the waitress chit chat club to ask about it. Once it did come out, it was black and dry on the bottom. Clearly it had been forgotten about. Will not return nor recommend.

This popular restaurant is closed…read more.. Seems to have done average business, with appeal to families and lower end orders

We decided to visit Big John's because their website said they had gluten free pizza. However,…read morewhen we arrived, there was no gluten free ANYTHING other than a salad or ice cream that I would not trust enough for my daughter with celiac disease to eat. The place is run down, the arcade (also touted on their website) no longer exists, and seating was pretty limited. Robert Irvine could probably help the place a little... Given that we were in the middle of nowhere, West Virginia, the celiac had a soda and the rest of us had a variety of food from the small menu. The food was ok. My husband's burger was overcooked (the menu stated all burgers would be cooked to medium), my kids burger was pretty good. Our group also had fries (yummy), a milkshake, kids meal chicken tenders, and a chicken sub. Would I go back? No. Do they need to update their website? YES!!!! Was the food ok? Yeah.

We ate at Mountain State and had a really good experience. The pizza was great, and the drinks were…read moreeven better -- I had a margarita that was perfect. We ended up coming back a few nights later just for drinks. We had a few beers and a few margaritas, and the servers both nights were very nice and welcoming. Later that night we ordered a few pizzas online and stopped back to pick them up. The pizzas were just as good as the first time. Overall, a great spot for both food and drinks!

We stopped into town for a long weekend, and it had been ages since I last stayed in Deep Creek…read more Had we not just had pizza the night prior, I would have ordered some here because it all looked (and smelled) amazing. The biggest thing of note, we had the friendliest, and most kind, waitress from any restaurant I had been to in a long time - so kudos for that! The food and beer were all decent, nothing stood out in particular but for the price and service, I would definitely be back.

The pesto pizza was citrusy and bright. Classic flavors, but elevated with flavorful ingredients…read more Mushrooms on the Bella Bianca are perfectly cooked. Garlic and white sauce bring this dish over the top. The dough altogether is amazing structurally- notably, a mixture between chewy and crispy that everyone can get with.

The food was excellent, so was the service. Fresh farm to table ingredients. Would definitely go…read moreback.

To start, I will be back 100%. The service is great and the place is a bit older inside but it's…read moreclean and comfortable. There were 4 of us this night. When we ordered we never expected for the portions to be so large. I am not complaining, it's was quite pleasant. Everything we ate was fresh and most of it tasted homemade. The food had love in it. Is there anything else to say with that? The pizza was tasteful every bite you took. My son had the spaghetti and I had to try it. It was great. Plenty of flavor but my favorite part was them meatballs. Not to dense, cooked great, and the flavor was there. The cheese bread doesn't even need sauce but it makes it even better. Thanks for the love you all show here.

Best lunch stop of our cross country road trip. Gennaro and our server made us feel so welcome…read more I had a tasty BLT on a fresh baked roll with thick sliced bacon. My husband had an enormous Italian pasta salad with the works. He was very pleased. So glad we found this place. Thanks Gennaro!