This is an edit and upgrade to my previous review. Service not so great my first visit, but much better on the second visit. Pizza is excellent. read more

Li’l Nick's Pizza - Homemade Italian sausage and bell peppers - Italian Near Me - Wheat Ridge, Colorado

Honestly, 2 pizzas for $80?! If you're gonna have a pizza place and charge that much the pizza better be at least one level above average. I can assure you this wasn't any better than a high dollar frozen pizza. I never would have paid this much for pizza but my husband ordered it anyway and it's just what I was afraid of...we got duped. Please save your money and go somewhere else. This is an absolute rip off. read more

The owner actually gave me two free pizzas for the mistake. It's too bad GrubHub was the one responsible. The new pizzas were delicious.

Delivery order- doordash -1st time trying restaurant. Garlic knots were not fully cooked - raw on inside. Salad was put in same bag as hot items so was warm when delivered. It had potential to be a great salad with all the good toppings. Ravioli was good. Fettuccini wasn't as rich and creamy as I like it and the chicken was a crumbled consistency. I would expect sliced chicken (breast) when ordering a pasta dish. read more

Order 2 large pizzas and had them delivered via Postmates. Not 1 problem. Pizzas arrived hot. I am not giving 5 stars as I thought they might have been a bit greasy and they were kinda pricey. With tip $60. Pizzas were very good and not skimpy with their toppings. I think I would order again but maybe for a special occasion (splurge). read more

Ordered a10" pizza and wings for carry out.. Pizza was pretty good and flavorful. Wings could be better . read more

Li’l Nick's Pizza - 10" pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and jalapeños - Italian Near Me - Wheat Ridge, Colorado

I don't typically leave reviews but I want to warn people! This was the worst food experience of my life... I ordered chicken Alfredo pasta and baked rigatoni on 9/9/22. The Alfredo sauce smelt as if it was rotting and tasted raunched! I smelt it when someone opened the container from the other side of the table! The Rigatoni was overcooked soft mush and tasted smokey. Not sure why pasta with marinara sauce would have a smokey flavor... The side salad lettuce was browning and hardly cut... The garlic knots were mushy... the food was served in what looked like a tiny trash bag and now I understand why... This was by far the worst food experience in my entire life. Maybe other items on the menu are decent but the pasta and salad was absolutely horrendous. I would give 0 stars if I could. Sorry Li'l Nick's... read more

Cold pizza and brown salad. We've been here plenty of times before but this was super disappointing. Food seems to be pretty inconsistent anymore. read more

We have eaten here several times and the food is just good. The staff is awesome and when they made a mistake on our order the gave us the pizza then gave us another one. Their beer list is great and the place is kept clean along with the restrooms, so every time we drive by we almost stop in, but not always as we do need to get home some of the times. However, you should stop in now and have a meal. read more

Ordered a 16 inch lucky 7 and a order of wings. Wings were bone in and breaded and lacked flavour, the breading was soggy and the meat was tough. The lucky 7 was like eating soup, all the toppings just slid off the crust because the dough was raw. We ate ( or tried to eat ) a slice each but ended up tossing the rest into the trash. If you get take out CHECK THE PIE BEFORE YOU LEAVE, I was not the one who picked it up or I would of caught it before It left the store. EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED TO SAY THE LEAST. read more

I grew up in this area but never been here before. Open in the 70's in this strip mall...maybe a 7 11 once. I finally stopped by. Very small bar and a slightly larger dining room. The bar was packed. I had spaghetti with meat balls and a pizza to go. Both great but the minestrone soup was my favorite. Meatball homemade. Pizza thin crust. Parking tight. read more

See all

Had amazing service!!! We came with hungry toddlers and they were fast and empathetic. The balls of fire pizza was incredible. We'll be back soon! read more

Ridiculously expensive ordered my nine-year-old grandson spaghetti with two meatballs $18.76 are you serious ? This is disgusting to take advantage of people like this I will not be back and neither will my big Italian family and friends do you know how cheap it is to fix spaghetti and your charging premium not on my wallet!!! read more

Best pizza around and their mozzarella sticks are top notch. Always quick service and friendly staff.

Lovely little Italian place with pizza, pasta and others. The server was good, we let her know we hadn't eaten all day and she immediately put in an order for cheese bread while we looked over the menu. We did a half and half medium so we would have leftovers. Pizza crust was fine, but toppings were yum and plentiful! Nice little place to stop. Only complaint was the server forgot my beer and I had to ask about it when we brought the pizza out; however, she was very attentive with every request before and after that. read more

See all

Deliciousness!!! I've ordered the pepperoni sausage and jalapeño pizza twice now from delivery and it's so tasty!! I def wanna go instead and try it fresh from the oven bc of it tasted this good after transport I can't wait to try it super hot. Get you some! read more

The food was amazing! I felt the care and love put into the food and I credit that to the amazing staff that is so welcoming and genuinely caring. The food was already out of the park but the staff's kindness only heighten my experience. read more

Disappointed. Picked up a 14" pizza, got home, opened the box to discover a VERY undersized (10-1/2") and moderately burnt pizza. Called the shop and were told there was "nothing they could do" and that they're website description "must be wrong". Was told they'd "pass the message on to the store manager" yet we've heard nothing back. Confused and disappointed. read more

Li’l Nick's Pizza - Receipt - Italian Near Me - Wheat Ridge, Colorado

See all

I never write crappy reviews. I just don't go there again. But this pizza was so abysmal, that I felt the need to protect anyone from ever being stuck with this for dinner. Tiny, premade crust, canned mushroons and not an artichoke in sigt on the entire pizza. The center was raw, and soggy. the canned raw garlic spooned on. There were like 5 pieces of sausage on the entire pie, and it somehow had no flavor at all. for $20, this is insane. Digorno for $4.99 frankly tastes much better. read more

It's not bad, but nothing special. The sauce they're most proud of is more herbal tasting than sweet and it's kind of cold. My overall feeling is that they're not too generous on the ingredients. Portion's not bad but each dish feels like there's something missing. read more

Oh my goodness I got the cheese calzone and Brookie and they were both to die for! Absolutely delicious!

Delicious salad, pizza, and wings! This place never disappoints! We have only ordered takeout but it's always amazing!

Great neighborhood pizza place. They are so nice and low key. Very friendly and the food is good. Home made salad dressings. This pizza was so loaded up you couldn't see the crust read more

Li’l Nick's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wheat Ridge, Colorado

We came for dinner on a Friday night and it wasn't too busy when we got there but it filled up quickly. There were only two servers and one person in the kitchen and they absolutely killed it!! Food was amazing, service was great, and atmosphere was pleasant. Highly recommend supporting this local treasure! read more

Just a great little hole-in-the-wall. So, I roamed in to Lil Nick's with a groupon type thing to use. I got an Italian sampler type dinner with lasagne, ravioli, linguine, minestrone & garlic knots. The pastas were great, the soup was that truly homemade kind (no Progresso here), and the garlic knots were good. They have really cheap beer here. In fact, their regular priced $3.25 drafts and $3.50 bottles rival most happy hours I have been to. I enjoyed a bottle or two of pumpkin beer, yum! The place was pretty dead the Wednesday evening before Thanksgiving. But, that was fine by me, since I'd brought in a pile of school work to do. My server didn't try to roust me out when I was done, just checked on me occasionally to see if I needed more libations. This is a great spot and I will definitely be back. It actually reminds me of a restaurant with virtually the same name back in San Jose. read more

The food and service are really good. First time there. Huge portions and great taste. Wait staff was attentive and friendly.

We ordered from Grub Hub and I think that's part of where we went wrong. The pizza and wings were cold when they finally got here. And the chicken wings were a bit of a let down as they seems to have been from baby alien chickens. read more

For the first time in years, the food was horrible. The usually incredible house salad was mediocre, they were out of croutons, the minestrone soup tasted like smoky ham hocks and beans, the red sauce was too spicy, the eggplant literally tasted like plastic and two peoples' stomachs were very uncomfortable right after the meal, as well as this morning. The leftovers will not be eaten and have already been thrown in the trash. The only good thing about our meal was the waitress and the Coke. Not happy this time. We will be taking a break from Lil Nicks for a while. read more

Ordered delivery for the first time, really underwhelming. Wings were soggy and tough, tasted frozen. Pizza had a lot of toppings, but not enough sauce and the dough tasted chewy and old, also probably frozen. Would not order again. read more

Worst pizza ever purchased save your money! The pasta (fettuccine Alfredo) sounded great homemade sauce no! Just bland tasteless and everything for my order seemed under cooked. read more

Ordered a large for my girlfriend and her grandparents. They brought us a small. The Sunday waitress would only bring us another small to fix it-- but charged us for both smalls, which costs way more than a large. She was rude about it too. read more

I've had two pizza'a from Lil Nick's. If I had reviewed after the 1st pizza they would have 5 stars but the pizza I ordered today was a 1 Star. It was so soggy it was wet. Soggiest crust I have ever had. I had one bite and threw the entire $24 pizza away. DO NOT ORDER the Lucky 7. It was terrible. The 1st pizza was the Guido, that was great. They only get 3 stars because the Lucky 7 pizza was so bad. read more

Terrible don't waste your time or $$ the garlic knots are just dinner rolls no garlic flavor or anything!!! The cheese tasted funny in the Stromboli I do not recommend!!!! read more

I took my first girlfriend here on a date in 1986, we were horrified at the service and quality of food. Flash forward 33 years later. I thought I'd give them another chance, but I wish I had gone elsewhere. Terrible service, bland food, flat soda. The fries that came with my dry tasteless sandwich were very tasty however. I wish the waitress would've brought me some catsup as I requested, but she didn't hear me as she dropped the plate on my table and ran away and never checked on me again. read more

I've loved this place for years! The freshest tastiest salads, amazing soup, the pizza is perfection (I always eat way too much), and the fries are the best ever. I love the family that runs this place. The bar area is welcoming and the perfect place to unwind with a glass of wine. read more

The pizza was pretty good. The salad had slimy bell peppers and I didn't eat it. The eggplant Parmesan literally tasted like it had been sitting in the package. It had a weird metal taste. read more

I haven't eaten here but they allow anti-maskers and the front of house lady wears her mask on her chin. I work as a DoorDash driver and this puts my safety at jeopardy considering I visit many locations read more

Very bad pizza undercooked chewy dough would not order again didn't even eat 2 pieces of the large

The pizza was great. We had fast service. Jake was great! Found this place thru Waze app. Great recommendation

I've always wanted to try this little pizza shop and my hubs and I were walking around that area and decide ..what the heck!! So we go in and we were sat at a round table by the bartender / waitress. She turns the game up (go Broncos) and gives us menus .. We are not on our diet and go with the fettuccini and calzone ! She brings us a side salad with these dough knots... I have to say the salad was so good..maybe it was the crisp lettuce or the croutons ..or both!! Yum The knots were delicious as well.. I mean by now I'm stuffed and then our dinners come ..lol My calzone was good and his fettuccini was even better ... I was sooo full and happy ! I mean I've read the other reviews and at least this time we didn't experience what they did .. So for now I give this place 4 stars ..id give it 5 but the place was kinda run down and out dated ..I mean I guess that doesn't mean too much but ambiance is kinda important ...Any way I had a good time - Next time I want to eat 5000 calories in one sitting I'll be back ! Thanks read more

See all