Lisa's been our local favorite for decades and decades. The new owners are making some changes but the pizza remains excellent. Gone is the old jukebox box and instead we get an incredible playlist of tunes from the 40's, and 50's. Craft cocktails are being added to the mix. Things are still shaking out but I'm thinking this is all going to be great. read more

Been here a few times now. After tonight, I don't know if I'd return. We stopped at Lisa's before catching a show. We had about an hour and a half to kill and we figured we had plenty of time. Boy was I wrong. We didn't get menus for 20 minutes, our salads didn't come for 30 minutes. And at the 45 minute mark when our appetizer still hadn't come, we started to get a little worried. The waiter came back to tell us our appetizer was almost ready and we asked him how much longer we should expect to wait as we didn't have a lot of time. And he responded with what was perhaps the rudest thing a waiter has ever said to me, "You know - I've worked here a long time and I'm not used to people being so impatient." He then went on to rant about how there's only 4 people in the kitchen and this is a "family" business blah blah blah. Meanwhile, I look around the restaurant and there are only 5 other tables seated and maybe one or two people came in for carry out. From there, I think he recognized he had crossed a line and offered to comp our appetizer and offered us a free drink. However, after 1 hour 15 minutes, our pizza finally came and we had to box it up and take it to go as we had run out of time. Look, I understand restaurants are a bit slower post Covid with the staffing shortage. But waiting an hour+ for a pizza seemed a little excessive and when we simply asked how long it would be for our food to come out, we would have appreciated a little less attitude. Still give them 3 stars as the food that we were able to eat was pretty tasty. read more

The "new" Lisa's just doesn't live up to what it used to be. Not sure what the new owners are doing here. They seem to have a huge employee turnover which leaves them short staffed with slow service and mediocre food. The pizza is not the same as it used to be and the prices have gone up. read more

Very slow delivery & not great pizza. delivery took an hour and 20 minutes & pizza arrived cold. Just a hard pass for me.

First time ordering since the new ownership Pizza is still delicious! Dinner salad is generous for $6 Happy Lisa's is back! read more

Hello, this is Dominic the food reviewer. Yesterday I reviewed a restaurant called Lisa's Pizzaria Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge. It is located on 2961 N. Oakland Ave in Milwaukee WI. What I thought was cool about the decor was that they had Christmas lights and old clocks inside. I thought our waitress was nice and kind to us. I shared a thin crust pizza with my mom. On my half of the pizza I got ground beef, black olives, and tomatoes. It was a really good thin crust pizza with sweet Italian sauce and it tasted fresh. My dad got their spaghetti & meatballs and tomato sauce. My dad liked the angel hair pasta and the meatballs. He thought it was delicious. My mom just got the sausage on her half of the pizza. She thought her pizza was very good and liked the sweet tasting sauce as well. If you like thin crust pizza this restaurant is worth trying. Thank you for reading my review today. read more

See all

Really happy we found our way to this spot last night. It's cozy but not crowded. Good wine and beer selections! The pizza is definitely where it's at. The atmosphere was like an Italian hug. (And I'm 50% by heritage.) Next t read more

Excellent service from our server Steelie. Food was delicious and wait time was reasonable considering they were busy. Place is clean and cozy. Can't wait to return. read more

Ordered delivery, an extra large "special" for three hungry guys. Placed order at 7:33 pm by phone with debit card including tip. Unfortunately pizza delivery arrived at 10:12 pm. By then, pizza was lopsided and cold. Spoke to management and they were fantastic. We got together the next night and ordered the same pizza. Everything was exceptional. They even use fresh grated Parm not fake parm. Delivery driver was on time, pizza was hot and intact. Love their sauce and fresh mushrooms. It is exceptional for pizza sauce and produce. Will order again. Thanks Lisa's! Brought back memories o eating Lisa's pizza after playing Friday night high school football read more

We heard great things about Lisa's Pizzeria and we were not disappointed. We got The Special, cheesy bread, and their chocolate cheesecake. All of it was delicious. We really enjoyed the thin crust and the sauce on the pizza. They had it 20 minutes after I ordered and it was ready for pick up. Over all great service and will be returning. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - The Special - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Very good pizza and very friendly staff . My order is always prepared to perfection. Lisa's gets it wall the time.

A friend reminded me about this place when I was craving pizza. I was thinking old-school, not too trendy or crazy with the topping combinations. It was after work, so I was also thinking close to home if possible. Lisa's hit the spot. The interior is quiet and even kind of subdued. There were quite a few couples and small groups enjoying their private conversations both times I've been. I've gotten a small pizza and eaten it by myself before. It's about the right amount for one hungry person. But this time I took the advice of other reviewers and got a large (veggie) and just took some home. Pizza keeps well, and this is the kind of thin-but-not-too-thin crust pizza that seems to make especially good leftovers. I said there weren't too many crazy topping combinations, but Lisa's does offer some offbeat toppings like tuna, shrimp, and broccoli. Most of the pizza offerings are single toppings or basic combos but others are available as add ons. It's not necessary to get too complex. But I did try a tuna pizza once. It's better than it sounds. Other dishes sound good also. Most of the other diners on my visits have stuck to pizza. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Veggie. Large really is best. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Good pizza... thin and crispy with a good amount of sauce. They use fresh mushrooms and fennel in the sausage. I loved the cheesy garlic bread. The bread is phenomenal! I went on Saturday night and no problem with getting a table and great service. I will definitely be back soon! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Cheesy garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Best pizza in town!!!!! Simply delicious!!!!! Great sauce!! Thin crust!! Ohhhh. It's. Soooo Goood!!! read more

Stopped in with my brothers last night. What a treat for us to revisit after 30 + years. Food was just as good as we remembered. Service was great. At one point it was just us and 2 of the wives. (NCAA final four was on) so pretty empty. We were able to chat with the 2 servers and the owner. I did notice a lot of take out business, to me that's always a good sign. I know we will be back. Had a great time and great food. read more

Well. Just trying to order and or use the coupons just the worst Svc. Then I called and I'm on hold now as I complete this review. Maybe I should cancel the order ?!!!is it covid excuse. Do they even know how to do this. So the person picking up the phone tried to ask others. I think they need more 420. Nice about the problems w orders. Apologized. Mrs T desperate for entertainment read more

All I can say is very disappointed. I ordered a pizza and the toppings were very skimmpy. There were only 2 other people in the the restaurant. Slow service and pizza was barely warm. Will not be going back there. Too many other pizza places that are way better. read more

We used to go to Lisa's all the time pre-COVID, tonight was our first time back since the new ownership. We were really excited to go back after reading that the new owners kept the pizza recipe from the previous owners. It was always a favorite. Unfortunately, if that is the same recipe, the new chef is not up to the challenge. The garlic bread was quite good - different from the past - but very good! Pizza - it was just okay at best. Very sparse toppings and, the biggest issue, a very soggy, under-cooked crust. I literally could not pick up a piece of pizza, the crust was that soggy. It just fell apart in my hands. The staff was very nice and attentive, but the food is just okay...nothing more. Really disappointed! I truly hope the new owners can make a go of it...but I doubt that we will be going back anytime soon. read more

This pizza is just OK. I wouldn't rave about it by any means but I also thought it was decent. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Lisa's is an Eastside staple, and offers a very popular pizza that I've enjoyed since my teen years. You'll usually walk into a quite dining room during the week, and there may not be anyone to greet you, but hang tight. Their likely in the kitchen and will be out eventually. Pizzas are served on thin crust. The sauce is thick and slightly sweet and delicious. The crust is crisp around the edge, but soft and floppy everywhere else, so plan to fold your slices or use two hands when eating them. Slices are cut into rectangles. The pepperoni could be spicier but it's really good, and the chunks of Italian sausage are large and juicy. It's one of the best tasting thin crust pizzas in town, IMHO, so pay them a visit if you like that style of pizza. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Best pizza in Milwaukee. Cracker crust, great sauce and toppings! Have been going here for 15 years and have never had a bad meal.

I have been wanting to try Lisa's for a while and finally got pizza to go tonight. The pizza was delicious!!! I love the thin crust and the sweet Italian sauce. We also ordered garlic bread that was ok. Nothing wrong with it ....just ok. I would recommend their pizza for sure! If you are looking for thin crust this is the best I have had in the MKE area. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Sorry about the half pie! Decided to take a pic after we dug in - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The pizza was excellent! We ordered Hannah's Favorite, The Pesto Veggie, The Super, and the Detroit infused with Pabst Blue Ribbon beer! The crust was crispy and the flavor combinations-super tasty. Service was excellent! Make sure you leave room for dessert! Tiramisu and Chocolate Cake are homemade by the new owner! read more

Lisa's pizzeria has been one of my favorites since the late 1980s. I had a chance to go there again this past weekend and my expectations were not disappointed. I love there thin crust pizza with a wonderful tangy sauce. The service is always been warm and friendly with a small cozy atmosphere of their dining room. read more

So happy to hear Lisa's reopened! Gave it a shot with the new owners and I'm really pleased much of the menu from the Bongiorno family is being carried on. Such a staple in our community. read more

Under new ownership but still top notch pizza. Brighter and warmer inside than before. Mini donuts for desert to die for.

Thank you Lisa's for a great meal tonight! Awesome appetizers, salads, pizza & desserts. We were stuffed before heading to the Brewers game tonight. We appreciated the wonderful hospitality & conversation too. PS MKE - Lisa's is currently in the top 5 for "Best Of Milwaukee County" Pizza category via MJS. Voting is open for a few more days. read more

Awesome food, great service and best pizza in Milwaukee!! I've been coming here for years and have always had a great experience!!

I went here for the first time with my family the other night. Hannah's favorite was also ((our)) favorite. Our server was so sweet and attentive. I found them on IG and like that the new owners are doing a mix of classic and new pizza combos. Will definitely be coming back! read more

We were very happy to see Lisa's Pizza on Oakland Avenue reopen. Advice to the new owners, get your act together before you close. What a disappointment, an embarrassment that you allow that quality of food to leave your establishment! read more

New owners same fabulous food! Got our pizza to go. My husband did pick up he had to wait a bit but everyone was professional and friendly. Will definitely have to try something new off the menu. We will be back for sure. Keep up the good work read more

Learned of this spot in my college days. The recent visit was yummy and a little nostalgic. The thin crust pizza is very very delicious as was the eggplant fries - just as I remembered, a very nice visit - will dine in again soon. read more

Had 5 different pizzas and all were amazing. Also had the homemade Tiramisu and chocolate cake that were out of this world. I would definitely recommend Lisa's Pizza and will be returning in the very near future read more

My favorite pizza. My wife and I have gone to Lisa's for 30 years, since our days at UWM. We (and now our kids) drive up from Illinois just for the pizza. I wish they would have kept the little pepperoni on the Super, but it's still the best Pizza! read more

Great pizza , what I order and it seems never to disappoint is the extra large pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onion, mushroom, extra mushroom, pizza. It's like you died and went to heaven. The key to Lisa's is to get it while it's hot. If you order for pick up and they say 30 minutes, be there in 20 . That way you will get it fresh out the oven. If you love thin crust pizza it's the best. I don't know Lisa's secrets , but I believe I detect a small amount of virgin olive oil in the cracker crust. If you are a pizza connoisseur like I am, you will pick up on that. If you have tried a lot of pizza and are now ready for a different ride. Try Lisa's. read more

The order took 1 1/2 hours. It was cold and undercooked. It was tasteless. It was one of the worst Pizzas I've ever had delivered in my life. Avoid this place like the plaque. read more

The Special is one of the best Za's in Milwaukee Caradero Club, Palermos the "special" is Milwaukee food at its best read more

Found open, which is unusual d/t poor staffing or other reasons. We were only ones there, 1.5 hours prior to closing. Staff complaining in back room that we were there and that we were eating 'too slow'. Not welcoming environment. Will not go back again. I can get thin crust pizza anywhere. read more

A nice cozy place to visit on a Friday night for dinner. We ordered breads mushrooms to start. They were fresh, easy to bite into and it at all mushy - a common mishap of the breaded mushroom. We also ordered a 14" SMO and it was good. It could have been a bit more crispy for my liking but it still hit the spot and reheated well the next day. If we find ourselves on the east side crazing pizza, we'll return. read more

Lisa's actual pizza: 5 stars Thin crust, a delicious, robust, slightly sweet sauce, and the right amount of cheese. (I generally avoid the mushrooms b/c they're canned.) Sausage/pepp/olives/onions/green pepper. (Or pepperoni + banana peppers if I'm feeling a little weird.) Their apps, not so much. But the pizza... my heavens, that pizza. Lisa's is a delivery go-to for me, and we go to it more than I'd like to admit. Turn on your Netflix-bot and get down with some House of Cards and some Lisa's pizza with your bad self, Milwaukee. read more