Lisa's actual pizza: 5 stars Thin crust, a delicious, robust, slightly sweet sauce, and the right amount of cheese. (I generally avoid the mushrooms b/c they're canned.) Sausage/pepp/olives/onions/green pepper. (Or pepperoni + banana peppers if I'm feeling a little weird.) Their apps, not so much. But the pizza... my heavens, that pizza. Lisa's is a delivery go-to for me, and we go to it more than I'd like to admit. Turn on your Netflix-bot and get down with some House of Cards and some Lisa's pizza with your bad self, Milwaukee. read more

Solid. Is Lisa's the best thin crust ever? No (that would be Wells Brothers), but it's absolutely very good. Pluses: + Really, really, really good Italian sausage + Nice thin, crunchy crust and not greasy (if you are my husband, you'd say that last part is a minus) + Fresh mushrooms, not slimy canned ones + Wonderfully crispy eggplant strips - again, not greasy or oily + Good sauce - not too sweet Minuses: - Wine is fairly overpriced at $8-10 for a teeny glass - They have a jukebox. You don't know "hell" until some jagoff gives a 9-year old a $5 and lets them go on a quest to play the Worst Music Ever. From "Call me maybe" to Peter, Paul and Mary (WTF, man?) they absolutely succeeded. All we were missing was the Eagles. - Service wasn't great despite only half the tables being full. She was super sweet, just a little out of her element. Overall, I liked Lisa's better than the other Eastside stalwart, Zaffiros. I wouldn't necessarily drive across town but I'd happily go if someone wanted to. read more

Really good Old School, laid back, neighborhood establishment. Classic Milwaukee thin crust pizza cut in squares. Excellent house-made sausage. Lakefront IPA on tap. read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Small sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Average in just about every way, except for our nice waitress ... whose name I sadly don't know. And except for the beer, which is priced way high, and where the selection is oh so poor. We're sticking with Ian's on North. Still the best pizza and vibe on the East Side, bar none. read more

Lisa's is the best delivery pizza on the east side. Lisa's is the best sit down, relax, and enjoy pizza in a cozy atmosphere type place on the east side. Lisa's Is the best carry-out/ pick-up pizza on the east side. Bottom line... Lisa's Is by far the best tasting thin crust pizza on the east side. Their garlic bread, calamari, and even their juke box are fantastic. If dining in, be sure to pay attention to the parking signs and regulations as they seem to change every few feet... don't let a parking ticket ruin a great dining experience. Lisa's is a Milwaukee classic and one of the only pizza places you could go to each week and still will love it as much as you did your first time. p.s. The thin crust sausage pizza is the best. read more

Social distancing was great. Pizza was really good. Our garlic bread as just French bread with butter andantes sprinkle garlic powder which was underwhelming and basically just buttered toast read more

This is hands down my favorite pizza place in the area. Small mom & pop operation that has been in business forever. It's my go to pizza anytime I order. Always perfect crust, toppings and sauce. If you like old school quality and are not into prefabricated food, give them a try. read more

My FAVORITE Pizza place! I usually get the X lg Pizza Supreme and the combo platter. I love their thin crust and pizza sauce, fresh mushrooms, and great sausage. Their combo platter consists of breaded mushrooms, cauliflower, and eggplant, served with delicious marina sauce. Also their juke box has a great selection of classic Rock! A slice of heaven after a hard day at work and a great place to meet out friends. read more

This is our favorite pizza place. My girl friend practically lives on their pizza. We are regulars. There is just no pizza that compares. We have eaten a lot of pizza in Milwaukee and this is the best we've had. read more

A group of friends and I went to Lisa's tonight and had a nice get together after not seeing each other for awhile. We ordered several drinks, an XL, a L, and a small pizza, as well as a few pitchers of beer. The bill was close to $300. A double shot cocktail cost $18 per drink. This is NOT Chicago, Las Vegas, or a city that thinks they can charge this amount. I understand restaurants are trying to get back money from their losses from the COVID travesty, but this is a disgusting example of taking advantage of people under the guise of COVID. The pizza was Outstanding this evening, don't get me wrong, but I'm completely disgusted with this overpricing of their drink charges. I will not be visiting their establishment again any time soon. I do appreciate the waiter being so understanding with our disgust when we mentioned our unhappiness with our bill. read more

Fantastic thin crust pizza originally recommended to me by an old work friend who grew up in the area. If I don't have plans with customers at a steakhouse, my go to is Lisa's. read more

Super awesome pizza so had pizza in Chicago and I highly recommend Lisa's pizzeria over Chicago. Good quality fresh superthin.

I enjoyed it! Prior to ordering I heard great things and one snowy day my fiancé and I were cravIng pizza and decided to order. We weren't disappointed. We will definitely be revisiting and trying what else they have to offer. read more

We did delivery to a local hotel while visiting the area. $20 for the smallest sausage, onion, cheese delivered pizza I've seen. We were starving and devoured it. Tasted ok. After all the reviews I was expecting something better than Dominos but not by much read more

Absolutely delicious pizza, from the crust to the sauce and the toppings, cannot be beat! 5 big stars!

I love Lisa's pizza and have been meeting my brother there for dinner for many years. last night we got there at 5 to find the doors locked. This is not the first time this had happened. I checked their answering machine message before leaving home and the message said they were open Tuesday- Saturday at 4. How hard is it to change the message on your answering machine if you are not open for whatever reason? There were other people waiting at the door who were looking just as angry as I felt. i know this is not an easy time to run a business with staffing shortages but at least make an effort to keep your loyal customers informed read more

I ordered from Lisa's tonight (9/2/2018) for the first time, the pizza was OK. Actually, it wasn't it was sooooo flimsy. Like, I had to eat it with a fork because you couldn't hold the piece without falling apart. The garlic bread did not come with marinara or anything which isn't the end of the world, but I would have preferred they told me ahead of time so I could order a side sauce. read more

I once thought that Zaffiro's had the best pizza in town. No longer. That title now belongs to Lisa's Fine Foods (which, bizarrely enough, everyone just calls Lisa's Pizza). I've lived in Milwaukee for twenty years and only recently discovered it. For shame. How good is it? Let's just say that I've gone three times over the past week. A few things I've realized in comparing Lisa's to Zaffiro's: 1) I prefer thin crust over cracker crust. 2) A little sweetness in the pizza sauce really makes a difference. 3) Crispy bacon on a pizza, along with sausage and onions, is the greatest thing ever. 4) Lisa's has a better wine list. I heard good things about their other foods, so I look forward to trying their lasagna and ravioli in the future. Being in close proximity to Chicago, Milwaukee gets the bum rap as their pizza establishments are overlooked. But let's be serious, does anyone REALLY like deep dish pizza? It's awful. The crust is barely noticeable, so you're basically eating a hunk of melted cheese with some pizza sauce somewhere in there along with some toppings. No thanks. I'll take Lisa's, Zaffiro's, and Fratteli's anyday over Uno, Home Run Inn, and Giordano's. /rant Seriously, eat here. read more

The perfect dive pizza place on Milwaukee's Eastside. Be sure to bring along some singles for the juxebox. But be warned there is no place to dance, just sit back down and enjoy your cheap drinks and delicious pizza. read more

Ate here this weekend with my boyfriend and his dad. Dining at Lisa's is an experience, and if I were to order food from here again, it would most likely be takeout. Here's why. Our waitress took about ten minutes to greet us after we sat down. I used to be a waitress, and where I worked, this is unacceptable. When she came up to us, she said, "Thanks for waiting for me." Of course we waited, we're freaking hungry! However, she was polite, so I can't give her too hard of a time. So anyway, we got our diet cokes (NO free refills - such a bummer). We ordered kalamari and italian salad for our appetizers. The kalamari was unlike anything I'd seen before. It came out in the shape of onion rings and was very chewy. The salad was doused in oil to the point of no return. I was actually pretty unhappy with the apps, but ate them anyway due to starvation. We ordered an extra large thin crust pizza - the deluxe, I believe. Basically it's a supreme pizza. This was actually delicious. It was warm, crispy, and gooey all at the same time. Everything I look for in a pizza. This is why I would lean towards takeout next time. Overall, the place is a little dingy and outdated, but it is a decent place to go if you find yourself in that area. I probably won't be back to Lisa's anytime soon, but I may call them for delivery during a future hunger meltdown. read more

Admittedly, I have not eaten here but I have done my fair share of take out/ordering from Lisa's Pizza (or Lisa's Fine Foods). Let me start with my critique - it's expensive for pizza. Yes, you could easily get a $12 Large somewhere else, but that's just it, it's somewhere else that is likely a chain, cut half hazardly, and tastes mediocre. This is where the few dollar difference with Lisa's matters. First, always order with a coupon. They have $2.00 off Large and Extra large pizza coupons in your money mailer, East Side Magazine, and even online. You have to have the coupon though, can't just show up without it. Second, get the extra large. If you have two hungry adults, you could easily finish the Large and want an appetizer or dessert. If you get the extra large, it insures a midnight snack or lunch for the next day. I would say 2 people for a Large, 3 people with less than average appetites for an extra Large. And lastly, my winning combination. Try it and comment because frankly, this is my go to order: Extra Large Pizza Pepperoni Garlic Basil Tomatoes Now my mouth is watering... read more

I've been going to this place for years and years and it has never disappointed. Whenever I go I always get thin crust loaded with toppings. The pizza comes out as squares, and as it is so full of toppings I have to accept the fact that I'll get a little messy or just eat it with a fork. But it is real-deal pizza with super delicious sauce and perfect sausage. It's a pizza joint where you get an extra-large for hoping for leftovers yet all too often see the whole thing disappear before you can help yourself. If you do have leftovers it saves really well. In fact, it saves so well that I've gotten pizza from there just to let it sit in the fridge and let the great flavor of the sauce soak in so I can enjoy that fantastic cold pizza flavor the next day. They place itself looks like a total dive bar from the outside (normally a good sign for a pizza joint) but the inside looks nothing like a dive bar and is pretty charming with quite a few tables and even a jukebox. read more

When I lived on the East Side, Lisa's always seemed like an underrated gem. When I would mention it to people, it was rare that somebody would know what I was talking about. A co-worker got me thinking about Lisa's again recently, and although it's been awhile since I've been there, I think it's still one of the more enjoyable pizza experiences I've had in Milwaukee. The sauce is really great. I like a heavy, hearty sauce, and that's exactly what Lisa's does well. The crust is some of the best thin-crust I've ever had. The topping options are all classics. I've never done delivery or takeout. I always ate in. It's a weird place, you have to climb a tall flight of stairs, but you settle in quickly. It's always been very home-y in Lisa's, and the staff was always very friendly. The cold pizza you're left with the next day makes for some of the best leftover pizza around, too. It's even better after a night in the fridge. read more

Ok foodies... prepare to have your elastic slacks let out once again. Lisa's has been doing, and doing it well (Thanks LL Cool J) forever. I think the first time Moses went there he was like "Holy Fuck! Shut the front door. This is my kinda joint". In standard Milwaukee tradition of that awesome cracker thin crust Lisa's delivers. Seriously, they actaully deliver. A touch on the highside for price, but hey it's Shorewood! 91 peperronis out of a 100. read more

I have just finished eating my first and last meal from Lisa's. On a Monday night, I've had a tough day and have a craving for breaded mushrooms. Thinking of Pizza Man first, I find they are closed Mondays and search for an alternative. I remember Lisa's and the good things I had read about it, and decide to take the plunge. One order of breaded mushrooms, one of onion rings, and a large (14") artichoke and black olive pizza. Ready in 20 minutes, they say, and $29. I get there in 25 minutes to pick up the order, drive 5 minutes back home. Open the onion rings. There are seven of them. Take a bite. Stale. Cold. Mushy and hard at the same time. Just... Terrible. Open the mushrooms. Exact same stale, disgusting breading. Dipping sauce is ok. Finally, the pizza. Mush. Lukewarm mush. Mediocre taste at very best. I really, really wanted to love this place. The man who took our order and the waitress were just lovely. Very cozy inside, completely charming. But this food completely ruined my night. I feel robbed. read more

Lisa's was recommended by several coworkers, claiming that it is the best pizza in Milwaukee. The place looks like a house and the decor is very 1980's grandma style. The walls are decorated with a barrage of strange clocks. The dining area is very small... Probably 15 tables. The place was packed with families, and it reminded me of old school Italian restaurants I used to go to as a kid on the east coast. Not a bad vibe, but just maybe like you're dining at your friend's grandma's house on Long Island. Service sucked! Two stressed waitresses dashing about the place is not the way to go. The pizza had a thin cracker crust which was very crispy. If that's your type of pizza, come to Lisa's. I was looking forward to a New York style pizza. Sauce and cheese were very flavorful, but the crust was bland. Wouldn't come here again.. Will go to Zaffiros for their tastier pies. read more

Had a sausage, black olive and onion pizza delivered to the Hilton on Milwaukee River.. It arrived nice and hot and smelled delicious. The ingredients tasted great and the crust was the right balance of thin, crunchy and supportive. The only quirk was that they forgot to cut the pizza! It was still great. I wouldn't say it's the best pizza I've ever had, but it certainly was a cut above the normal. Would have it again! read more

Pizza is always great. Fries are never good at all but that's fine. It's fries from a pizza place. I use to order them a lot when I lived closed by. That was about 4 years ago. Ordered them again yesterday. The biggest issue I have with them is they make you print their coupon online. I ordered 2 xtra large pizzas with lots of toppings. 40 some dollars worth of pizza and you won't give me the dollar off because you need the coupon printed from their website. Just annoying. Otherwise great service. read more

Lisa's can still stand out amongst all the pizza places on Oakland Ave. Whether you have dinner in their small but inviting restaurant or ordering delivery, you wont be disappointed. The wait staff is excellent and seems more like a family. When I have dinner there I always go for the lasagna! Comes with bread and a side salad! They baked the lasagna on the dish! Not cut from a large pan and reheated! I Love Lisa's pizza! Perfect thin crust, sauce on point but I would like to have more toppings... We always order extra pepperoni. A definite staple on my beloved Eastside! read more

Love this pizza. I would say best pizza in Milwaukee. It competes with the NYC pizzas. I have only got this as delivery or take out so don't know about sitting in the place but the pizza is super thin crust and has an amazing sauce that is so flavorful. The sausage they use on the pizza is very good as well and highly recommend this pizza as it is the best on the Eastside. read more

Continuing my quest for best Milwaukee pizza we stop in at Lisa's. There is ample seating in this dimly lit pizza joint. There are also plenty of options for your toppings. There is your usual fare of cheese, sausage, mushroom, etc. But I believe i saw items like shrimp and tuna on the menu. That's a nice way to mix it up for others...not me ;) I have a standard I like to order to taste test pizzas for comparison purposes. Cheese, Sausage, Pepperoni and Onion. Because Lisa's offers a bigger x-large pizza we did half with minced garlic. The crust is a little bit thicker then a super thin crust pizza. Don't be confused this is still a thin crust but I have had thinner. The little extra actually goes a long way in offering stability. The sauce, cheese and toppings often times can leave a crust soggy and flimsy. This retained it's crunch and strength only slightly buckling under heavier loaded center pieces. The crust was great. The toppings were good and the garlic wasn't as strong as i anticipated. The sauce kept me thinking throughout the night. It's almost like it needed something for me personally. When i tasted it by itself I could feel something was missing. Don't get me wrong though because the sauce was good but I would have loved a little bit of a bite. I found this to be a bit mellow. I found myself wanting to squirt lemon juice on the sauce. (Don't judge me) The pizza was perfectly finished with a nice slight golden brown beginning on the top. The edges of some pepperoni were crisping up nicely. It was served piping hot at our table. An extra large pizza is a rather large pizza for a table of two. If it hand one of those stands to sit on where we could position other things under it that would solve the problem of the table feeling slightly cluttered. The service was good. I feel the waitress really balanced all the customers well. Granted it wasn't super busy but I noticed that she checked in with people in a timely fashion, had a great personal interaction and really just did a great job. I was pleased about that. I never once had a lull where i was waiting too long for something (drinks, check). The menu was bigger than I anticipated with a variety of other options. Fish Fry, Fried chicken, Lasagna, etc. That easily makes it worth coming back to. We got a good amount for our money and I would definitely recommend this establishment for pizza. read more

Lisa's Pizza is about 12 times better than Zaffiro's. That being said, it wasn't the best pizza I've had in the last month, but it's among the best I've had in Milwaukee. The garlic cheese bread could have been better, it seems like one bite pulled the entire shell of cheese off.....but it was light years ahead of Zaffiro's. We ordered a thick crust pepperoni pizza, the crust was really good, the cheese and pepperoni were spot on, but the sauce had a bit of a funk to it. Not sure exactly what it was....but it just tasted off. Later in the day, it turned out to be one of the best cold pizzas I've ever had....so there's that. read more

I really wish that Pizza Man delivered but I had heard pretty good things about Lisa's so I thought I'd give them a try. I looked at the online menu and the veggie pizza had mushrooms, green peppers and black olives. That combination is a little outdated and a lot of places now have a few combo pizza's that are more unique. But I ordered it and added artichokes for an extra $2.50 (I think). I also knew I had garlic at home, pineapple, and jalapeno slices, oregano, and red chili pepper flakes that I could add when I reheated the slices in the toaster oven. Delivery service was quick and friendly. I opened the box and was pleasantly surprised about the quantity of toppings. Sometimes they are sparse (a disappointment). It seems like the technique that they used was to chop up all of the veggies together and then disperse them in smaller bits ... that meant you got all the flavors in one bite. So, a nice technique. What was also nice is that they insert this mesh square below the pizza which keeps the pizza from sticking to the cardboard which can be an issue because of moisture or steam. I liked the crust which reminded me of a big matzo cracker; both flavor and texture. The sauce was the right amount and had a sweetness to it which I liked. My ONLY problem with Pizza Man is that I don't think they use enough sauce, so I need to remind myself to ask for extra. I have had some stellar pizza's in my life and I would consider Lisa's just average. Pizza Man is still the winner and Classic Slice probably second place in Milwaukee. I've also had one of the best pizza's in my life at a restaurant in Santa Fe, and another in Playa del Carmen. I did not go inside Lisa's because I ordered delivery, but it probably suits the outdatedness of the pizza. Some people might find that that suits them, but I prefer innovative creations, and especially wood fired pies. I can enjoy a dive or someplace old fashion once-and-a-while as a novelty, but not usually for food, just drinks. read more

Ordered pizza for delivery last Friday night. (The ordering process over the phone turned into quite the long ordeal, but that's an entirely different story). Pizza got there within the promised amount of time, which was good. HOWEVER, we don't live that far away from Lisa's & the pizza was definitely not hot when it got to us, which was super disappointing. Also, the "large" is the smallest large I've ever seen in my life. The 2 of us devoured it and were still hungry. The flavor was good, but who wants cold pizza delivered to them? Helpful hint: get the biggest size you can if there's more than just 1 person eating it! read more

I came here this past weekend for dinner. Our coach grew up in the area and always brings the team here. It is on the northside of Milwaukee, and is fairly easy to get to. The atmosphere is great, very old school, very italian feel with the light music and dim lighting. We started off with a side salad, nothing special, but their homemade italian dressing was delicious. We got an order of the fried eggplant, which I thought was fairly tasty, however I wish the pieces of eggplant were a little larger, sometimes thinking I was eating just breading. The pizza was what I was here for. Man oh man it was good. They cut it in smaller squares which I liked, and the sauce was just a little sweet. I don't usually go to places with a sweet sauce so this was a nice surprise. The pepperoni and housemade italian sausage was something I would recommend to everyone. If I am ever in the area I will definitely be coming back. read more

Best pizza I've ever had, literally. I crave it so much that I almost demand it when back in Milwaukee. Delivery is awesome and a family tradition but Lisa's Pizza must also be experienced in their homey little dining room. The garlic cheese bread is delicious. I played "Revolution 9" on the jukebox just for kicks. The sausage, mushroom and onion pizza is fantastic and Lisa's is the pizza to which I compare all others. Authentic, no-frills, tasty great food. A landmark on the East Side. read more

Why Lisa, why is your pizza so good? Crust is just so, crispy good and the sauce, well my dear, taste better than mama use to make. Everybody is so nice, shucks it is like a little village. My man thinks your pasta is the best ever. Love you Lisa, see you again soon. Hearts read more

I've been craving Lisa's pizza for weeks even though I hadn't had it in a few years. A group of five of us stopped in last night for dinner around 9pm. Here are the pluses: 1. Pizza is as good or even better than I remember: thin crust (not cracker), slightly sweet sauce w/o being too sweet, excellent sausage, lots of toppings) 2. Decent beer and wine lists 3. Crispy, not mushy eggplant fries 4. Reasonable prices ($85 for an extra large pizza, a combo appetizer basket, 7 beers & 2 whiskey drinks) 5. Very nice and personable server 6. Cozy atmosphere Here are the couple of minuses: 1. Our server was very welcoming, but the other servers were clearly cleaning up even though it was still over 1.5 hours until close 2. Poor juke box selection (not a huge deal, but it's eerily quiet without the music and our server encouraged us to play some tunes) read more

Why do restaurants insist on keeping single stall bathrooms gendered??? It's out of date, inappropriate and pointless. The pizza's okay here, but a waittress essentially policed my date's gender by correcting the bathroom they were walking towards. We are *not* returning. read more

I've always considered lisa's pizza as the best in the city. the perfect thin crust squares. my favorite is the pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion and black olive pizza, with a side of anchovies. the jukebox is awesome, with a selection that ranges from journey to frank sinatra to bb king to the isley brothers. I highly recommend lisa's pizza to anyone! eat and enjoy! read more

Lisa's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all