The food itself I would give 4 stars, the pizza was good. The vibe inside with the decor and hometown pride was really cool. But the experience as a whole left things to be desired. We ordered for dine in, we were told to get our own cups from this little bar area. However every cup had a nasty smell like it was stacked while wet and had black dots on and specks of things (mold maybe?) I asked the girl working the counter and she gave me some styrofoam after I told her the cups were dirty. No problem. Our pizza came out with the wrong toppings at first which was fine- We waited and they corrected it. What I couldn't get over though was the absolutely filthy plates. The plates again on this bar thing were self serve and I don't think had been cleaned at all and if they were the dishwasher needs to be retrained on sanitary rules and food safety. The stacks had old food stuck to the bottom of nearly every plate. I know this because I sifted through to try to find ones that would work for my little family. I couldn't find any that I felt comfortable eating off of, and I got the impression they weren't really washed. I began to feel annoying to our waitress "Addison" because I again brought up something.. and now the plates were gross. Addison - who in general was very kind and doing the best she could. She explained to us they are short staffed and that the boys in the back weren't doing a good job washing. She personally took 4 plates for us and washed them- which I really appreciated. The table behind us though - not even five minutes later I watched her serve with the dirty cups and plates. That grossed me out so much especially after I had just told her about the cleanliness. It took all I could do to not say something to the table - but my husband said not to cause a stir.. I'm telling you - I'm a person who isn't afraid of a little dirt. This was UN CLEAN. I'm rating it 2, not to be a jerk- because the food was pretty good - but because the cleanliness needs be addressed. read more

See all

Long Branch Pizza in Centerburg It always smells so good when we go by and now I know why!!! Holy cow!!!!! Phenomenal is what it is!!! We got the Bosco Sticks (cheese stuffed breadsticks) and the Supreme Pizza (Pepp, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers) It was fantastic, delicious, didn't want to stop eating, mouth said more, tummy said don't do it read more

Long Branch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerburg, Ohio

New owners continue to make tasty pizza. Our go to is the Supreme or the Big Cheese with pepperoni added. We pick ours up but that's because we live close by. The inside is unique and open so you can dine in. read more

Some of the best pizza around!! Just wondering what's up with the dining/bar area?? Looks great but doesn't appear to be used? read more

Yeah, It's some really good pizza. I'll touch on that in a second. Clean place!! Great service!! Really good atmosphere!! 12" pizza, pepperoni, Sausage and Banana Peppers was my order. Couple drafts beers. frosted pint glasses! Sauce people, great taste, not too spicy or sweet. Just right! Crust snobs, in between doughy and cracker. Soft on top, a little crunch on bottom. Not thick. Cooked very well. Cheesers!! I really liked the taste. That bite with all cheese is satisfying. I would order a cheese only and be good with it. Pepperonis that curl up when cooked and crisp a little around the top ring. That's how it should be!! Nice sized nugget sausage that added a little spice to each bite. Banana peppers with some snap when you bite them. Not all thin and dehydrated from cooking. Saw a few subs other diners were eating after I'd ordered. I'm going to try one of those next and maybe one of the many desserts read more

Our go to pizza place...great service and great pizza (and more) We love Chicken Bacon Ranch, Old World Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken and the Bosco Sticks! Eat in their newly renovated dining room that is unlike anywhere else! read more

While I wasn't a fan of the pizza, not that's it bad, it's just ok. And for the cost, nah not paying that much for it. The competitor in the area has a better pie but also overprice for the effort. But when you only have two, it is what it is. HOWEVER, the subs at Long Branch remind me of my childhood pizzeria! They are really good!! I haven't tried anything else, but pizza and subs so will have to come back to this! read more

First time, will be returning. Pizza is really good. We got pepperoni and mushroom and some garlic bread. Both good. The dining area is pretty awesome as well. read more

Absolutely love long branch. Their Big Cheese pizza is my favorite. We used to order lunch for the whole store once a month. Only reason we don't now is because their hours changed. People answering the phone and working counter have always been friendly to me. read more

First time that we have eaten here since new owners took over. The recipe has changed and not good compared to what it used to be. Had both a pizza, salad and an Italian sub. Both pizza and sub were sub par. Could barely find the sausage as it was very skimpy, as were the rest of the toppings. The crust has way too much sugar in it and leans toward chewy instead of crispy. The fillings on sub were also very small. More bread than anything. The salad was very good however. The young girl at the counter was very friendly and her service was excellent. read more

We like this place for subs. Haven't had their pizza yet. Prices are ok. If they raise them we'll go elsewhere because the subs aren't that big. Their subs do taste good. There always ready when we get there and their hot. It's also convenient for people in Centerburg,Johnstown, and Mt Vernon. read more

Have enjoyed their pizza, but tonight crust was burnt and seven squares missing sausage, apparently the pizza maker has no heart in his pizza making, lost me for a customer read more

Don't eat here !!! These people are very rude, girl at the counter didn't even acknowledge our presents and when we spoke to her she ignored us , so we left ! Would give zero stars if i could read more

They literally have the BEST cheese bread sticks and cheese and mushroom pizzas!! It literally just a hole in the wall and if you don't know it's there you will never see it but they have good food and they even have a big dinning room!! read more

The service is fast and effcient.The sauce has good flavor. The delivery service is very good also.

I have always loved their steak subs and have been getting them for years. Lately, they're not good. Bread is just different and not as tasty. The actual steak was so salty in spots that made me sick. Steak seems smaller. Just not so good. New ppl that just bought it have cut corners and costs too much. Probably not going to eat them much longer. I've always loved their food but .... Idk anymore read more

Always get a hot pie when ordered pick up or delivery favorite pizza place in town good service when dining in lots of pizza in Centerburg but my first choice when getting one read more

this is my second time trying this place and the pizza is really good! the wings were pretty good and the mozzarella sticks were good too. i definitely recommend this place to anyone that loves pizza and would definitely come back again if i'm in the area! read more

It's good not amazing but good. If you are looking for a quick and easy dinner this is a good place to stop, I especially love there veggie pizza. It's great! read more

This is the absolute worst pizza I have ever eaten in my life. I had a server by the name of Leshawna and she was absolutely horrible. Completely rude and refused to give me my hot cakes while they were warm, she stated that they had to be cold. Who wants to eat a cold hot cake? Not me for sure. We also ordered the barbecue chicken pizza and it ended up tasting like cow manure with a few slices of cheese on top. SLICES OF CHEESE? I'm an Italian and this is absolutely despicable. read more

Long Branch Pizza - ed sheerer on the red carpet - Pizza Near Me - Centerburg, Ohio

I have never gotten a bad pizza from Long branch. Their cauliflower pizza crust is awesome and the customer service is always on point.

Love Long Branch! They are patient, kind, and make excellent pizza. Best pizza in town!

Wow, I was really surprised at how good this place is. Apparently there is a vicious rivalry between the two local pizza places in town - Pizzaburg being the other one. In fact, I was told this one was going to be mediocre by comparison. I've had just cheese pizza from here because that's what I prefer. The service both on the phone when I ordered and in person when I picked it up was friendly and welcoming. The price is reasonable and it feels good to support a local place. I was a bit worried that the crust would be too thin, or there would be too little sauce or cheese. So I have to admit, I ordered extra sauce and extra cheese both times I've ordered from here just to be safe. And that order made my pizza just right! I say, if you're going to Centerburg or just passing through, give this place a shot! read more

It was good. Ordered a 3 topping medium pizza which was perfect size for 2 hungry people, had a couple of pieces left over. We were taking a motorcycle ride, so we also got an italian sub to share later down the road. The sub was actually really good cold, so I could just imagine how it could've been hot. We seem to always ride pass this place when we ride East, so we may need to stop again for a hot sub. Keep in mind, looks like this place may be family owned, & they only had 2 people working during lunch time on a Saturday, but everything was still pretty prompt & they were still really friendly & helpful. read more

See all

We had a pepperoni pizza and a bacon pizza. The pepperoni is very high quality and the bacon was outstanding. My kids now consider bacon pizza to be their favorite. read more

Was visiting town and popped into this little gem. Ordered the All the Way pizza and it was fantastic, crust fresh and crisp with toppings edge to edge, not greasy. Will visit again! read more

Long Branch Pizza - All the Way pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerburg, Ohio

I personally am not a fan of the pizza here. I've never ate inside but the plce seems kinda small in my opinion. Just because your all the way out here doesn't mean the pizza can be cheaply made. read more

The pizza is really great. The amount of cheese they use is to die for. The pepperoni is also delicious. The only reason for a 3 star review is the service/delivery time isn't great or takes forever. read more

Have never had pizza here before. I got 12 inch meat lovers pizza. Love the crust. Plenty of meat and was cooked just right. Ordered on way to campgrounds and was ready in 17 minutes when I got there. read more

Just got a to go pizza and it was excellent! The crust was crispy and the tomato sauce was just right. Highly recommend them!

well, I did write a review and it was "Deleted" huh? Go figure. This is really great pizza and really great location. JUST EXTREMELY price for what you get. You used to get 2 meatballs in the spaghetti dinner, now you get ONE CUT IN HALF. Great staff and very friendly. Just not a place to go with the family more than 1 time a month. You can get a steak dinner cheaper. read more

The pizza and garlic bread were very good. The girl at the counter when you walk in, was not very inviting, at all. We were in the area to pick up our daughter from a retreat in the area and needed somewhere to eat. Was hoping for a nicer reception for out-of-town guests. Maybe we'll try somewhere else the next time we're up in that area. read more

New ownership and such a big improvement! Order there regularly now. Very pleasant on the phone taking the order to picking up order.

Good, but not great. I prefer my crust to not be soft. Service was quick. Nice dining area with sports on the television.

Hot and crispy crust pizza! Spaghetti, subs and bread sticks are also tasty. Worth checking out. Clearly not your average pizza place. Food is not greasy and served very hot. read more

Had Long Branch Pizza last weekend and it was really good. Been a while since I have been there prior to that. The time I did go prior to that was about a year earlier and the pizza was kind of bland, mainly because that time it seemed like they were just spooning tomato sauce from the can onto the pizza and not adding any spices to the sauce. Last weekend (last Friday afternoon 1/12/2018 around noon to be exact) it was definitely different - the sauce tasted like it was spiced and like pizza sauce, it was cooked just right and really good. Hope they keep making good pizzas and continue to spice the pizza sauce so it tastes like pizza sauce. read more

For the 5th time in a row my order was either missing something or over 1 hour and 45 mins getting to me. Tonight was no exception after 1 hour and 50 mins. I called and was treated with the utmost disrespect so I cancelled my order. My order did show up at 2 hours and 19 min mark. I would definitely NOT RECOMMEND Centerburg longbranch. read more

Pleasantly surprised. Had never eaten Longbranch before and was very impressed with the pizza I got from them. Great flavor, reasonable prices. read more

We are from the Atlanta area visiting family in Centerburg this weekend. Although my wife and I had already eaten, they either got pizza from them via take out or delivery before we arrived. I confess, one of my greatest weaknesses is good pizza. The pizza was pepperoni and sausage. I typically do not like sausage on my pizza. However it looked really good so I tried a piece prior to picking it off. OMG, I loved the sausage and was rudely picking sausage off other pieces in the box and eating pizza even though I ate not long ago. I'm glad this pizza is not available close to where I live. I don't eat the ends of the crust much but this pizza I did. The sauce was tangy, flavorful, and robust. The toppings where very desirable and adequate. If they didn't order extra cheese, this had more than what I see on my other pizza places which of course I liked very much too. Yep, I really really enjoyed this pie and have no problem highly recommending. Lastly, I will eat here again. read more