Ordered for delivery at school for our newly created "Pizza Club" based on Lucia's strong reputation. Sauce and cheese were on point, but the pizza was a little too chewy for my liking. It was a very doughy pie that was some of the chewiest pizza I've ever had. Not a bad pie flavor-wise, but also not quite my cup of tea. read more

Lucia Pizza - Regular pie - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

Plain pizza - their tomato based pizza is the best. The only reason I give it 5 stars. Brocolli and chicken pizza - avoid. It was a non-tomato base. Not a fan of the taste. It tasted like leftover chicken and Brocolli and they forgot to add tomato... Cannoli - it was nice to try. Wouldn't order again. The shells were store bought, so it didn't taste as crispy. Garlic knots - it was okay. Would order again because it adds variety to pizza. read more

You have to order a slice and sit there and eat it. Takeout means you're getting nasty pizza for some reason. The service is okay but nothing to brag about. It's decent to sit down for a slice. read more

Pros: + Lots of space for seating + Quick service + Friendly staff + Convenient parking + Delicious! IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC read more

Here's a much shorter, more straightforward version that sounds natural and not "polished": --- I was really excited to come back to Lucia's since it was my childhood pizza spot, but this was a big letdown. Ordered a large veggie and added pepperoni. Was told 25 minutes, picked it up a few minutes early, got home in 4 minutes and the pizza was already hard and tough to chew. I live 3 blocks away. Once I chewed like 4 bites, my jaw actually hurt and my dad couldn't chew it either. It tasted like an old pizza that had been sitting out and reheated with extra toppings. Definitely not fresh. 4 slices we threw away. For $34, this was disappointing. I don't mind paying the price, just make it fresh and right. Please stop cutting corners and serving food like this. Why would take a legacy neighborhood brand and destroy it? Save a morning pie from being trash and instead lost a customer. read more

Lucia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

See all

For a quick grab and go pizza, this spot isn't a bad option. If you want some quality pizza, you might be disappointed. Inside is decent spaciously if you do want to eat it there and they're located in a good space where you won't be able to miss it if you pass by. I got their plain pizza slice and it hit the spot for a classic easy grab and go slice but it wasn't amazing. The cheese was kind of thick but since I got it warmed up and fresh, it was melty! It has the classic thin crust with a little chew, which I liked. There was a decent amount of sauce but the sauce wasn't very flavorful. I would still get it again if I was craving a simple slice. read more

Spacious pizzeria, parking is a little tough in the area, but I did see a sign in the front that they have spots in the back. Quick service. The regular size was good, not the best in Queens but good for that area. Large slices, thin crust, needed a little more sauce. The drunken grandma slice looked really good, but was disappointing. The crust was super thick, and there was barely any sauce, I felt like I was eating a piece of bread. Good prices. read more

Lucia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

This is the definition of a NY slice. This is what I grew up with. Not thick, but not too thin medium crust with soft inside but crunch bottom. Maybe I've been in Long Island too long but I miss this style of real NY slice pizza. The plain slice was on point, the buffalo chicken was definitely generous on the chicken and the pepperoni is classic. I did forget to ask what is the difference between a large and house pie because we ordered large pies. Next time I shall ask because I left it here in the review as a note read more

So stoked to see Lucia open another location in Bayside. I always dread having to drive to Flushing to buy a pie. What both location's suffer most though no fault of their own is parking. Picking up a pie is a two person job in both locations, the Bayside location does advertise curbside pick up though. I ordered a half pepperoni cheese pizza which had perfectly melted cheese, flavorful tomato sauce and a delicious savory pepperoni. The "undercarriage and flop" of the pie was a little under charred and on the softer side. The crust was a solid 10 for crunchiness and struck the right balance between crispiness and chewiness. On my next order, I'll ask for the pie to be baked well done, hopefully that will improve on the "Flop and undercarriage" Looking forward to trying the other items on the menu soon. read more

See all

Second visit in the past week. Eggplant Parm with penne with so delicious can't put it in words. Service was excellent, food is very fresh and no rush for service. Place is clean as last time. Very great place to visit to come next time to try different pizzas and foods read more

See all

-This Here, i have to Say; Is One of the 'BEST' Pizzerias is aLL of Queens (and Probably BEYOND) -1st, One of the Tastiest Crispy Slices (Around) -2nd, O.M.G. the Sauce (Incredible) -3rd, the Freshest Ingredients Around, Salads (One can Taste IT) -4th, They're Heros, Chk Cutlet Parm. and They're Chicken franchise Hero, with the lemon Butter Sauce (Omg. The BEST Ever (Theirs a Gentleman named Francisco, What a 'Chef' and Nicest Guy Around..... the Staff is Very Friendly (Even on Snowy-RainOut Days) the Place has a Nice Flat Screen Tv, and Most Importantly (They're CLEAN as Heck) -So, for a Great Slice, and Delicious Food and Hero(s), This is the GeM.... -just Don't take My Word; TRY IT -You Will Thank Me in the Long Run (For Those Who Don't Know, Already) -ReeseB. NYC read more

Great to see Lucia pizza in Bayside. I've gone to Lucia in Flushing since I was a kid so there's a bit of nostalgia here. Delicious pizza and a solid place as your go to pizza. Slightly bigger than the narrow pizzeria in Flushing. Good service and in a convenient location a few blocks from Bell Blvd on Northern Blvd. read more

Lucia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

We are very big fans of Lucia in Flushing and was estactic to hear they were opening a new location in Queens. Their new location in Bayside opened to the public yesterday. The new location isn't very large with only three or four tables but interior feels spacious and clean. We ordered a medium regular pie ($14.50) and six garlic knots ($2.95). Everything tasted great and prices were reasonable, specially for this neighborhood. Staff were so nice and they have extended hours of operation (open every day from 10am to 9pm everyday except for Friday and Saturday it's 10am-10pm). So glad they have expanded too this neighborhood. read more

See all

If you're from Queens, the name is no stranger to the game. If you're not from Queens, you probably still heard the name thrown around in controversy among who has the best pizza. The original location in the heart of Flushing has been a staple to the community. It's as classic as a NY slice gets and has grown a big enough following for them to open this 2nd location in a much more accessible area for us locals who drive. Out of convenience, I find myself frequenting this spot over the original now. Taste wise, its not too far off from each other, though subtle differences, it's just as delicious. The original location definitely has nostalgia points for sure, but this location is easily one of the better spots for Bayside. Stay fat mother suckers read more

Updated: I wanted to love them. I want to be floored. I wanted to shout from the rooftops that everyone needs to go to Lucia Pizza. I wanted to because I absolutely love love love their location in Flushing but to get to it is almost impossible, and I live in Bayside. I was soooo excited when they opened. So the first time we ordered it was about a month after they opened. We figured a month was enough to at least get their "mojo". Well we ordered one plain cheese pie and one pepperoni mushroom pie to go. I always order a plain cheese pie and a second pie with toppings of choice of my husband and son. So the plain pie was very blah and floppy. The mushroom pepperoni was even floppier than the plain one and the toppings all slid off when taking a slice. They weren't crispy or foldable. They were just "eh". Okay so fast forward to last week and we once again gave them a chance (again, I absolutely love their other location) because they're new here and wanted soooo much to love them. Sadly, again we were disappointed. BUT we are troopers and will give them one more shot, but the next time we'll eat a couple of slices there - hot out of the oven- and then come back and update with the findings and some pictures. There is one thing that can't be denied is that the staff are wonderful and definitely service with a smile! read more

Pretty good pizza. Friendly and polite staff/service. Very clean inside. Pizza was really. read more

Lucia Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

I can't compare to the Lucia in flushing but this is my go to. 5 stars because the pizza is crispy and they always accommodate any orders. They will make a half white pie along with a sausage pie. Now that's service. And it's soo good read more

Lucia Pizza - Margarita pie - definitely my fav. I can definitely taste the fresh garlic. - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

Got 2 large pies with sausage and bacon be with extra cheese for the office with chicken wings. The delivery time was pretty good but idk when we got the pizzas the pies were all fugly and like looked like the guy tilted my pies to one side. And they didn't give any pepper flakes or anything. Wings were fire doe not gonna lie deff recommend the wings. read more

Lucia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

See all

Finally got to try this location out. Grandma slice delish White slice delish Drunken grandma delish Regular slice is okay. Not as good as the flushing location. Def coming back to try other specialty slices. read more

Best pizza in Bayside period. Quintessential New York City -burn the roof of your mouth good. Ingredients and sauce (which they won't sell) is what you want and what you deserve. Tons of my HS friends grew up having Lucia's in Flushing and now all of us can have the same quality with better parking options in Bayside. Enjoy! read more

See all

went in here to grab a quick meal of 2 plain slices. Brings back memories of Lucia of flushing. So good fresh and hot

I didn't think that they could duplicate the slice of pizza from Flushing, but they did and I think it's even better than the one there. It's great service is dedicated to the customer it's worth a trip near or far. read more

I understand they're brand new and they have to work out some of the kinks but my goodness the service is terrible. The kid with the glasses and backwards hat, God bless his soul, has no clue what he's doing. The paste e fagioli taste like dirty water pasta sauce thats about to go sour. The penne bologonese is a 3/10. They boil the penne and dont drain it enough, mix it with their sauce and meat they make in the pan. But the end product is underwhelming. The wings good, the plain slice good. JUST COME FOR THE WINGS AND SLICE, that is all. Anything else don't waste your money. read more

See all

Solid as usual, definition of a New York slice. Instant nostalgia whenever we eat here. Always taking a pie home as well.

My high school years were full of Lucia's amazing plain slice from their location in Flushing. But Flushing has gotten less and less driver friendly over the years, so I stopped going. I heard about Lucia's opening in Bayside and decided to see if the pizza is as good as I remember. The Bayside spot is located right on Northern Blvd next to the Tiger Schulman's karate center and across from a current empty lot. It's a quaint size, two counters (one for the pizza/food orders and a register, and the other counter with icees and a register). There's about 6 small tables with 2 chairs each to eat inside if you choose to. I came on a Friday at 7 pm. There were 3 folks ahead of me waiting to order. It took about 15 minutes before I was able to order. The staff really seemed to be trying to stay on top of everything but obviously struggled. Not much organization as far as ordering either; while I was waiting several more folks came in and either stood behind me waiting to order or went to the register by the icees and started ordering pizza/food which had the staff all over the place trying to get all these orders done. All together, it took me about 25 minutes to get two slices to go, not warmed up at my request. While there, a customer approached the counter asking how much longer he needed to wait for 2 slices to be warmed up, I heard him mention being there 20 minutes already. I ordered a plain slice and a buffalo slice, came to $8.15 with tax and you have the option to pay by card with no additional credit card fee, which I am seeing more food establishments doing. Right after my charge went through, the young man who rang me up disappeared for several minutes, and I stood there waiting for him to return so I could ask for a receipt. The pizza is as good as I remember, and the buffalo slice had a good spice to it. I may try to visit again on a different day/time and see if the service is better because the amount of time it took to get two slices to go was a bit much. 3 stars given because the pizza is great, and the staff remained kind and calm throughout my time there. read more

New location and nice little store to finally sit and have a nice pie. prices are great and the pizza never disappoints. Better spot if you do not want to go into their original location as there is never any free parking. definitely my favorite spot for pizza in queens! read more

We've been Lucia pizza lovers for over 30 years, but Roosevelt Ave is crazy. So glad they're in Bayside now. The pizza tasted the same as Flushing. YUM! The place is clean and has about 5 tables. They're still getting organized/settled - forgot our order, had to remind them we were still waiting. read more

Lucia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

The best in Bayside, great service very friendly And clean Recommend the "Drunking Grandma" read more

Lucia Pizza - My favorite - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

I ordered a pizza and chicken roll through Uber Eats , I said well done . Pizza dough was thick and soft and very chewy and same thing for chicken roll . Nothing like the Lucia I remember in flushing read more

Great thin crust pizza just like the original location on Roosevelt Ave. The employees are pretty nice and welcoming unlike most places. Prices are in par and worh the cost. Definitely must try this place read more

The guys here are slacking. Waited 1 hr for a pie. No one knows what's going on besides the guy in the bathroom that doesn't tell the employees the orders that come in smh read more

At this point most people are aware that it is the second location to the very well-known Lucia's pizza on Roosy in Flushing. Now let's start with the fact that it's rare to find the same exact product in two separate locations when it comes to any establishment. I never expected it to be the same exact slice of pizza but I was expecting it to be solid slice. And that is exactly what it is, a solid slice of pizza. Definitely not the same as the original in Flushing but it's not a bad pizza at all. They are relatively new and you can tell that they are trying to figure things out, which is understandable. It is a nice and clean spot with a variety of options on the menu. The garlic knots are delicious and the marinara sauce they offer on the side go really well with the knots. I usually get a pie, half pepperoni & half cheese, and it hasn't let me down as of yet. The entire family has enjoyed it on multiple occasions. I don't know if this is my official go to pizzeria in the area but it is certainly in the rotation. I would suggest giving it a try without constantly comparing it to the flushing location. read more

Pizza has been disappointing me lately. Rose's is consistently too salty and even with all that salt, it kind of lacks flavor. VIP is still good but not what it used to be. So glad I stopped in today to Lucia's. Their pizza is everything I want in pizza with tasty (non-salty sauce), crispy crust, and perfect cheesy deliciousness.All this and super friendly staff. The next time I order a pie, it will be from them. Love. read more

I ordered to delivery margaritas pie it was so yummy it's came early highly recommend

$3.00 is amazing for the quality they serve I recommend for anyone as they have a great variety of options and their customer service is amazing! read more

Food is very good and staff is very professional and friendly. Music is actually really good also read more

See all

The flushing location I've been going to since the 70s when I was a little kid, I was excited to find that they're branching out to bayside where parking is a lot easier, However the slice is NOT the same. The sauce doesn't have that sweet sugar taste the OG spot in flushing has, and it's bland overall. Lucia has a very signature taste and this location doesn't have it. Tell me you're bringing the identical slice from flushing and I'll be back to try again. Til then, gotta battle for parking on Main Street in flushing. It's like Peter Luger, the long island location tastes worse than the one in Brooklyn. read more

It's clean, friendly service and quick. Ordered a large cheese pie for pick-up. I like how thin the pizza is, but wish it was less salty.

WARNING: THEY DONT KNOW HOW TO MAKE PIZZA The hawaiian pie here DOES NOT come with tomato sauce!!!! First time ordering from this pizzeria and did not expect my hawaiian pie to arrive with no tomato sauce. Never been to a pizzeria that did not have tomato sauce for their hawaiian pies. Poor service as well. I spoke with the manager and he did not care enough to offer any solution- no refund or new pie with tomato sauce. Manager stated hawaiian pie comes with mozzarella, ham, and pineapples as shown on menu but none of the other pies specify tomato sauce either???? Worst pizza I've ever had. read more

Lucia Pizza - 0/10 their disgusting hawaiian pie that doesn't come with tomato sauce - Pizza Near Me - Bayside, New York

Great pizza. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese and dough cooked just right! A little bit of flushing right here in Bayside. We're very happy. read more