Ordered for pick up and it was soooo worth it! Meat lovers, cheese, and Margherita pizza were all delicious! We ordered on a weekend around noon and it was a quick 20 minute wait. The crust was crispy and the sauce was so tasty. And can confirm the leftovers also taste good cold which I believe is a true sign of a great pizza read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

More NY style pizza vs the Ohio type. Good Pizza but lacking spice of the Italian fare. Overall for my area I would buy again.

I had a great time coming here. The staff was incredible and very friendly. We got their New York pizza with double pepperoni and Buffalo wings. Both were very tasty. I will be coming back very soon to try many more options on their menu. read more

See all

This was some really good pizza. Tony's is in the strip mall at Galloway and Hall in the spot where the OH Pizza & Wings recently closed. The inside looks basically the same, with a small counter for pick-up and a few tables if you want to eat there. I've never had pizza in New York, so I can't compare this to that, but I can say this was delicious. The crust was cooked perfectly, mostly chewy, with just the smallest bit of crunch, and had a nice bread-y flavor. And the Meat Lovers pizza was absolutely loaded with meat. The garlic bread was better than most pizza places -- crunchy on the outside, soft in the middle, with more of a real garlic and real butter flavor. And the marinara sauce that came with it was really good. If it's the same sauce they use on their pastas I'm sure those will be great, too. The menu is huge, with appetizers, pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, salads, wings, desserts, and more. I will definitely go back and try lots of other stuff. Hopefully everything is just as good and I'll have an update to post here. Edit: We went back and got a Stromboli (pepperoni and sausage). This helped solidify my 5-star review! (Two stromboli pics added.) Note: We ordered garlic rolls this time and they were good, but the garlic bread was better. read more

See all

Tried Tony's Pizza for the first time this past Saturday. Tony's is located in a corner plaza in Galloway. It occupies the former OH Pizza & Wings that closed a while back. Tony's is a small place with only a couple of tables and a counter. There is a television on the wall but I wouldn't classify Tony's as a dine in place. Which is fine since I was taking the food to my dad's. I was told that they deliver through a couple of different third party outlets. I was also told that I could follow them on Facebook for deals and coupons. Aside from the owner, I was the only one in there but it was just as they opened. I told the owner that this was my first visit and I was very excited to try his food. He told me he hoped it exceeded my expectations. I ordered a 14" cheese and pepperoni pizza and two 12" Italian subs. He asked if I wanted the subs as they came and I said yes. That meant along with the meats and cheese they were topped with lettuce, onion, and tomato. The owner disappeared into the back to cook my order and I sat at one of the tables. Tony's is clean and uncluttered and bright. My food was brought to my table in about 15 minutes and it smelled heavenly. The owner told me that since this was my first visit he included an order of garlic rolls and marinara sauce for free. That was above and beyond and I thanked him for his generosity and customer service. He also told me that he put the Italian dressing on the side which is exactly how I like it. He then opened the pizza box and showed me my pizza and it was all I could do to stop myself from digging in right there. The pizza looked just like I was hoping it would. Thin crust with wavy pepperonis, the smell of herbs, and covered with lovely cheese. I thanked him and wished him well and left to go eat. The garlic rolls were soft and chewy and seasoned well. I didn't try the marinara sauce and only had one roll. The sub was massive. If I hadn't been so piggish I probably could have gotten 3 meals out of the sub instead of 2. The sub was packed to overflowing with toppings. The bread was very fresh as were the toppings. I dipped the sub into the dressing/oil once and felt it added nothing so I skipped it. The sub was very good and I enjoyed it but the pizza was the star of the show. Fresh tasting crust was nice and soft underneath with light browning and the back end crust was snappy and firm. The cheese and pepperoni was salty but not overly so. A sign on the door said that they use Ezzo for their meats and that is great as they have exceptional meat. The pizza was cut into 6 slices and with my 3 slices, half a sub, and a garlic roll I was ready for a nap. I ate the other half of the sub later that night for dinner at about 8:00pm. I reheated it a tad in the microwave and it was a touch better than it was for lunch. The tab for a 14" cheese and pep pizza and 2 12" Italian subs came to $39.00. My dad and I each got 2-3 meals out of everything so that makes it a bargain every day of the week. Especially for the high quality and tremendous taste. I'll definitely go back. read more

Tony's Pizza - This pic does not do justice to the sub. This sub was enormous. - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

See all

My son got a carry out for first time from this place after his soccer training. The pizza was great, sauce cheese pie everything so different and so tasty! Will make sure we get food from there next time we are in that area but we might even just drive for a nice weekend bonfire cause the food is amazing and worth the drive! read more

Decided to have a pizza night, and check out this pizza joint that took over OH Pizza and Wings. This place is right around the neighborhood from me. So it's very convenient. I gave it a 4 because, well, it was my first time on only really got this mushroom, sausage, and pepperoni pizza in this image. I apparently spoke with the owner and had a little chat with him. Enjoyed the chat, and I got the scoop on how it generally came to be Tony's Pizza. So with that said, at this moment I think the cost was a little more expensive but then again so is everything else. The pizza was very good and I will be obtaining more in the future. read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese, of course, mushroom, sausage, and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

Food is pretty good. They make a pretty good pie. Bonus we can get it delivered to our house through one of the delivery services.

Tony's is our family favorite. My six year old will not eat pizza from any other place!! On vacation she ate easy Mac as an alternative to different pizza‍. Their toppings are great especially pepperoni. Their crust is absolute perfection every time. read more

My husband sent me a link for 'my kind of pizza'. Having been raised in NJ biting into a slice of pie it brought me back to days on the shore and family gatherings at the local pizzeria. Cannoli was perfect, pizza perfect. If you have ever missed a bit of home this is it. If you relocated to Cbus from the East Coast this will take you home again. Amazing, perfect I can't wait to try more items read more

Tony's Pizza - Perfect slice of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

I've been searching for a NY style pizza in Columbus for years that reminded me of pizza I get in the NY/NJ area. I ordered a cheese pizza here and was amazed. This was it! I ordered another pizza a few days later. This time with pepperoni. For some reason, I didn't like their pepperoni. Cheese pizza was perfect, though. I'll revisit with sausage next time. Their salads are quite awesome as well. Giving 4/5 just because I don't care for the pepperoni they used. Definitely recommend giving this place a try. read more

My first time ordering a stromboli from this restaurant. Not exactly what I expected. I think it would be better if all the ingredients (spinach, tomato, mushrooms) were cooked prior to putting inside the stromboli. There was alot of excess liquid, causing the bottom of the stromboli to be soggy. I also expected it to rolled in a spiral like a stromboli, this is folded over like a calzone. read more

Tony's Pizza - Primavera stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

My wife and I were craving a good ol' NY style cheese pizza and Tony's hit the spot. Good crisp crust, cheesy and delicious. We loved it! It was our first order with them so we are looking forward to trying more of their menu in the future. read more

The pizza I ordered, was pepperoni with 1/2 jalapeños, and was excellent! The crust was perfect, and the toppings were an excellent ratio. Delicious and is my new favorite! read more

Their food is absolutely amazing! We only live a half mile away and we order almost three times a week!!!! That says a lot considering we are pizza snobs! read more

I have not tried the pizza yet but we were in the mood for subs. The subs were good, diced tomatoes instead of sliced. We also got the garlic rolls, I would rate a 1 or less as they were so hard and we had to toss them. The sauce was good. I will give them another shot with the pizza to see if we like. read more

Ordered a large pepperoni and Xtra cheese. Old world slightly spice pepperoni and great crust. I own a wood fired oven. I haven't perfected the crust. They have. Great pizza, friendly staff, definitely ordering again. Thanks. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pepperoni & xtra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Galloway, Ohio

See all

Food wasn't good at all !!!! Ordered a large pizza all the way looked like they counted every single piece of toppings on it ... I've gotten more toppings at little Caesars, also ordered cheese garlic bread the cheese wasn't even melted the bread was cold and no flavor at all..in my opinion don't waste your money... read more

So we tried Tony's for the first time today. Pizza was awesome (pepperoni pizza and spinach pizza) Real New York style crust which we struggle to find on the west side. We will definitely be ordering again! read more

I had a high expectations for this place, I need to say that the owner and the service was excellent, what I can't say that the pepperoni pizza was good. The pizza had no or little sauce on it making this uneventful experience taste wise. The crust was extremely salty the Little Cesar's quality, very hard and tasteless after cooling for a while, since the advertised statement was hand made in house. I always give any place a second chance, but the pizza needs to be corrected, especially that there is not really a room to eat inside so majority business is a take out. Most of the customers in this case will not be back, think about that. I will give another chance with something else like wings, which they advertise, we will see. read more

Very tasty pizza baked perfect wouldn't change a thing. quick delivery and very courteous driver. Definitely trying it again

I just ate my first piece of Tony's Pizza and it was fantastic!! This will be our go to pizza for sure. Galloway has some good pizza places but people need to try Tony's. The crust is just like our favorite pizza shop in New York and the sauce / toppings are A1. They have an extensive menu that we will be exploring as well!!! read more