This location is a little weird as its very small and not really lit up at all. its easy to miss it. the food was all good as normal. The brisket is definitely the winner at Dickeys compared to everything else. I also enjoyed the ribs. service was a little slow but the guy was nice and having to do everything himself. Overall, I like Dickey's but dont know if ill be back to this location. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

There was a recent change in ownership. The new owners are still getting their feet on the ground, but for us the service change has been excellent. I go semi-regularly with my daughter and they always treat her like a queen. Just recently, we had a meal on Halloween and one of the staff brought out a free brownie for my daughter just to celebrate the holiday. The restaurant was already providing a free meal for Halloween, so more was completely unnecessary, but also appreciated and brought a lot of joy. The new owners have had nothing but trouble with the soda machine. When they bought in, there was one of those fancy touch-screen machines where you pick from a million flavors you don't want. It broke, so they replaced it with a traditional soda machine. That one broke and it has been broken for a while. I was told on Halloween that it is finally fixed and now they are just restocking supplies for the machine, so it should be ready to go soon. The vibe of the place has moved from kind of corporate-standard "this is Texas" decor, to more of a country biker bar vibe. There are a lot of personal touches that I really enjoy including some interesting toys scattered around the place and a station where you order your food where you can play sudoku or do a word find while you wait for the server to take your order. There are some rough edges to smooth out yet. On our last visit, there was no plasticware available at the drink station, so I had to go and ask for it. The soda-machine, as mentioned, was still broken, but that is on the mend. I didn't really talk about the food. Seems like some reviewers have had trouble in that area, but I haven't. I don't exactly exercise the whole menu, but my westerner combo with brisket and jalapeno sausage is always delicious and the portion is plentiful. I like several of the sides including the baked beans, potato casserole, and green beans. There are several sauces to choose from and I like the regular well enough. Sometimes I mix it with the spicy for a bit more kick. Many BBQ restaurants can't maintain reasonable meat quality when there isn't enough volume to support it, but I think Dickey's has that mostly figured out. It isn't going to beat the best restaurants in the country, but it is going to provide a decent, consistent product that is worthy of your business and definitely holds up to other places in the area. read more

Terrible experience, only one person working. Said their system was down and only cash. No fried foods available. Green beans had no flavor. We were overcharged. She said drinks don't come with the meal. 3 meals and a kids meal for $73. She did give us back $6.50 for 2 of the drinks when we complained. The bathroom smelled like weed. We will never go back there. We have a Dickeys in Springboro, we have never had a bad experience there. read more

I heard from someone that they were good and was surprised by the quality of food I got. I ordered to go and I was really disappointed. I ordered a 2 meat plate. Everything was cold. The brisket was the best part and juicy, but there tons of fatty pieces. The pulled pork was really dry. The Texas toast tasted old and dry. The Mac and cheese tasted like the Bob Evans pre-packaged Mac at the grocery store that you just heat up. The mashed potatoes were awful. They smelled disgusting and tasted sour. It was gross and I just threw them away. I feel like Dickey's was pretty pricey and for the quality of food they serve I'm shocked they are still open. Since I ordered to go I cannot comment on the service and ambiance. The staff didn't look too happy, but my food was ready when I picked it up. Given this experience and the price, I won't be back and do not recommend ordering food from this place. read more

This place needs inspection. Dark inside and in back. Menu online isn"t correct or updated. No turkey or ham. This place has been given years of constructive critism to improve according to our reviews. Lost my appetite when I saw the managers dog in back by the grilled foods. Is this allowed? Eight years later they still don't greet you when walk in. read more

Customer service was awful, guy was not friendly whatsoever. $17 for a sandwhich, Mac and cheese and a drink. Crazy overpriced! Music was loud and needed to yell at some points to talk to my peer. Not many drink options. Food was okay. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - $17 Pulled Pork Sandwich Combo - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Honestly would rate this experience a 2, and I probably should, but my love for this place makes it a 3. I placed a pickup order for 1:45pm. Now for most people that means the food is going to be ready for pickup at 1:45, packaged and ready to go. Even Google says the same thing, but anyways. I show up at 1:42. The employee comes to the window (drive-thru) and asks for my name then walks aways. They then come back to tell me that my order is for 1:45, and that I can either wait in the car or sit inside while they prepare it. It's currently, 1:45, so I go inside. The place is empty, the entire time I'm in there, aside from one person that walked in and picked up their order and left. After 12 minutes I sat back down into my car at 1:57pm. So I spent 15 minutes there when it should've been at max 5 - FOR A PRE-PLANNED PICK UP TIME. Okay, now the service. I'm not sure if the employee got something going on outside of work, but yea if they were my employee I'd fire them. There's no reason to have attitude, or a slight temper. I didn't do anything and my food definitely didn't do anything. So 15 minutes there, and a 13 minute drive home. Me and my girlfriend got - Loaded baked potato (everything on it), Smoke Stack (pork and Mac), pulled pork, fries, & a side of Mac. No sour cream on the potato, fries were cold and soggy, and the standalone pulled pork was cold (thank god for my air fryer). Will I be back, probably, just hopefully when this employee is at home. read more

See all

Following up, it's been 2 months and I still haven't received a reply from Dickeys. I can't stress enough how important it is to have decent service. Dickeys you received my email and phone number, but still no reply from Dickeys in Hilliard or the corporate office . I should have noticed people have had the same experience with poor quality food and the standard Dickeys " we're looking into it or thanks for telling us something we already know " I can't stress how important it is to support good business in your community and warn against the ones that don't deserve to have yours. You only get one time to make a first impression or one bite at the Apple, my bite was extremely dry pulled pork . read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - SO SO DRY! Not Texas Toast - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Just went there this evening. They definitely had some hiccups--pop machine not working, no ice, sweet tea wasn't sweet, silverware wasn't out (aside from spoons), food took a little longer than one would have thought it would--just little things. It could've been a frustrating experience BUT the service was OUTSTANDING. Literally above & beyond. The 2 gentleman that were there said they bought it in March & one went to grab ice somewhere for us, gave us cookies/brownies to make up for the hiccups, just overall 12/10 on service. Food was great too! There's some kinks to work out but I look forward to the next visit! I recommend checking them out. read more

If this were the last place on planet earth I would rather starve than get the amount of food for a 100$ order!!! If you can't fulfill an order or you are too tired to make it. Than close early . You should be ashamed of yourselves even being open for business. Like I said DONT GO TO THIS PLACE FOR ANYTHING!!! Please do everyone a favor and shut your doors! I sure hope DoorDash will refund us because if not we need to call the Better Business Bureau you are a total disgrace!!! I only wish I could give it negative stars! Thanks for RUINING Fathers Day for us. Shame on you all! You should all be fired asap!!! And by the way Yelp isn't the only site I'll display my review. Google,Bing, Reddit etc... you get my drift? read more

See all

I ordered the 2 meat plate. Jalapeño cheddar sausage with sliced brisket. Green beans and mac & chz. Pros: meats were good. Cons: the sides were dry. No fries at this location, the roll was hard and Brisket wasnt sliced like I asked. They didnt have any onions to go with the pickles. It was like they were closing up shop early although they had an hour until close. There were no tops on the food. I guess I should of known that the sides would have been dry. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - 2 meat plate: sliced brisket, jalapeño cheddar sausage, mac & chz, & green beans - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Always terrible attitudes not friendly! Ridiculously slow nothing is ever ready when u get there! Place is always a mess. Sat there forever and they didn't say a word . Complained whole time about having orders. Was very rude to everyone. read more

I'm glad this bbq place has stuck around. Great catering service. I would not go in and sit down to eat there. Their food is yummy, but I think it would need to be bigger for a more easier feeling when you walk in. More sides would be nice too and more of a selection of different cuts of meat. But, the food is good, the catering is good and the bathroom was clean! That is always a plus. read more

I Pre ordered a delivery for 12:00pm which is the earliest you can order since they don't open until 11:00am. I Ordered a full slab of pork ribs requested it to be left whole with sauce on the side and the 3 meats with 2 sides this includes Texas toast. We selected sliced brisket, ribs, and jalapeño kielbasa sausage. Our delivery order arrived before the estimated time which was nice all utensils were delivered no items were missing! However the reason for my 1 star is because this was our very first time trying Dickeys Barbecue pit and we had high hopes. The ribs were dry and tasted as if they'd been sitting out for at least a whole day! Nothing about them were succulent, juicy or even had that grilled flavor or taste they just tasted old :(... the brisket came chopped even though we selected it be sliced and it was overly salted ;(... the jalapeño kielbasa was actually pretty tasty. For the sides we got the green beans with bacon but it was missing bacon and the baked potato casserole which was my personal favorite. This was overall an absolute disappointment :(. read more

See all

These poor people are always understaffed, which probably explains why they're always in a bad mood the two times we have come. The food would be good if they didn't feel rushed to prepare it. The fries aren't crispy and the mac n cheese my son got was stone cold. The place was fairly clean though. There was another customer we overheard asking about the specials, the lady responded "We don't know what the specials are, you have to order them online". If you don't know what they are, how would you be able to make them whether they ordered online or in store? We wanted to love this place due to it being so close to our house. We hope they get someone in there to help run it who cares about their customers and employees. read more

My go to place I always go here for my birthday and it's always the best barbecue in hilliard.One thing that I dislIke is that their hours maybe need to be changed but there is nothing wrong about their food. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - the outside of the store - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

If the brisket here is smoked, you couldn't prove it by me. I ordered a half pound of the chopped brisket. It had absolutely no Smokey flavor whatsoever. It was also a bit dry. There are several other places in the Columbus area that offer excellent brisket at about the same price. read more

First and last time me and my wife will be here. We live 10 minutes away and the food showed up late and ice cold.

I had the Beef Brisket and Beef Burnt Ends with BBQ Beans and Mac & Cheese. Very disappointed with the cold bread. Loved the different BBQ sauces like Original, Sweet, and Spicy. Next time, I am doing the Baked Potato Casserole. Happy about the Coca-Cola Freestyle machine where I had half Cherry Vanilla Coca-Cola Zero Sugar and other half Cherry Vanilla Diet Dr. Pepper in the Big Yellow Cup. Enjoyed the Mac & Cheese with drizzle of the BBQ sauces. Dickey's do gave back like Hilliard Special Olympics fundraiser a couple of years ago. It is still not City BBQ, but will come back because of great service along with the Pit Boss at each store. I would go for the Yellow Cup, despite it is clear and have a Little Yellow Cup too. read more

See all

First time ordering. We ordered delivery. My husband added a rib and they didn't sent it. We ordered the Dino nuggets for our child and they sent pulled chicken. Luckily GrubHub refunded our money. I got the Polska kielbasa which had good flavor. The baked beans tasted exactly like Bush's. Not bad food but won't likely order again read more

amazing service, loved my food, the employees I interacted with we're fenomenal. I loved the French fries and brisket that I added with Mac n cheese, overall great experience will come back to dickeys barbecue. the employees were Jacob and Karen. read more

Foods dry says enough to feed two people. It's not enough to feed a child. For $30 I should've gone to outback and got a T-bone steak.

Cheap and disgusting Mostly fat too much salt wrong sauce. I don't even know where to begin to start nothing it's just no. read more

Went here for lunch, there was a sign on the door that said to be patient because they were understaffed. It was a pretty decent wait but they only had two people working there so you have to cut them some slack. They were also out of a bunch of things, she said she just didn't have time to make them. My son enjoyed everything he had and has also had their ribs before which they were out of and he says are very good, same with the jalapeño kielbasa. I had a loaded baker which is a huge baked potato with bacon, green onions, cheese and sour cream, plus a meat of your choice on top. I had the brisket which was very flavorful and tender. They have a seasoning rub that my son decided to shake on it to his meat which was pretty good If not salty, probably because it's meant as a rub and not a seasoning! They also have a pretty good spicy barbecue sauce. Their soda machine Is the Coca-Cola freestyle. It's a little on the higher and pricing for a casual barbecue joint, but certainly reasonable. They have a lot of extra options that places like city BBQ do not, more interesting sides and salads, etc. read more

If you're in the area and have a taste for BBQ give em a try. Emphasis on IN THE AREA which means that there are way better places in Columbus vicinity to get BBQ but we didn't feel like a fight to get there. We didn't feel like fighting traffic to get downtown with minimal parking for B&K smokehouse, Ray Rays Hog Pit, or Smoked on High. We didn't feel like fighting traffic up north on Bethel Rd for Hoggys either cause again we were in the Hilliard area closer to 270 North & South freeway exits and didn't feel like going deeper in Hilliard on Main St with the numerous Hilliard speed traps and police posted everywhere to get to Legacy Smokehouse. Nevertheless if you don't give a damn about an hour round trip plus wait time for your order and $5 per gallon for gas then have it to various places mentioned around Columbus & Hilliard. Now specifically back to this place, ordering is seemless and straightforward but the portions are on the smallish side for an average of $15 plus for "platters" and combos. The two bone ribs they give didn't have that much meat on them, the pulled pork and brisket was slightly dry but all had a rich intense bbq flavor without sauce. Their bbq sauces were delicious. The roll was really good. The Mac and cheese not pictured was Okay and the potato "casserole" was just mashed potatoes with maybe a little cheese and bacon bits barely mixed in. Nevertheless there was a line out the door for this spot so they seem to be doing alright business wise and the staff was friendly and worked efficiently without a bunch of horseplay or shooting the shit instead of doing their jobs. Again if your near the 270 Cemetery Rd/Fishinger Blvd exit areas and have a taste for BBQ give em a go. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - 3 Meat Platter Two bone ribs, pulled pork, brisket, bbq sauce, roll. Mac & Cheese and Potato "casserole" not pictured. - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I'd been to the one in Delaware, and thought it was just average. Why did I try this one? Well, to give them another chance, and of course this one might be different. Plus I love BBQ in general, and was nearby, and was starving since I'd just fasted for my physical. It's... good not great. A-OK, as Yelp says. I had a Westerner sandwich with brisket and pulled pork. Very good sandwich, held together even though loaded up- great bread. The pulled pork was very good, in texture and taste. No sauce needed. The brisket was tender and juicy, but had little flavor. I doused it in sauce - they have three fairly good sauces. The side of spicy beans was barely spicy at all. The creamed spinach side was good- comfort food. The sweet tea was not sweet- bummer. The pecan pie was very, very good, though the plastic wrap packaging makes for a sloppy mess when trying to eat it. All in all, a mixed bag. Not bad, but not amazing. Great service, decent prices. Weird access to this location- very visible from the street, but awkward to get to unless you are already at Giant Eagle. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - Westerner sandwich, creamed spinach, "spicy" beans. Oh, and pie. - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

When you travel for work and need to fuel up for a long day. Great service, friendly people, clean place and good food.

Some of the best barbecue I've ever had. Great prices. Highly recommend the westerner or the ribs. Kids eat free on sundays! read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Dickey's was... in a word... disappointing. The brisket was tasty and property cooked. The barbeque sauce was very tasty. But that's where the tasty ended... Sides were too salty and uninspiring. Mac & cheese was too salty. Mashed potatoes were too salty. Creamed spinach was - you gusted it - too salty. Save your time and money and go to City Barbeque or B&K Smokehouse. Even better - try both and try to figure out which is better (both are incredible, and the best in Columbus). read more

I finally got around to trying Dickey's Barbecue Pit last night after my husband came home from his doctor's visit in Cincinnati. Here's what we liked about it, the meats were delicious we both ordered the beef brisket and they were cooked well and succulent taste. What could have been better is their sauce, but I won't ding them on it as we didn't know which one to go with doing a carry out order here. My husband orders the 3 meat with 2 sides combo. He got the brisket and 2 different kielbasa's. We both got the creamed spinach side which was great. I got macaroni and cheese as my 2nd side and he got baked beans. The food is a lot like City BBQ where you get the sandwich or meat and 2 sides just a little more money depending on which meat combo you choose to go with. Although I will admit that the quality of this food is better than that of City BBQ's as their brisket was the best I've had in a while and so was the sides. Would I come here again? Totally, pick and day and time and I'll meet you here for lunch or dinner if you've never tried this establishment! I highly recommend it to my barbecue lovers out there. read more

Stopped by for a quick late lunch. Excellent choice! The beef brisket was flavorful and tender. The baked beans and baked potato casserole were good. The lemonade is super refreshing. The roll was smaller than I would have liked. The person taking my order was very patient as I was taking a while to look at all their choices. The one meat and two sides combo was $11.95 and it was a good amount of food. They offer catering and delivery, so I will definitely give them a try for one of our work meetings. The location is pretty small, so even though it wasn't crowded when I came in, I imagine it can get pretty crowded during high traffic times. They offer online ordering, so that may be the way to go, especially for larger orders. read more

See all

20 percent off advertising was not working through online ordering. Went into the store, showed them it wasn't working and still refused to honor their advertisement. To make it worse, they're refused with attitudes. Asked to speak with a manger and the guy calls his mother. Well after he greeted his mom in front of us, she refused to honor it as well. Puzzling isn't it? They literally could not honor their own advertisement, needless to say we left and went somewhere else. As you can see on the reviews, all they do is paste thoughtless, in genuine responses instead of making things right with customers. Save your time. read more

Got this delivered today extremely dry. Absolutely no juice at all my whole meal was bad the baked beans were almost watery the roll was raw in the middle. Tried to contact them and they said there was nothing to be done about it. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - Burnt overcook brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

This place is serving something akin to dogfood, except I wouldn't serve my dog this chow. The pork was dry enough to splinter the tongue, the brisket was a band of unrendered fat, the mac and cheese was straight up water and yellow, and the loaded mashed potatoes.... Let's not continue. This place should not be serving human food. Or any food for that matter. There are at least three BBQ places within 2 miles and I highly highly recommend you find them and slide on by this atrocity. read more

I am Sandra Newsom Brown ! I ate lunch on Aug. 11, 2023 there in Hilliard. And the lunch I bought the chicken sandwich was so delicious. The workers who work there Dalton and Shelly. They are such wonderful workers and work very hard at their job. I give them a 5 star rating for the best meal ever. read more

Some of the food items are pretty decent. Some are not good. Overall, I would say the food quality is around slightly below average. We have frequented Dickey's out of convenience as we live walking distance from this location. The service is hit or miss. The worst experience (until today) was calling in an order for pickup and when I arrived at the designated time, they had clearly not even started on my order and gave attitude when I asked how much longer it would take (waited another 25 mins btw). However, today the family had been out of town and we just wanted something quick. I called to place an order and was told, "we are way too busy right now, call back later." No "can I put you on hold for a moment?" or even "can you try ordering online?". Obviously I'm not going to call back later or, in good conscience, frequent this location again. The food simply isn't good enough to blow off customers. read more

Really rude service, basically I felt like the girl who was serving us was like "why are you here?" They started closing an hour before the close time. She put away the sauces before we could get anything..shut down the ice cream machine and was putting chairs up on the table around us. She put our food in a to go bag without asking. I will make sure none of my friends and family even consider this place. read more

I'm surprised it's been awhile since I've been here. Tried the Brisket Frito Chili ...or is it Texas Beef Brisket Chili Frito? I can't remember name but it's not bad, it's a little spicy for me but probably neutral or bland for those of you that love spicy foods. Bought my usual brisket sandwich and it is excellent. Like I've mentioned in previous review I've been to Texas, Kansas City, etc and ate BBQ from those places and all have different variations of BBQ (even in Texas has different options and there is even Korean BBQ) and the Columbus area is blessed to have a little bit of everything but I think that leads to confusion as to why some call one better or worse than others because they don't like the way it's made or taste. It's just different methods for different people. I appreciate Dickey's BBQ Pit and other BBQ's and hope they stay around a long time. I realized I forgot my favorite bread. I didn't see it. Insert sad face. But still satisfied. Thanks Dickey's. read more

See all

Very good BBQ and very affordable! We came here for the first time the other night and there was practically nobody in there. This was a good thing because we had a chance to look over the menu and ask the staff about their recommendations. They said that many people get the deal of the day which was $9.99 and included a pulled pork sandwich, two sides, and a large drink. We decided to go with that option and it turned out delicious! The buns that they use are very fresh and warm. They use this machine to get butter on bun as well which added some great flavor! I got coleslaw and cheese on top of my pulled pork sandwich and creamed spinach and mac and cheese for my sides. Creamed spinach was really good although the mac and cheese had a sharp cheddar flavor that I don't particularly like. My partner really liked it though so I gave the rest of mine to him. You will like it if you like a sharper mac and cheese flavor. The pulled pork comes without a sauce on it as they have all of their sauces in heated pots next to the soda machine. The fact that they were warm really makes a difference because there's nothing worse than putting cold sauce on a hot sandwich! They had original, sweet, and spicy sauces to choose from. I mixed the original with the sweet and it was very tasty. You can mix and match however you want to find the best combination of flavors. All in all this was a great experience and a wonderful alternative to the other BBQ chains around Columbus. read more

Dickey's Barbecue Pit - Creamed spinach and Mac and cheese - Barbeque Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

I was greeted at the door as we came in. she walked us to our seats told us about the drinks and appetizers . she said the server would be right with us . the server was at the table with our drinks in less than 2 minutes. the service was fantastic and the food was del ious read more