The last review is not kidding, this is the best pizza in the Midwest! We've been eating here for 10 years and it's still my favorite pizza spot. The food is consistent, fresh, & the customer service is excellent at all of their locations. My go to pizza order is always the hand tossed, Garlic sauce, Chicken, & chopped jalapeños. Warning- if you try this pizza you will love it and so will all your friends. The combination is so flavorful, with the garlic sauce it's not spicy at all, even my grandma loves this pizza! Our second favorite is definitely the bbq chicken pizza, plenty of sauce & chicken. All of their pizzas are very filling, evenly spread toppings. Inside the store they have 6-8 tables, always a movie playing, great for families, and feels like home! Lastly, The house made ranch dressing deserves an honorable mention, I think the pizza is great as it is but the ranch is actually quite nice for dipping. read more

See all

Magoo's is our household's go-to pizza spot for when we want a hot, delicious pizza for takeout or delivery on the west side of Indy. They have their original location on 38th street that I think the dad still runs, but the Avon location that the son runs is a tad bit closer to us (and also the one that we can do delivery from), so we almost always order from the Avon location. The owner is almost always working when we go in and is so friendly. Always remembers your name/order and makes you feel welcomed. We have been going here for years and I always rave about them to my co-workers and friends. We discovered early on that you can do half red, half garlic sauce on the pizza, so we always order a supreme that way with 2 cups of ranch. The ranch is house-made and worth the extra $1 per cup. And that is coming from a girl whose family was a blue cheese household growing up. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

By far, THE BEST pizza in the Midwest, hands down!! (I don't want to offend many people by writing best pizza in the USA, but I DO say this to everyone I mention Magoo's to) My favorite is their classic Creamy Garlic Sauce Chicken Tikka Pizza...Zabiha Halal meat, generous toppings, top-notch quality ingredients and the most unique and heavenly white garlic sauce (Everything else on the menu is pretty yum too) Also, I must mention that eating it at the restaurant vs takeout makes an immense difference. Although the pizza sits well at room temp too and also after reheating (air fryer/toaster oven works better for pizza than microwave), eating it fresh and hot hits different, and totally melts in your mouth. If you haven't tried Magoo's pizza, you have NOT had great pizza at all. read more

Spicy Hawaiian pizza & Chicken Tikka Magzone with ranch. Fast service, great food, fun vibes inside. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The service was so friendly and fast! He made excellent suggestions. The pizza was delicious. We ordered meat lovers with the garlic sauce based on recommendation from employee and a gentleman standing in the lobby. I would go here again and again when visiting Indy. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Cheese pizza and a Magooey brownie - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Continued our new (as of last year) day after Thanksgiving tradition and took the family to Magoos. Forgot to grab pics as everyone just dug in, but we had a large chicken Tikka and a large Supreme along with an order of cheesy bread. We were warmly greeted when we entered, and thanked for our business. Great locally owned establishment. Food was out very quickly and was absolutely delicious. One day I'll remember and actually get a pic of the pizzas. Definitely recommend and will try and get back before next day after Thanksgiving. read more

Coming from California I can say Food is delicious, flavor point on and crispy. 100/100 Service was fast easy to order and on time Ambiance loved it feel comfortable and friendly read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza is delicious - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Magoo's is one of those places we keep coming back to, and every time, it hits the spot. Their pizza? Top-tier. The crust is buttery and crisp, the sauce has just the right touch of sweetness, and every bite is phenomenal. The owner is just as much a reason to visit--one of the friendliest people you'll meet. He genuinely cares about making sure every customer has a great experience. This time, he recommended the Tikka pizza, so we took the leap--and wow. So cheesy, so flavorful, and such an unexpectedly delicious combo. Definitely worth trying! Of course, we couldn't leave without the jalapeño garlic bread (because, let's be real, it's impossible to pass up) and their homemade ranch, which is next-level good. If you haven't been to Magoo's yet, consider this your sign. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Jalapeno Garlic Bread with Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I was born and raised in California. Spent my first 50 years there. I don't see anything "California" about this pizza. That said, it's pretty decent pizza, but nothing to drive across town for. The ambience is just a notch above an Amtrak station, which is good to know if you're eating in. It's pretty obvious that 95% of their business is takeout. read more

We ordered a delivery order of pizza for the first time trying this. I didn't use the app to order but wish I would've. You can track the delivery and you get points for every dollar spent. I did sign up after the fact, but I wasn't able to track my order or record the points. Our pizza arrived about 15 minutes late of their estimated delivery time, but it arrived in 45 minutes, which was fine for us. Considering I ordered around dinner time so they were probably busy. We got the chicken tikka pizza and I substituted banana peppers for bell peppers, we thought it was very good and will definitely give them another try the next time we want pizza. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chicken Tikka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good pizza and friendly service. First time trying their pizza had a large supreme. Good tasting pizza but could have used a bit more sauce. 4 stars read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Came here after my OB recommended Magoos during my appointment and was pleasantly surprised! The son of THE Mr. Magoo was running the store and you could tell by the way he spoke of the business and food that he has a genuine passion for the food he makes and growing the business. It was refreshing to listen to him speak of the meat they bring in from their own farm and to see the joy on his face when he explained how long the company has been operating and what they do with their food to make it so delicious. I'm a firm believer that in order for 5 stars, it needs to be good food, service and atmosphere and magoos was it! Aladdin made our experience trying this food even more enjoyable than the way the pizza and jalepeno cheesy bread tasted (which was 10/10). Highly recommend! Update: HE BROUGHT US A COOKIE AS WE WERE LEAVING TO SAY THANK YOU FOR TRYING THEM read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pepperoni and jalapeño large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We ordered take out pizza and wings and it was delicious! The chicken tikka pizza was a hit. The wings, even though they're baked, were crispy and had a good portion of sauce. Highly recommend! read more

Food was AMAZING, got the chicken tikka and jalapeño cheese bread. The ranch is delicious!! Best pizza in Indy hands down. The service is friendly, clean and comfortable environment. Coming back for more!! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Chicken Tikka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I chose to try Magoo's because of the good reviews, however, I was highly disappointed. In it. I ordered the meat lovers pizza, a Hawaiian pizza for my child, and the garlic cheese bread. The pizza sauce was off-putting. The meat lovers had very little meat or cheese, and my child said it was the worst she's had. The garlic cheese bread tasted good, but lacked volume. It was just six inch and a half pieces. Donato's is 100% better and only a block away is you want something better. If Magoo's is the pizza quality you want, try Little Caesars or a frozen pizza. They both taste bad too, but are less than half the price. read more

First and last time I have ever ordered from Magoo's in Avon. First I order 3 pizza's totaling $60. I paid online with a credit card and went to pick up the order. I was charged a $5.34 Service Fee and I have no idea what could cost $5.34. Second, the pizza sucked. They were not that big for $20 each and the taste was average at best. On top of that the stamped dough they used is dense and very chewy. But the thing that ticks me off is the $5.34 Service Fee with no breakdown on what exactly it entails. And as a bonus, when I walked in, it smelled heavily of weed. Somebody is baking high. read more

We drove two hours for this pizza and honestly, 10/10 experience, no notes. Guy at the counter was super nice, the food was DELICIOUS, and the portions are huge like we have sm leftover !! We got the chicken tikka pizza with the white sauce and it was incredible. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Magoo's Pizza was a hit! Fusion doesn't always work, but this middle eastern pizza did more than work for dinner. RJ working the front of the restaurant was helpful the whole time. The feel of the place is exactly what you want for a good pizza dive. Give this joint a try today! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Half Chicken Tikka Pizza and Half Chappli Kabob Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Very good pizza , I ordered the sausage with white sauce and it was amazing.. Customer service was excellent .. He even brought my pizza out to the truck.. Very clean restaurant... Gone try the red sauce next time . read more

I stopped by to pick up an order for lunch, and the food was hot and ready at the time I was told while ordering! There was a parking lot in front of the restaurant that could fit about 12-15 cars, and I didn't have any trouble parking, which is always nice. The inside was pretty calm and quiet when I walked inside, and I would have liked to sit down to eat if I hadn't been in a rush I got a personal cheese pizza, but the menu had a few items that caught my eye, like the chicken tikka pizza. I believe this is one of the few pizza restaurants in the Indy area that use only halal meats in their recipes. I was able to snap a quick picture of the pizza I ordered, but the fries I ordered on the side were gone before I knew it.... They were well-seasoned, crunchy and, deliciously crispy--I wouldn't have guessed how much I would enjoy fries at a pizza restaurant :) Will be going back to try the other menu items and those fries again! read more

Magoo's California Pizza - cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great pizza! Love the white garlic sauce base on the pizza. Very good group of people. When I'm back in Indy will get it again.

I can't believe I have driven past here so many times and never stopped in. Today I decided to try a pizza, and it was a very nice experience. When I walked in I received a friendly greeting, and was asked if it was my first visit. I was given a quick explanation of the menu. I ordered a veggie pizza with garlic sauce, garlic cheese bread, and a side of ranch. The pizza was delicious, and I really loved the garlic sauce. It was covered with a generous amount of veggies, all the way to the edge. The crust was a little different, it had kind of a softer texture that was fairly unique. Garlic cheese bread was perfect, especially when dipped in the ranch. It was baked to perfection, not too hard and crunchy. The restaurant was very clean. I'm looking forward to returning to try some of the other options. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Garlic cheese bread with a side of ranch - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is always a treat for us. I think, it's the best pizza in western Hendrick's county. Their pizzas, magzones are always awesome. The have fantastic sides. We've had their pizza for many years and this is always our first choice. read more

I can't rave about this place enough! We had seen other Yelp reviews and needed to find a vegetarian/vegan friendly restaurant open early to meet a friend for lunch and picked this spot. The parking lot has ample spots and the building and signage are easily spotted from the main road. Upon entering it is obvious you order at the counter and their menu is posted behind on the wall as well as in a laminated menu at the counter. We were enthusiastically greeted by the owner/manager who asked if it was our first visit and then proceeded to give us all the specials and best loved options. He recommended the garlic sauce but as we were being good we wanted a vegan option. In the end we got a large vegetable pizza with regular crust and added spicy Indian spices. He recommended we try regular crust as it was our first visit, and we could go to the in crust another time. We had a seat as they have a few tables and it is a clean and well spaced out seating area. They only have bottled drinks so we went with water, but keep that in mind if you want to dine in. Our food came out fast and it was delicious! The sauce and veggies were ample and went all the way to the end of the crust, a personal favorite (hate being given only a few veggies)! The spicy ginger and flavoring was just right without being too much, and it was a really decent size for the price. We loved the regular crust so we were glad we took his advice. We finished almost all of it as I couldn't stop eating! We had done no cheese and found out later while chatting to the owner/manager that all his dough is vegan. Awesome! He was super kind and chatted with us and also gave us some treats that are vegan which aren't on the menu seeing as we couldn't have the other options for a sweet treat. He told us a lot about the cooking and spices and was answering all our questions about pizza and Indian spices. Wonderful spot for lunch and very kind staff! I would highly recommend going here and we might even cheat next time and try the garlic sauce they are best know for despite it being cheese based. Yummy pizza and a fun local place! read more

See all

Have been going here for 3 years with my boyfriend, every time the food is AMAZING! don't breeze past the appetizers/ sides on the menu, they are just as great as the pizza! Staff is always SO nice and helpful and they have come to know us by name! Best pizza in Indy! read more

Fantastic pizza and service ! Chicken Tika with garlic sauce is Fantastic and so was the Supreme !

Best pizza I've had in a long time, service was great, met the owner, such a great guy. Relaxed atmosphere everyone that came in was greeted by name believe it or not. Support your local businesses. read more

The pizza here is a 10/10 every time we go! I love the white garlic sauce option and multiple sizes to choose from. You will not be disappointed! read more

Went in with lots of hope after reading the positive reviews. Tried the famous chicken tikka but that was a big let down -- it had an odd sweet/tangy flavor that sounds better than it actually tastes on a pizza. Tried the veggie but the cheese was probably damaged irretrievably. Either that or something was off in the sauce. Anyway, bitterly disappointed because I really wanted to have a great pizza here. read more

Decided to meet up with friends and try a new place. Looked on line at the menu and reviews and all looked good. Night before decided to look more at the menu. And saw Halal ( what is Halal ) So a little on line research was done. Then flash backs to the beef bacon we had in Egypt, it was bad. Decided to give Magoo's a try anyway. Worst case we stop at McDonald's on the way home. We got half Chicken Tikka with Ranch Sauce and Half Pepperoni and Sausage with tomato sauce plus garlic bread with cheese. The pizza was great. I liked the Chicken half better then the pepperoni and sausage. The Halal Pepperoni and Sausage is beef not pork. So it has a diffrent taste and texture but not overly. The garlic bread with cheese was also good. Restaurant is very clean. As people left the tables and chairs were all cleaned. Service was friendly and he helped us with the menu. We will be back. read more

See all

I have wanted to stop here and eat for a long while. Only reason I have not stopped here is it is in a bad spot. The parking lot is also not that big. The dining room is also not that big but I would call it cozy. The staff is very friendly and the service was very fast even though I think they do more carry out. We got the potato wedges and they came with homemade ranch they were both delicious. Also had the garlic bread with cheese and it was very flavorful. We ordered the meat lovers although it tasted very good it was lite on toppings and I think the sausage was smoked and that was a bit odd. Dining room and bathroom's were clean I will be back to try their other pizza's and they also have a garlic pizza sauce I would like to try. I would recommend to anyone one in Avon looking for pizza. read more

See all

This has been a favorite since I was younger. I was passing through Indianapolis and had to make a stop despite it being out of the way. I am so happy that I did. I ordered a mini supreme pizza which was delicious, I am a big fan of the white sauce pizza and loved the spice of the meat. Extremely flavorful! I also got the chicken tikka pizza which is awesome! I love that they add plenty of chicken that is finely cut up. Everything is seasoned well and the flavors are great! Will stop by again when I drive through the city again! read more

See all

TL;DR: Really good, but not quite my style of pizza. Food: We got a large 1/2 Chicken Tikka, 1/2 Chappli Kabob as these were the top recommended. The reviews aren't wrong, these are very good pizzas, but they definitely have their own niche and unfortunately aren't quite my style. Service: Ordered to-go over the phone, no issues. Price: About average for a large pizza, but they let you split 1/2 and 1/2 with the specialties which is really nice. Overall: Glad I tried it, but not quite for me. I would definitely recommend you give it a try though if you're on the fence. read more

Wow, the ratings don't lie with this gem of a pizza joint! From the ordering (via phone) to pick-up, it was a super easy and friendly process. The man at the counter was so nice, and even complimented my outfit. He offered me a side of their ranch salad dressing as well and mentioned it was homemade. I was also impressed my the overall cleanliness of the store's interior. When I arrived home, the size of my medium pizza was quite surprising...a great value! Prices have understandably gone up in recent times, but their medium rivals some large pizzas I've had from other places. Both the pizza and ranch tasted very fresh. I'll absolutely come back again and recommend this spot to friends, as well. read more

See all

They have a take on pizza that is out of the ordinary. It tasted good and very fresh. The people are very nice and helpful. read more

Magoo's California Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

excellent service and food. fast friendly and very kind, the chicken tikka pizza was phenomenal. add a little house ranch to really top it off. 10/10 will go back and recommend for anyone looking for a good pizza read more

Different take on amazing pizza. Regular options as well but you have to try something new! Family owned !

Italian food with no italian salad dressing. They are not aware of difference between fresh and dry mozzarella. I elected to avoid. Anyone can put toppings on dough... but really thought I would give them a try. Only disappointed. read more

whoever the guy is running the place Friday nights is an awesome guy! Best pizza in Avon and the customer service is what helps me decide its def a five star place of business!!!! Go try magoos you WILL NOT be disappointed. read more

Hands down one of the most unique and flavorful pizzas I've had; the chicken tikka pizza. I also got the pepperoni pizza and that's was top quality for this type of pizza staple. The ambience was clean and open and the staff were very nice. read more