Fast, friendly service and exciting flavors to choose from. They have a few tables inside as well as an outdoor seating area. It was tough to choose which kind of ice cream I wanted to try (because, really, I wanted them all), but I managed to settle on three of their specialty flavors: grandma's banana cream pie, carrot cake and marshmallow peep. They were all very good, but I enjoyed the banana cream pie the best with real pieces of banana in it and no fake, runt-like, banana flavoring. My dad hit the brownie mudslide and chocolate peanut butter. He said the chocolate peanut butter was really good and the best one he's ever had. read more

See all

Cute inside, cozy. I used to go there all the time when I was a kid but now I can't have icecream without it coming back up unfortunately. delicious here. great spot so you could walk around. service was always good when I went. read more

Last visited a WHILE ago, so when I saw their April Fools post for 2025, Pizza Ice-cream sounded weird enough to try! It was $1 per scoop and the donations went towards an event for local veterans. Who could say no to that?? Lines were long, it was refreshing to see so many members of the community trying this ice cream and donating to the cause. It was cold but worth it. I got 3 scoops for my family and I and a store made cotton candy stick ice cream they had available for myself for just incase. Pizza ice cream was icky to me, but from the crowd watching, and my family's reaction, the taste and likeability was extremely mixed. The cotton candy bar was a refresher for after. And refresh it did! It was very yummy, and with their amazing customer service, and yummy flavors they have available, I WILL be back. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - 3 scoops of pizza ice cream and my cotton candy bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

Family owned, family operated amazing gem in the village of Hamburg. Remind you of an old-fashioned ice cream parlor. Even has the chairs like Carvels used to have when we were kids. The ice cream is delicious. They have many flavors custom novelties and more. We literally drive 40 minutes to come here for the molasses ice cream cookie. The family that owns. This is always friendly. It is clean and a asset to the community. Love the atmosphere of the people the prices are fair and the ice cream taste like ice cream. Five stars. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Love coming to this place to try all the different flavors. I tried the key lime and honey Lavender. Nice sized scoops and decently priced.. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

I was here to experience the eclipse ice cream. It is chocolate ice cream mixed with orange sherbet. The orange sherbet is nicely refreshing; the chocolate, is good, but not as rich as I hoped it would be. Perhaps a dark chocolate ice cream? My serving was fine. A single scoop is reasonable priced. It is a very small ice cream shop, with only four small tables. read more

Some new additions to the menu, since my previous post include gluten free/ dairy free sandwiches, an oat milk variation which is vegan/ dairy free, Christmas in July flavors and Lavender Honey hard ice cream. This was the perfect way to cool off on a hot and sunny day. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Menu and dole whip & raspberry sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

Awesome ice cream shop has lots of great flavors, generous portions and friendly staff!

Okay SO GOOD. We stopped here after dinner, there's a reason there's always a line. I will absolutely be back. I got their cookies and cream, and as a self proclaimed ice cream connoisseur, this was probably the creamiest and most delicious version I've ever had. I could eat a gallon to myself. The line is well worth it, once you order, service is super quick. Pleaseeee go here, you won't be disappointed. read more

I'm not embarassed to say that I've practically become a regular here. I had to up my review score because this place really does deserve a 5 out of 5. So many different ice cream options and you can't get any better than their home made options like monster mash or pumpkin pie. I also have to give them alot of credit for their home made dairy free options such as almond milk and oatmilk soft serve. I also love the doggy sundae that they offer for the puppers. This ice cream shop is by far the best in Hamburg and will continue to give them my service whenever I have a craving! read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Vanilla soft serve with cherry dip and oatmilk soft serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

Stopped here just before Christmas to get some seasonal flavors for home.  Who can resist the sounds of Gingerbread Man and Eggnog, especially knowing that they are homemade?  Well since it was the week of Christmas, they had shortened hours and weren't open until the evening.  I figured I would shoot the owners a message via Facebook to see if there was any possibility of picking up in the afternoon the following day.  They quickly responded and told me to give them a call to see if I could set something up.  I ended up chatting with Randy, one of the owners, who gave me his phone number and told me to give him a call the next day when I was in town and he would make sure he was there.  How nice!  And sure enough, the next day, he had my pints of ice cream ready to go. And let me tell you, the flavors are spot-on.  I was surprised, but the eggnog ended up being my favorite.  I'm not even upset I didn't get actual eggnog this year, because the ice cream made up for it. Can't wait to try more seasonal flavors. read more

See all

Enjoyed some ice cream today at Main Street Ice Cream in Hamburg, New York. Nice little shop on Main Street with really friendly service and great ice cream! There is seating inside or out and establishment was very clean. They have soft and hard ice cream and ready to go items and cakes as well. Very nice unexpected treat! read more

See all

I ordered the ice cream cake sundae and got a few bites into it before I remembered to take a picture! It tastes exactly like their ice cream cake. The service was very good and very fast. I love their outdoor seating options, it's great to sit and enjoy their ice cream. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - ice cream cake sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

We decided to stop here quickly but I'm so glad we did. They make the ice cream themselves and it took less than 5 minutes for both of our items to be out. They had seating outside as well as inside and you could also order from the outside. Very cute little place to stop by to fill your ice cream craving. read more

See all

I loved this little place on my visit on the Fourth of July this year and I had to go with their specialty fourth of July ice-cream! My sundae came out super quick and it was colorful and tasty. The staff were very friendly and pricing was good as well. I love their location on Main Street and there are benches nearby to sit and watch people and traffic go by. A great little ice-cream stand and a nice part of summer! read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Best ice cream and service around! Always friendly service. The smell of fresh made waffles is amazing as you walk in the door. I love the old milk bottles and pictures. read more

Absolutely love this place. It's a locally-owned business and they make their flavors. The line may get crazy during the summer but it's worth it. read more

Main Street ice cream is my favorite place to get ice cream in Hamburg. I used to love Charlotte, but I've changed it to Main Street. I especially love a double scoop of mint chocolate chip and a waffle cone dipped in chocolate. read more

Fast and friendly service, lots of choices like soft serve ice cream, Sundaes, smoothies, floats and milkshakes.I tried the caramel Sundae and it was very delicious. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Speedy service with a smile , I tried the very delicious strawberry sundae.So much to choose from including a banana split, slushies, floats, smoothies and sundaes. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Read about this place online so we packed up the kid and drove 20 minutes to come try it- definitely not disappointed! My son couldn't decide between literally every flavor so we got him a flight and narrowed it down to 4. I had the pretzel cone and it was delicious! We're already planning when to come back! read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Flight of icecream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

I expected something a little other than Turkey Hill and Upstate Farms ice cream when I came here, so I was disappointed. Despite the mass-produced and distributed ice cream, it's still a fine ice cream store that will surely fill your needs and will be a better alternative than going to a chain place (tastier and prices are competitive). There's an outdoor patio (of course, there has to be!) as the inside is a little too warm / stuffy on the hotter days. I ordered an "Almond Joy" sundae which was delicious with freshly chopped almonds and nuts and a topping of whipped cream and a cone on top. The vanilla soft-serve it came with was tasty, but all that chocolate syrup they put in there was overkill. I thoroughly enjoyed it though and ate every last bite. My friend ordered a milkshake and although I didn't try it, he assured me it was delightful. If I'm in the area, I'll be back, but I'm not sure I'd go out of my way to get here. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Almond Joy. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

This place has some of the best ice cream I've had in Buffalo. The portions are huge and everything tasted super fresh. The menu also had a ton of interesting options and I can't wait to go back and try something else there. read more

The ice cream homemade ice cream in the store is excellent. I recommend the coconut flavored ice cream that's my favorite. The service was also good. The ambience is great too photos of old businesses, various statues of cows, etc. etc. read more

We are lucky to live close enough to walk to Main Street Ice Cream. It is our favorite place to go for ice cream! I love that they have specialty flavors throughout the season. My all time favorite has been carrot cake. They have all the traditional flavors as well as a lot of originals, like Key Lime Pie (another favorite!). They've been doing a great job during Covid keeping everyone safe by using their take out window and maintaining 6 feet distance while waiting in line. Keep up the good work and thank you for all that you're doing for Hamburg! read more

Great ice cream place, every year they get better and better. Friendly owners and excellent staff. Great inside and outside venue for a family treat (including the pup)! Warm and welcoming atmosphere and even better is they are VERY SUPPORTIVE of the local community. Would give them 10 stars if I could! read more

Awesome awesome awesome!!! I see other reviewers on here mentioning they have nothing unique..... well, they must not have been here in a while because I found all kinds of great things here. When we grabbed some ice cream here I found a huge unique selection of great frosty treats. One thing I didn't try, but stood out to me was the home made blueberry ice cream. I had some sort of sundae which consisted of delicious ice cream, peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, peanut butter cups and resees pieces, a piece of a waffle cone and whipped creme. It was awesome and HUGE!! Great place for a cold treat with the family on a hot summer day. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Me: "Man, I really wish there was an ice cream place around here." *Looks up* "hey! An ice cream place across the parking lot!" Really glad we stumbled across this place our first visit to Hamburg. The staff is very friendly and didnt seem to be bothered by the fact that it took us forever to decide what to order (too many delicious looking things). I settled on the homemade peanut butter fudge ice cream popsicle. It was SO good! Just the perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate. Can't wait to come back! read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Peanut butter fudge ice cream pop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Hand made ice cream and you really can tell the difference. Always grab a few pints for the freezer and with a variety of flavors in addition to monthly specials you can't go wrong. Takes you back to the days of old school ice cream parlors. They always have a long line due to the COVID precautions but worth the wait. Highly recommended for a sweet treat while you stroll through the Village of Hamburg. read more

Where to begin??? Ice cream is one of my favorite things and Main Street does it so well that whenever I want to get ice cream out it's usually the place I go. They're creative with their flavors and keep things fresh. My favorite flavor is key lime. It's fun to take the dog for a treat here too. read more

So Lee and I were on our way back from hanging out with some friends down near Angola, and we'd made a few geocaching stops on the way back. It was getting hot. It was time for some ice cream. We checked to see what was close, and this is what popped up. I was honestly a little bit disappointed with this place, price wise. Their sundaes are good, and they have a nice selection of ice cream to choose from. The amount of ice cream for the price was not that great though. I'm not looking to enjoy a gallon of ice cream, mind you, but although the ice cream was good, it was nothing spectacular, and I am not sure if we'd come back. read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

A small village creamery with all of its own homemade ice cream. My husband and I were in the mood for milkshakes, but I can't wait to try the cones. The price is reasonable, less than $10 total for two milkshakes. The to-go window outside makes it super easy to grab something on the run, but there is a spacious inside if you need some more time to decide. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Drool- the waffle cone smell. We walked in and I knew I had to have one. I got mine with banana ice cream. "The cone is warm because it just came off the griddle, so the ice cream may melt a little faster." ... No problem, sir. Fresh waffle cone and homemade ice cream?-- it didn't stand a chance :) read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Waffle cone and banana ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Main Street Ice Cream is, by all appearances, just the kind of friendly neighborhood ice cream shop everyone wants to have next door, with fun signs on the walls, nice folks behind the counter, and some pretty delicious-looking flavors in the case. According to Merridy K, who first recommended this shop to me, the store has decided not to raise their prices this year, in order to continue providing affordable treats to their neighbors. So, as Smita C says: seems like the people here are as sweet as their sundaes. Though there are a lot of full-cream flavors from Turkey Hill Dairy (a PA-based ice cream producer), the tart yogurt with fruit is also a yummy, refreshing option for mid-summer. Not every ice cream shop in this area has it, so enjoy it if you live nearby! read more

Main Street Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

We always enjoy the homemade ice cream flavors at Main Street Ice Cream in Hamburg. Small place with a selection of homemade ice cream, custard, or shaved ice. We recently tried the buffalo chicken wing dip ice cream (special limited time) and it was good. Best part is our $1 - 1 scoop try went to a charity. Try the peanut butter ice cream it's delicious! read more

Perfect day for a milkshake! My wife and I were walking around at the annual Burgerfest and it was so hot and we treated ourselves to some nice cold milkshakes. They were reasonably priced and the selections were good. I went with the raspberry milkshake and it perfectly hit the spot. I am excited to come back to try some of their ice cream! read more

See all

Talk about the small business owners putting themselves out there for customers- I applaud the owners of Main Street Ice Cream for a recent email that they sent out to us customers. I've copied it below, please read and then show your support for these fine members of our lovely village. Three cheers for them!!!! Opening tomorrow - Thursday, March 8th Let Spring begin We at Main Street Ice Cream are sick of everything going up in price, so have decided we are going to put our foot down and did not increase prices this year on our menu items. We are a family oriented ice cream parlor and care about you, our customer, and want to make your family outing a fun event, not a stressful one. Most other places raised their prices but try to make you feel better by giving you a coupon every couple weeks. We at Main Street Ice Cream are going to cut back on advertising and coupons and pass that savings on to you everyday. Same great quality products, with even a few new products this year. Believe me this is a little hard to do, since most of our items went up in price, so we are going to ask you - our loyal customers and friends to help. Pass this email on to everyone you know, put it on facebook and get the talk going. "Go to Main Street Ice Cream - we are fighting back and not going to take the price increases any more." "You deserve it" Hope to see you this weekend. read more

Great place great ice cream home town atmosphere awesome for a night with the family. Hidden gem of Hamburg definitely check it out!

I don't know why everyone's so disappointed that they serve Turkey Hill ice cream. They're not claiming to or trying to be an artisan ice cream stand (side note: if you're looking for that, try Lake Effect in Lockport; also excellent). They serve a great product, are fantastic people, love that their local, and do a few specials like fresh squeezed lemonade slushies (amazing!). They are my go to ice cream place! **And really, fresh squeezed lemonade or limeade slushies, it doesn't get better!** read more

Reasonable portions (if you get the baby size...haha) for reasonable prices. If you like a lot of ice cream, consider the medium or - if you dare - the large. What an awesome late night treat! read more