Food is good if you can get in..,, visited before and did wait but we had kids in the party this time, and it's not worth the wait. The bar is not a welcoming spot for kids to wait (it's not welcoming either because it's so bright - not cozy at all). Actually this spot is not cozy even in the dining room, but if you can get a seat, food is good and the prices are really reasonable. Go for the fish - you can't go wrong with fish here. read more

Meh. Very underwhelmed. Food was akin to eating at a Ponderosa. Waitstaff was not friendly or accommodating. Was lead to believe this was a great place. Don't waste your time! read more

Wow, what an amazing experience! We were staying in Sheboygan for the night on our way up to Door. We love the whole supperclub experience and always try to find new ones. You know it's got to be good when they have a system for reservations. Reservations for the week open on Wednesdays and I called and was able to get in on the Thursday night we were staying. I knew they had a bar so we got there a little early, Its very much in a neighborhood, in the woods. Very cool looking and just looks like a picture of authenticity. It's divided into 2 rooms, you enter in the bar and the restaurant is next door. The bartenders were very friendly and nice, we had a few old fashions as one should do at a supperclub bar. $4 drinks...crazy, all in all for what we got the place is an amazing bargain. We saw an appetizer that was kinda different called Chippers - homemade chips with parm and truffle oil..... amazing, better than we expected. We both got Walleye, which was really good. They have great warm rolls, I got mine with a loaded baked potato and coleslaw and my wife got the caesar salad and coleslaw. We also had wonderful Strawberry Rhubarb crisp for dessert. The food was amazing, the atmosphere was great, and the service was great. We even at one point saw a bunch of deer in the back through their big picture windows. An amazing experience, one of the best we have had. read more

See all

Wonderful staff with great quality fresh food. Everything tasted great. So glad we found this restaurant read more

Steak is amazing! Also the coconut shrimp. You can see many animals out there window while dining. You NEED a reservation, and it is a long wait, but food is worth it. read more

2nd time coming to Majerle's and would go again. The service is so friendly even when they are busy. The dining area is small so expect a wait if you don't have a reservation. The old fashioneds are excellent and so is the tenderloin and blue gill. Tried the fried ravioli this time and would order again for an app. read more

Great atmosphere with a view of the deer outside the window we were seated at. Service was excellent and very attentive and friendly Steaks were excellent and tender read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - Quite a surprise with our 'neighbors' while we had dinner - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Great place, Great Food, Great Drinks, Nice big picture windows to view wild life. Super wait staff and friendly. Reservation required call Wednesday after 2 PM. read more

Wow! What a place. A true Wisconsin Supper Club experience. Step back in time...Order a Brandy old fashioned to start your experience. Move into the dining room for the unique experience to continue. Excellent food & service awaits as you take in the ambiance of being in the woods. Pay attention and you'll see some of the forest creatures up close. read more

Definitely the place locals visit. We had a party of 10 adults and 5 children. We called in advance and the table was ready, no wait despite the restaurant was nearly full at 5:30.. I had their 4 piece broasted chicken and the meat was very moist with a very tasty light coating. My wife had walleye and it was also moist and fried just right. It will now become our go to place when we visit Sheboygan again. read more

See all

It was a Friday during lent so we sought out a Fish Fry while staying in the area 2 months ago. Yelp reviews directed us here and glad they did!! We posted up at the bar and had a few Wisconsin Old Fashioned's and after a 20 minute wait, our table was ready. I will say everyone was friendly and while it's filled with locals, alcohol brings everyone together! The perch fish fry was amazing as was the server and it was a nice portion served which was 2 large pieces and fries. I'm not sure we'll be back in this neck of the woods anytime soon but I would come back here for sure! Some parking available but a tip here. For an after dinner drink at the bar, get a Dirty Girl Scout. It's the perfect after dinner drink. read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - Entrance - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Arrived at announced the desk we here early and had a seat at the bar and had a well made martini and it was reasonably priced got a table by the window and ordered a steak medium rare and it came out perfect this is a place where locals eat read more

Food is not only very good but also very reasonable. It's no wonder the place is always busy. The staff is amazing behind the bar as well as the wait staff and hostess! The ambiance also deserves a shout out as you can watch wonderful wildlife while you dine. Pretty awesome! read more

Cute supper club, surrounded by trees. Saw deer outside dining room window. Great food, reasonable prices. Broasted chicken & potatoes were delicious. Prime rib soup was great. Hubby had blue gill special & said it was wonderful. Warm rolls, tasty spinach & artichoke dip with crispy pita chips. Great attentive service. Love supper clubs & this was top-notch. read more

We stopped in on a Sunday evening and told it was a 40 minute wait for a table. We sat at the bar and had a drink and 20 minutes later our table was ready. We were greeted by our server, Katie who was friendly and attentive. I ordered the special which was 2 pieces of broasted chicken, beef tips and gravy over mashed potatoes and soup or salad. I opted for the seafood chowder which was so delicious. My wife ordered the Black River entree salad which was huge and packed with strawberries, orange, almonds, and red onions over greens. It was excellent and priced at only $13.50. This is a small restaurant with moderate noise level. All the employees were very friendly. We live 60 miles away but will return. read more

We stopped in from out of town on a Friday evening and were surprised reservations were encouraged given the smaller, local, hidden feel this place has. By the end of our experience here, we understood why. I got the fried fish sandwich with a side of sweet potato fries. It's not often I'm so impressed by sweet potato fries. They're perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Nicely seasoned. The fish was crisp and high-quality as well. Flavorful tartar sauce and buns toasted to perfection. We'll be thinking about our meal here for some time and will definitely be back next time we visit Sheboygan. read more

What a surprising find! made a detour her after reading the reviews and will likely become one of our frequent stops. We had the broasted chicken meal which came out hot and crispy. The meat was tender and juicy. Even the white meat was delicious. We sampled both of the made from scratch soups. both of which were quickly devoured by the kids. The kids meals (mini tacos, chicken tenders, and fish) were fresh with lots of flavor. All came with crispy and perfectly salty fries. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating with my daughters diet. We were sat very quickly despite being pretty busy and our food was served equally fast. Great little diamond that is worth the drive! read more

Showed up at 5:45 on a Saturday, no reservation & 1:10 wait. We Secured a seat in the bar and were served within 20 minutes! Great service, classic WI Old Fashion was perfect, thank you Abby! Had fried green tomatoes and O rings for apps, delicious! Wife had prime rib, perfectly done! I had the ribeye, also fantastic! Great atmosphere inside and out as we watched several deer just outside the window. Could not have asked for a better meal and experience! read more

I hate writing bad reviews but our experience was not good. We went here based upon reviews and I don't know if it was just an off night or what but we were pretty disappointed. My husband ordered the haddock fish fry and the pieces were super thin and overcooked. I had the bluegill and it was good but not great. We both had fries and they were the ones that had some coating on them, not homemade, which I am not a fan of, though they were cooked well. The coleslaw was inedible and the color was off. Seemed really old and flavor was not good. Tartar sauce was fine though salad dressing based versus mayo which we prefer. Rolls were good. He had a beer and I had an old-fashioned which was not good. Tasted like nothing. read more

Excellent food and atmophere. Drinks were very good and the fish fry was awesome. Will definitely be back.

Great spot! Service was terrific as was the food. Have an old fashioned while you are there.

Loved this place. Great north woods feeling vibe but not in the north woods. The food was delicious. And we had a deer show with our dinner! read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - deer in the woods - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Lovely supper club, set in the woods south of town. Ordered the fried bluegill, which was excellent. They know what they're doing! Watching the deer feed outside the picture windows was the bonusl read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Welcoming hometown service, and excellent food. Our table had ribs (fall off the bone), broasted chicken, stir fry veg, garlic mashed, salads and rolls. Everything felt home cooked and fresh, even kid friendly for pulling the chicken and vegetables off for our toddlers. Deer out the window, and not too loud. Thank you for adding to our family vacation! read more

Business is good, so the parking lot was full and we had to park on the road without a parking lane. The bar was full, so no place to sit and enjoy cocktails while we waited for a table. The wait for a table was 90 minutes. I would avoid going there on a Friday night but would go back because the food was good and prices were reasonable. read more

A wonderful restaurant, great atmosphere and friendly service. We ate there Saturday evening after hiking with friends. I had the Prime Rib which was delicious. Our server, Katie, was positively friendly and professional. Terrific food at a phenomenal price. read more

Great place to eat...the food is delicious! Highly recommended! Don't miss this restaurant!

We chose this restaurant based on Yelp reviews & so happy we did! We really liked the setting in the woods. Our meals were terrific & the prices were moderate. I had the haddock grilled & it was quite good, particularly considering I requested no salt. Our salads were excellent, as was the vegetable. Plan to return. read more

Awesome little dinner spot it's hard to get a seat sometimes but that's because the food is so good. The broasted chicken is my personal favorite. read more

While on our way to visit my grandparents, we stopped in Oostburg with plans to have an early dinner at our usual place we had found years earlier when they were in their previous location. But alas, by the time we made it from the airport, they had closed 15 minutes earlier. We searched Yelp for some place nearby to eat, and saw this place in Yelp's list. With a good rating in what we considered to be the middle of nowhere, we set off to our new destination; but really, let's face it, a restaurant in the middle of nowhere with mostly good ratings is bound to be good eats. When we walked in the front door, we stepped into the bar, and thinking the Yelp listing was way off. Turned out the restaurant was in the back. It had a cozy feel, kind of like being in a larger version of a home dining room. We were one of the first diners to arrive that day, which worked out great. Apparently it is common for this out-of-the-way gem to have an hour wait or longer for the restaurant side. For as quickly as it became busy, the service was still great and the food was excellent. There was more perch than I could eat so I took mine home. When I went for my perch later that evening, imagine my surprise to find my container had made its way to the trash can with no trace of my perch anywhere. I can only surmise that my remaining perch was delicious by the lack of any evidence that it had ever been in the container. If you have the chance, definitely make a trip here for some good food. read more

The absolute best!! The staff, cocktails, and food is fantastic. We are lucky to live close but definitely worth the drive when lived in the Milwaukee area. Highly recommend! read more

First I have to say: Always a great meal. The atmosphere is warm and the bartenders have been there a very long time so they know you even when you haven't been in for a while. Love the location! read more

I stopped in last night, and while I've always been a fan of the food, I question their safety protocols. I came in wearing a mask, and was disappointed to see that not one person sitting at the bar had a mask on. The only person I saw wearing a mask was the bartender, and she had it pulled down under her nose, to the point that her lips were visible. I wore my mask the entire time I waited for my order, and was rudely stared at by the other patrons. When I left, someone actually baaa'd at me. I laughed, as I'm not sure why my wearing a mask was bothering these people so much. I'll not be back as safety doesn't seem to be a priority. read more

Little place in the woods. The food was amazing and not over priced. Highly reccomend

Our first choice for dinner when up from Illinois We don't have anything close to the Black River Grill at home. We gave a difficult time finding anything close to B.R.G. on Monday and Tuesday. The owner, manager is Nichole who we call our Black River Girl. read more

When we walked in we were a little worried because you walk into a bar. In the back is the restaurant, the prices and food were amazing. The widow looks out into a wooded area where we got to watch 5 deer. We stopped at the restaurant after I found it on Yelp, because we had just flew in from out of state. It was so good we stopped again as we left Wisconsin. read more

This place is great. The people are AMAZING and the food is DELICIOUS!!!!! Must try the Broasted Chicken. read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Ordered my nye take out meal at 230pm that day. We drove 30 minutes there and 30 minutes back to Plymouth where we live to find one lobster tail missing, inedible prime rib. Asked for medium rare, the steak was barely cooked and my boyfriend wasn't even able to swallow and swallow it. It was all cartilage. This was an $85.00 wasted on an incorrect and inedible meal. Thanks. read more

A wonderful place that is tucked away on a beautiful stretch of road. And the food and service was wonderful.

This was a delightful find. The atmosphere was warm and cozy with the fireplace lit and snow on the ground. We were told that we missed the Free grazing outside the dining room window. The Old Fashion we ordered was outstanding and we had to have two. The special was a porterhouse steak which was delicious along with the house salad, baked potato and best of all warm bread. We ordered an appetizer of cheese curds, it is Wisconsin after all, and devoured the whole thing. We too a lot of our main meal home because we wanted dessert and it was well worth the sacrifice... always save room for their dessert. read more

Majerle's Black River Grill - American Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all