Marco Polo Pizzerias

The second time we've been here. Had pizza the first time and a a sausage and pepper roll this…read moretime. we sat outside, Our waitress Olivia brought us coffee and drinks and took care of us The pizza and roll were both very good. i would highly recommend it.

Over rated The 16 inch pie is called "large" every one know…read morethat is a small or med pie! 18 inch is the standard large! Over priced for sure too.

Counter service area very clean.

Big Mac slice. Pie of the week. Tasty!

See all

Food counter

Mozzafiato Pizzeria

4.3(115 reviews)

5.4 mi

Better than Most My…read morefamily, at one time or another, have eaten at all Pizzerias/Italian restaurants in our town and neighboring towns. All were very good. We discovered Mazzofiato about a year gone. This pizzeria/restaurant surpasses all the others we've been to. They offer a typical diverse menu always served hot. The sauce used seems to taste better. The staff is always accommodating and friendly. If you want extra sauce, they'll provide it. The restaurant is always clean and the atmosphere pleasant. Take-out service is prompt with home delivery available via third-partly. I have no reservations giving a five-star rating. If you're in the neighborhood, please stop in and meet their staff. I'm certain you won't be disappointed.

What an amazingly delicious pizzeria serving some incredibly mind blowing pizzas. Their upside down…read morevodka is a show stopper, I would drive an hour just to eat this slice but when every other slice looking equally as incredible, this drive would be a no brainer. One of my favorite pizzeria's period. Such friendly customer service and large dining area to enjoy these great creations. Highly highly recommend if you love Pizza. FYI regular slice is amazing as well as all the other flavor options.

See all

Nashville chicken

Edesia Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.5(34 reviews)

1.3 mi

usually, this place is good but today it was terrible. got a sausage and pepper with hardly any…read moresausage on it and didn't look like it was cooked well and an anti-pasta salad that tasted funny like it wasn't fresh. Not going there again second time it was gross. I'm done.

Food was good, great place to grab a bite after the nearby MacArthur pickup. I got the BBQ chicken…read moreslice and was really happy with it, also had a pepperoni slice, which was okay. Ambiance - dining area is more pizzeria type than restaurant, but at least it's chairs and tables, not booths. They do have a full menu. Service - Gio was really great and overall, good experience. I'd go back when I'm in the area.

Decor

See all

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

4.5(126 reviews)

7.7 mi

Amazing restaurant once again. Other things I tried and that I would recommend are the ricotta…read moretoast , the arancini rice balls ( amazingly creamy and addicting ), the pizzeria chicken but with grilled chicken , the wings ( I only tried the buffalo and they are meaty and soft but crispy ) , the ceaser salad wrap ( the dressing is soooo good and the wrap is like this soft scrumptious pizza dough wrap ), the bruschetta pie, and the bar pie ( simple and doesn't look like something to order but trust me so flavorful but it does have a bit savory and sweet which I love ). I honestly haven't tried something that I didn't like .

Skip the Sicilian!!!!…read more Crust was old. Many pizzerias make the Sicilian crust ahead of time and you run the risk of serving dry, stale tasting crust. Our first time trying this place but that's a big deal. I can't even tell you the sauce and cheese were good since the overall taste was ruined.

Chicken chili pizza

See all

Me and my bestie.

Colosseo

4.1(400 reviews)

10.4 mi

New to the area and we've been looking for a new pizza spot...WE FOUND IT!! Pizza was AMAZINGread more

Stopped by Colosseo Pizza recently and it felt like stepping right back into my childhood. I used…read moreto come here all the time as a kid, and even though it's been years, that same no-frills, neighborhood pizza place energy is still very much alive. We started by sharing a salad and WOW. Do not skip it. It's one of those simple Italian salads that somehow just hits perfectly, and adding the mozzarella is an absolute must. Fresh, generous portions, and way better than you'd expect from a classic pizza joint. I could've eaten the whole thing myself and been happy. We each grabbed a slice and shared some garlic knots, which were warm, soft, and loaded with garlic flavor (aka exactly what you want). The slices were classic New York-style, nothing overdone, just solid, comforting pizza that reminds you why these spots never go out of style. The menu keeps things simple in the best way. Pizza, slices, and, salads. All the staples you expect, no unnecessary extras. It makes ordering easy and keeps the focus on what they do well. You're not here for trendy toppings or experimental flavors, you're here for reliable, satisfying food. The vibe inside is super casual and welcoming. It feels like a true local spot where regulars come in, families stop by, and no one's trying too hard. The staff were friendly and easygoing, which just adds to the comfort factor. I'm already looking forward to coming back, and next time, I might just order that salad for myself.

The pizza options

Extra cheeses and mushroom...soo good!

See all

Pizza Stop

4.5(115 reviews)

4.6 mi

Stopped here for a quick slice of pizza and it was 10/10. Had to come back later in the week for…read moreanother. Friendly staff, the perfect pizzeria in my opinion.

Sorry to say. This place is now terrible. Sal is a great guy but seems to be overwhelmed now and…read morethe food is suffering. I have gotten a burned pizza from there twice now and had to return it. I don't mean properly charred, I mean, burnt. Why is he microwaving heroes ?? This destroys the bread and render it in edible within 10 minutes. The young guy who sometimes answers the phone there has zero personality and is almost sub-verbal. Everything in the place is old, worn out and filthy. Sad.

The front

FOCCACIA PIZZA - Sicilian crust, crushed plum tomatoes, garlic and olive oil, light cheese. Delicious!

See all

Pizzeria Undici

4.3(125 reviews)

20.1 mi

Excellent Pizza. Thinnest crust around - sauce is on the sweet side. Regular slice is excellent…read moreand I fully recommend the Spicy Margherita, & the Pepperoni Hot Honey. Top 5 spot on Long Island.

I Ordered at 11:40am on a WEDNESDAY! Asked for an CRISPY…read moreupside down pie. 1 and 1/2 hours later, They delivered the SOGGIEST pizza, that I have ever had in my entire NEW YORK life. Even the CANNED SODA WAS WARM. I mean seriously? At $32 a pie... You guys should be ashamed of yourselves. No excuses. Terrible experience. This is how businesses fail. You came highly recommended.

Inside

See all

La Focaccia

4.3(279 reviews)

15.0 mi

I walked in at 915pm on a Monday night and when I pulled up I realized the pizza slice case was…read moreempty. I figured I would walk in just to get a drink knowing they closed at 930 to be welcomed by all staff. Remaining slices were offered and the team of three even offered to warm up like it was not closing time. When I asked about knots they said no problem. What they didn't know is I hadn't eaten all day and just wanted a slice after long travel day. I was so thankful to be greeted, get great service, amazing food from an amazing place at closing time . I always remember to combination of service and food being really good but I have say even at closing the same standards! Thank you for always being amazing and allowing me to buy dinner:) I am so incredibly sorry to walk in so late but thank you all!

I have not had such delicious penne, à la vodka, and fried calamari in very long. We stopped by…read morehere after going to White Post Farms. It's literally around the corner and it was so delicious. Staff was friendly. Excellent excellent. I will probably be Uber food from here all the way to Queens.

930 closing amazing grandma, baked ziti and knots

See all

Cheese Pizza Slice

Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant

4.0(435 reviews)

4.5 mi

Branchinellis always has great food. They make a very good pizza and they have the best pepperoni…read morein the area. The restaurant is always clean and the counter staff is friendly. I typically recommend the Sicilian pizza but the round is good as well. The staff is always friendly and their prices are good. There is plenty of parking and it's a huge space so you're never waiting very long at all.

Love this place! The service is great, the food is like 'comfort,' food for me too! I love the…read morepizza too... my fav's is their pasta with garlic and oil with a side of chicken.... The eggplant, lasagna-too! It's always busy but the line goes quick! My husband and I have been going to Branchinelli's for over 20 years! Our grandson now comes with us and LOVES their focaccia bread

Spaghetti and meat sauce

See all

Exterior.

Carmelina's Pizzeria and Ristorante

4.0(31 reviews)

5.4 mi

Great pizza in the corner of Uncle Guiseppe shopping center in Smithtown. Friendly service and…read morequality pizza Can stand up with the big boys of Brooklyn and Queens Try and judge for yourself

Now let's keep it real, it's very hard to find a good pizzeria that is worth 5 stars especially in…read moreNew York when there's a pizzeria on every corner. Now this is Tucked away in the corner of the parking lot with lots of competition around so it may go unnoticed. But from the food and the service from the girl at the counter this was a great experience. The inside is very cool, they also serve alcohol. I loved the decor all over. Now it is a bit pricy, I paid about $7 for a buffalo chicken slice which is fine considering the amount of chicken they put on the slice! This slice was loaded. I asked for it well done and they delivered. The buffalo chicken slice was crispy, no flop at all and loaded with flavor. Absolutely great place, now granted my rating is based off just trying this once but it was outstanding. The girl who works the counter is super sweet and very very well deserving of 5 stars herself. When I'm in the area I am excited to come back and try some more of their pizza. Great experience.

Things to do in Ronkonkoma

Chicken Parmigiana Penne Alla Vodka

Chicken Ceasar Salad

See all

Outside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lina G.

68

4

0

7 years ago

Best pizzeria! Very friendly and true Italian owners who speak Italian as well which I like a lot it makes you feel at home. Everything I get from there is fresh and delicious they never disappoint me. Thank you very much from bringing me back home. read more

John K.

0

10

6

7 years ago

Best pizza around Suffolk. Been coming here for 20 years and ive yet to find a pizza with a crispier crust. Awesome pizza, great staff, very family vibe. I hope more people can try their food! read more

J B.

0

2

0

14 years ago

Great Pizza !Good Food! Great Price! I go here every Friday for my lunch break besides not having enough tables cause its always so busy this place is GREAT!!!!!! read more

Francesca G.

19

1

0

7 years ago

This is my favorite Pizzaria. The best crust and the sauce is great. Always fresh! I go there all the time and will not go anywhere else. True Italian . read more

Dinamarie R.

93

1

0

7 years ago

Always amazing. Favorite pizza in the area. Never disappointed. Always quick and always delicious.

Marco Polo Pizzerias - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Ronkonkoma

People found Marco Polo Pizzerias by searching for…

People who viewed Marco Polo Pizzerias also viewed

Little Vincent's Pizzeria

3.6

(482 reviews)

Little Vincent's Pizza was one of our favorite food finds during our stay in Islip!…read more We stopped in for dinner the day we landed in New York and absolutely fell in love with their cold cheese slice. It was so good that we knew we had to come back before heading home. Sure enough, our last meal before leaving New York was right back at Little Vincent's! The food was delicious both times, and the service was great. Everyone was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. When a place is both your first AND last meal of a trip, you know they're doing something right! We'll definitely be back whenever we're in the area. Five stars from us!

I've heard their heroes are good (never had) but the pizza is trash. The sauce is very sweet and…read morethey don't put enough cheese or cook the pizza long enough. I remember it being better 20 years ago. The workers are nice and polite. Cash only. The only plus for me is that they are open late.

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe

3.9

(210 reviews)

Good pizza and fries when you eat in but they messed up some takeout orders would recommend for…read moredinning in but not for takeout.

Pizzas are outstanding. So is service. A+. My husband and I are there at least 2x a weekread more

Matt's Pizza

3.7

(80 reviews)

I've been told this is a tucked away hidden gem and I'd have to agree. The staff treats you like…read morefamily. The food is quick, cheap and delicious. With a couple of tables with chairs you do have the option to dine in. Overall pizza is tasty and we look forward to coming back.

A hidden gem! Not only is their pizza great they make a really good Hawaiian and I do not like…read moreHawaiian! Also a fan of their lunch specials. They have a nice small sit down space and the staff is very friendly and helpful.

Pizza Stop

4.5

(115 reviews)

Stopped here for a quick slice of pizza and it was 10/10. Had to come back later in the week for…read moreanother. Friendly staff, the perfect pizzeria in my opinion.

Sorry to say. This place is now terrible. Sal is a great guy but seems to be overwhelmed now and…read morethe food is suffering. I have gotten a burned pizza from there twice now and had to return it. I don't mean properly charred, I mean, burnt. Why is he microwaving heroes ?? This destroys the bread and render it in edible within 10 minutes. The young guy who sometimes answers the phone there has zero personality and is almost sub-verbal. Everything in the place is old, worn out and filthy. Sad.

Nino's Pizzeria

3.6

(44 reviews)

This seems to be a once-notorious pizza restaurant that actually knew how to make pizza. But no…read morelonger... The pizza sauce was just flavorless. No point in mentioning anything else. If you're gonna charge $20+ a pie, it had better be good. The competition is real. Will not be returning!

great service! Nice people, Quick service & The foods good. First time here and definitely worth…read morecoming back for another meal

Milano Pizza

3.8

(70 reviews)

I got a pizza from this place on Sunday and it was some of the best pizza I've ever tasted, the…read moreemployees were very nice, there was a nice kid named Anderson and he helped me pick out what I wanted, I was unsure and he helped me, it was amazing, the place was also very nice like the furniture and lights felt like I was in a high end restaurant, nice spot and nice people as well, 10/10 would recommend.

Place looks run down and tell me why the pizza had zero taste at all I was basically just eating…read morecardboard but the crust and slice was crunch but the taste was just horrid absolutely no taste at all

Ciro's Pizza

4.4

(182 reviews)

Really nice people and great pizza! I had the sausage pizza and it was delicious. A lot of fun…read moregetting a good slice visiting all the way from California.

Just found out about Ciro's pizza…read more First off, super friendly staff. They greeted me when I walked in. A few guys behind the counter and they were chatting with me while I waited for my pie. Traditional style pizza place. A great NY style slice. I like how the doughy the crust is. This is one of my new favorite pizza places. The pizza wasn't too oily and the cheese was the perfect amount.

Rocco's Pizza and Pasta Patchogue

3.9

(77 reviews)

The food is traditional the service is fast yet not hurried. Parking is something there is plenty…read moreof just around back.

I ordered Pasta Bolognese, which is supposed to be pasta with meat sauce…read more There was no meat just pasta and ricotta. Also the garlic bread didn't have melted butter just herbs tossed on some bread. Very disappointed. Worst Italian food in Patchogue!

Monte's Pizzeria

4.0

(51 reviews)