Amazing restaurant once again. Other things I tried and that I would recommend are the ricotta toast , the arancini rice balls ( amazingly creamy and addicting ), the pizzeria chicken but with grilled chicken , the wings ( I only tried the buffalo and they are meaty and soft but crispy ) , the ceaser salad wrap ( the dressing is soooo good and the wrap is like this soft scrumptious pizza dough wrap ), the bruschetta pie, and the bar pie ( simple and doesn't look like something to order but trust me so flavorful but it does have a bit savory and sweet which I love ). I honestly haven't tried something that I didn't like . read more

Skip the Sicilian!!!! Crust was old. Many pizzerias make the Sicilian crust ahead of time and you run the risk of serving dry, stale tasting crust. Our first time trying this place but that's a big deal. I can't even tell you the sauce and cheese were good since the overall taste was ruined. read more

Here we go, Here is a little hidden gem in Bayshore on Maple Avenue. Not matter what time of day you come to this pizzeria its busy. The customer service is and was outstanding. Location is in Bayshore on Maple Avenue under the new apartment building. Its located on the same street as though you were headed to the Ferry. Great location. Walking distance from Main Street. Parking is across the street or on the side streets. You have to pay for on street parking. Overall this place is crowded no matter what time of day or night you go. As far as the food . One word delicious . I tried the Thai chili pizza . Wow amazing. Sitting is very limited but the restaurant is organized and clean. Pricing was reasonably fair. Overall experience I rate a 9 out of 10. Customer service was fantastic. Happy yelping. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Chicken Thai pizza - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

The food was good, and refreshing at the same time, along with the whole scenery they have going on! And of course, the staff were very friendly as well. read more

See all

Retired NYPD, Moved to Georgia from Bay Shore, upon returning for a weekend wedding, I said to my son before returning to Georgia I need the best pizza on Long Island. He immediately said The Pizzeria of Bay Shore. I said "Oh the place where they have those deliciously garlicky garlic knots, yes please I need that". The pizza is so delicious, I wish that they had this in Georgia, but nope not even close. I could eat from there every single day only fresh ingredients used here. I recommend the addictive garlic knots, reg cheese pie, chicken parm,100% you can't go wrong with any menu items. "I'll be back" in Arnold voice.Lol read more

We came at end of the night and place was still super busy.. band was wrapping up and grabbed a quick slice of pizza.. what big flavor they had!! I wish we could have come earlier and hung out had few beers but we were with family . Really cool place in heart of bay shore ! Highly recommended! read more

See all

Gotta say was pleasantly surprised ..food was much better than expected. I had a chicken Caesar wrap...fresh, warm & tasty & huge. The wife had a "personal" pizza arugula, eggplant, burrata, balsamic...ridiculous could easily feed 3 or 4....leftover 2 days later warmed up not soggy or wet....delicious...highly recommended read more

Delicious pizza and lots of choices! Loved the outdoor seating. Had a great meal with friends in a lively, busy spot. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Really cute casual place, a lot of seating and they had a decent crowd. Food is good, service was a bit slow for a pizza place. Overall good vibes and good prices. read more

See all

So Im originally from Brooklyn and lived some time in the Bronx and The Pizzeria is the closest ive come to tasting authentic New York style pizza. The dough, the sauce, the cheese along with the toppings...it just so delicious. Ive tried their different types and im yet to be disappointed. The calzones, the rolls the food...its just all so good. And I say this along with saying that I've only ordered delivery and my food and pizza still arrive hot and tasting delicious. Delivery is always fast and if I've ever needed to change something I can just call and no problem, they are very friendly. Its a great Pizza place. read more

If you love pizza you will love this place. It's not only pizza but you have all type of different slices and pies. It's a must try!! It also has a bar where you can relax wine down and watch the game. The service it good everyone I came across was friendly. It can be a family outing a date or by yourself. Located in the heart of Bayshore right off Main Street is this place for a great time. read more

See all

We went on a Saturday night and were sat immediately at 7:30. The personal pizzas were a great size, plenty of food and enough to take a couple slices home. I got the burrata pizza with hot honey and they didn't skimp on the toppings. They have a cute covered outdoor seating area that was nice and our server was attentive. You can also order slices while seated too if you want to try a couple different options. read more

See all

Six of us had dinner last night. The atmosphere and staff were excellent. Ashley, our waitress was funny, attentive, and friendly. The appetizers, dinner, and food were delicious. Definitely will be back. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Rainbow cookie cake. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Pizza is excellent! I had the Margherita and husband had meatball slices- great tastes and flavors- relaxed atmosphere read more

Food was really tasty! My party of 4 got 2 honey pep pies and 1 order of fries which was enough food for us. We went on a Friday night so the place was packed, but it was only a 15 min wait for a table. Despite how busy it was, our server was very attentive to us and we certainly enjoyed our stay. They had so many different pizza options that looked good so I'm excited to return and try a new one. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - The Honey Pep Pie - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

You know why I know the whole Michelin Star business is a gimmick? Because this place doesn't have one (YET deserves THREE). When I wake up weary and weathered for work at the hospital down the street...you know what gets me through the day? Knowing that these fine folk and the fruits of their fine labor are less than a mile from my reach (unless there's some whacky Bayshore street festival in which case ...maybe TWO miles due to rerouted traffic). The outdoor seating will make you realize how much miss summer. Then you'll sit in the cozy indoors and realize summer's overrated. The staff's hospitality and good spirits will warm you right up. And all this was not enough, the food will keep you coming back. Plain and grandma and vodka slices cannot be beat ...BUT, guess what. -- for the first time in my 37 years (excluding maybe the first couple due to lack of teeth), I cleaned off a WHOLE SALAD at a restaurant (I legit think it was called "The Salad"). Wildly good. I would probably give up a pinkie toe if it would guarantee me two slices a day for life (I'd pay of course + tip). In all seriousness, thank you to this great place for their hard work and great food. read more

Hands down, they have superior pizza. I love their crust. The Pizzeria is my favorite pizza place. Great service too. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Partially eaten honey pepperoni pizza. My favorite. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I met a friend here for dinner. We opted to sit outside as it was nice out. We started with vodka fritters as an appetizer. It was delicious. Deep fried (need a I say more??) spaghetti with vodka sauce to dip. It was so yum! The vodka sauce was out of this world in flavor. I'd definitely be back just based on that! For my meal I couldn't decide if I wanted "The Trifecta" personal pie or "Uncle Benny" personal pie. I asked our waitress if I could do half/half. She told me I couldn't but asked what I was deciding between. When I told her she told me to definitely go with Uncle Benny. I'm glad I listened because I'm all about Uncle Benny tonight. It eas absolutely delicious and a happy marriage of flavors! My friend had the margarita personal pie. She enjoyed it as well. The personal pies are huge! We both had leftovers to take home. Ooh drinks! I had the watermelon martini. It was very refreshing. I forgot what my friend ordered but she liked it. Our waitress was Ashley. She was really good and patient with us. A real rockstar! 5 stars all the way! read more

See all

This Pizzeria is close to my bayshore work office. It's a Good place to grab a quick bite. My favorite is THE salad. It's a nice medley of pecans, Parmesan crisps, and other tasty notes. I usually ask for grilled chicken. It's a large portion for the price. Other times I got the grandma slice which was excellent. There's a nice outdoor section you can enjoy as well read more

My go to pizza place. I love that they have a full bar. The paper plane is definitely a highlight for me. The uncle Benny and the trifecta are my favorite slices. You have to try the meatballs, gnocchi, and arancini. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

In a world where pizza can be extremely hit or miss The Pizzeria has been consistently outstanding. The variety of clever concoctions is quite impressive and thus far we haven't found any duds - even the garlic knots they somehow got just right, moist without that off putting oil squirt you often find and the balance of seasoning spot on. But I'd be remiss if I didn't mention my top two pies: the trifecta and the bruschetta. For my money they are next level and a must have every visit. Hopefully things stay this good as they seem to be expanding to more locations pretty frequently, should they stay on their game they've got loyal customers right here. Now if only they expanded to Farmingdale...one can hope. read more

They serve Balthazar Bakery (NYC) pastries for breakfast. My favorite was the sticky pecan roll until deliveries stopped due to a lack of demand for it. La Colombe cold brew and coffee are poured from the draft. They taste bolder and more flavorful than the bottled ones that I buy in the supermarket. The Pizzeria's chicken wings are one of the best deals in town: 12 for $10 every Sunday. I had the dry rub today, which was served with house-made blue cheese and buffalo sauce. Next time I will order the plain or Thai chili wings. Note: my favorite wings on the Island are the ones made at Avino's Italian Table. They taste closest to the chicken wings I ate when I was going to college Upstate. Sign up for The Pizzeria's text messages to be apprised of all specials including football specials that have discounts for pizza pies and drinks. TEXT "YES" to 855-734-0300. Ken, one of the owners, is jovial and interesting. He said that he is a former employee of the renowned restauranteur Jean-Georges. read more

See all

As we know.. When a new place comes to town sure the may be good for a few months perhaps.. But not here it's been open for over 2 years now and it's just as great... Today's go to was THE SALAD with eggplant... And a clam person pie.. Expresso Martini and one other drink I can't recall something with spicy bitters.. Sooo good.. We sat at the bar the bartender was simply amazing at her job... Super friendly and accomadating.. Well light. Good room temperature and the music was good. Great hometown place.. I frequent often... Dog friendly! read more

See all

Wow ! Everything looks as delicious as the Islip establishment with the same amazing selections of pizzas, wraps , pinwheels , hero's and so much more ! It is super spotless and inviting . Everyone was very polite and attentive ! This location is a bit more upscale with a bar and a large TV. There is a sufficient amount of seating indoor and outdoor . We enjoyed eggplant parmigiana served with a lovely fresh salad and a chicken wrap . All very good ! Although I did think the tomato sauce on the eggplant , although tasting good , was a bit acidity . The wrap was excellent with a plentiful amount of tender chicken , arugula and roasted peppers . Yum ! read more

See all

10/10 experience, plus the two pizzas were top tier! 10/10 costumer service, everyone was so nice! Lovely environment!

We love the Pizzeria! We think the best pizza around and come to the restaurant or order to go all the time. They also offer individual pies. They also make a killer espresso martini for dessert! read more

See all

Everything went well right from the beginning. The guy behind the pizza oven acknowledge us and was personable. A hostess came over and gave us water without us asking. And our server was very knowledgeable and provided feedback. And all in all the food was excellent. read more

yes yes yes! Amazing pizza and amazing prices! I've found my pizza spot for the area! The hot honey pep was delcious as well as the margarita allá vodka slice! We came after an event and enjoyed every second of the sit down experience! Highly highly recommend! read more

See all

Wow. Great place, lots of choices, full bar, great seating, plenty of parking in a public lot (you have to pay $1/hr), and most of all, very good pizza. Slices are really big, thick, and tasty. Right up the road from the Bay Shore Ferry to Fire Island. Modern looking and clean. Definitely recommend. read more

Finally checked out The Pizzeria! They are opening up a few locations on the south shore and one coming soon to Babylon (woot woot). Decided to try the Bay Shore one as a sneak preview. We ordered a classic pie and it did not disappoint. Annnnd of course some knots (how can you not get some knots?) When I went in to pick up the pizza it was popping inside. Guess everyone else decided pizza was on the menu tonight. I saw in the display case they also have buffalo knots which I will have to try next time. Everything on display looked delish - will try the margherita next time as we didn't notice it on the menu. Some of the pizzas have unique names - I think the margherita here is the Bay Shore special. In any event they were super friendly and I can't wait for them to be in BV. Quality ingredients, great customer service and yummy food. read more

Ordered a pizza while at the hospital visiting my mom. Delivered promptly and was really good. Only issue we had was delivery was left at emergency room even though we specifically asked the delivery driver to call cell when arrived and we would have met him at entrance. Not the pizzeria's fault though since it was done through DoorDash. read more

I know I already posted a review but I needed to post another I work at Southside hospital down the block so we decided to go back to the e Pizzeria on Friday as we enjoyed it so much prior to this. My coworker and I stopped by to pick up a Bruchetta pie that we love woth two extra slices and drinks. I paid and had to leave a box on the counter because I had too much in my hands. The worker (who I think may be the owner) noticed I left the pizza box and thought I had forgotten it- he ran outside after me to make sure I didn't leave without it! His kindness really spoke volumes to us! That's the kind of business we love to return to and spend time at! Thank you for your kindness and great food from your health care Heros down the block! read more

See all

Nice addition to the Long Island pizza scene. The regular pie is cooked nicely. I love all the customizations available on the online ordering site. The speciality pizzas are flavorful. We especially loved the buffalo chicken, the chicken was good quality and the sauce was top notch. We'll be back to try some more soon! read more

Just 2 ladies enjoying wine and a chicken roll along with spicy calamari. A feel good place and friendly people. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Bar on a Friday eve 12/30/22 - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Delicious pizza, on time & super nice person on the phone. If I could give them an extra star for calling me back to double check the dairy allergy, I would! We called in from Fair Harbor, they delivered the pizza to the ferry in Bay Shore & then we picked it up: nothing better when most island options are closing after Labor Day. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - These pizzas were huge!! Each slice fills up a dinner plate. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Very nice staff. Pizza is excellent. And they've got wine. A must check out kinda place Very nice staff. Pizza is excellent. And they've got wine. A must check out kinda place read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Pesto grandma pizza didn't even make it long enough for me to take a picture lol very good - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Stumbled upon this place with my boyfriend and so glad we did because it's amazing! They have pastries/breads from Balthazar and their pizza, both incredible! The ingredients are so fresh and they have interesting selections like Buffalo garlic knots which were delicious. Balthazar makes some of the best bread in my opinion and they are located in the city so it's nice to be able to get pastries from there on Long Island! Their hot honey slice with mini pepperoni is to die for and the aesthetic in general is beautiful! I also noticed they have a regular menu with salads, pasta dishes and more so I would love to come back and try something other than the pizza! A table next to us got a salad and pasta dish that looked incredible. There's also a beautiful bar , so whether you want something sweet, savory or a drink you have everything here! They are located near the main area with other shops etc. definitely worth checking out! read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Hot The Honey Pep Slice Buffalo Chicken Slice - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I've waited to review this place after I tried it for the 2nd time. The first time we ordered a large regular pie and garlic knots. There was nothing special about either of those, so I wanted to wait and try a few of their speciality slices before I left my view. The sad part is that the pizzeria is beautiful, but the food is bland and for the most part, tasteless. I went in today, we ordered 5 different items. A pepperoni slice, which was like a deep dish style, just too much bread, and didn't taste that great. We tried their "bar pizza" which was mikes hot honey and Burrata, it was tasteless. Couldn't even tell there was mikes hot honey on it. The chicken sweet tai chili slice was 2/5, and the grandmas slice was decent. The best thing we ordered was this chicken roll, had fresh mozz, arugula and roasted peppers. The only issue with that roll is how round it is. It's not like a regular roll, so it's hard to eat, and falls apart. I really think it's their sauce, it not good. I wouldn't go back or recommend this place. read more

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Love, love this new addition to our town. As soon as you walk in you're greeted with a Friendly "hi, welcome" Food: We ordered the shrimp parmigiana with a side of rigatoni ( we opted for the spicy sauce) amazing! Shrimp and pasta cooked perfectly. Tried the Buffalo knots, wow! Service: outstanding, you can tell everyone who works here is happy to do so. Seems the management and team work extremely well together. We had the privilege to be helped by Ali. Not only did she make great conversation but her knowledge of the menu helped us so much. You can tell she's comfortable and loves her job. Tony another great addition. Came over with a slice my husband and ordered. Great young man, once again you can feel the love and appreciation of their jobs. I wish I had photos of our food. It just escaped me this time. We dove right in! read more

See all

I've been to multiple locations but this is specifically for takeout from the Bay Shore location. I ordered on uber eats and when the food got here it was missing something so I called the restaurant and the manager (I believe) was so nice he sent someone out within 10 minutes and delivered the missing item and extra. We were so appreciative! Food itself was (as always) outstanding. read more