I am stunned by the bad reviews. I kept reading the negative reviews thinking I must be looking at the wrong place... This place has amazing food and incredible customer service. We've been there for an impromptu birthday party, pick-up, and low key dinners. Friendly, good with kids, and amazing pizza. Try it. You will not be disappointed! read more

Always our GO TO for pizza and hoagies. Don't know what they do with their hoagie rolls or where they come from...maybe heaven? They are so soft and good! My teen daughters LOVE the White pizza! read more

Good pizza, friendly service, and at a decent price. It is a good back-up to my primary pizza destination for sure. It would be Amy primary goto for my pizza need, but for the location. However, really good pizza and nice establishment to boot. Have not really sampled to much of their other fare though, but since they take care in the preparation of the pizza it would be a strong possibility that the rest of the menu should pass the muster at a minimum. Enjoy! read more

Horrible customer service with an employee named Angie working there. made our experience what some would call a trip to hell, couldn't serve us correctly either. I'd also like to add she looked like she was dipped in glue and dragged through a flee market. read more

Awesome pizza and Marco is a great host! I had the Hawaiian pizza and the pizza with bacon, chicken and mustard too which was magnificent but when I took a bite of my daughters white pizza with what tasted like ricotta cheese on it, that bite was amazing!!! I would highly recommend Marco's Pizza in York. I am from Maryland and consider myself a pizza connoisseur, and Marco's pizza was great. I told him to come to Montgomery County, Md, he could easily triple his prices and clean up! Thanks for our meal while we were visiting at York College for a basketball tournament, we will definitely come again! GRAZIE!!!! BUON APPETITO!!! read more

First time there. Had delivery. The service was fine came hot, lots of toppings on my custom pie. ONLY problem there is tooooo much salt it takes away from the taste. I will go back but specify no salt.... read more

Delicious! Pizza is wonderful and Cheese Steaks ... YUM! Fresh rolls.i cannot day enough great things about the food. Staff is friendly and fast. Bathrooms clean. One of my family's new favorites. read more

The closest place that delivered to our friends place was this Marcello's and we didn't want to go out so we picked up the phone. The food portions were very large, but the chicken cheesesteak and cheese fries were just your basic pizza shop fare, nothing special. I would probably order from them again since they got the order right and were faster than they said they would be over the phone. But you get what you pay for. Their prices are lower than others in the area and that may be why they are popular. read more

When the food is bad, the management blames the customer. Our food stromboli for 6 smelled and tasted like perfume or detergent and after waiting 45mins for delivery I had to return it to the store and all i got was a remake of the food, nothing for the inconvenience but blame on us; the customer and then being asked "what do you want for free" was the chief insult. What I was looking for was a bit of sympathy and for them to "make it right" but their arrogance and inability see it from a customers standpoint was appalling. I Will never go there again. 9/20/18 read more

10/10 experience! Easily order online, fast delivery, good prices. There are even gluten free options that actually taste good! You guys will definitely be my go-to pizza place from now on! read more

Huge selection of specialty slices. I had the Taco pizza and it was delicious! Friendly employees and good service. Reasonably priced.

Ordered a Marco special Fantastic. I am on the road alot. The best pizza I have had in a long time

I highly recommend Marco's. They have the best pizza , every time we get a pizza its always delicious. Staff is friendly and fast.

Still our family's go to place to eat out. The customer service is great, even when they are super busy. Today, 6 of us (2 adults, 4 kids) had lunch here. Our order consisted of, 1 kid's cheese pizza, 1 lasagna, 1 spaghetti w/ meat sauce, and 2 fettuccine alfredo. Salads and bread came shortly after we ordered. Everything was fresh! When the main entrées came out both alfredo dishes had very al dente pasta. The server quickly took care of this, and fresh alfredo was soon on its way. The owner sent 2 cannoli to our table along with the steaming hot, creamy alfredo. It is easy to see why Marcos is a busy place! Great food, fabulous and friendly service at inexpensive prices. read more

Delicious pizza and subs! Yummy! Very friendly and makes you feel like home! Does a great business!

Food was good and came out fast. The staff was very friendly. Place was very clean Will be back again.

This was our first time there. We were not sure what the process was ( order then pay?). We hesitated and no one bothered to acknowledge us. They were busy cleaning and chatting with each other. Finally we asked where we should place an order and a young girl helped us. After placing the order we looked for a clean table however there were none. We took the least dirty table and wiped off the crumbs and liquid. There did seem to be 2 older people working with all young kids. I would have to say I would not return. No one acknowledged us or thanked us. We seemed to be invisible. I am not sure how they have such high reviews?? read more

These folks always rock it. You can't beat the lunch special, the staff are great, it's fast, and they aim to please. Most of all, the food is consistently delicious. Love the new place, too. Incidentally, for the first 6-7 years of my son's life he had a dairy allergy which made family pizza dining difficult. The guys at Marco's always welcomed us though, and we'd bring soy cheese which they'd be more than happy to make my boy his own little pizza. Most places won't do that for some reason so I'm not sure if the guys doin' the pies know just how much it meant to our family. THANK YOU read more

Best pizza, subs and salads in York. Nothing bad to say except I live on the East side and they are only on the West side :-( they need a Marco's 2.0 setup on the East side of York. read more

Incredibly good pizza. Incredibly good people making it and serving it. An amazing pizza joint. There's really no need to go anywhere else. Go for the white cheese pizza. The steak and cheese is killer. The veggie pizza amazing. The salads are fresh. The place is spotlessly clean and new. It's great. Congrats Marco & co. You're a very impressive pizza shop. And thank you for feeding my volleyball team. They all loved it. Just make a note they've moved from White Str to Carlisle Str around the corner. read more

Pizza was absolutely delicious. Plenty of cheese, and they cooked it just how I asked. Onion rings were bomb too. I'm sure everything on the menu is good, because usually a restaurant's food is either ALL good or none of it's good. I'll definitely order from these guys again. read more

This was not he best pizza place. Most of the slices are way to big and they should probably make it fresh. Overall their pizza is really good. read more

We absolutely love there food. It's always fresh and well made. We have been loyal customers for over 10 years. We have always had wonderful customer service and everyone is friendly and professional. read more

I've been a fan of Marcello's since the downtown location opened up on Market Street many moons ago. Loooooooove the pizza and cheeseburger subs. read more

First time review. DO NOT waste your money at this establishment. Phoned an order for delivery. Three sandwiches and a salad. Took over one hour for delivery. ... I had to call to remind them of my order. Results were cold food. Fries that tasted as if they had already been reheated. When I made the reminder call the excuse was that they "got backed up." There are to many other places locally with better food and much better service. Don't make the same mistake. Just pass. read more

If this is the best pizza ? You better go for a drive. Ordered a large cheese plain - for delivery at lunchtime. The pizza was hot and round other than that nothing stood out, crust very average cheese not special , sauce at summer freshness peak tasted like it came from a can off the shelf of sams club. Not particularly friendly on the phone, Delivery was good fast and friendly. Won't try again if your entry level pie is blah. read more

Hadn't been back in York for a long time and gave them a try for Stromboli. We usually get J&N's but wanted to try something new. Had the original and the special, both in large. Very reasonable price and fed 6 people for dinner and breakfast leftovers. Very good Stromboli, good bread and the right ratio of meat to dough. They also give you marinara with your order and don't ding you for a side like some places. Took about 40 minutes from call until it was ready, but to be fair they were very busy. This was the only reason for the 4. read more

Paid with credit card over phone for delivery. Card information stolen and used. Never will go again.

I eat here at least once a week. They have great prices and the portions are huge. Best pizza and subs in the area. I've recommended Marco's to all of my family and friends and they drive from wherever they are to pick up food from here. Food is incredible. I've honestly not had anything from Marco's that I was disappointed in. read more

My friends and I love Marco's for pizza nights. A large white pizza and an order of nacho cheese fries and we're good to go! The pick up service is always speedy and the food always tastes fresh. My uncle (a Brooklyn native) says Marco's is York's best spot for New York style pizza! read more

I'm sorry, but I sort of thought this pizza was fairly awful. I got something that was supposed to have sausage on it... it wasn't any kind of sausage I know of. It was super cheap though, so that's nice. I will come back and try something else in the hope of upgrading this place to a 3. read more

Best place in York to get pizza, subs and so much more! Family and I go here at least once a week!

If there were 10 stars on a review I would give it to Marco's for customer service. As first time visitors to Marco's we left feeling less than excited about returning. The food was very good but our service that night wasn't. My husband ate alone because my food did not come until he was almost done. After giving a low 2 star review, that same night we received a call from Vito explaining why my meal selection took the length of time that it did in comparison to my husband's. After that call we understood it was not due to poor service; but, an honest explanation by Vito was not enough. He insisted we come back to dine again so that he could make a good experience for us. We went back and true to his word, the food was excellent and the service was excellent. Most importantly was the fact that it mattered to him that we were satisfied! read more

I hope they get better kitchen help soon. If you order only from the menu and not a pizza you like or make changes to a sub it's still the most awesome place around but the second you place a custom order it gets screwed up. We've been ordering since a year before they moved and it was ALWAYS perfect and delicious. The last 4 times we've ordered something has been made wrong, as in ordering a classic philly and getting one with tomato sauce. Sauce on a cheesesteak turns it into trash for me. Another order of a cheeseburger sub with grilled onions, double tomato and no lettuce was received as just the standard off the menu cheeseburger sub Yuk. read more

i eat slices here alot you get many toppings for a great price there are many types to choose from great pizza

Marco's is absolutely the best pizza in York. The staff is so friendly and reliable and even when mistakes are made, they're quick to fix it! I love the ranch fries (I get no bacon) and the veggie melt wrap. The plain ole French fries are my favorite out of any I've had elsewhere. This is a super vegetarian-friendly place! read more

My default pizza and sub shop. Small places like this alway blow the big chains out of the water.

I ordered a veggie stromboli (broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, cheese and sauce) and had pepperoni added to it. It was horrible. The mushrooms obviously came out of a can, the spinach was black and tough so it was either really old or from a can and the broccoli also appeared to be frozen or from a can. I can't believe how awful it was especially for $20. I could have bought fresh ingredients and made it myself for less money. I won't be going back there again. read more

Do not eat here! Charged a friend twice for the same meal, when presented with the bank statement PROVING what my friend was claiming the owner still denied it and refused to refund her money. Eventually ended up rudely throwing money in her direction to shut her up but wasn't the amount trey over charged her. Will NEVER do business with this place read more

SUPER love this place. You can't go wrong with the cheesesteaks or the pizza. Every bite you can tell that there's genuine ingredients. They deliver or you can order to pick up. Customer service is always great and doesn't ever take to long to get the foods. read more