Cancel

Open app

Search

Mario's Pizza

3.9 (43 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian
Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Mario's Pizza Photos

Business Info

MARIO'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Loud
Casual
Dogs allowed
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mario's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Two slices of cheese to go
Bryan B.

Swung by quick to grab a couple slices for take out and they were just as good as I remember! Used to frequent this place often when I lived in Owego. Their sheet pizza is top notch, and provides a different style than what you would find at Rossi's or Nirchi's. Next time I'm in town, I'll be dining in to order some wings!

See all

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

nice staff super clean best gluten free pizza not greasy or boxed crap! got the cheseless pineapple and spinach, yumm!!!11 divine!

Business owner information

Photo of Vinnie P.

Vinnie P.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Mario's Pizza

Review Highlights - Mario's Pizza

Their sheet pizza is top notch, and provides a different style than what you would find at Rossi's or Nirchi's.

Mentioned in 7 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 949 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Donoli's Restaurant

Donoli's Restaurant

3.1
(92 reviews)
6.0 mi
$$

Okay so I know I've left a review from this place before however I don't see it on the list and the…read moreYelp is prompting me to do it again.. possibly because a few months ago the ownership changed. This restaurant is known all over the area for having the best prime rib and I'm assuming it still is as good as like I said there's new ownership and I don't believe they changed a whole lot on the menu but until I've actually tried it again I can't say for sure. My wife has always enjoyed the lobster ravioli however a couple weeks ago when we were there she had it and it does taste different. Now I do have sort of an inside track on this because my daughter works there now however she didn't know for sure if any recipes were changed or not. Now don't get me wrong the lobster are we only still tasted great but it wasn't what my wife expected because something was different. She still finished it and was happy. I went with a broiled fish option which was also tasty and the place was as usual clean and appeared to be a very nice atmosphere. This was the last time I was there a couple weeks ago, I also visited on Easter this last April, and that experience wasn't quite as nice. And the only reason I say that is because they had a buffet and there's nothing against the buffet at this restaurant it was done very well and everything was presented beautifully however in my opinion buffets just don't seem to taste as good as when you get a fresh plate from the kitchen. Now coincidentally, my birthday was a couple days ago and this weekend I will be going back here to have dinner with my in-laws and with that being said the possibility does exist I might come back and add to this review. I'm fully expecting it to be another nice dining experience so I might not revisit this perhaps only if something really outstanding or horribly tragic happens. I did give this particular review four stars instead of five five partially because of that lobster ravioli tasting different and partially because I'm not quite yet convinced about the new ownership not affecting the overall quality. We will see how this weekend goes and like I said perhaps revisit this then

Went at 515 pm ordered and 16 minutes later waitress tells us no med rare prime rib.if we want Mr…read morehave to wait till 615. Was told med was good so we said ok. At 605 brought out medium, very dry and no more garlic taste. They said they would bring out MR when ready, not sure it would of mattered. We are done with Donoli s. Been going for nearly 30 yrs. The last few years not good Waitress was fantastic.

Photos
Raw and cold Prime Rib with loaded potato under cooked  motazella cheese on it.
Raw and cold Prime Rib with loaded potato under cooked motazella cheese on it.
Garlic Parm Bread Sticks & Side Salad
Garlic Parm Bread Sticks & Side Salad
Chocolate Lovers Spoon Cake

See all

Chocolate Lovers Spoon Cake
The Cellar Restaurant

The Cellar Restaurant

3.6
(116 reviews)
0.4 mi
$$

Excellent meal !! A tad noisy. January 2026…read moreThe Great: The food was excellent. Best meal I've had in some time. All agreed our shared mushroom crepe appetizer was delicious. My wife and I had the pork loin special (don't recall exact name). Probably the tastiest pork I've ever had! Really!! The sides were just as yummy. We both agreed it was a seriously good meal. Other couple had Ciopinno and seafood czarina. They both loved them and shared a taste with the table. Have to agree, they were fabulous. Our waitress was timely, attentive, and friendly! No issues at all. Due to impending snow storm, they reduced prices on entrees and drinks. A nice bonus. The Good: Beer selection was pretty good. My request was tapped out, but it turned out, the replacement was even better. A delicious nut brown ale. Wines were also very good albeit a tad pricey. The price special mentioned above helped. Overall bill was on the high side partly due to the drinks and slightly higher prices for the non-special meals - even with the price breaks. Needs work. We were two couples. Sat near the maître d' podium. The inside door of the foyer kept sticking open. Had to get up to close several times as it was about 5 degrees outside. Not a huge issue but should not have been an issue at all. Slightly more annoying was the noise level. The restaurant was full and very noisy. It was a bit challenging to have a conversation at our location. It eventually quieted down and all was well. Definitely something that needs improvement though. I gave it 5 stars due to the excellent meal and service. Considered dropping one star for the noise and price, but the meal was so good, I just couldn't do it. Looking forward to going back.

Had three appetizers- all great! Chick peas, lamb lollipops and shrimp in butter and garlic. Great…read morerestaurant!

Photos
Come check out the full bar and enjoy the ambiance!
Come check out the full bar and enjoy the ambiance!
The Seafood Czarina
The Seafood Czarina
Check out our rotating craft beers!

See all

Check out our rotating craft beers!
Owego Donut & Beer

Owego Donut & Beer

4.9
(31 reviews)
0.3 mi

Okay so I've been here a few times, and honestly I should stop more often because I live rather…read moreclose. They have what is in my opinion a better donut than Dunkin donuts down the road. (I'm still partial to Krispy Kreme however that's quite a drive from here.). The place is rather large, the dining area indoors looks like it's good for at least 30 people anyways and then the outdoor porch weather permitting is probably good for another 20. I arrived about 15 minutes after they opened and the line was forming pretty quickly however it also moved along pretty quickly. The person that takes your order is not the same person that gets your donuts and puts them in the box, so that seems to streamline things pretty well. There's a display up by the cash register with one of every donut that is currently being sold that morning/day so you can make your selection easier. The menu is a little more extensive than donuts, as they also have hoagies and shareables and of course coffee/ juices. For whatever reason, somebody decided to put donuts with beer... Yeah I don't know... But, if the mood strikes you they have a very fine selection that they rotate from time to time of draft beer. It's a pour your own kind of a thing and they also sell growlers. There's of course t-shirts and other random souvenirs that not only have the company logo/wording but Owego in general. Bottom of mind this place is definitely worth a visit.

The ambiance was very nice. The employee's were very sweet and helpful. The donuts and coffee were…read morevery yummy!! I highly reccomend this place and will definitely go back.

Photos
So cute!
So cute!
Gluten free almond joy donuts
Gluten free almond joy donuts
Outdoor seating area, there's a few more behind me as I take this picture

See all

Outdoor seating area, there's a few more behind me as I take this picture

Mario's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...