Labella's "Valatie" is amazing. I do not believe it is affiliated or related to any other…read morelabella's in our area or elsewhere. This place has it all. Great wine list, great pizza, delicious entrees, great service and huge portions /good value for price point. The in house made "house" salad dressing is the bomb. It's a balsamic something. The cannolis are better than most anywhere and large. I've been on a cannoli kick over the last year or 2 and this was better than any, including from Italian bakeries that I've had recently. The wine list is expansive and at $11 a glass, with a great pour, is reasonable, as is the bottle prices. I've been many times for both eat in and pizza for take out AND attended a catered event here and they really get everything right all the time. See you there!

4.25 Although we weren't too hungry, it was getting late and…read morewe needed to eat. We looked up Italian food options, and while there weren't too many choices in the area, this place's pizza looked really good--so we decided to give it a try. You walk in and the space feels much larger than expected--high ceilings with some familiar décor I've seen in other Italian restaurants, like small statues, vines, and painted scenery. You could also tell that this is a popular local spot, since it seemed like the staff knew several of the guests personally. We ordered a medium Margherita pie and a Penne alla Vodka--both simple and safe choices. The pasta dish came with a side salad (choice of house or Caesar), which was perfect. Note: if you prefer a small amount of dressing, you may want to ask for it on the side. We did make that request, but unfortunately, the server seemed to have forgotten, and our salad came drenched. We didn't mention it, though, because we weren't that hungry and just ate what we could before moving on. That said, the pizza and penne were both excellent. The pizza had that great brick oven flavor, fresh mozzarella, and a robust tomato sauce. The Penne alla Vodka was also flavorful and nicely seasoned. If you're ever in the area and in the mood for Italian food, definitely check this place out.

great food great server:becky…read moregreat place wonderful wonderful only love towards four brothers

Greek inspired restaurants mostly serving Italian-American food with some options for Greek snacks…read moreand dessert. Liking the history wall and the story behind the four brother. A local place to eat, nothing extraordinary but such a comfort when away from home

Having spent a good portion of my childhood in Brooklyn (Park Slope section) I learned to really…read moreenjoy pizza there. For $0.25 I could get a slice and a soda, yes those days are gone for sure. When I saw Brooklyn style pizza I decided I'd take a ride and give it a try. Upon entering the restaurant I noticed that there was a lot of nostalgia from Brooklyn including subway signs and pictures of the "Wonder Wheel " from Coney Island setting a nice atmosphere for the restaurant. The young man behind the counter took our order and when the pizza was ready delivered it to our table. We ordered a sausage pizza and I'll tell you they aren't afraid of using cheese, Plenty of it and sausage. The pizza was very tasty, but not exactly what I remember from my childhood. Now this is just my personal opinion so please make sure to give them a try, everyone has different taste buds. Personally I would prefer a thinner and more crusty dough, and less cheese. This DOES NOT mean I didn't enjoy it, just my personal preference. Also, there are lots of other dishes on their menu besides pizza! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed!

Phoned in an order for pick up based on their website. Ordered a Toscana pizza. The girl that…read moreanswered had no clue what that was. OK, maybe it was her first day. We explained it to her.She quoted a price $8 higher than what the website said ($25 verses $33 using round numbers.) When we arrived and told her the disparity on price, she said well this is what the computer says. We showed her one of their menus which said the Toscana costs $27. We were fine with that. She went and got the 'chef' and he took the menu from us and said the higher price was it. We opened another menu and showed them the lower price again. They weren't going to budge. When I said we were going to leave without the pizza, they reluctantly have us the price that their own menu stated! Not one apology, just attitude. I understand that prices change and maybe new menus weren't re-ordered yet to reflect that. But I know how easy it is to change prices on a website. Horrible customer service. Entitled 20 somethings. Pizza was good, but we will never go back there again. Sticking with LaBella's who knows how to treat customers.

Finally!! Without question, best pizza I've had in this area. I'm a born and bred Jersey girl, so…read moremy standards are high. My husband went with a friend a few weeks ago. He raved about the pizza, but since he's been known to eat (and like) $1 hot dogs, I had to judge for myself. We got takeout, so I cannot comment on ambiance, but service was as expected. That is, the order was ready in a reasonable amount of time and packed well so it arrived at my home hot and intact. Though I was very tempted by the Italian sausage and hot honey option, I decided to go with my usual (white pizza base, tomato, basil, black olive, extra cheese) to keep my opinion unbiased. Oh. My. Goodness. The flavor. The crust. The CRUST. crispy and chewy and everything a pizza crust should be. Even if you have to cross the river, it's worth the drive. I will go back for the Italian and hot honey. Yum!

This pizza was absolutely wonderful and definitely some of the best I've ever had. If you're ever…read morein the area, I highly recommend stopping by and seeing Ryan and his team. The service was absolutely wonderful. Ryan came by personally several times to check on me and so did some of his servers. His place is very clean and it's a nice atmosphere. There's also a very nice outdoor dining area. All around just a very nice place to sit and have some good pizza! I also noticed, on the way out, that they have hand dipped ice cream, but I was absolutely stuffed! Maybe next time, for sure ! Thank you, sir. I do appreciate it.!

Got to go here when in town for Thanksgiving. Was great quality and many options. Would get again…read moreif in town. I liked the chicken parm Stromboli and chicken broccoli pizza

Was a good place at one time. Went in to place an order for a couple pies about a month ago at 8pm…read more Person behind the counter told me they shut off the oven because they close at 9pm and can't take pizza order. I left and placed an order at another pizza place 15 minutes later who was still taking orders. Tonight I attempted to call Mateos to place an order. It sounded like the phone was picked up and hung up. I called back 2 more times and got the same result. I see on their website you can place an order online, which costs a fee. The order has to be paid by credit card. No thanks! Mateo's just lost a customer. With the way rents are, they should not be turning away business.

Excellent food and service, will definitely be back. Great pizza in a small communityread more

Indoor and outdoor seating at this cute pizzeria off a busy road with ample parking. Not your…read morestandard red sauce slice outlet, the pies are gourmet style with names to match-- salads are fresh and tasty . Connected to a pub, wine and beer available. The experience will set you back at least $50 for two, which is what pizza costs in today's world.

Had a wonderful experience with my sister Wednesday evening visiting with Johnny. Super…read moreknowledgeable and so interesting to hear his experiences regarding the beer industry! Pizza was delicious as was the IPA. Highly recommend experiencing Night School!

Really enjoyed our experience here we will definitely be back. There is a nice paddling put in…read moreright down the street. We ordered the smash burgers she got the single I got the double, so two patties for me. Mine were really juicy and flavorful hers was overcooked. They did not ask for temperature I guess normally would smash burgers they don't. We also got a slice of pizza each she got plain cheese I got pepperoni. The texture of the pizza was nice and crunchy very strong pepperoni flavor I loved it. Her slice wasn't that great because the cheese or sauce flavor it wasn't amazing, I guess my pepperonis dominated the flavor of my pizza which I was very happy with since I love pepperoni. I got an amazing West Coast IPA called West Friend from there, which I would definitely get again thank you for making that style of beer!

Husband and I stopped in on a whim today. Got a few slices to eat in and a pizza to go. Everyone…read morethere was super friendly and it's really cute inside. I got a grandma slice and the husband got some cheese slices and a cheese pizza to take home. Everything was excellent, we will definitely stop back in when we're in the area!

Pizza tastes bought frozen then thawed. Disgusting pizza and terrible food. Nobody i asked likes…read morethe food

I'm giving it 4 stars because our options are limited where we are, and this is the best we've had…read moreso far. One thing that's helped us like it more is asking for half the amount of cheese. Otherwise it's too much, like a lot of mediocre places that are not in pizza towns. We like their toppings, including fresh mushrooms, and it's close only 6 miles from us. They also have Stewart's soda in the cold case, including birch beer! The people are pleasant, although they do step right outside the kitchen and smoke, which can make the outside tables uncomfortable. There are a couple games inside, not a full arcade, but a happy diversion for some people, and a cozy stove (pellet or gas, i can't remember) which is really warm in winter. We've emitted stopping here after working on the house, when we're tired, hungry, and a little grubby. We're always welcomed.

We stopped into Pizza Plus after a hike at Mike Kill state park. I had a slice of pepperoni pizza…read moreand a buffalo chicken salad. The pizza was fantastic. It was more like a NYC slice than anything I've had near home (Rochester NY area) and it came out quickly. The salad was satisfying and flavorful. Even the desert (peanut butter pie) was fantastic. The service was friendly and the dining room was warm and spacious. If you are going to eat someplace like Grand Gorge with just a few choices, be glad Pizza Plus is one of them.