Five of us were there on a Wednesday for dinner and were able to order off the $40 three-course special menu, which was more extensive than others we've seen. Like most three-course special menus, there are upcharges for various selections. Sometimes in retrospect I regret ordering three courses because a single entrée is sufficient. That was the case here because I was almost full after eating their chopped salad appetizer and the heated Italian bread and butter that preceded the entrée. I was surprised because an appetizer salad is often a small or medium sized plate, but here it's a full sized platter. Also, I ate it all, when I could've taken home half. Ditto for my entrée, their chicken marsala. I know that some of our friends purposely take home half of everything, so they get two meals out of one order. My decision, however, piggy as sounds, was that one of their included desserts was the tiramisu, which I have trouble resisting ... to the point where I try to sample them in as many restaurants and bakeries as possible, as if someday, somewhere, I'll submit an article on the subject ... "Tiramisus of Long Island and NYC." The food and service were very good, we had a large round table in the back, that made it easy for us to talk, a nice tablecloth and thick napkins, but I've had better tiramisu. A free glass of white or red wine came with the special, but I didn't like mine and should, like my son, have gotten a diet Coke instead (a permissible substitution). The parking situation was a minor hassle in that there was no valet, and while a sign in front of the restaurant suggested parking in the lot across the street, when we went there, the signs said that after 5:30 PM they'll tow you away, so we found a spot in the neighborhood and walked a few blocks. We'd be happy to go back, although there are Italian restaurants just as good that are closer to where we live. This Matteo's was half way between where we five reside, and convenience matters, especially on a weekday night. read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Chicken Marsala over pasta - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

food service hospitality ALL EXCELLENT !!! brian u are the best - thank U for the last-minute table at one of our favorite spots !!! see u soon read more

See all

The food is okay I guess the stuffed mushrooms is my favorite thing and it's like art of flavor exploding your mouth like Anton Ego eating his childhood meal. The rigatoni is so good! It's a Al Dente. The dessert is nice and it's nice and fresh. However I don't like the steak because it's too chewy but I still love the flavor and the temperature of the steak is perfect. The service is nice and it's kinda slow but I get it I think the server wants to served all the food at once so that's okay but it's slow but efficient. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The Ambiancr is cozy and like a nice cozy restaurant but it's not too Italian theme enough it I have suggestion I think if we have calm Italian music it will give the vibe of this restaurant and maybe have pizza on the menus to make it Italian theme but if you don't want to that's okay![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Always a great experience, and tonight was no exception. The food, the service, the atmosphere all outstanding. Well worth the cost on any given day, but If you have the opportunity to try the price-fixe, you will absolutely love it. The selections and portions are incredible. Big shoutout to Nicole, who we love, and Brian the manager. Both made our visit for my wife's birthday a phenomenal experience. Highly recommend and we will continue to return often. read more

Brian manager in Roslyn was excellent. He helped all the waiters. Vrry personable. Very people friendly. Will go back. Last guy was horrible. He is an asset to Rothmans. Will come back again soon. ​​​ read more

Another amazing meal at Matteo's! Branzino was Amazing! So was the cocktail: cosmic twist? Love the stuffed mushrooms, stuffed clams, and calamari and octopus salad appetizers. Waitress was good with recommendations and remembered all our requests. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Classy ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Matteo's Trattoria - whole branzino - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Matteo's has a great vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food is great, there is a great selection of entrees, pretty much everything you can ask for as far as Italian goes. The drinks are excellent. There has a great prix fixe that offers full sized appetizers and dessert and wine. Brian the manager is a great guy and makes sure everyone is happy and is always willing to accommodate . Dana is the best server and is very sweet. A definite must to try you'll be very happy. Highly recommended!!! read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Chicken sorrentino with spaghetti bolognese and truffle fries. Delicious. - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Two tables of over fifty plus available tables were seated when we walked in, we were dining with her friends - I've never met them and I head they're a real rowdy bunch. So, no surprise when we're were seated in the back, in a private room by the rear exit, they've been here before and must have left an impression[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. Eight people eating family style together, I was mostly quiet and didn't wanna flash my camera so I have no pictures to share. Mozzarella Balls and salad, antipasto and volumes of alcohol except for me. Well, I ordered a wine which I swirled and smelled and sipped upon lightly. Thick white tablecloths with little covered lights were soon covered with what, the women chose for the appetizers and entrees and the men talked kids and college and I swirled and smiled with interest. They're all really cool people, I just didn't have much to add so I focused on the food and the wine bottle wall as the volume steadily increased some more. Penne alle Vodka wasn't a vodka sauce at all, I think they had a little mix up in the kitchen but nobody noticed i don't think. Sausage and meatballs over spaghetti is good for Grannys house on Sunday, I'm starting to grow anxious while wondering if they ordered the homemade pasta, I'm hoping against hope, it never came. They all hate seafood and I think I'm the only Italian at the table as I longed to stand with menu in hand and start ordering the food all over from the beginning and if I was drinking, I probably would have. A few breaded pork chops appeared, a tough family style dish to equitably carve up and share, I'm not feeling the Italian food I believe Matteo's Restaurant can properly prepare is on the table. [[HIGHLIGHT]]And as we exited I had an opportunity to spy a few dishes as I slowed my pace and weaved around waiters and customers, the restaurant was now packed to the rafters[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. Perhaps another time she and I will return and order the dishes that I thought we should have. read more

Been here twice now, once back in Dec. 2023 when they offered Prix Fixe meals for $40/pp. It was the best deal - appetizer, entree and dessert. Choices were about half of the regular menu but very manageable. Last visit was Valentine's Day with my family. The restaurant was 85% full but still lucky I made a reservation. Given the snowfall the day before, it could have been hit or miss. Reservations made on Open Table, super easy. Appetizers we enjoyed: - prosciutto and mozzarella, you can choose 2 or 4 slices of prosciutto and then it's paired with huge cut pieces of fresh mozzarella. Plating wise, wish they had more fresh basil or garnish for color. And the mozzarella portion which was generous but oddly sized. Like balls split into halves. See photo. - grilled octopus with cannelloni beans over greens with vinegar and olive oil. Favorite appetizer of the night. - second favorite appetizer was the meatballs. Excellent sauce. - previous visit I had the baked clams and stuffed mushrooms. Those were good, same breading though so I probably should have ordered differently. Entrees: - veal milanese was delicious. Thin pieces of veal, nice shareable portions, breaded and served with fresh cut up tomatoes and chunks of fresh mozzarella. Again missing some green but it was really good. - mushroom pasta was creamy and rich. Enjoyed this. - Veal Parmesan was again, generous portions. Great sauce. - penne a la vodka with prosciutto, needed more sauce but it was very robust in flavor. This one had parsley on top, gave it a nice finished look. Complimentary bread basket and butter on the table. Nice table setting and when the waitress realized how cramped our table was, she opened up the panels on three sides, to give us more surface area. That made the dining experience more enjoyable. Desserts were also generous in portion. Can't believe that Napoleon was for an individual portion. Totally recommend this place but someone needs to work on the plating to make the dishes just a little extra. read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Food and ambiance is always excellent.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Brian is a great manager who accommodates your requests. If you want a lovely dinner out, go to Roslyn Matteo's. It doesn't disappoint. Thank you Brian. read more

Excellent food and most importantly service was above and beyond at Matteo's tonight. Dana, our sever and Brian, our host were extremely professional, polite and patient in taking care of us!! And ofcourse food and wine was the best we've had in awhile. Will absolutely be coming back!! read more

Had the prix fixe. Rather disappointed. Calimari was hard and over-cooked. Chicken parm was not very good. Wife's shrimp dish was so-so. Service was fine but can't overcome lousy food. read more

Enchanted Octopus - This was our first visit to Matteo's even though it's less than a mile from our home. My mom and I walked in on a Thursday evening at about 6pm and asked if there were any tables, as we hadn't a chance to make a reservation. The young lady at the front desk was sweet and friendly and told us to follow her. She gave us a phenomenal table and left us with her beautiful smile. Moments later she returned and was our waitress, apparently she was handling the entire front room which had about eight or nine tables totaling close to 30 people, usually a recipe for disaster. She was obviously more than just a pretty face. She charmed the entire room and was always checking to make sure her tables were happy. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Interestingly, the first seven or eight songs were Sinatra. I stopped her and said, I love Frank, but does your playlist contain anything other than Sinatra, perhaps Dean Martin, Tony Bennet or even Bobby Darin, she laughed and said, one of her customers had requested it and it was just a playlist and that she would change things up if we wanted.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] No. We love it, just curious. Anyway, the Caesar Salad was delicious, both Eggplant and Veal Parms were solid, more than we could eat, cheesy and delicious, and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the restaurant looked like a million bucks and functioned perfectly.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Dana made the night better than we thought possible and without eight arms, I can't imagine how she would have pulled it all off. Five stars ***** for Matteo's and Six ****** for Dana. read more

Thank you so much, Matteo's team and Brian, for making another company dinner truly amazing! Brian was beyond welcoming and accommodating during our service. The level of hospitality last night was incredible--every time we visit, we're greeted with such a warm welcome! The food was outstanding, and the service was exceptional. Brian, you truly did an amazing job leading the team. We love dining at Matteo's and look forward to visiting again in the near future. If you're looking for a place to host any event, this is THE SPOT! You won't leave disappointed. Thank you so much, Brian and the entire Matteo's team! Liz & Entire North Bay Cadillac GMC family. read more

food wasn't that good and service was very slow I wouldn't go back or recommend it to any of my friends

Great food and service. Always attentive to our needs and experience. Drinks were mixed to perfection

Food was delicious and the service was great! They were very attentive, our water glass's were never empty! We opted to do the 3 course price fix dinner. Such a great deal and a nice place for a Friday night dinner! The ambiance was quite nice, and it was a good meal. read more

See all

Matteos did it again! Our takeout order for New Year's Eve was spectacular! The quality of the food is consistently great! The portions are very generous, and the stuffed mushrooms melt in your mouth! Brian and his kitchen staff went above and beyond! We love Matteos, and we always look forward to dining there! We have recommended Matteos to friends and family, and everyone loves this beautiful restaurant! read more

I don't know what happened from the last time we were there, but I was truly & totally disgusted & Frustrated with what occurred there tonight! I've been in the food service business for over 30 years, & I have always loved this place & have always given them the respect & love they deserve, but not tonight. It started out by not getting the table we requested, they had a 6 top in our space but no one never called us to let us know, that they couldn't accommodate the orginal request. When we sat, we were greeted by a swarm of servers? It was nice to see but we weren't in the restaurant 5 minutes. The young man who is African American was the star of the show tonight. He didn't speak English but this young man was kind & on point! So we were rushed to place our order of appetizers , so I saw the baked clams,the server told me there were 8 in a regular order, & 12 in a family style order? He asked me if there was a problem & before I could answer, I stood looking at the menu because they were asking 29 dollars for 12 clams? I could not believe they were getting that kind of money for 12 little necks? I'm not usually cheap nor do I question prices, but that is ridiculous!!! The warm mozzarella was not warm but tough & cold. The calamari were average & under cooked. For the main course, we ordered, Veal Milanese & PapaDella pasta with a Mushroom crème sauce. The Veal was not Milanese, & when I asked the server, you guys don't melt the cheese on the veal?,His answer was, the grated cheese is right there? What the hell was that???The veal was flavorless as was the little bit of salad they give you with Milanese, The salad Lacked even the slightest of Parmesan shavings. The whole plate was cold. As for the pasta, that too was cold as well, in fact, both plates were sitting at the side of our table, for about 10 minutes before someone took it away, before they re-Served us? Where did they go with the plates, only God knows! We ordered Caesar salad in between the appetizers & the main course, & it lacked flavor & dressing!! BTW,Milanese means melted cheese on top of the cutlets!!! Last time we went, it wasn't a big deal, because they had chopped up fresh mozzarella & they put it with the salad on the side. I ordered lentil soup & it was the only thing that was done properly but they should remember that garlic is a seasoning not an ingredient. I don't know what has happened here but the place has changed. Maybe it's an isolated incident or it's become an on going problem because the owners are spreading themselves too thin now, with the acquisition of Louie's being their baby now. Quality is always so much more important than Quantity. If every one of your places aren't top notch & aren't serving your customers with the best of service & satisfaction, then having 10 restaurants means nothing! I'm taking a break for now because I'am truly dissatisfied & disappointed. My daughter ordered the 11 dollar sundae for dessert, which was one scoop of vanilla & chocolate cream, with whip cream, & chocolate syrup! I wouldn't have a problem with this, but then my daughter showed me a picture of the sundae the last time we came here, & as she pointed out, the size was very different. It's obvious the waiters or the runners are setting up the desserts. This looks like it was just thrown together & rushed!!! Sorry but when I spend 300 dollars on dinner, it has to be better, taste better, look better... The bread on the table was even hard, regardless of how long you heated it up!!!!!! read more

This is another one of those restaurants that I don't go to often then after I leave, can't understand why. This shop is not far from me, parking is easy, the place is big-bright with a lot of electricity in the air. They have been here for many years and they have a definite group of regulars you will see here all the time. My wife and I came during restaurant week. We ordered calamari to start. Perfect, just perfect. Great crispy coating with a very tender calamari inside. Very tasty too. We also had the baked clams which were delicious. A nice crispy light baked breading over a tender-delicious little neck clam. Both had enough liquid in the serving dished to properly dip our bread. Main dishes included Shrimp Oregenata for my wife and I had the Sole Oregenata. These dishes were prepared perfectly. The shrimp were tasty and cooked perfectly. A light brown bread crumb over the shrimp. My sole was also prepared the same way.. The two entrees were hot and loaded with flavor. We came late and they were still very busy. I was impressed at the attention to detail that. the waiter always showed and just how pleasant he was. I realize that it gets tougher as it gets later and this is an amazing team of people. Perhaps that why this restaurant has been here so long. KUDOs to the team at Matteo's Trattoria read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Busy night here for restaurant week. - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

I've been to this location twice and really enjoyed it. It has a modern open airy vibe and the staff was attentive. Both times I had the prix fix (not available Fri or Sat). Both meals were good but unfortunately I became very sick after my most recent meal. I'm not sure if it was the Cesar salad or the salmon and spinach. Still, I'll probably give it one more try... I'm hoping it was just a fluke. read more

See all

Excellent food and service! The staff did a fantastic job putting together a party for my mom's birthday. Leading up to the party, they were super helpful and willing to answer any questions, as well as provide recommendations for cake and flower vendors nearby. They were incredibly attentive the day of the event and everything went off without a hitch. read more

We had a wonderful meal at the bar. Everyone we met was welcoming and friendly. We've eaten at Matteo's for years. The food is consistently delicious. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We loved the transformation of the inside[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] , as well read more

I came here on a Friday night with my husband and baby for a date night, and the restaurant was so so accommodating! I called first to see if they could accommodate a stroller, and they said they could. We brought our baby in his stroller and they sat us in a corner where there was plenty of space to park the stroller and not have to stress about getting in anyones way! We ordered calamari to start, and my oh my was it FRESH! No chewy rubbery feeling, it actually melted in your mouth! My husband got the bolognese, which they were kind enough to make with a pappardelle instead of the rigatoni listed on the menu. I ordered the chicken Milanese with a side of rigatoni Alfredo. Everything was absolutely delish, my husbands only complaint was he felt the bolognese was a little too meaty. The wait staff was so kind, and even provided a cup of hot water to heat our baby's bottle! Solid choice for a delish Italian meal, clean bathrooms, and lovely wait staff! Would go back!! read more

See all

Long Island Restaurant week kick off! $37 per person + $3 for wine or beer (GREAT DEAL!) Started with calamari, baked clams and Caesar salad. The options are endless. The next table got the burrata and I'm just wishing I could order the whole menu. Service was attentive and polite but definitely our waiter was annoyed I brought kids ‍ the manager or owner was super nice though and even came to speak to them. Cute. Our service was quick and food came pretty on point. The house wine (red cab) was full bodied and great tasting. We went with the pork chop, the salmon, bolognese. Everything was cooked to perfection and the flavor was delightful and delicious. The kids loved the ice cream and canolli and we enjoyed our coffee, Irish coffee read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a such great place to host a party and family gathering dinners![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food is amazing and delicious. The staffs are professional and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant for all of you! read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

Great food. Stuffed veal chop is amazing! Great weekday night specials. [[HIGHLIGHT]]lovely restaurant.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Baked clams are delicious read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The food, service and ambiance is wonderful there![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Had a great waiter, named Darwin who provided excellent service. I love Matteos and go weekly! This is the 1st time having Darwin as a server and he was wonderful and has great personality!!! read more

Darwin was the best! His customer service was above and beyond. Always checked on us and asked if there was anything we needed. Food was good and we will be back! read more

What an awesome meal ! We went with the price fixe for dinner. Plenty of food for 39.99. Started with the stuffed mushrooms which were delicious . Had the chicken ultimo which was outstanding . Chicken cutlet in a franchese sauce with hot cherry peppers and melted mozzarella. This dish as a killer. I can't recommend Matteo's enough. We got there early around 5:30 by the time we got our apps the place was crowded. read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Chicken ultimo - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

See all

Came for Valentine's Day and had a pretty good experience. Our server was incredibly attentive and made sure we always had what we needed. Food was huge as far as portion size, and good in taste - though nothing I have an urge to go back and get again. We started with the warm mozzarella and Caesar salad, which were plated for each of us table side, and for entrees we had the spicy rigatoni and rigatoni siciliana with eggplant and mozzarella. Dessert was probably the biggest disappointment - though the napoleon looked amazing, it was very fluffy and whipped and didn't have the custard consistency that a great napoleon has. read more

See all

I went with family to celebrate- The veal which should melt in your mouth ( if cooked correctly) was tough, another dish was very spicy- which it should not have been- almost like someone poured hot chili powder in it. The acoustics in the restaurant are terrible- very loud, could hardly hear myself or anyone speak. The waitstaff were wonderful... ( 4 stars for them) and should get a raise. Overall, it was very disappointing. Maybe I just had a bad dish- they offered to replace it which was nice but by that time I lost my appetite. I did not want to leave a bad review- but I was not happy. read more

I recently dined here for LI restaurant week. The restaurant was making sure they take precautions with guests that dined there with spaced out tables and staff masked the entire time. I decided to go the seafood route in my options on the LI restaurant week menu. For the appetizer I got the baked clams which had a crunchy buttery seasoned breadcrumb topping and served with a slice of lemon in case you prefer an extra squeeze of acid to the palate. For the entree I decided to go with the filet of sole oreganata style. It was light and flaky and just the right amount of food. My sister in law got the roasted chicken which the dish was large enough to save for a second meal. For dessert I wanted to try their tortoni, but they ran out for the night. Instead I opted to get the biscotti with homemade cannoli cream. The cream had just enough sweetness that paired well with the crunchy biscotti cookie. I would definitely return back in the future. read more

See all

Came here on a Tuesday for a $39.95 special with a wine, app, entree, and dessert. The portions were large and delicious. I the got the sangria, stuffed mushrooms, spaghetti bolognese and the amaretto ice cream. My friends also got shrimp pasta and zucchini fries. Everything was amazing A must go to ! read more

My family and I Just had dinner at Matteo's in Roslyn. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The food , service and ambience were absolutely amazing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server Nikki was attentive and couldn't have been more accommodating. Can't wait to return! read more

Returned here in Jan 2024 after spending 15 years living in LA and dreaming of the chopped salad, clams casino, and veal parm... and my expectations and experience were surpassed! Not only did the restaurant interior have a beautiful makeover but the recipes were exactly the same and perfect as I remember. The prices have gone up but so has everything, I believe the midtown tunnel was about $4.50 when I left and now it is $12! Back to the restaurant, it's best to call for a reservation ahead of time. The waiter was prompt, the food was cooked to order and I highly recommend all things Italian on the menu! read more

See all

The food & service at this restaurant was awesome. Our waiter Al was amazing & knew the new 3 course menu which was $39.95 like the back of his hand. He suggested items on the menu that we may like as well as knew pairings of wines with our food. He was extremely pleasant & allowed us to enjoy our dining experience with great service but little interruption! My niece said she visited this establishment 2X before & loved everything about it. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

The food was delicious. There was a price fix. I had chicken francaise and it was definitely a winner. My appetizer was calamari which was also good. My friend had fried zucchini and it was excellent. I'll definitely return. read more

Solid spot We went there for our anniversary dinner last year and the food was very good. Today, we had some friends over and I had a craving for Italian food so I was browsing their website and found a family dinner deal for $79 which includes: - house red or white wine - loaf of Italian bread - tray of salad - tray of pasta - tray of chicken or eggplant dish It was such a good deal! I called them to place and order and picked up in 30 minutes. Judging from the food containers piled up by the reception desk, takeout seems to be much more popular than dine in during this time (understandably). However the customers dining in appeared to be appropriately socially distanced. Will definitely keep Matteos in mind for future family dinners! read more

Matteo's Trattoria - Family meal for $79 during COVID - Italian Near Me - Roslyn Heights, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Hector and everyone was so so unbelievably great and best food, service and ambiance!![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] My favorite spot in my neighborhood... read more