My favorite pub, bar and grill in Putnam County! Appetizers are excellent (buffalo calamari) and dinner's are great too (Veggie Sandwich). Let's not forget they have great Guinness too!!! read more

Delicious food! We love to go there for lunch and enjoy their outdoor seating near the waterfall. Most of all, we love our waitress' Gina and Beatrice!! Very attentive, friendly and accurate! My menu favorites:Chicken Bruschetta sandwich, the Chicken Parm Wrap, and the Balboa steak sandwich. You will not be disappointed with their salads either! Always FRESH! Love their homemade croutons and zesty Italian dressing...mmmm! My friend often orders their spicy Cajun sauce with grilled chicken and mixed veggies. The sauce is perfect for you spicy lovers! read more

Love the food here but they outdid themselves tonight. Got take out. The portions were huge. Food excellent. Also our bartender/ server Gina is the best. Always a good time there with friends and their extremely friendly and great staff. Check it out. read more

Great comfort food, excellent soups and friendly bartenders. I stop here every time I am in the area.

This is a wonderful restaurant for family and friends to gather. great food and service. We enjoy trivia on Tuesday night and happy hour.

For Superbowl we had wings catered from this place and holy crap were they terrible. Firstly they were so small my infant child was able to fit the entire wing up his nose with ease. Thats not all ! They didn't even burn the little guy because the wings were not even sauced with anything remotely "buffalo" flavored. After nibbling at a couple wings i grew tired and only ate the celery and chugged the bluecheese just to get come calories in my body . Also just gonna throw in here that the bar is shitty to. read more

Delicious, down to earth, amazing service. The menu means that the whole family will be accommodated for, and their specials are always great. They have a full bar, and a dining room in the back if you prefer to have a quieter meal, or if it's nice out the outdoor seating area is beautiful. They've done a great job with McCarthys -- go for lunch, dinner, or even throw a party in their private room! read more

My family and I eat here often! The food and service is great even when they are busy! Very expansive menu with great options! During the spring and summer months it is so nice to sit outside by the waterfall! They have great specials and the price and portions ate great! Very kid friendly, I definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

Great drink specials, delicious food, attentive staff and beautiful outdoor area. Really not understanding these reviews. We will be back and back and back. read more

We have all of our parties at McCarthy's. They are so welcoming & attentive. The food is really good. It is laid-back casual too.

Had a nice lunch, friendly service. Impressive soup list. Would go back if we were in the area again.

Good place for a burger and a beer. Great for watching games; they always have specials during big games.

Went for the wings, which were simply tremendous. Maybe the best wings I've ever had in the area. Nice, clean inside with a big menu. Decent beer selection, good service. I would go again to try other food, but I will definitely go again to have the wings. read more

This is a solid restaurant. Good comfort food. I never review on the first visit, but I like this place. Listen, it's not fancy. The nachos are served on parchment paper in a plastic basket. But they're good. Sloppy, yummy, loaded with all the good stuff. My son had a cheesesteak. He liked it. My husband had a specialty burger. He liked it. It was cooked properly. I had the shepards pie. It was good. Too much to finish. The wait staff was great. Plenty of tv's. Great music playing. There is a nice patio out back that must be great in nicer weather. I am looking forward to coming back. read more

My salad was wilted and actually starting to brown I had to send it back to be replaced with fresh salad the second salad came out fresh so that tells me they had fresh salad but chose to put out the wilted salad first. My burger was under cooked instead of giving me a new burger cooked properly they chose to give me back the burger ripped in half and buns still soaked in Greece when I spoke to the owner and the answer was very poor I also ordered a carafe of red wine and because they were out of The house wine they couldn't fill my request. they could not give me the next red wine?the wine being sold out is not the customers fault,The right thing to do would be to use your better wine and make the customer happy. the downfall of this restaurant is the owner The staff is friendly but the owner has ruined this place she is the cause of the negativity the only thing on her mind is making money not recommended anymore by me i'm not going back read more

This has been a regular place for us but I am very unhappy with the quiet changes they have been making. They used to have great fries but have now changed to a cheaper tasteless French fry. I did let them know it was an awful change. Tonite we went for my favorite half honey dipped fried chicken. They have now reduced it to three pieces. So my half chicken was missing a thigh and hubbys was missing a wing so every half a chicken is missing a part and yes the menu claims half a chicken? Bummer when your farorite places makes changes to save a buck read more

My friends and I were in the mood for some buffalo wings and some cold beer on tap.well the wings were the worst I've ever experienced ,they were small and meatless and dried out .to make it worse we needed to wash done these lousy wings with warm beer , we couldn't wait to get out of there .....no go! read more

$10 for a well vodka and tonic for a local bar is more than I have paid in even a fine dining establishment. Used to frequent this place a few years back but for sure won't be coming here to drink or eat when I can pay half the price 15 minutes further at the pawling tavern. read more

Wing night is the bomb. So delish and kids eat free on Mondays. Lots of drink specials and very nice to sit outside on a summer day. Casual and good service. read more

Great food, nice atmosphere, and the bar tenders are excellent. great place after a round of golf, or on day off.

Fun place to be at night, younger crowd but the bartenders are always friendly and you can grab a decent bite to eat as well.

I have been to McCarthy numerous time, my meals have always been pretty good to say the least. That's why I have been a repeat customer. Last nite I went there with my wife and daughter for a early dinner. The selection of soups are amazing the two soups we ordered were perfect and great tasting as well. The wife's cranberry bleu salad was very good and a great portion size. The waiter was very friendly and a pleasure to be served by. The 2 burgers we ordered on the other hand were not good to say the least. I ordered mine medium which pretty much was as rare as you can get. After the second bite the blood running out of it was way to much for me by far. Actually when the waiter came over to see if all was ok, I said not really my burger was way to rare he said no problem we will recook that one I also said all the blood on the roll can I have another roll with that burger, absolutely. My daughter who ordered her burger well done, was also rare after her third bite no where near well done hers went back as well. Mind you we are the only ones in the restaurant at the time so I believe its kind of hard to not pay attention to the only two burgers cooking in the kitchen. Well to my surprise the same two burgers we sent back came back well done which I knew was going to happen to my burger anyway at least now my daughter was happy as I was not, I did get a new half roll to accommodate part of the burger that was cut off to make it look appetizing when they sent it back to us, I guess. My complaint, to send out the same 2 burgers your chef screwed up on is not acceptable, you guys could do better and put 2 new burgers on the grill and send those out, are you guys that hard pressed to save a dollar come on penny wise dollar foolish!. I won't be back for a while so now you guys saved a penny but lost my dollars in the the near future!!! Good Job read more

My father and sons (ages 14 and 12) frequented McCarthy's last night (February 17th) for dinner. We ordered two 16 ounce NY Strip Steaks (one rare and one medium rare), fried Haddock, and 2 bowls of French onion soup. One order of the soup was requested to be brought with the entrees as a meal. I'm sad to say the steaks were TERRIBLE. Not only were they cooked well done but one of then was almost completely fat and grizzle. My father would NOT let us send the food back. Normally that is something I would never do either but this was just terrible. At $24.99 per steak, this was very disappointing. I would avoid McCarthy's for this reason. read more

I live very near McCarthy's and I'm so glad I do. The best burgers, fries, soup and sandwiches in Carmel in a relaxed setting. While the decor could use a little updating, the menu and service are just what you want in a casual restaurant. During the warm months there's a great outdoor area...as long as you're upwind from the smokers. During the cold months, there's a huge soup menu to enjoy. read more

First of all don't listen to a word Vincent says. Vincent is a carnivore and doesn't even eat salad!!! He's just complaining because he got bullied I'm high school for not liking salad. The ambiance is great and the checks are hand written. Mccarthys rules. Fuck you Vincent. read more

I would highly recommend McCarthy's. My husband & I went to dinner there one day & the food was great, the waiter Mike was fabulous & they do parties their too. I had my mom & dad's 50th wedding anniversary party there & I couldn't be happier with the service they provided. I absolutely give them 5 stars. read more

Good soups. I love the wings I just wish on wing night you can get any flavor for the deal, not just regular bc buffalo sauces tend to give me stomachs in general. Burger night is good too! read more

Love this place! Excellent food, excellent service. Great place to bring the whole family. Best wings and burgers in Carmel.