For a hole in the wall looking place, the food isn't bad. Have never seen more then one or two other groups in there at a time. They have a small variety of sandwiches and more sauces then you can shake a stick at. If you are hankering for a sandwich, especially something BBQ, it is not a bad option. The cost seems out of line with the atmosphere. They recently started carrying Mr. Cupcakes. Nice idea, but do yourself a favor and drive down to Clifton to get some fresh ones, as you can definitely tell the difference. read more

Food is good, the owner is friendly and pleasant, but their prices are very high. I somehow spent over $ 20.00 on lunch for one and I only ordered a cup of chili, onion rings, water and a pint of their jar sauce to go. crazy, crazy, crazy. read more

The food is good but not exceptional. Their prices are ridiculously expensive. They charge double what other grills charge. You leave here feeling ripped off. However they are the only grill in this part of town. If it wasn't for the prices, I would eat here more often. The atmosphere is enjoyable. It is an old fashioned, American classic type of restaurant. read more

Food is average at best. Just "meh", as yelp would put it. The pulled pork is kind of dry, and the chicken sandwiches are bland. I've never encountered a less friendly staff. They aren't mean, but every time I walk in I get that "I was trying to text my boyfriend and now you interrupted me and I can't smile" vibe. The only redeeming quality is the ice cream bar. Their ice cream comes from Gelotti's. They have a ton of flavors and make sundaes. read more

Nice place, decent food, but I thought it was extremely expensive for a hamburger place! Their prices are like a restaurant.

Even though they have Delicious ice cream, I don't think I'll be back. Kids meals too expensive - $10!!!!!! Inside is for food orders only - so if it's 90degrees, you can only order ice cream outside. read more

$7.45 for small onion rings!!! What? Stopped in for a quick pulled chicken sandwich, small onion rings and a small coke - over $20. That's crazy. Chicken sandwich came with small cup of cole slaw and a small cup of bbq sauce and a few pickle slices. It was just OK, big enough for me but not huge, served on a burger bun. Onion rings were pretty good, lots of breading but very crispy - enough for 2, but I'm only 1 and $7.45 is way too much. For that much $ I can get a really nice dinner from a better restaurant - sorry, I'll never go here again. read more

Ridiculously over priced! Over $8 for a cheeseburger that was dry and literally had nothing on it except cheese. The fries were bland and what was supposed to be potato cheddar soup tasted more like potato tang. The soup is actually inedible! My total was $20.21 for this slop. I will never eat here again! read more

I REALLY WANTED TO LIKE THEM. I REALLY,REALLY WANTED THIS TO WORK. BUT,I'd give no stars if I could. I know years ago THE MILK BARN was packed which was nearby and torn down ( maybe McCobbs is trying to be like that and they do advertise Gelotti....(I like Totowa s gellotti flavors) So that is what they trying to emulate as a family gathering along with an ice cream stand....nice outdoor tables, a stocked trout river behind them,hotdogs, shakes, burgers, and other items It can be a hit or miss dr pending on the day or nite . Not cheap either. The grilled chicken sandwich was good. But,I would rather go to Paul's in W.Milford or Hiram s in Fort Lee ( my fav) for dogs, shakes, burgers, etc.if I had the option. NOW FOR THE WORST PART. THE MILK BARN IT'S NOT! I did not want yo wait on the long line at Curlys around the bend. And I don't know , or have family involved or work for either of them I must mention.( the line at Curlys and no line at McCobbs on a nice summer evening should tell you something right?) We'll , knowing their shakes and seeing the Gelotti brand( which supposedly comes from the place I go in Totowa I figured how bad can it be? Well, EVEN if it's family at least train the window person before you throw her on it! A young girl who I asked for two vanilla soft serve sundaes ; one with strawberry , one with chocolate.She looked at me like she had never heard of one let alone made or seen one. Many places have made their smalls become mediums and the mediums become large in this economy like everything. I did not however expect a sundae that was melting before I even paid for it handed to me! Not even syrup but a jellied , or congealed strawberry topping (really gross put in the clear lid,instead of the usual white Styrofoam cup bottom. I asked where the lid was, so she put the white Styrofoam bottom on it but as I tryed to pick it up and pay for it it was spilling everywhere since it was the clear flexible lid on the bottom. I was so preoccupied with my situation and the guy behind me was seeing this and getting impatient since it looked like a Charlie Chaplin comedy short. He was finally offered help by the same girl because he spoke up as I was trying to mop up all the mess. He walked away disgusted because they did not even have Italian ice. Meanwhile while I was waiting for the girl to make my second sundae ,the soft serve vanilla with chocolate syrup , some older person had noticed this science project and me trying to pick it up and mop it up as the girl had given me a LG white Styrofoam bottom to support the medium size clear lid now a bottom.The adult told her to make a new one. I also at that point added that I would appreciate having a "complete sundae"with whipped cream and a cherry on both sundaes. She did remake the strawberry one, but I also had to wait yet again because she made the chocolate sundae with chocolate soft serve instead of vanilla soft serve. A pretty simple order turned ridiculously bad. And the whipped cream ( chemical or cool whip I am not sure , but it was awful to taste AND look at .In addition the whipped cream & cherrys she also forgot again ,so she put them all in separate containers ? A fix it yourself with more mess? Both sundaes were melting into ice cream soup and over flowing and the night was not that warm. I was the only customer during all of this except the other man who left. I forgot what it was for the two large sundaes ; but the bill was not cheap either, but it was also not worth it in anyway. The probably should have just offered them to me I guess for my trouble . Still even at that, I know NEVER TO GO THERE FOR ICE CREAM EVER AGAIN. Like the other guy said to me as he left, there's obviously a reason there's no line here on a nice night like tonite. All I can say is if Hal Roach had seen it, he would have filmed it. read more

good food but the most expensive hot dog joint I have ever been to.. definately good all the way sauce and shakes

We used to come here a few years back and the food was good, however, and I hate to say it has truly gone down hill. The food quality was awful and extremely overpriced. What a shame. read more

The best Chocolate Carmel Macchiato coffee I have ever had anywhere! They also have excellent BBQ food and the place is always clean and we'll kept. I also enjoy their Geloti' s ice cream and home made Cannoli's! read more

McCobbs is a great place with great food. The employees are friendly however they are quite pricey.

This was my first visit to McCobb's. It was on the off-peak time of 4:30 on a Monday afternoon. I ordered texas weiner all the way, a small quarter pounder cheeseburger all the way and cajun fries which came with bleu cheese or some other sauce. I sat at my seat, waited for my order to finish and paid at the registered. I listened to country music while enjoying my food. The cheeseburger was much smaller than expected, perhaps more of a slider. The hot dog tasted great as an all the way meal. The topping is top-notch in comparison to others. Much of this meal content came from the fries. Burger and hot dog are probably not enough but the fries made it too much. At least I didn't have to worry about being hungry soon after. $5.49 for the "slider", $4.19 for the hot dog, $2.99 for fountain soda and $5.25 for the fries which is considered an appetizer got a bit up there in price. They have outdoor seating in the back and live music some evenings. read more

A "family" restaurant designed to gauge families of their money. Kids meal is $10. Smallest size ice cream is $5. So feeding two kids is minimum $30 plus tax/tip. The $9 sandwiches come without fries, which are $5 to add. The space out back is great and the food is decent to good. Could be a great spot if they just priced the food more appropriately. read more

In a word: HORRIBLE!! Overpriced, poor quality, TERRIBLE service.

way way to expensive for sub par food...go to Pompton Queen Diner for way better and way way cheaper food

i ate here one time a couple years ago and ordered the pulled pork sandwich. it wasn't bad but very pricey and not too filling. observing the rest of the menu i saw how prices here were much higher than your average grill. i'll certainly take my business elsewhere. read more

Yelp really needs to add an option of ZERO stars. McCobbs used to be very good-even with the high prices. I don't mind paying when the food is good, but sadly it has taken a huge downward turn. At least they used to give giant orders of fries so you could fill up on those - now it's just a small cup- so what was a signature item is now just a tiny cheap cup of fries. I guess since no customers are going there they have had to cut back to save money. The hot roast beef was tasteless and bland - the optional sauces didn't help it at all. The macaroni and cheese was lukewarm spiral pasta on a styrofoam plate with a horrid sauce poured on the center. The milkshakes were small and absurdly overpriced. For over $50.00 ..... ANYTHING would have been better. They mistakenly gave us an order of onion rings (also a small order compared to what it used to be) and one of the fry cooks came over to the table and when they picked it up the onion rings spilled all over the table- he swept them back in the plate with his hand and took them across the room to another table. Disgusting. So obviously they don't follow any health protocols either. Bad food, bad attitudes , no concern for health protocols... Now I know why there was no one else in there. For the sake of your health and your wallet skip it and keep on driving. This place needs to close and end its death spiral. read more

Food was gross. Owner boasts about getting the ground beef from a butcher for an unheard of price per pound. Well I ate the burger and it tasted like scrapple. They must grind up the gizzards, hearts and add something else like corn meal into their burgers because it definitely tasted stale and like scrapple! Also, burger for $8.99 doesn't come with fries. Sodas are $3...ridiculously priced considering the place is always dead. Gravy fries were gross, gravy is right out of a can. Heck, I'll go to Johnny and Hangies where the same money gets you twice as much food and it's delicious and fresh. This place needs to listen to it's customers that are ALL telling them their prices are too high. Their head is inflated thinking that they have old school customers that come here purely for nostalgia. Well, this area is changing. If you don't listen to your CURRENT customers then you might as well put this horse out of it's misery. Otherwise it will be a long and steady decline if things don't change. read more

I've passed this place so many times and I finally stopped there for lunch with my fiance and two kids this past Saturday. Let me start out by saying that I WILL NEVER GO THERE AGAIN. Our bill was $60.00 and I have no problem paying that amount of money if the quality is there. My meal was a cheeseburger for $8.00 and fries for $3 and some change. You would think that the cheeseburger would come with lettuce, tomato even some onion but nope just a patty with a slice of cheese on bread. Got a hot dog for $4.00. A cup of Chili that I can't complain about. Chicken Tenders for $8.00 and another set of fries. In all honestly, the quality was not there, you can tell that everything was frozen. Completely over priced for what they give you. Also the girl at the counter was very impolite couldn't even give you a smile. Save your money and go to the Lantern in Haskell or Jersey Johnny's in Pequannock. Much better quality and more friendly. read more