Doing campaign canvassing for the 2024 election. I time to be selective about where to eat. I see the shopping center with two restaurants, one closed, so this the choice. Looks dreary, large space with an inactive billiards table and a bar area, don't know if this place is popular in the evening. TV is on some nondescript program. I order a fish sandwich and a bottle of Diet Coke. I sit in a booth, the seat cushions with depressions from presumably decades of tushys sitting. This place needs to invest in modern upgrades to the interior The sandwich was excellent. Icy breaded and cooked (likely frozen mass produced but still good, with shredded lettuce and a bit of tomato on an excellent soft Italian bread roll, plus the right amount of tangy tartar sauce (also mass produced). I really enjoyed it! My rate: service 3, food 4, location 4, atmosphere 2, value 4, for an overall score of 3. read more

See all

Stopped here for lunch while we were waiting on tire service and was pleasantly surprised at how delicious our pizza was for a completely random stop. The menu had a wide variety of Italian offering like pizza, calzone , parmesan and assorted pasta dishes . We went with a NY size "20 large pie with bacon and pepperoni . The service was very friendly and our pizza was cooked to perfection. The crust was crisp and airy with generous portions of toppings on a bed of delicious cheese and sauce. Cozy , simple dining area is more than sufficient for you to enjoy your pie and a beer. read more

Midtown Pizza - Take out NY Pie w bacon and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

I absolutely loved their Jumbo Shrimp Platter. I was in town and decided to go in. I sat in.. and ordered my shrimp platter, and a bottled water. The man who waited on me, seemed nice. My food came out, it was nice and hot. I went to bite into the shrimp, immediately noticed it was very buffet from before. Very mushy and an odd after taste. I did bit into a few more, figuring maybe it was just that shrimp. No, all (4) that I tried, the other two shrimp, I didn't even see. Fries were good, but their ketchup, is really odd. Has a bad taste. I went to pay my bill, as no one checked on me, and he asked if I wanted a to go box, of course I refused. When he asked if something was wrong, I did tell him. He said, oh, ok. He did nothing for me .. left the whole meal. Will not be going back. read more

Best cheese pizzas in middletown. Every time I order it's fast and delicious. Was going to another pizza place nearby and it doesn't even come close to how good this pizza is. The staff are always super nice when I pickup or they deliver to me. read more

Good food, good service. It's our go to pizza place. Prices are reasonable. Option to eat in or take out.

Delivery to hotel Aug 7 Very user friendly website to order food - thank you! Delivers to the new Fairfield Inn hotel at the airport - one of a handful that does. Ordered Chicken wings and I am going to blame them on me. I clicked on "extra crispy" and they came pretty much too fried to eat. again - I blame ME..So heads up - extra crispy means just that! I also would order extra sauce on the wings as well - next time So what I really really liked was the Hot Meatball Parm sub. The large was huge and full of very good meatballs. cheese melted properly and bread was fresh. My only add would be extra pizza sauce next time. read more

Midtown Pizza - Meatball Parm Sub - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered 2 pizzas, 1 meat lovers and 1 primavera pizza. Also got fries which were portioned way more than expected! You can definitely share with someone else and it'd be more than enough! The meat lover pie wasn't bad by any means. This pie was of the thin crust variety that you'd get from a frozen pizza. The primavera pizza wasn't bad either but the crust was just a bit too thin and didn't really pack that "fresh" made punch that other pizza shops in town deliver. 30$ for these two pizzas and fries. Not bad for the price but, would take my money elsewhere for better pizza! read more

We ordered online for pickup. We ordered a plain cheese New Yorker and garlic butter wings. Everything was very good the pizza was huge, the wings could have used more garlic. read more

Midtown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

See all

Midtown Pizza will always be my preferred pizza place near home, or even bar when I am in the mood for a drink. The staff is always super friendly no matter where you sit. We were waited on by Sherry who happened to be the only server/bartender on the floor - the bar was packed and two booths were full. Sherry did her absolute best to provide us with a good experience, which is appreciated. I also took a friend for her first time and she is excited to come back! Thank you, Midtown! read more

Midtown Pizza - Malibu diet, whiskey ginger, alcohol, mixed drinks - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

Worst pizza and delivery ive ever had. If i could leave zero stars i would. Placed an order for delivery and expectation was 20 min to delivery. An hour later and no pizza. Had to call and ask what was the problem. Delivery showed up, with a cld pizza non the less and the pizza sucked! Not sure how you screw up a pizza. read more

I ordered online for delivery only to get a message after I finished paying with pick up instructions. I had even added and paid a tip for the driver. I called them and was told they don't deliver to my address. They have delivered to me several times and as recently as 2 weeks ago! Since I had already paid I went out to pick it up. I'm glad I did. I was really surprised how crowded it was and employees in the kitchen and working the counter were not wearing masks. They were in a small space, unmasked, preparing food. They would not refund my $5 tip because the owner wasn't there. And the pizza was not good. read more

I'm very picky when it comes to pizza but my mother insisted on this place. They have a full menu with a lot more than pizza. We ordered a whole pie with pepperoni. I was surprised I didn't even have to tell them to brown the bottom a little. The pizza was perfect- just enough cheese and sauce. The crust gave off a little crunch just the way I like it. This location has indoor and outdoor dining plus beer and wine on-site. I noticed they have weekday and weekend specials too! The staff is friendly and the food was ready in a timely fashion. The pizza was even better the next day after popping it in the oven. I don't order pizza often but Midtown will be on my list if I do. read more

As amazing as their food can be, they frequently mess up our orders. Recently We had family members over and we bragged and bragged about how great midtown pizza is so naturally they wanted to order from them. An hour plus later the delivery driver did not provide the entire order. Nor did they provide an accurate order on the items that were delivered. It's been very frustrating. Especially since we live here and we really like their food but only when they get the order right which is 50% of the time. If they'd up their quality control game they could be 5 stars. They need better management! read more

Ordered take out a couple days ago from them. The Buff chick pizza was ok. I think there were a few pieces of chicken somewhere in there. Also ordered the calamari. In a word: awful. 11 little rings that tasted and looked like they were fried last week and were the leftovers from a regular order. We've noticed the quality of most take out during the virus is less than mediocre, maybe because they know the paying customer is grabbing the order and leaving. We've ordered wings from this place many times and they were great. Maybe we'll keep it to just wings. read more

My wife and I stayed at the comfort inn and called for dinner. We had a sandwich and lasagna. I mean this was not like being in Italy but the food was decent and the service was excellent. I will say that it was convenient to deliver the food to the hotel after a long day of travel. we will use this restaurant again when we are in Middletown. read more

We have visited this place a few times now and it is our favorite pizza! We had no issues with customer service like previous reviews, it's more of a sit down on your own and refill your own water kind of place. I definitely plan on returning when we are Portland again. read more

Midtown Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

See all

From the outside this restaurant looks tiny but you'll be suprised by the size of this place. There's a nice little bar, and the lighting is relaxed. The interior decor is pretty fancy. (Well looking at their sign and comparing it too the interior). This place definitely got me off guard. They have more than just pizza. My roommate and I ordered their calamari, which was excellent. And we got their Hawaiian style pizza which was delicious. The pizza is more like the authentic style crust, and did I mention they handmake the dough? It's good stuff. I'll definitely becoming here more, now that I know its not a shady pizza place. read more

Hands down best cold cut or hot subs ive EVER had. Bread was nice and crisp but still really soft. I came another time with my wife to dine in and the food was absolutely amazing. Ordered the loaded fries and was amazing at how good they were. I then ordered the gnoochi bolognese with side of meatballs and i cannot stress enough how flavorful and filling this food was. Ive eaten at some really good places and this place has the 2nd best gnoochi compared to the gordon ramsey steakhouse in baltimore. This place is really under appreciated but at least I appreciate it so keep making good and cheap food read more

AVOID AT ALL COSTS I cannot actually give Midtown Pizza a star. The Yelp app forced me to rate it in order to post this warning to all mankind. Rewarding this place with a star would imply that there was some redeeming quality, there was none. The tap beer tasted as if the tap system had never been cleaned, ever. Needless to say there are a few organisms growing in there. I ordered the wings and loaded fries. Now, I realize that it's just "bar food", however that doesn't mean that a restaurant shouldn't put in an effort. The wings were undercooked, the sauce (jalapeño-ranch) were completely VOID OF ANY FLAVOR. Let me make sure that sinks in...spicy Jalapeño and creamy ranch, two very zesty and robust flavors, should have made for a very tasty sauce. However this was not the case. The sauce did not stick to the wing, instead it was very runny, as if cut with water, a dubious cost-saving tactic that renders the customer sick and disappointed. If you like under cooked, unflavored wings and cherish the feeling of disappointment, you'll love these wings. I hedged my bets and also ordered the "loaded fries", the name is just a flat out lie. There is nothing "loaded" about them. It was maybe 12 small fries with a drizzle of cheese sauce, "mozzarella" sprinkle cheese, and about 5 bacon bits. That's not an estimate my friends, I counted the bacon bits...there was only 5. Both of these bets, proved to bankrupt my tastebuds. The staff, while not rude, did not bother to ask me how the food was, as if they knew it was awful. Essentially, they left you to your own devices, to navigate the disappointment on your own and discover the depravity of truly awful food. Ultimately, Midtown Pizza just left me sad, wondering why John Taffer, from Bar Rescue, doesn't fly in, scolded everyone, and just "SHUT IT DOWN!" Even the mighty bar hero cannot save this place. Starvation not only tastes better, but is more compelling than the bacteria-tasting beer, terrible wings, and the sparse "loaded" fries. There is a calming reassurance in knowing where the rock-bottom of the food-service industry is, it is Midtown Pizza. read more

About average. Nothing special. The usual Central Pa pizza and sub fare. And they, like so many others out here, use pizza dough for their hoagies and cheese steaks. As a Philly boy, Let me say one thing about cheesesteaks: if you're going to call yours a "Philly" cheesesteak, you need to get the roll (noted before) and cheese right. The proper cheese for a Philly cheesesteak is either whiz or provie. Not American. Blech. And the sauce was a bit too sweet, but that's the least offense committed here against cheesesteakdom. read more

I like the people working here, but had a bad experience tonight. An order for delivery was to arrive 30 -45 min. 60+ minutes later they showered up (they are almost 1 mile away). The "30-45 min" is a no commit estimate. My boli showed up tepid, not even warm. The "crust" was slightly browned, but very chewy. I hope I'm able to reheat it in an air fryer and get some crispiness. If not, I'll have to just eat the filling separately. I also ordered an Italian hoagie with a few add ons. Extra Mayo is an unknown reality. If it was there, it was lost before I had a chance to check for it (30 min after delivery) Not satisfied with food, but staff are relatively good. read more

I came here last week for a cheesesteak and it was very good. Decided to bring some people with me and come back. Ordered the same cheesesteak for 12 dollars and it literately has enough meat for half the sun on the hole sub. Highly dissapointed read more

Ordered large pizza ( the works) from their menu when I recieved the pizza it was completely wrong ok it happens I get it , however when I called the OWNER said I was wrong even though the reciept and their own menu agree with me. I told him I would either give the pizza back or send a picture I was informed that I was the one who was wrong and they wouldnt do anything about it . Well thats pretty damn nice since I am allergic to black olives guess I dont eat tonight . And never again from this establishment. read more

Midtown Pizza - Their menu , the reciept and what I actually recieved - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Pennsylvania

Great Place. Fast service & good specials. read more

See all

My favorite pizza shop! They not only make great pizza; everything we have had is delicious. We dine in or order out, and have been so pleased. We ordered 9 dinners to be delivered and our guests loved the food. One last thought, best cheese steak ever! read more

Love this place its a great place For Food great services I been coming here for Years keeps getting better lots of changes I love to see a reasturant grow read more

Very very very very slow . The service sucks. Food sucks . Rude staff acts like they don't care about the customers . Highly overpriced . Just avoid at all costs . Ordered a large pep and a large cheese . How hard is that ? An hour later I watched my pep boxed up and sat on the counter while my large cheese was still cooking . Eventually I got a cold pep and a warm cheese . Never again read more

Probably the worst steak boli I've ever had. The meat looked undercooked and disgusting. The taste was just as bad. The pizza was decent though. I do not recommend ordering steak stromboli here read more

The food is okay. However, the customer service is terrible. Ordered online and didn't get my order because they closed "early" but they didn't say in the online website and accepted orders still. Contacted the owner Waited forever to get reply's, go to the store to get refund( didn't get it because the owner is not there). Ask him to deliver that order, it takes him forever to do it. I like supporting small restaurant but please do something about your customer service. I probably won't eat here again because there are stores having similar quality foods but they treat their customer much better read more

I WILL NEVER GET DELIVERY FROM HERE EVER AGAIN! Breaking down the entire experience: 2-1: when I order the gentleman taking the order wasn't fully focused on taking my order 2: service was "meh", having been to the restaurant many times before and meeting the owner. I am honestly baffled at the lack of customer service and urgency. 1: the appetizers were delivered in bags not boxes, which caused the grease to go through the bag and the brown bag... boxes were better. 1: the fact that the 2 liter was forgotten, told by the delivery driver that he will be right back with it. 10-20 mins later- no soda delivered, so I called and then another 20-40 mins later I get the soda...FINALLY. Over all a TERRIBLY HORRIBLE performance, which I will never repeat. read more

Just got a delivery. Wings were under cooked and just plain gross. Pizza was ok. Never again .

We go to Midtown frequently and have ALWAYS had wonderful experiences. We are proud to support local businesses and their families. I personal favorite is the eggplant parm entree. You can't go wrong with the fettuccine Alfredo or even the midtown burger. Service has always been fast and you can't beat the price for awesome food/drinks. Love this place! read more

I am a regular customer of midtown pizza... Today I decided to get takeout and bring it home to watch the Super Bowl... My Super Bowl dinner was penalized due to my take out being substandard! Long story short I got the chicken Marsala dinner for my wife ... As I have done before ... And there was no pasta with the dinner... I called to ask if it came with pasta and the person said no... So I told him we got the se dinner in the dining room less then a month ago and his reply was sometimes they give pasta to dine in guests but not all the time!!! Are u kidding me... A scoop of pasta costs 24 cents and they are going to cover up their mistake with a lie... Just lost me as a customer!!! read more

Horrible customer service. Was out of an item ordered, so they substituted it without asking first and delivered my food. When I called them, I was told there was nothing they could do about. Not ordering again. read more

I came in to get something quick, maybe a slice of Pizza. There was only seating at the bar. I had to sit next to an alcoholic who stunk up the place with his beer breath, constantly moving about the bar, in and out on the cell, rough-housing with a friend, trash talking women, etc etc. The cook emptied a 5 gallon bucket of waste water out the front door. It took 10 minutes for the food to come (I only ordered loaded fries and a coke). The fries were very very dry, cheese was gross, and there may have been a tiny flake or two of bacon. I will not ever be coming back here again. Sadly, I had to give it 1 star. I wish it could be lower. read more

Last time we ordered, we were very disappointed with the food (pizza and wings). Tried again tonight. Delivered the wrong thing. Called and was told they'd correct and deliver right order. Never delivered. read more

I am not sure why this place has 3 stars. I got 2 slices to try out after getting groceries nearby. One for my mom and one for me. Well, the slices were HUGE! When I got home, mom and I split one first. The pizza was taste-less, oily, and had too much cheese. The crust was too chewy. There are alcoholic beverages lined up all over the restaurant - it's a sports bar too - I guess people don't notice the taste of what they are eating since the alcohol and beer must drown it out. I actually regretted buying the second slice. I am so glad I didn't order a pie and didn't spend more than $5 here. Will never go back! read more

Don't know where begin an how many stars to give .... Food wise a 4star service wise at least bar area -1 star .. During day time ... Fuhgetbout it ... Better service at fast food place ... Good prices good flavor on all but also need better service . Prices , taste food great but need better service ! That's what brings customers back at least where I come from northern NJ read more

Came in ordered a cheeses steak waited for 10 mints. Didn't even have it on the grill. They don't speak English here so make sure your very clear. Too many other place to go with cheaper prices. read more

I got all excited at the thought of the "pizza/sub" buffet as it was more than reasonable? But the pizza was awful..dry, doughy crust and bland. Oh - and even after an hour? No fresh pizza or the promised subs never appeared. One star for the sweetheart server that we had...tipped her well. She didn't make the food.. read more