Mikes pizza is absolutely delicious. I can agree, a bit pricey for its location (it has Manhattan prices) but you get what you pay for. One thing I do recommend is to order for pick up if you can. Delivery does take a long time and your pizza won't arrive as hot as you want it. The staff is always friendly and professional and Mike himself is there to greet you (always with a smile). I love their buffalo chicken or barbecue chicken slice. I do wish the slices came with a bit more chicken since they are about almost $4 a piece. It gets a bit crowded but you can always find a little nook to sit and eat. Otherwise, flavor, customer service, cleanliness and quality all get an A++ from me. read more

Quite tasty! Probably not the cheapest around, but tastes so good and the size is fine.

Pizza here is good. Not the best but pretty good. Enjoyed the buffalo chicken slice very much. Nice blend of blue cheese and crust was really good. Regular slice was average read more

First time ordering and the Buffalo slice is the way to go but their plain slice taste like cardboard. $2.75 for a slice where's it going to? read more

Decent space to dine inn and delivery. Pizza is ok. Calzones and chicken bbq pizza are a delight to eat. Very friendly staff and quick delivery. read more

The worst service and pizza you can ever get, don't bother ordering there. When I complained about how long I waited she hanged up on me. That's the type of customer service you get from mikes pizza rudeness and disrespect. Oh and no the pizza was not good. read more

I've been eating at Mike's for about 10 yrs. The food is good, the service is good. I don't usually dine in since it get a bit rowdy there due to the train station being right outside of their door. In reference to the other review that said they don't serve people with Spanish accents, thats completely absurd as the pizzeria is in a predominantly Puerto Rican/ Dominican neighborhood. Half of their staff is Spanish. read more

Good pizza, wings & sandwiches. I would eat from here again but an exchange of words with the delivery guy (Sean) on more than one occasion has made them my last choice for neighborhood eats. read more

I've coming here since I was a child. There use to be another pizza establishment I used to frequent, but when they closed down, I by default went to Mike's. The staff at Mike's is always friendly. What I especially appreciate is that they hire folks from the community. Folks that may need a 2nd or 3rd chance, and I've always especially respected them for that. The pizza is good here. I know folks who come from far just to get a slice here. I guess they have what you call the authentic "Brooklyn slice." My favorite slice is their buffalo chicken slice. It's probably the best buff-chick slice I've had. What makes it great is - my New Yorkers are not going to like this - that it's a deep dish slice. Yes, a pizzeria in Brooklyn makes a Chicago-style pizza as one of their specialty pizzas, and it's pretty darn good. The only other no-pizza items I've had that I can remember what the taste are the garlic knots, beef patty, and chicken gyro. The knots taste good but are way too oily. The beef patty tastes fresh, and the chicken gyro is solid. However, Mike's is not cheap. A regular (cheese) slice is$ 2.75, though that seems to be regular price everywhere (a NY trivia: it seems pizza prices increase as the prices to ride the subway increases), which is ashamed. Though, the buff-chick slice is $3.75. It's definitely a hefty slice, but almost $4 for a slice is pretty high for a regular pizzaeria that's supposed to serve the community. Other food items also seem more expensive than they should be (beef patty - $2.75, small french fries - $3.75, specialty dinners range from 11-$15). This is a working class neighborhood, so it's surprising prices are so high. Over all, good food, good pizza, and I would recommend. But be cautious of what you order because you can be spending a lot more than you wanted to if you don't pay attention. read more

The food is decent. Don't ever order delivery. They have messed up my order 4 times. After calling and discussing my issues with the owner, He gave me store credit that didnt really exist. They just lost a loyal customer. read more

Very good food. I was very greatfull because they came to deliver even in very bad weather. I even called to check the status of my order and they were very nice over the phone and the food came promptly. read more

The food here is pretty good. Use to be better. The restaurant itself is spacious enough to eat in. The prices here aren't cheap.. They have Manhattan prices. Never any specials going on. Which would be nice. The price of some food are not displayed. So you'll never know what a regular slice of pizza with or without toppings cost. Customer service is okay.. Use to be much better when they hired decent people. read more

Online ordering sucks they forgot to put dressing for my salad so I called back and they said they would bring it in 10 mins I waited 35 mins and nothing. This Is the second time this happened I will not be ordering delivery with them anymore. read more

Number of times I've been here: Over a dozen times starting last year. Mike's Pizzeria, in my opinion, is a quality pizzeria that offers a quality menu. I discovered this place while I was actually craving a burger and fries. I was going to order from my go-to pizzeria, but I remembered not being impressed by their burger and fries. So, I did a little research online and found Mike's Pizzeria. Their bacon cheeseburger deluxe which comes with french fries won me over right away. The burger was filling, the meat juicy, and the accompanying french fries were crispy and nicely salted. Next, I tried their onion rings, and they are one of my favorite onion rings that I found out there. I was so hooked on this place right away that I ordered from them two days straight. In those two days, I ordered the same burger and the quality was consistent. Their pasta with white clam sauce was a pleasant experience. The noodles were a little bland, but the rich sauce made up for it. I have little hesitation trying their other pasta dishes. Their garlic knots have been hit or miss. I somewhat judge a pizzeria by how well they make garlic knots, and Mike's was crunchy and garlicky one time, but dry and bland the next. I do enjoy some garlicky garlic knots! As for their pizza, I haven't tried their traditional offering, but I am hooked on their gourmet Grandma pizza. It is a square-shaped pie, but unlike Sicilian, it's thin crusted and more seasoned than usual. The best part is that it's garlicky, which caters 100% to my taste buds. Grandma's pizza is even better with a topping. The few times I've been in-store were pleasant. I recall my experience with a friendly female cashier and she informed me that the garlic knots were free when you order in-store. That would have made me come in more often, but I do live a short distance away, and I would prefer the laziness of delivery. I give Mike's bonus points for having a website to maneuver through their menu. My only complaint is that there are no topping options on some items, such as the Grandma pizza, but you can leave a comment on how you would like each dish to be prepared. This is helpful because my father undergoes dialysis treatments which means he can't have salt and so I am grateful that they accommodate special requests, such as no sodium on the chicken noodle soup. In my short time being acquainted with Mike's Pizzeria, I can definitely say that this pizzeria has become my new go-to place for, not only pizza, but also burgers, french fries, onion rings, and perhaps other dishes that I haven't tried, when I'm home feeling lazy to cook. Although this place is a bit pricey to feed my family, I think it's definitely worth it. Four stars... I really like this place. Will I return? Of course! Grandma's pizza is great! read more

Mike's is located right under the Crescent St stop of the J train. This place has been around since I was a kid and I've always frequented it but in the recent years it's gotten especially good. Their specialty slices are a bit pricey at 3.50 a slice but man oh man are they delicious. My favorite is the Chicken Alfredo slice. The chicken is juicy, the sauce is so rich and tasty, and the crust is amahzing with just the right amount of crunch and chewiness. I'm there every Monday for one of these slices, they're my guilty pleasure. The service is always good, they're very nice and attentive and they have no qualms about cutting up a slice in itsy bitsy pieces for my little one. Delivery is also very quick . Love this place. read more

Decent food, great place for a late night snack! Love the burgers and wraps. The delivery is pretty speedy. read more

I used to come here all the time back in the day when I lived in the neighborhood. I stopped by recently for old times sake and the place has changed a bit as they've added to the menu. I ordered a regular slice and it was pretty much the same as it was in the '90's - a good typical New York slice. This isn't a place that you go out of your way to visit, but if you happen to be in the area, you can't go wrong eating here. There's another pizza shop right across the street closer to Pine St. that's also is pretty good. read more

I like the pizza here. It is one of the best in the area. One of my favorites is the buffalo chicken slice. A little on the expensive side compared to the other pizza shops in the area. But I think it's well worth it. read more

Really use to love mikes. I was raised on his pizza but they are getting crazy expensive lately. Also I order a salad & it was even worth the almost 12 dollars o paid for it. Also the delivery guys he has working for him sometimes come blasting music from their cars like they have no home training. I'm done with mikes. Not how it use to be. read more

Food is good, the prices are just wayyy too expensive. About $3.00 for one slice of pizza. Prices are a ripoff.

The food is to die for, fresh ingredients & amazing customer service. 2nd order from here & i absolutely loved it

Reliable delivery, love your pepper n pepperoni pizza ! Best in Brooklyn

Delicious...Tasty.. but my pie was cold:-(. Last Saturday, I randomly chose this pizza spot after getting tired of waiting on our Domino's pizza order. Speedy service even in the rain! Kinda wished they took a little longer to at least let the cheese melt more and the ham and pineapples heat up. However, my very critical nieces loved the pie and are about to order from Mike ' s again tonight. read more

Love their food, my go to place to eat like every other day when I was pregnant! Amazing chicken Alfredo and chicken salad.... Yummy

Mike's pizza is my go to pizza place if dominos is too expensive. Although the pizza is a bit too greasy (you could poor it off the pizza), it taste delicious. The garlic knots are the best because they put the perfect amount of garlic on it, that you can taste it, but your breath won't clear out the place. Everyone there is very sweet and nice. I've never had a bad service there. Delivery is awesome too, but my only problem is that you must purchase a minimum of $10. Meaning I have to order pizza, garlic knots, lemonade, and a dessert to have it delivered. Other then that, the place is awesome. read more

This is probably one of the best pizza shops in the neighborhood. I've been eating here for a couple of years now. It's like family everything is always hot and fresh. Great place to eat read more

Worst customer service! Always forgetting to pack what is ordered and then accuse the customer of wanting free food. Ridiculous ! The owner should not be allowed to talk to customers nor pack the food as there is ALWAYS something wrong with the order ms delivery. Won't Oder again, not worth the aggravation. read more

The pizza's are great. The prices are a little high but you receive the food in a decent time. My only complaint is the desserts. I ordered cheesecake and they sent me a quarter of a slice for $3.00 a slice. So anyone interested in ordering dessert PLEASE DONT CAUSE YOU WILL BE PISSED. read more

13.50 for the tiniest two pieces of chicken and there excuse was because I ordered cheese. Your a pizzeria in East New York, Brooklyn, Not the upper east side, Manhattan read more

I work in Brooklyn and let me tell you its hard as hell to find any good food around here that don't leave your stomach trying to escape your body because the food is so disgusting !!! BUT one night (Thank You Heavens) I found Mikes Pizza !!!!!!!!!!!!! They answered the phone politely and spoke clearly and I ordered my chicken parm hero a certain way and WOW came exactly they way I asked ... one night I called and asked if they were still dlivering she said yes but ya gotta be quick cuz were closing soon .. trust me called back in 5 minutes and got my order delivered in 30 min... now people understand as in any business (especially restaurant there's that nasty rush hour so yeah sometimes its a lil late but its still hot and your gonna eat (or hello go pick it up) just stop whining !! but back to the food it was AWESOME . So next night me and a co-worker tryig to figure what to get ?? hmmmm! yep thats it Mikes Pizza and ironically I work at a place called mikes for a guy named Mike and will def eat at Mikes again and again !!! so if your ever in brooklyn (e ny section) Please stop at Mikes and enjoy real good food read more

I just recently ordered baked ziti and penne vodka from this restaurant and I have never been so disappointed. I ordered it off an app EAT24 and for some reason their prices on this app were more expensive then their actual prices so when I ordered my food they charged me the real prices then added an additional charge. When I called to try to fix this issue the man I spoke to was nothing but completely rude and did not care. I also brought up an issue with the baked ziti because it had one slice of cheese on it and the only response I got was "that's just how we make it" with all attitude. I spoke to someone from the app about my issue and they instantly helped me. After this, the man from the restaurant called me back and instead of apologizing he told me I should not have spoke to him the way I did. This is a greedy, selfish restaurant that I would never go to again. I have never experienced this kind of service before and it was unacceptable. read more

My buddy brought me there for lunch and I had the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza, it was delicious and looking forward to going back to try other creations read more

I love Mikes Pizza! I always order the same thing, fries and chicken fingers but I've ordered other things and the food is too die for!! They also deliver which I really appreciate! Give them a try def worth it! read more

Gotta try their Philly Cheese Pizza.. sooo soo good! Other than that everything else is just the average pizza. They have a lot of specialty pizza. Ive tried the Chicek Cesar Pizza but it was a little too dry to me. Delivery is usually fast. read more

Pizza is good but prices are insane this isn't 34st Manhattan it East New York seriously... Seems to be no lack of customers pilling in the door. I would avoid the pre made slices if you can. Freash made pizza is the way to go and it's very very good. read more

horrible, small, salty, rubbery pizza.. it was so bad and expensive 13.75 for a 16" pie. maybe i'm just spoiled when it comes to pizza i ordered this for a friends house. i ordered a salad as well that was good, very fresh and crispy romaine lettuice. read more