Got 2 sandwiches off the menu and they were delicious. The roast beef is always perfectly pink. Fast service, especially if you place it online. Inside was cute, great deli. read more

Millburn Deli - Godfadda - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Stopped here for a sandwich after seeing plenty of reviews on the place and it was pretty good. When you walk in you can order on a screen which is pretty cool because you can make all your choices without feeling rushed. If you prefer you can also order live at the register. The service was friendly and quick. I got the sloppy Joe with turkey and swiss cheese and it was very good. It was loaded with Cole slaw which was great. There was no way I was finishing this sandwich so I got two lunches out of it. One of the better sloppy joes I have eaten. The iced tea was also very good. Saw some reviews on it and it was worth the try. I will definitely be back to try other options. The menu is pretty big so if you're looking for different sandwich options they have them. Definitely a good find. read more

So good! I've never been to this location - ordered for pick up on a Saturday morning and that was great! Aside for the double parking / no parking situation.. worth it! Grabbed an iced tea (so good!!), a chicken sand (Griller #8) excellent and a turkey sloppy Joe! So good! We loved it all! Would 100% recommend! read more

Millburn Deli - Griller #8 (excellent!!) - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

This deli serves terrific food , clean as a whistle with attentive service Folks who are friendly and seem happy to work at Millburn - I've been many times ! read more

Two salads ordered for pickup- 1 Farmstead, 1 Build Your Own Farmstead Salad was 90% lettuce, 10% other ingredients. Crunchy. Not much flavor. Scant amount of anything other than lettuce. Packaged croutons which had more flavor than the salad Build your own was terrible & basically inedible. Chicjen was barely cooked & dangerous to eat. Greens were soggy. Everything tasted "off" and we discarded it Very disappointed, as the sandwiches are usually very good & well made​​​​ read more

So cool to see Millburn Deli expand to so many locations. I've had hundreds of millburn deli sandwiches at this point from the original location, so had high hopes for this location. I think it's a newer operation and the energy and atmosphere at the original location can't be beat. The staff are great there, and it's a well-oiled machine. This location felt like it was still figuring out it's rhythm to be efficient, but the sandwiches are almost as good as the original location. I couldn't quite put my finger on what was missing from my sandwich that I usually get, but I'll still be back. My favorites are the Godfadda and Griller #8. A great chicken cutlet option and then the latter is a nice chicken breast option. read more

These sandwhiches were absolutely delicious and huge chicken cutlet on them was awesome. Very fresh ingredients and soft bread. I'm a big eater so I would have liked the sandwich to be a bit bigger for $15 but that's nitpicking. Try a bunch of different combos because i've never had a bad one yet! The homemade iced tea reminds me of brisk iced tea but not as sweet so it was good. Definitely would recommend read more

Millburn Deli - Tuscan Chicken, ice teas & godfadda - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I miss Watchung Deli. But must say Millburn Deli expanding franchise hits the mark. Got the chicken cutlet Grandfadda and a Sausalito Sloppy Joe. And an iced tea. Good service and to go. read more

See all

I order online ahead of time when I know I'm going to be in the neighborhood and it's around lunchtime. My go to is the pressed Rueben sandwich. They have lotsa healthy choices as well, but it's a once in a while treat for me. Chocolate chunk cookies are very good too. read more

Millburn Deli is always delicious, fresh food and the homemade russian dressing is a STAR! The service is quick too!

This restaurant is pretty popular so I was eager to try it for lunch. So many choices! I don't think I picked a very good one. I picked the Santa Fe since it comes in a flatbread. I was hoping they had wraps but didn't see any on the menu. The reason I didn't love the Santa Fe is because it's a grilled chicken sandwich but the chicken was sliced thin like deli meat and was cold. I was hoping for a hot (or at least warm) sandwich. I would def come by to try something else because the quality was good but I did not like the cold chicken against the other ingredients. read more

Millburn Deli - Santa Fe - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I'd been to the original location in milburn and used to get the Godfadda. I decided to be healthier today and opt for the Bruschetta with grilled chicken. This sandwich was absolutely phenomenal. The ciabatta bread was super fresh and the chicken was so juicy. The star of the show, however, was the garlic mayo which made the whole sandwich POP. Definitely try the milburn deli, and get the chicken bruschetta if you're feeling frisky! read more

Millburn Deli - Chicken bruschetta - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Saturday lunch via delivery. Basic chic sub. Grilled chicken well seasoned. LTO, and I added cucumbers. Complimentary slice pickle. read more

Millburn Deli - Basic chick no cheese - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Slow service with lots of people standing around talking to the people making the sandwich's . No utensils or napkins in bag . must get sides drinks napkins and utensils yourself . no potato salad on menu . This is my 3rd bad experience with this (so called Deli) Strike 3 for me . I will not return . I really don't see what people like about this place, other than it's slightly better than quick check . No worries I'm sure they won't miss me. read more

Don't miss out on Millburn deli's salads- they are hearty & you won't miss the carbs at all! read more

Millburn Deli - Make your own salad - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

The atmosphere in this establishment exudes entitlement, and the staff's behavior is saturated with a toxic blend of unchecked arrogance and class-based condescension. Upon entering the space, I was met not with hospitality, but with aggression--an immediate assumption of inferiority rooted in bias and emboldened by a culture of impunity. The incident I experienced was not an isolated misstep--it was a symptom of deeper organizational dysfunction. The employees, instead of offering service with dignity or professionalism, were combative and dismissive, weaponizing "policy" as a pretext to belittle and invalidate. When I addressed the issue through proper channels, the response I received was not one of accountability or reflection--it was a masterclass in gaslighting: a smug, self-justifying diatribe aimed at discrediting rather than understanding. This brand of deflection--drenched in ego and devoid of empathy--reveals the true ethos of this establishment: one that lacks cultural competence, emotional intelligence, and any grasp of ethical customer engagement. Let me be clear: I am not a passerby or "just a delivery person." I am a Montclair native. I grew up in this town. I was educated in its school system. I walk these streets with legacy, not insignificance. The fact that your staff and leadership failed to recognize that speaks volumes--not about me, but about your own narrow lens and implicit biases. The fact that management not only condones but co-signs such behavior is alarming. Your internal "investigations" seem more like internal justifications--rote attempts to maintain your illusion of infallibility. Your sandwiches may travel well, but so does your reputation. And this? This is a red flag wrapped in wax paper. Because right now, your brand reads as bitter, not bold. read more

Just go. Order the Sloppy RB Joe. If you don't like it... I will buy it from you . Just have to deliver please

Gone downhill. Had a tuna sandwich that was simply gross. Felt like I ate a jar of mayonnaise. The sandwiches are too big, too expensive, and unnecessarily loaded with all kinds of extras they don't need. Oh how I pine for the days of the Watchung Deli. read more

Some were more heavy than others but all the sandwiches we ordered were so good! Looked crowded for weekend lunch so we had to wait a bit. Can't wait to try the other flavors next time. read more

Millburn Deli - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

In preparation for some dinner guests, I placed an order for 6 sandwiches at 2:30 for a 5:15 pick up. I arrived @ Millburn Deli at 5:15 and the order was not ready. Intermittently when I checked on the status, I was told "we're busy right now" and was promptly ignored. Order was not ready until 5:35 - after waiting 20 minutes. They had almost 3 hours notice to have the order ready. They made no extra effort, nor any acknowledgement of that they had any responsibility to try to correct the situation once they were made aware of the problem. read more

I have friends who rave about the original location in Millburn. So when I saw this location right by my nail salon I had to stop in! I had the Little Italy which was Proscuitto * Fresh Mozzarella * Roasted Garlic Tomato * Arugula * Balsamic * Sub Roll and was amazing! My only complaint is the roll. It was ok but a little on the soft side and quickly soaked through with the dressing. Not that I minded but I've had similar blends on a good Italian semolina baguette and it really makes a difference! Other than that the deli is clean and bright. A little confusing as I came in one door and ordered at the counter only to find that there are kiosks at the other end by the other door. Luckily it wasn't too busy so it didn't really slow things down. Grabbed a soda and chips and enjoyed a delicious sandwich. Now I get what all the hype is about! read more

Just left the Montclair store with my free sandwich after donating a few food items. Great promotion and the most amazing sandwich everrrrr! Thanks!! read more

Delicious sammy's and sides too. Pickles rock! Don't forget the iced tea Great service Clean Love! read more

Quick and delicious! Delivery was above and beyond. Salad was enough for two. I'll certainly be ordering again and spreading the word!

Excellent crafted sandwiches. Place is clean and staff is accommodating. Highly recommend for lunch.

I was so psyched to see this spot open so trekked out soon after opening. The place is takeout only FYI. Service was super friendly and attentive. Huge menu of sandwiches and even salad but that is it. No sides to really speak of besides chips and some things like pasta salad in a grab and go fridge. My Mutz sandwich ($12.50) which is one of the veggie ones as it's basically just pesto, veggies, and mozzarella. Verdict: Nothing too special, hearty but meh. The Mac n cheese and sloppy Joe (we also ordered) were also sort of bland and "just ok." read more

Millburn Deli - Mutz sandwich - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I got the big bird buffalo sandwich... I literally thought I was eating big bird from Sesame Street because there was a good amount of chicken in it, I wonder what Elmo would taste like. It was good I will be back. read more

Some of my favorite sandwiches come from Millburn deli. Can't go wrong with pastrami Reuben and godfadda. Sooo good! read more

See all

Not sure I understand why this location doesn't get as good reviews as Millburn. Ive been to both. My experience is consistent across both. Sloppy Joes are always solid. Sandwiches aren't cheap but considering the size of the sandwich they're reasonable. The people who work here are always nice and the sandwiches come out pretty fast. Plenty of seating inside and outside. There are parking spots in the back dedicated to the retail space so parking isn't an issue. read more

Millburn Deli - Pastrami Sloppy Joe - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

We ordered lunch from this deli today and I have to say that my sandwich was F'ing delicious! A 10/10! You definitely tell there is attention to detail too. A few co-workers ordered salads and their croutons where bagged separately so they're not soggy. I ordered the chicken Fresca and it was delicious for sure. Ate the entire sandwich. I cannot to order from here again. Hands down best sandwiches I've had in years. read more

I was soooo excited to try Millburn Deli in Montclair. I was tired of driving to Millburn for my fix. For those who have never been to the Millburn location, just know that Millburn deli has hundreds of ways to customize your sandwich or you can order one of the options they have standard on the menu. No matter what you choose to order, just know it's going to be good! Everything from the meat to the bread is phenomenal. They use great ingredients and you can tell. At this location, I finally tried the "Godfadda" sandwich for the first time. I know, I'm late to the game. I took off the bacon. It was amaaaaaazing! I've been missing out on this great sandwich for too long! The inside is very open and clean. There are kiosks where you can order your sandwich and then a counter where you go to pay. Of course, you can also order ahead through their website. I definitely enjoyed the experience here a lot better than at the Millburn location. It was easy and quick. The staff was friendly and welcomed us upon walking in. I'll be back for sure! read more

Millburn Deli - Godfadda no bacon! - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

This place has over 30 types of sandwiches, honestly anything you can think of they probably have. The service is fairly quick and the prices are a little higher that most deli places but it's worth it because they are big sandwiches. I tried the Tuscan chicken sandwich which had breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, red peppers, arugula, and a garlic Mayo. Overall the sandwich was good but when I got home and pressed my other half in the panini press it was even better. Don't worry they also have regular sandwiches too. read more

Millburn Deli - Tuscan chicken sandwich - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I was real excited to hear that Millburn deli was opening ANOTHER storefont. Went to check it out on a Saturday afternoon and got the Jay Ray chicken cutlet sandwich. It wasnt busy when I went so I didn't have to wait long. You can also call ahead or order online. read more

See all

This place use to be really good. Prompt orders, made on time. And I've been coming here for a few years now, often coming on a weekly basis. Past two orders over the past two weeks have been terrible in terms of service. Ordered on-line at 11:10 with an estimated pick up of 11:30. Food wasn't ready till 11:55. There's too many good sandwich shops in the area to keep frequenting a joint that's routinely 30 min delayed on their orders. read more

Ordered corned beef sandwich. Disappointed yet again. Seems as if cut on a machine. No texture to meat, no flavour.it seemed like a mystery meat. Service was good. read more

Best food (and its not) + terrible service = bad restaurant. Respect your customers is your way for success read more

Salads are so good and plentiful. Online ordering easy and loyalty program is a plus

Went in hearing from a friend that grew up getting Sammie's from the OG location. Ordered the pastrami sloppy joe to go for the classic experience. Had high hopes. Vibe wise the place seemed "cool" with loud hip music and people in white deli coats. That was a positive. It ended there. Overall an unmemorable sandwich that wasn't fully consumed. For the price I would not go back but it was the construction of the sandwich that gets the 1 star rating. The sandwich was poor on pastrami count and filled to the guts with mayo heavy cole slaw. I could not taste the pastrami!!' There were 3-4 thin slices of cold pastrami on the sandwich. Really weaksauce. More like a finger sandwich. A three biter. If I was these guys I'd load up the pastrami and reduce the cole slaw. Build with thicker cut pastrami that's hot to start. Pastrami was generic. It was more like a cole slaw sandwich with Swiss and pastrami was an afterthought. Ps- no deli pickles at a deli sandwich place. Boo. No pic. read more

I finally got to try the hyped up Millburn deli. When I first arrived I was impressed with the ordering computer system which allowed me to see all the sandwich options and it was an easy way to add/substitute ingredients. I got the godfadda and the turkey sloppy joe. Both were delicious and filling. It definitely lived up to the hype and I will be coming back. I can't wait to try some of their other sandwiches too. read more

Millburn Deli - Outside - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

First time going ... My husband took me for lunch . Not your everyday spot to go to because it's very expensive but a nice place to go for a nice treat. The place was nice and clean , the staff was cordial and friendly. The food was ON POINT !! I had the perfect ten which is supposed to be very rare roast beef (it wasn't but I'm assuming that because it was pressed in the panini machine it cooked somewhat ) the garlic Mayo is seriously to die for SOOOO DELICIOUS. My husband had the Gobbler which for the record he had to get double meat to actually be full.. be careful because it adds up. But a very Delicious treat .. I would DEFINITELY go back read more

See all