Millburn Deli

Great Deli, loved pre ordering and then walking the town! Cute little spot, pretty much make…read morewhatever you can crave from a deli!

First time coming here. I had the Lodato Special - Roast Beef, Fresh Mozzarella, Long Hots, and…read moreBrown Gravy on Toasted Garlic semolina Bread. It was delicious! The meat was rare. The bread was fresh. The fresh mozzarella was a little bland, but mixed in was fine. Could have had a bit more brown gravy but aside from that it was still a tasty sandwich.

Nicky Boy (~$17)

See all

Nicky Boy

Dutch's Sandwich Shop

4.5(85 reviews)

1.4 mi

Wow what a superb breakfast Sammy! The layers of my Becky were absolutely scrumptious, and I made…read morean excellent choice of adding a hash brown. Everything was so flavorful. Don't sleep on the donuts either! The Nutella Cronut was a delightful treat. Parking near here can be tough on the weekend.

My friend picked up this sandwich for me while I got my hair done and WOW did it hit the spot! From…read morethe sauce to the crispy hash brown and bacon to the soft bun - it really was delicious. Messy but worth it.

See all

Christo's Wake and Steak

4.6(109 reviews)

1.3 mi

Quality food, quality service, and little wait…read more Definitely try the New School for a next level cheesesteak experience!

stopped in for the first time for a breakfast sandwich w my buddy from work and boy, I regret not…read moretrying Christo's sooner...I don't really eat too many unhealthy things like this anymore, but felt like having a cheat meal ~ 100% worth it. We both got the steak, eggs, hash brown and cooper sharp sandwich, it was outta this world!

Chopped cheese sandwich

See all

Corn fritters

Mastriano's Quality Market

4.7(66 reviews)

1.0 mi

Excellent small deli, but a huge menu compared to its size. Really, well run…read more It's not cheap, but nothing is these day, and the pricing is absolutely fair.

I spend my Saturday mornings collecting delicious ingredients for the week ahead. This week, I…read morefound Mastriano's on Yelp and decided to give it a try. Very cool "old school" butcher and sandwich shop! Staff were pleasant and professional. I purchased Berkshire pork chops, prime New York strip steaks, and a rack of pork ribs. All of it looks great! The sandwich list was too good to pass up, so I got a chicken cutlet, mortadella, broccoli rabe, and fresh mozzarella wrap. All of the ingredients were top notch and the flavors came together really well! Will gladly return to Mastriano's!

See all

Agamie Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers

4.7(90 reviews)

2.6 mi

Fantastic dishes, delicacy, cold, cuts, sandwiches, hot, or cold like they used to be in back in…read morethe day‍. What a delightful atmosphere and friendly staff. My cheesesteak sandwich was custom with shredded lettuce and flavorful chopped steak . Also, the Italian Classic sandwich is above the best deli.

Delis like this are all but extinct. Live that this place still exists…read more Think 1980's and you will be transported back in time. Not much special here just your run of the mill deli which I love. Their bread isn't great but it goes well with their meats and cheeses.

Front of Agamie Deli.

See all

Classic Italian .

Tony Boys Sandwich House

4.4(30 reviews)

1.4 mi

My daughter surprised me with this Tony's Boys tuna fish wrap, fantastic! From the moment I…read moregrabbed the cold bag, I knew this tuna was freshly prepared and taste great Needless to say, it was heavenly well prepared with fresh lettuce, tomato, and wheat wrap. I will be back Jack! Awesome staff with order on time. Show me sandwich deli.

Came here during the week for lunch with my girlfriends. My one friend and I got two different…read moretypes of their cutlet sandwiches. They were a pretty big size for a good price. The cutlet themselves were pretty tasty. My friend got the buffalo chicken salad and she liked it, but she wished she got a cutlet sandwich after seeing them. I do wish the cheese on my sandwich was melted, but that was my mistake. I could've asked for that.

The Nutty Pig - Chicken Cutlet w/ warm peanut butter sauce, jelly & bacon.

See all

Salads, Cold Subs & More

Fish Delish

4.9(71 reviews)

0.6 mi

I try to be the Nate Silver of Yelp popularity statistics, analyzing and aggregating the metrics…read more Ordering the highest-ranked item at any new restaurant has a 94% success rate. But the awesome Fish Delish offers a slight conundrum as the fish-and-chips is a great choice but they're also crafting some other offerings that can't be found anywhere else. The salmon dog is great for the palate and for the 'gram. Even as someone who controversially extends the boundaries of what counts as hand food, I had to use a fork for this epic sandwich. The fish is great, as are the bells and whistles. Wasabi mayo is enticing but my favorite component was the smoked mozzarella.

With better-tasting entrees and new menu items, Fish Delish raised its game sometime after my last…read morevisit. The cod fish & chips, at $19.50, consists of flavorful filets and is now a large enough portion to be a whole meal. When I dined in, I was offered one of three kinds of mayo dip - spicy, garlic-infused, and one more that I can't remember - as a supplement to their creamy tartar sauce. in addition, clam chowder has been added to the menu. I agree with another poster that it would have done well to have more briny clam flavor, but nevertheless, it was still good enough for me to finish. I really like that the person running the front of house brought the orders to the table, greeted frequent patrons with a "nice to see you again", and asked everyone if the food was good. I'm interested to see how my next visit goes!

Tables and counter height seating

Cod fish and chips

See all

Hero King - Nutley

4.5(173 reviews)

2.6 mi

Got the Larry David (pastrami), was a bit suspicious that a pastrami sandwich came with cheese…read more... Full hero for$24+tax tip (inflation and tariffs suck), sliced cold then warmed pastrami over cheese in hero. Not what I was expecting, will go to a real pastrami place next time. Otherwise a standard hero place, looked like they had decent hero/sandwich choices. Maybe I got the wrong sandwich, but it was just ok.

First time stopping in last night. He stayed opened for me so I could have my sandwiches prepared…read more Got a chicken cutlet hero and a roast beef hero. Both were VERY good! The guy at the counter was friendly and accommodating. We will order again and probably try some different items off the menu. Don't let this small spot discourage you from stopping in.

Inside menu

Roast beef, turkey, cheddar cheese horseradish mayo

See all

Outside

Belgiovine Delicatessen

4.7(223 reviews)

1.3 mi

fantastic. I got the Belgiovine Special sandwich and it didnt disappoint. Made very meticulously…read moreand seasoned approproaitely. Could be my new favorite italian deli.

What is going on here?…read more I ordered the First Avenue sandwich -- a cheesesteak with bacon and sautéed onions -- and it was an absolute salt bomb. Not "well-seasoned." Not "bold." Just aggressively, overwhelmingly salty. Every bite felt like a dare. Between the bacon and the cheesesteak, it was sodium stacked on sodium with zero balance. I genuinely couldn't finish it after two bites. At that point, it felt like I had just thrown money straight into the trash. The sausage stuffed peppers were decent...thankfully. Not mind-blowing, but at least edible and competently made, which is more than I can say for the sandwich. They saved me from a starving morning. Extremely disappointed. I'm all for flavor, but when the dominant note is "are they trying to preserve this for winter?" something has gone very wrong in the kitchen.

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich

See all

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich

Mikki & Al’s Noshery

4.2(105 reviews)

1.3 mi

Better or at least equal to Katz without the ridiculous lines. My wife and I shared a fat pastrami…read moresandwich ($18). They also sell pastrami by the pound ($30). I don't think I'll ever go back to Katz unless it's with friends who are tourists.

Because it's "kosher style" and not kosher, the pastrami just wasn't up to par from what you can…read moreget in an old school NYC deli. I was hoping to recreate that experience in the suburbs. Pastrami is a pretty expensive meat, but it was also drier and tougher than I was expecting for the price. I think it was more like corned beef than traditional pastrami. I usually don't do any sauce, but I laid on the mustard just to make a moister sandwich. It was overall pretty disappointing. The employees were nice, but there isn't really any dine in option. We customized it to put on club bread (for an upcharge). Mustard was on side to add at leisure. It was hot out of the bag. It came with pickles and cole slaw. It was overall just a pretty disappointing version of pastrami. In these cases, actual kosher is worth sticking to.

See all

Delicious corned beef sammie on rye.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

James L.

5 years ago

Working my way through the menu. I have a long way to go but so far the Chicken Bruschetta, Gobbler, Godfadda and Black Bull have been amazing. read more

Mike L.

Elite 15

169

182

5 years ago

Sandwiches are on point, just like the other locations. Some small things to work out but overall a great meal

Justine D.

5 years ago

Try it and you will not be disappointed. Fresh, delicious sandwiches and quick, friendly service

Am D.

5 years ago

The best addition to Montclair. Great sandwiches and friendly staff

Brielle W.

3 years ago

Griller #8 is the greatest of all time. Obsessed with this place

Millburn Deli - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Millburn Deli also viewed

Torpedo Base

4.6

(64 reviews)

A classic spot that's been open for decades, making delicious torpedo sandwiches and giving great…read moreservice. My love for sandwiches started here, when my father would bring me as a kid. I remember fully loaded subs with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onions, and dressing. Another classic is the warm pastrami sandwich with mustard and cheese. Amazing to taste something that brings you back in time. An absolute must try.

Bacon Roast beef Eggs lettuce and onions. Had it for the first time. Never going back. Super sloppy…read morewasn't cut in half. Bacon was limp not crispy Bread was squished wayyyy tooo much mayo that taste bad (def not Hellman's) too overwhelming to taste the rest of sandwich asked for onions lettuce didn't get any of that and there was a hair in between the eggs and cheese. Counter lady was rude On top of the fact that they charge 2$ for card use. SMH overhyped sandwich spot. Don't go here!!!!!

Dutch's Sandwich Shop

4.5

(85 reviews)

Pete's Delicatessen

4.3

(86 reviews)

They didn't have what I was looking for - roast beef club - so they did their best to approximate…read moreit, and here's the kicker: this was $11. Look at the pictures. These days you can't open your front door and take a deep breath without it costing you more than $11. Look at the size of this sandwich! I don't know how they do it, but this place is absolutely recommended. Talk about bang for your buck, and GOOD! Please go and enjoy.

Pete's has been serving up the neighborhood for a very long time…read more We used to go at lunch in HS and get dollar subs. They were good sized sandwiches geared to us broke kids. It was a blessing at the time. My go to was and still is, cajun turkey, yellow American, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a round Portuguese roll. They also make incredible pepperoni bread, potato salad, chicken cutlets and a bunch of other goodies. I saw they had brownies, donuts, and crumb cake last time I was in.

Blimpie

3.7

(19 reviews)

Blimpie in Woodland Park was unbelievable, as usual, but this visit was especially pleasant. The…read moreowner is a genuinely nice man who clearly cares about customer satisfaction. One of his employees was not only friendly but went out of his way to be kind. He made my sandwich perfectly--ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar, extra vinegar, mayo, and light oregano. It tasted exactly like I remembered from childhood, just as good as every time I've had it growing up. Blimpie's consistency is what I appreciate most, and I couldn't be more thankful for that. Clean place as well.

Who charges 3.99 for cheese to put on a Sub when you're a SUB SHOP. I paid $20 for a sandwich thats…read moreprobably worth $10 or $11 at most. Wont be going again.

Staci's Sandwich Joint

4.8

(73 reviews)

Okay - I went here because a coworker was insisting that this sandwich was something you had to…read morehave. AND OH MY GOODNESS. I think it's my top sandwich I've ever had. We brought it back home and the cutlet was still plenty warm and the romaine was cold and crunchy. My coworker and boyfriend suggest getting some extra Caesar dressing on the side for dipping. The place was cutie pie - I liked that they were playing good music and had a silly book of animals I could browse at while I waited for the food to be ready. There was an altercation of two couples yelling at each-other and causing a fuss. Lowkey I wish the manager would have refused service to all 4 of them because why were they being absolutely terrible at 1pm on a Saturday. Not kicking them out promotes they can act like that and have no repercussions. But anywho guess the sandwiches are worth fighting over. I will be returning!

Went just passed noon on a Saturday and the wait wasn't too long but there were lot of people -…read morerain didn't stop anyone! The size is so much bigger in person vs. shown online, so come hungry or be prepared to pack leftovers. They're a bit hard to eat like a sandwich so we had to use a fork and knife to cut it up into smaller pieces. I can see why people get a side order of dressing as it could be a bit dry - would recommend doing so (some people get buffalo sauce).

Barry's Bagel & Deli

4.2

(127 reviews)

Tried for breakfast and found a good variety or bagels including a few whole wheat varieties which…read moreyou don't always see. I had the whole wheat everything with scallion cream cheese. My husband had the Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a sesame and also enjoyed that. Overall an enjoyable visit with a friendly Hispanic family running the place. They did also offer lots of other items like sandwiches and salads too!

This place is definitely a go to breakfast place. We went in there and got a delicious egg sausage…read morecroissant sandwich so good they were super fast. Everybody was going in. They had a line. It was definitely worth it if you need a little breakfast sandwich that's the place to go in New Jersey.. the ambience is definitely just like a deli you could sit down. I think a couple places, but I can't remember either way they had lots of selections..

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.7

(61 reviews)

It has been a while I have had some Mike's . This is…read moreprobably my favorite Mike's. I walked in around 11:30 and the first thing I notice was how clean the place was. I ordered my sandwich from the Young ladies on the other side. They were very attentive,friendly,and most important they listened really well. The were also all in Uniform looking clean and ready to work. The station for sandwich making was spotless and the ingredients were all fresh looking. Great work to all ! I did not have to ask them tp keep adding more onions/tomatoes . When I ordered I told them I would even be ok if I had to pay for the extras,and the mgr I believe ,told me that it wasn't necessary.The sandwich was 4 stars the experience 6 stars.I just hate that Mike's stopped making the Roast Beef in house. This was a covid thing. The final review would be 4.5 ! Thank You to the young ladies who helped me.

Major shout out to whoever provided the extra oil & vinegar I requested with my turkey and…read moreprovolone bowl this afternoon. Kudos to you!! I usually request this but never get it in mobile orders. Thank you for going above & beyond for me. #DayMade

Habit Burger & Grill

3.8

(38 reviews)

Stopped in as I wanted to try out Habit Burger experience. Ordered from their electronic kiosk and…read moreopted for the bacon cheeseburger, onion rings, and a sweet tea. Food was ready quickly, place was fairly empty (I went early) and the attendant delivered my meal to my table - a nice touch. Burger was excellent. Onion rings were cooked perfectly and the ranch dipping sauce was a nice accompaniment. Clean place, nice location, and good food. Not your run of the mill fast food burger - better.

I had a very concerning experience at The Habit Burger Grill on Hamburg Turnpike in Wayne…read more I ordered the chicken bites, and after actually biting into one, I realized the chicken was RAW/undercooked inside. I had already taken a bite before I noticed it. I'm attaching a photo because this isn't simply a matter of not liking the food or receiving the wrong order. Raw chicken is a legitimate food-safety concern. I understand restaurants can make mistakes, but chicken needs to be cooked thoroughly and there should be safeguards in place to make sure something like this does not reach a customer. I have my receipt and photos documenting what I received, and I am also submitting a formal complaint to management/corporate. Please check your chicken carefully if ordering from this location. I sincerely hope management investigates what happened and reviews their cooking temperatures and food-safety procedures so this does not happen to someone else. This was so gross and disgusting they need to be reported to department of health. This is so unsafe

Christo's Wake and Steak

4.6

(109 reviews)

Quality food, quality service, and little wait…read more Definitely try the New School for a next level cheesesteak experience!

Charleys Cheesesteaks

3.9

(30 reviews)