Better or at least equal to Katz without the ridiculous lines. My wife and I shared a fat pastrami sandwich ($18). They also sell pastrami by the pound ($30). I don't think I'll ever go back to Katz unless it's with friends who are tourists. read more

Because it's "kosher style" and not kosher, the pastrami just wasn't up to par from what you can get in an old school NYC deli. I was hoping to recreate that experience in the suburbs. Pastrami is a pretty expensive meat, but it was also drier and tougher than I was expecting for the price. I think it was more like corned beef than traditional pastrami. I usually don't do any sauce, but I laid on the mustard just to make a moister sandwich. It was overall pretty disappointing. The employees were nice, but there isn't really any dine in option. We customized it to put on club bread (for an upcharge). Mustard was on side to add at leisure. It was hot out of the bag. It came with pickles and cole slaw. It was overall just a pretty disappointing version of pastrami. In these cases, actual kosher is worth sticking to. read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami on club - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Finally tried this spot after eyeing it for over a year. I was mildly impressed. The knish is pretty rosemary heavy which I didn't mind but didn't love and wasn't prepared for. The sandwich which delicious was nothing too outstanding. The pastrami was a bit dry. I liked the Sloppy Joey for sure. It's a massive sandwich. Def can feed 2 people or 3 if you get sides and such. The reuben roll was great! The service was pretty quick considering we were 6 people with a large order. Stuff came out fast. There's 5 seats along the window inside and they brought us out a 6th chair which was kind. Loved the hospitality and the vibe there was immaculate. I don't think the food quite lived up to the hype in my head but it was a good stop for my mom's Birthday lunch! read more

See all

It's just okay, matzoh ball soup was good but when ordered with an additional matzoh ball they don't package it separately and end up giving you much less soup. The knish was just okay, like that it was house made but needed some more seasoning. The marble cake smelled like a dirty rag/laundry. Yuck. Didn't eat it. read more

Sandwiches are big. The corned beef on rye is very good though I'm accustomed to thin sliced corned beef, and this is sliced thick with a knife. Fries were hot though somewhat soggy. The sour half-pickle on the side was exceptionally crispy. The cole slaw was tasty. Very limited counter seating available. read more

Very good for a quick sandwich. Had a good whitefish salad on rye with lettuce snd tomato. Solid but I wouldn't call it outstanding. Very nice people. Cute shop. Nice to sit outside on a beautiful day. Only 2 small tables outside. Quiet-ish street. Also bought a hand-rolled bagel that looks amazing to eat later in the week. Looks bready but good. read more

Mikki and Al's hot pastrami with mustard was one of the last sandwiches I bought in Montclair before I relocated and it was a memorable one. This sandwich is definitely on par with some of the other great pastrami sandwiches in the tri-state area. The pastrami wasn't overly fatty and the rye bread was fresh- perfectly supporting the density of the meat. Worth a shot if you're ever in the area! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami with mustard - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

A nice pastrami sandwich albeit a bit pricey but hey, it's Montclair. One complaint though, don't make me wait so you can make a takeout order when I'm right there and tell me it's for pick up and that I have to wait. Let the pick up wait. Not a good thing if you want repeat customers read more

I am giving three stars because I was disappointed. Food was okay. But not what I thought it would be. Also $100 for the takeout order for three people who had high hopes. Had a Lox and bagel platter. Did not get a bagel, got a bread in the style of a bagel. Like eating lox on white bread. Pastrami was cut "chunky" style, not thin sliced. Whitefish salad, way too much lemon. Pickles were good. read more

Another delicious lunch. Solid service and cozy tables. Sandwiches made in full view and service is quick and efficient. They are moving next month and bottom line - we will follow you!!! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami on rye with mustard! Classic - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

This was DELISH! the meat was flavorful, tender or juicy. I HIGHLY recommend stopping in if you have a chance. My friend and I ordered curbside and the experience was easy and seamless! I will definitely return! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Whoa. This place has the most delicious pastrami sandwich. Definitely up there with Katz if not better. I ordered take out with curbside pick up which was very easy. I really enjoyed this sandwich and will def order again! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami sandwich - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

So glad there's now a place for sloppy Joe type sandwiches in Montclair. A drive to South Orange is no longer needed. If you're having a party, can't go wrong with a sandwich platter or two. read more

Fantastic Pastrami sandwich!!!. Lots of meat , pickles. Bit pricey, but big enough to split with someone.

We ordered take out . The food was terrible. The pastrami sandwich was Chand had s smoke flavor, the latjacwas had and not very tasty. xexcited to find them in area, will not be returning. read more

Jewish delis are hard to come by these days. My go to was always Hobby's in Newark but it's a bit of a hassle. You can imagine how excited I was to find out one was opening up in Montclair. I've had a little bit of everything and so far all of it was amazing! Chopped liver - excellent Corned beef - excellent Knish - excellent Latka - excellent Pickles - excellent Health salad - excellent Pastrami - excellent. AND one thing I NEVER order is a turkey sandwich, but I saw someone eating one. OMFG it was the juiciest turkey sandwich I have ever eaten - and with Russian dressing? Amazing. Washed everything down with a Dr Browns diet cream soda! Can not wait to go back! read more

I will be back. This was the best Matzah Ball soup of my life; I must figure out how to recreate it. The Reuben Egg Rolls were off the hook, the coffee was the perfect roast, and the Noshery Sampler was ample as well as fresh and delicious. The owner/chef is there and she is informative and talented. Take out encouraged as seating is limited. read more

See all

This is one of my go to lunch places. Their knishes are awesome. Amazing conned beef and pastrami. Great matzo ball soup. A Montclair gem

The Sloppy Joey is one of the most delicious sandwiches I've ever had. Their whole selection of sandwiches are impressive since they have great meats in store. They also have delicious pickles and I don't even like pickles that much! The staff are all friendly and they give this place a 'small town deli' feel which I love. It's a cozy shop that's a wonderful sandwich option in Montclair. Highly recommend if you're into Jewish style deli foods. Apparently they have amazing matzo ball which I will certainly try next when the weather is colder. read more

I have never received such terrible customer service in my life. Last night I ordered a Rueben, when I got it home the sandwich was ice cold and when we tasted it the flavor was off and it smelt weird. They were closed so I was not able to speak to them immediately. I called the restaurant this morning and was greeted with extreme hostility. The woman answering the phone continued to defend the sandwich and speak over me for the entire 15 minute phone call. Not once did she acknowledge that it could be an issue from the restaurant but instead told me that it was my fault because I didn't not show up for the sandwich exactly twenty minutes after ordering it. If a item needs to be picked up in a strict time period for them to guarantee it, that needs to be written on their website and on any other app that they choose to take the orders through. The woman who I believe is the owner offered me to bring her the other half of the food and that she would give me store credit. I do not want store credit for a $20 sandwich that made my partner sick. I will never eat at that place again. She refused to reimburse me for it so now we are out $20 and have spent the previous evening feeling ill. That's a pretty expensive stomach ache. I can't speak for everything they make but I can speak for this particular Rueben and on how poorly this establishment is ran. As someone who has owned a small business, maintaining a good rapport with my community and customer base has always been top priority, not my ego. read more

We ordered from here only for the sandwiches. A family member made latkes so we didn't need knishes as a side, or soup. Completely LOVED the hot pastrami sandwiches (with Swiss), which were generous, moist, and very flavorful, on very soft rye. Like another reviewer noted, the pastrami looked more like corned beef, but the flavor was definitely that of pastrami. The coleslaw was sweet, creamy, just wonderful. Another delicious and HUGE sandwich, cut in thirds, was the Sloppy Joe. We picked up, so no comment on the atmosphere or staff, but giving the order by phone was very easy as I am always challenged when ordering online, especially for 8 people. That said, the online order format provided many options to personalize each item. My one sandwich, I had half for lunch, then the other half for dinner, reheated in foil in the toaster oven with a little extra Swiss, which melted into the pastrami beautifully. I want more soon ! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Sloppy Joe - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Mediocre at best. Pastrami was dry. I forgot to ask for fatty but there always be a good mix of lean and fatty in a sandwich unless otherwise specified. Didn't have a good crust. It was almost pasty and didn't have enough pepper. (Too much coriander?) It also didn't have the deep red look of a good pastrami sandwich. Based on all the hype this was disappointing and there's a better pastrami sandwich to had in Garfield. read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami on rye with mustard - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Great food. Superior bagels. Loved the health salad. Good coffee. But, as a dining-in customer, I would have enjoyed my meal more with real utensils (not wimpy plastic). Next time, I'll order my Nova and cream cheese sandwich as open-faced and request a knife and fork. Speaking of which, I have one-half of said sandwich left over for dinner. Generous portions. read more

Best pastrami ever, but mediocre service. Tried to buy a half pound pastrami and white fish, and they couldn't assist because they were too busy preparing for a catering. Management needs to figure this out. Customers don't like to be turned away when they are ready to spend their money. Just sayin'. read more

Enjoyed a corned beef sandwich with mustard on a club roll. The bread was super fresh & the corned beef was very tender and delicious - I highly recommend! read more

A friend had me take her there for a Gemisht (pastrami, turkey, corned beef in rye with mustard) in September, I think. She told me how large the sandwiches were, but I was not prepared for the massive pastrami sandwich I received.OMG!!! It was sooooo good! I'm in love. I reserve going there as a treat. If I went there all the time, I would have to start butteríng doorways to get my fat butt through them! I was so impressed that I mentioned it to a couple of people, and when they came into town, they insisted I take them there. They purchased a pastrami sandwich & a couple of hot dogs, and I had to take them back for more a few days later. All in all everyone I take there is pleased, and now it's a new place for me to treat myself. read more

OK . My wife and I have been Joan-sin for a Pastrami Sandwich for many months. So the other day she comes across a Yelp review of Mikki & Al's. We drove one hour to eat one of the tastiest pastrami's ever . And that includes the places in New York City . And the pickles were home made . The pastrami had a great smoky taste and cut to the proper s read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Best pastrami sandwich in NY and/or NJ. Easily beats Katz's. Perfect balance of tenderness/juiciness without making the bread a soggy mess. Love it! read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

What a delightful, sweet place. You can't help but be drawn to this adorable little restaurant nestled near Montclair's Bloomfield Avenue with friendly, efficient service. Absolutely top notch pastrami, corned beef, matzo ball soup, and egg salad (with way more on offer, such as mega-sized latkes), all fairly priced and in generous portions. It seems they do a brisk take out business but for some instant gratification, there's some seating inside (good for parties of 2-4) as well as 2-seater tables outside. read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Generously portioned egg salad - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

What a disappointment!!!! Matzoh ball soup was super salty. Pastrami was right out of a plastic shrink wrap bag. Dry, thick sliced and almost inedible. Best part of the meal was the Dr. Brown's soda. Wasted $50 on lunch for the two of us. Go to Kosher Nosh in Glen Rock for a real pastrami sandwich!!!! read more

Top drawer, freshly fried latkes for a friend's Hanukkah party? Yes. Yes, please. I also ordered some mouth watering smoked whitefish salad to go, a few pretty potato knishes, and some (delicious) chopped chicken livers. (Life without high quality noshes back at my hotel simply isn't worth living. Fact.) Yummers! read more

We were huge fans of Plum on Park so when Natalie transitioned over to Mikki and Al's we knew we had to try it. We had previously ordered deli sandwiches for dinner once and they were delicious so we were ready to mix things up and try the brunch. Hubby got the Bagel with Lox, onions and capers and he said it was amazing. A super generous portion of fresh cut lox with all the fix-ins done just right. I got a delicious Reuben. The pastrami was perfect topped with swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing on soft fresh rye bread. We each got a potato latke, one plain, one sweet potato with sour cream and apple sauce. To be extra indulgent we got an order of Rice Pudding. Outstanding. Although we miss the Gluten-free options at Plum on Park our deli dishes were excellent. True deli is a indulgence and Mikki and Al's did not disappoint. read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Delicious world-class Rueben sandwich - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I really dislike writing a not-good review when a restaurant is clearly trying hard and is lovely. And it is. But. I just wasn't very impressed. Specifically the Pastrami Sandwich, Latkes and the Chopped Liver just lacked ... flavor. They were beautifully and clearly lovingly made, but they just lacked some ... oomph. The Split Pea Soup with ham was not bad, but the ham itself had NO flavor. Just none. In their Matzoh Ball Soup, the matzoh ball was delicious, but the soup again: no flavor. They also like dill. A lot. While it doesn't detract from the Chicken Soup (which also needs salt IMHO but that's easy to add and its lack lets those salt-sensitive enjoy it), I do NOT believe dill belongs in Chopped Liver. It just doesn't. It's Natalie Lee's place and she gets to make how and what she wants; this is just an opinion from one customer. The Latkes too by the way desperately needed some salt but again: that is remediable, just not when on the road. I admit my standards are high, formed from places like Liebman's Deli in the Bronx. I was really hoping to not have to schlep to the Bronx for my kosher-style deli fix, but this ain't it. Mikki & Al's is new and/or maybe it's just not to my taste. I'll be curious to see what others think and what happens over time. read more

Delicious and consistent with quality. And my go to matzo ball soup when I'm sick! And the hamentashen are a yummy treat!

The goal here is to capture of the spirit of the Jewish delis of yore that to an extent, have died out. Mikkis is largely successful I think - the hand cut pastrami is what I have been sticking with and it has been superlative. If I had one suggestion it would be an option to grill press the Reuben - it's a messy recipe by nature and pressing might keep theirs held together a little better. But considering the generous portion size and rarely found quality of their house pastrami, I think most people should just skip the extras and get a straight pastrami and mustard anyway. read more

Mikki & Al’s Noshery - Pastrami Reuben - Delis Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I ordered a hot pastrami on rye with mustard. It was the worst pastrami. I am not sure if it was pastrami or corned beef. Could they spare the mustard? The pastrami or corned beef not sure because the meat had no flavor was cut thick a dab of mustard did not cover the bread and the meat was cold I also received a pickle and cole slaw. The cole slaw didn't cover the bottom of the cup. I was very disappointed. Never again. read more

We picked up from here for lunch and were so happy we did! I had the split pea soup and pastrami sandwich, and they were both the best I've ever had (and I've had a lot in NYC & NJ). My wife got the latke platter (with smoked salmon, onions, tomato, capers, etc) which she said was fantastic too. While the pickles and coleslaw were very fresh and obviously homemade, their flavor wasn't my favorite (there was an herb or something I didn't like). We will definitely be back to try more on the menu. Highly recommend! read more

Such a great find. Will definitely return! Even the kids enjoyed so much from our order, it was all perfect. Thank you so much!!!

The best chicken noodle and chicken matzoh ball soup I have ever had. And that is saying a lot. Chicken soup is my thing, I usually only like my own homemade, and this puts it to shame. The. Best. read more

Ex-NYers looking for a Katz replacement in the burbs should look no further. We ordered the pastrami, a Reuben, and a "sloppy Joe" which was hot pastrami with coleslaw and turkey. Amazing! Want to try back and try everything else. read more