Great selection of gluten-free items, both fresh and frozen. They have a nice case with beautiful desserts displayed, too. We really enjoyed the take and bake pizza, bagels, English muffins and bread we tried on our most recent visit. Everyone was super friendly and helpful. Can't wait to come back to try new items! read more

See all

Got a box of 25.00 cookies. They added 4 peppermints and the rest of the box was tainted with the taste .the cookies seem sloppy and I have had better cookies else where ,I should have bought one to try and than judge...lesson learned. I won't be getting anymore of these .Ive been GF for 14 years and understand the diet well and quality well. read more

We went here last week. Had the chocolate cupcakes. Aldo had the carrot cake cup cakes. It was good

Great variety of gluten free goods, both sweet and savory, and very reasonably priced compared to other gluten free places. We bought their coffee cake, brownies and pizza and it is all great tasting. Super nice staff and overall a 10/10 experience especially with the other cute shops in the same building!! read more

The bakery is inside another store, "Vintage Barn Chicks". It is just that - a bakery, and not a cafe. Don't expect to come in for coffee and dessert. It is, rather, a bakery with lots of gluten free options for breads, cakes and desserts. They also seem very open to experimenting with other food restrictions (egg, dairy, etc.) and I can see how it would be appealing to people with food allergies and problems. While I am not sensitive to gluten or any other food, I do like to vary my diet. I believe there is too much soy and wheat and everything we eat already, and do enjoy alternative foods for balance. And for taste! Many of the gluten free options are delicious! And while I enjoyed finding a place with as much options as this place had to offer, I wasn't wowed. To be fair, I am only comparing the cookies I had here with other gluten free cookies, and I must say, I've had better. Also, despite the friendly "ask about" signs, asking questions to the person manning the cash register was like pulling teeth. They weren't friendly, and made me feel like I had to hurry up and leave. As much variety they had in the store, I didn't feel comfortable looking through the items. Hence I ended up with just a box of chocolate chip cookies. That were just, as we say in yelp-land, a-OK. read more

See all

New owner, Heather and family, are doing an amazing job! Had the hot dog buns last weekend and GF sausage pizza this weekend! So many great options! Love that I can shop in person on the weekends! read more

Will not disclose ingredients. They only ask what you're trying to avoid and will let you know if it's an ingredient. Sorry but I won't eat anything if I don't have a fully disclosed ingredient list. Especially when asked for!! read more

My husband and I stopped into this bakery and got the Twinkie like pastry and that was delicious! My husband is GF so it was really neat to find out about this bakery. We picked up the gf garlic bread to take home and make later. We came towards the end of the day so you could tell that they had been busy and sold a lot. The bakery has a variety of options and loved the take home fridge with all the pizza's and bread's. read more

I've never been so let down the birthday cake before. This thing is like car engine oil in your mouth and on your fingers it is literally filled with palm oil and cotton seed oil oh but the chocolate cake I'm describing from Molly's does have ingredient chocolate listed... WHOOPTY DOO! read more

I started shopping Molly's menu during the covid pandemic. She had such a great system for ordering and pick up. I appreciate how sensitive she was to her customers' needs and her employees' health while keeping everyone safe and satisfied. Her doughs are the best! read more

Super cute bakery in a charming setting in Pewaukee. Great selection of gluten free goods and they also have dairy free items on request. Delicious! Must check our! read more

FIVE STAR FIVE STAR FIVE STAR! I cant even put into words how GREAT this place is.. I had tried their products in grocery stores ONLY to find out that it was made locally and near a place I would be for work within the week! DOUBLE GRANDSLAM HOME RUN BATMAN! Its a little hard to find, but Mapquest somehow knew and put in key pointers like "if you hit this street youve gone .2 miles too far) but if you take 94 W to 16 then get off on the K exit and then take your first right down a frontage road it is right by the big silo.. I havent found anything there I didnt LOVE.. we tricked my dad who is a notorious complainer when we have family events and make things gluten free for me about the taste.. EVEN HE LIKED IT! Pizza Crusts- AMAZING! if you arent cooking it on a pizza stone or anything though watch out because the sauce tends to leak through the aerated pizza crust.. again.. NOTHING that would EVER cause me to NOT buy this. They also have premade pizzas if thats what you are looking for. Ginger Snap Cookies- DELISH.. they actually taste like cookies and arent too crunchy... just really done right The French Loaf- AMAZING! I made garlic bread that tasted like garlic bread for the first time IN FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Such a relief Choc Chip Cookies- REALLY GREAT! They were gone before I even got a chance to put them in the freezer... which brings me to my next point: Marbled Rye Loaf- REALLY REALLY GOOD! I made a grilled cheese sandwich on this stuff yesterday and it was DIVINE! The bread holds together without being too dense. Its amazing. Seriously.. get out there... I want to start a carpool for every two weeks.. if you are GF in the Tosa area, let me know! haha read more

It's quite a compliment to be able to order a gluten-free birthday cake and have everyone -- even those who have never had to eat gluten-free -- say it was fantastic. Molly's Gluten-Free Bakery - I'm a fan. The yellow cake you make for our company's celebratory party was amazing. And, all the extra goodies I took home for my husband to try were delish as well. Thank you, thank you, thank you. read more

This is one of my favorite food-related places these days. At the suggestion of my Dr. I needed to do an elimination diet with no wheat for 30 days. This did not sound appealing to my as I love my breads and I would not have made it through if not for Molly's! So many good things, where to start? Everything in this bakery is GF and delicious. The bakery makes those wonderful pizza crusts for Transfer and VIA, looks at their reviews and see the raves for yourself. The take home version is just as delectable. The thin cracker like crust bakes quickly, browns well and tastes fantastic! Pita bread- makes excellent personal pizzas a little thicker than the pizza crust. Everything bagels- Good flavor but best to keep frozen and pull out what you need. Frozen Soft Pretzels - one of my favorite things to get here. Not on their regular menu but they seem to have some in the freezer each time I go, which I appreciate. Large almost stadium size with no salt. Bake them for a crispy crusty outside and a soft and fluffy inside. Not only was Molly's a lifesaver during my elimination diet, they continue to be my go-to place for wonderful bakery good, even though gluten free is no longer a necessity. read more

Delicious gluten free bakery! Customer service was superb and I love that they sell cookie dough too.

Worth every mile out to Pewaukee, and it is now in the same building with the Gluten Free Trading Company. Great customer service, they truly care about their customers! What to try: --cinnamon raisin rolls (my favorite thing out there!) --any of their bread loaves --Lemon bars, pumpkin bars --Mint chocolate brownies --Mexican wedding cookies --PIZZA (buy frozen crusts or pre-made-frozen and bake at home) Have not found one thing there that I didn't just love. :) read more

I truly cannot say enough good things about Molly's Gluten-Free Bakery. I contacted Molly's to make the cutting cake for our wedding, and despite it being one of the busiest times of the year for their team (Thanksgiving weekend) they went the extra mile to ensure that my wedding cake was everything I wanted and more. The cake was absolutely beautiful, exactly as I pictured it, and I kid you not, was the best cake I've ever had. (It took a lot of willpower to save some of the leftovers for our 1 year anniversary and not eat it all the next day. :)) Thank you, Mary and the rest of the Molly's team for making our day! read more

Molly's Gluten-Free Bakery - Our beautiful wedding cake from Molly's Gluten Free Bakery! Photo by Studio 29 Photography - Bakeries Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

One word, AMAZING! Everything is wonderful. I bought more than I could eat, froze some of the cupcakes and they still were delicious after being frozen. You MUST stop in and pick up one of EVERYTHING ;-) You won't be disappointed! read more

Wow! The vegan vanilla cupcakes are wonderful. The buttercream is far more tasty than any regular cupcake frosting I've had, however, the sponge is slightly dry. Friendly employees as well, and a great location right off of the freeway. read more

Lovely little gluten-free bakery with a big all gluten-free grocery store. The workers here are lovely people and everything is baked with a passion for making yummy treats and staple grains for those who can't eat gluten. Try the bagels and whoopie pies! read more

Not sure it would be possible to give anything less than 5 stars to Molly's. The service, either in person or over the phone, has always been extremely friendly. Anything I have ever gotten from Molly's has been amazing. From pumpkin loaf to sugar cookies or pizza crust. I recently went to an event hosted at Molly's and they went above and beyond for us. I went there expecting to have a couple of cookies to try and maybe a slice of pizza. I left will a belly full of delicious food! I live in Milwaukee and often pick up their products at the Sentry on State St. Although just as delicious, it's just not the same as picking it up fresh from the bakery. I think it is time to open up shop in Milwaukee!! read more

My son is on a gluten-free dieat and mine is nearly gluten-free so after seeing an ad and some write-ups we decided to drive out to Mollys. Very attentive and friendly cashier who gave us samples of some items. Actually one of the largest gluten-free stores in the area. read more

Had my first Molly's cupcake today. Amazing. I have yet to go to the bakery. But discovered today that Metcalf's Sentry carries Molly's. I had the red velvet with cream cheese frosting. I will be back to try the bread! read more

The first time I went here I must have walked in late because the lady who helped me did not seem happy to see me. It was my first time going there, and I didn't know I had to walk into one of the other shops to find the place. However, I didn't let that discourage me and I have gone back a couple more times because I really like the place. They have a pretty decent dairy free/egg free selection here that they keep in a fridge/freezer behind the counter. I look forward to ordering specific items and going back to pick them up. read more

Molly's made our cutting cake for our wedding. Being a gf Milwaukeean I was very aware of the tastiness of Molly's products (coffee cake anyone?) but I had never had their cakes. Mary was so easy to work with! We communicated via email which was really helpful since planning a wedding meant we were available at odd times. The cake itself turned out exactly how we had imagined, and it was delicious! I absolutely recommended Molly's for events and daily treats! read more

Love Molly's! The carrot cake is to die for!!! You couldn't even tell it was gluten free. Will definitely be back for all of my cake needs!

DO NOT go here if you are a VEGETARIAN! I am extremely disappointed I bought pita's to find out that they were made with gelatin. I thought it was odd there were no labels on the packages. When I went in again I asked to see what was in them and gelatin was in there. I looked at a couple other products and noticed all the basic white dough had gelatin including the other bread. I have been a vegetarian for 9 years and stayed clear of gelatin products but, it is now ruined. I should have asked to see the list of ingredients but, I also think Molly's should have labels on there food. Some people may not think twice of gelatin or butter being in bread because it is not common. The only reason I give this two stars is because it's partly my fault. I want to inform vegetarians/vegans who may not think twice about gelatin being in their bread when it very well could be. read more

Needing a GF wedding cake "the owner will have to call you back for wedding related questions & ordering" Makes sense. ...But It's been well over a month since the first call.....2 weeks since I called last. If they struggle to return a simple phone call...they cannot be trusted to make a wedding cake. Very disappointed because there are so many allergies & intolerances with myself & our guests. read more

yum yum yum!!! was in milwaukee and decided to order some gf bakery goods to bring back home to illinois!!!! what a gem....still have a few items in the freezer...but the creme rolls...like a twinkie....fabulous! raspberry dream cakes...heavenly:-):-).... iced cookies..fantastic...lemon squares..muffins.....mexican weddng cakes...huge cherry pie........very inexpensive compared to the gf bakeries in chicago land. met a couple there from batavia, il...doing the same thing....picking up items to bring back home....can't wait until our next trip! already have a list started....plus my total bill was less than $100 and we received alot of freezable items! keep up the great work! read more

Every time I visit Wisconsin, my mom makes sure to have the fridge stocked with Molly's for my arrival. Every time my mom visits me in NYC, she makes sure to bring a suitcase full of Molly's goods. First of all, the prices are ridiculously cheap. By gluten free standards, and even regular bakery standards. You would think the quality would have to be compromised because of the price, but no! I think I've tried just about everything Molly's has to offer from their extensive selection, but some notable items on my list are the mint chocolate brownie (I thought I was eating a non-gf brownie when I first tried it and got a bit scared) The brownies are so moist and just the right amount of mint. The creame cakes, wow. They are like a high-end version of a twinkie. So, so good. The lemon bars, amazing. The pumpkin cake with frosting, wow. The little raspberry cakes, Ohmygod. The english muffins are great - but I would say they are more like t he consistency of a crumpet. But who cares, it's good! The everything bagels are great toasted with some butter or cheese. Yummmm. I really can't say enough good things about this place. For the quality, price and variety of goods, you just can't find anything even close in NYC! read more

AMAZING! AMAZING! AMAZING! What an incredible treat to be able to have so many gluten free foods that were all unbelievably delicious. I HIGHLY recommend the creme cakes, they are like Twinkies, only better. The brownies and breads are also amazing. I cannot believe how light and airy they are. I have been missing those little air pockets in all other gluten free breads I've tried, but they got them just right! Will definitely return next time we are in Wisconsin. Bravo!!!!! read more

What's not to like? The staff is friendly and helpful and everything they bake is delicious. The chocolate chip cookies are to die for and would compare well to any cookie. I recently tried one of their soft pretzels and it was wonderful. Stretchy and light with just a hint of salt. I split it with my husband and we both thought it was excellent. Lemon bars, rolls, ginger cookies, brownies--I can't think of anything I don't like at Molly's. read more

Stumbled upon this gem after a wrong turn- lucky me!! This is some of the best gluten-free baked goodery I have had in my 20+ years of dining on gluten free baked goodwry! The flavor and texture of her breads, cookies, English muffins, and cupcakes are AMAZING. My favorite takeaway was the cheese garlic scone. Nom. read more

What a blessing it has been to find Molly's bakery! My son is allergic to wheat, dairy, all nuts and eggs. We ordered a chocolate birthday cake w/o any of the above for his birthday party and the kids came back for seconds! Since then we are regular Molly's customers ordering, bagels, pizza crusts, bread, cupcakes, cookies, delicious brownies, all, dairy, egg and gluten free. It's such a pleasure having foods my son can eat that looks like other kids food. Thank you, Molly's. read more

Only gluten free bakery in the state of Wisconsin that I am aware of. I have a 9 year old daughter who has celiac. I am beyond grateful for this bakery. Finally a place to grab cookies and cupcakes. read more

This place is amazing!!!!!! There is nothing there that is not amazing!! Pizza, cakes, cookies, cupcakes, you name it, mouth watering. Bread, AMAZING!! Service is excellent! I can't say enough about this place, only that now I know it exists, so I have to have self control!! read more

Molly's is as good as it gets. Customer service is excellent as well as her items. Will custom make items for those who must have gluten-free, dairy free or egg free products. So much easier to order and just pick up. And the items are delicious. Brain-free shopping, which is a delight. Absolutely love going to Molly's. read more