The breakfast food is magical... overall they are good. I used to love this one salad but I think they may have changed the chef and things just aren't the same. The meat became kind of thick. Wait staff is nice but I had an instance where I felt rushed and watched while I was eating. Overall, the place has a real diner feel and is well known around the town. read more

Good local diner with a liquor license but, they decided to use a no name ketchup instead of National brands such as Hunts or Heinz to save some money. Sad decision because we would rather pay a penny or two more for the meal and have ketchup we enjoy. Off to find another local diner with ketchup we like read more

All I got was wings the sauce on these wings were fantastic .. Best sauce ever! (Traditional, mild)

Been to this Diner many times .... always the food & service are excellent ! But ... F.Y.I. ... their "Taylor Ham " sandwiches do contain PORK ROLL ... but not the Taylor Ham brand ... The Taylor Ham brand is the BEST Pork Roll made !! read more

This review is on behalf of my parents that went and were treated with utter disrespect. They enter the diner and the waitress directs them to the inside area of the diner, until the tall middle aged gentlemen, presumably the manager signals the waitress to put them towards the benches in the end. They follow the waitress and have a seat. Another couple walks in and the manager himself directs them towards the inside area where my parents were initially supposed to sit. My parents then got up and left. Not sure if this was because they were of ethnic background or they didn't meet the standards of an average diner. Never happened before, discriminating and highly disappointing. read more

Best diner in the area. Worth driving an extra 10-15 minutes to get to. Great food & excellent prices.

I have been going to this diner for years and I always liked the people and the food. Their wraps and french fries are always good and they now sell alcohol if you feel like a drink. It's a nice place to just relax and eat some comfort food. read more

Best pancakes in the area! Be sure to check out their mimosas as well. I love their berry packcakes as well as the Oreo pancakes. Their selection of items is great and pretty consistent! read more

My wife and I had breakfast here during a recent trip to NJ. The service was good, my wife enjoyed her breakfast. Mine was not as good. I ordered plain pancakes and a side of sausage. The pancakes had no flavor and the sausage was cold-but I would give the place another try if I were in the area. read more

This is the cleanest diner I've ever been in! The windows between our booth and the front area where the register is were so clean that one of our party didn't know there was glass there until he noticed the etching ehich was higher than eye level! The food was very good--I had the portabella and chicken sandwich. The bread pudding was warm as requested and it was very, very good. The waitress was attentive but not intrusive and very nice to my grandson. We did have a little mishap with the stuffed animal grabber game/machine in the lobby but the staff was amazing in resolving the problem. Many thanks to the sweet woman at the regster who gave me back the $2.00 we lost in the machine/ I ended up returning that money because another very thoughtful server took the time to test the machine which worked without a problem for her. She got a little stuffed allegator out of it and brought it to my grandson who had been very upset about the whole "nothing happened" problem. So, for the food, the cleanliness and the very, VERY nice people who work there, I give the Montville Diner FIVE stars! read more

Just came from eating dinner with my family here. We were sort of a regular customer over the last year we all had one of the worst meals we ever had at a dinner anywhere. Salmon not cooked enough sent back only to have it microwaved and brought back 1 minute later. Just bad. A chicken panini that bread was not pressed or cooked enough, never had a panini where the bread was fluffy. Even the salads tasted funky. About the only redeeming thing was some french fries that came with a burger that was not really good either, but can you really give more than 1 star for good french fries. When we showed the server how bad it was and asked to talk to the management they took $6 off the meal. Do not ever plan on going back. read more

Stopped in for late night breakfast. The eggs were wet and spoiled and that horrid lady Lynn bitched when we wanted to divide our checks. Never again read more

Came in at 2 AM. Food was average but old lady Lynn was nasty an obviously on something

Their food is mediocre at best but I go there w a family member and they seem to like it there. Anyway, today I witnessed something that truly bothered me and bothers me even more that I didn't speak up. Today around 1230 I was eating lunch (burnt bacon) and bad soup, when I family walked in and they had a service dog with them and the owner denied them entry. I was so shocked that he refused them but more angry at myself for keeping quiet. The dog had the proper documents but still refused. read more

Food and prices okay. We waited patiently for service, but were rushed out after we finished. ( If they need the quick turnover, quicken the service ! ). Better off at Empire Diner Parsippany or West Side Diner Denville. read more

This diner is just plain bad. The service is horrible. The owner has that "give me your money and get the hell out" attitude about him and doesn't seem to have any patience when it comes to you requesting things like water, napkins, etc. The food is bad for diner food, which in itself, is not meant to be really good. I stopped coming here after high school and usually frequent the Empire Diner. Every once in a while I get lazy and order from here, and every single one of those times I am reminded why I boycotted the Montville Diner in the first place. My advice, drive up rt.46 west for another mile and go to Empire. read more

Food was not good. Matzo ball soup took forever to come out (after everyone else had eaten) and was cold. So were the fries. At least they had enough how tables to fit our party. I wish it was better because I like a good diner, but it's worth the drive to go elsewhere. read more

Don't even think about it. The food is atrocious, the last time I had a good meal in this location is when it was called the Dakota Diner they was many many years ago. read more

Don't order the Patty Melt! Worst dinner I have ever had. It cost $10.00 and it was a thin frozen patty with no taste at all. I have ordered the Patty Melt at many diners through the years and have always had a fresh big hamburger not a small thin frozen patty. Definitely not worth the money. The french fries were good but the patty was terrible. Big ripoff! read more

This diner should be closed down! They truly have no clue, and have the nerve to accept payment. The waitress staff doesn't listen to the customers and the cooks, well they should learn how too! I will never eat food from this poorly run diner again! read more

ok diner food not cheap enough for me though i'd rather not spend 10$ on a cheap diner lunch read more

Nice local diner. Friendly people. Good food and the service is fast and friendly. Recommend.

The place was fine. Our waitress was great. Food was good. Maybe too many onions and tomatoes in the salad but that isn't a big deal. Overall we all enjoyed our meal. read more

Unfortunately business has dropped off from when I was here almost daily years ago, but thankfully the food hasn't changed a bit! Everything is good, full menu, friendly staff. I see some negative reviews and all I can say is please remember it's a diner. It's about friendly service, quick service, good simple foods and cleanliness and it is all above. Please check it out. read more

This is the worst diner I've ever been to. Should have know when parking lot was empty at 6pm. Fries tasted 2 days old. Pastrami was like leather. I asked for mustard and waitress threw 2 packets of cheap mustard at my table. Find someplace else to eat !!! read more

Read some reviews before trying this diner, but we we hadn't eaten all day and decided to try it out despite seeing the words "Worst diner in Northern Jersey" on TripAdvisor. Well, we should have heeded that warning! I ordered the French Onion soup. The broth was so tasteless that even salt would have helped. It was nothing more than a flavorless broth with cooked onions and melted cheese. Melted cheese can usually make anything better, but not this time. My husband had a corn beef and pastrami omelette with a side salad. He said that the entire omelette tasted like hotdogs. Good pastrami and corn beef should not taste like cheap hotdogs, and I could visually see the side salad was nothing more than a pile of limp lettuce. Diners used to be a trademark of Jersey, and I grew up going to some of the best ones. What on earth is happening out there? People who don't know anything about how to run a diner shouldn't be in this business. The place was empty during a normal dinner hour. We should have walked right out. read more

This diner is great. The people are very nice. The food is great.. I have had breafast and dinner there and was never disappointed.

I used to go to the Montville Diner regularly years ago. The food was quite acceptable then. But my husband and I went back one day last week, and we had the worst food ever! I had stuffed cabbage, and their was no liquid in the stuffing. It was just dried out cooked beef and rice, with no seasoning. It was absolutely awefull! My husband ordered a side of spinach and rice, and it smelled worse than dog food and tasted worse. I had to spit it out. Tasted like old canned spinach mixed with dried out rice. Needless to say we will NEVER go back there again!! read more

I stopped in tonight for a quick dinner with the family after a long drive home. It was 8:30 and mostly empty. The food was mediocre at best and the host made it worse with his comments when we were paying the bill. He asked me the obligatory "How was everything"? I responded "eh, not so good". You'd think at this point he'd ask why and at least apologize. Instead he said nothing and really didn't respond at all. So I volunteered the details of how my wife's egg white omelette was wet because the frozen spinach they use was not properly dried before being added, my chicken souvlaki sandwich was served on a slightly stale pita, my kids pasta with butter was awful (how hard is it to melt butter?), it wasn't butter but some imitation product or margarine or something, and all of the hash browns were undercooked and bland. The pizza cheesesteak was more like a steak-um with sauce and cheese on it. In fairness, my 10 year old ordered Oreo pancakes that were delicious. After this, the host only offered a "we were very busy tonight" but nothing more. I even offered him an excuse when I asked if there was a fill-in chef or something out of the norm going on with the kitchen. I'd eaten there before for work lunches and it was always fine. Needless to say, we will not be returning anytime soon. It's one thing for a place to have an off night as it happens to the best of us. But when 4 out of 5 dishes are just not that good and the host shows zero remorse or customer service, it's not worth venturing back. read more

So overpriced. Disco fries are okay but there are much better diners in close proximity to this place

One word to describe it, HORRIBLE, DO not waste your money. Went there last night for dinner, 9/12/14. Ordered crab cakes with Mac n cheese. Well what I got was potato pancake with a hint of chopped up sea legs in it. The Mac n cheese was Kraft box Mac n cheese. My husband ordered broiled scallops that could have been used for fish bait! Hard, rubbery and disgusting. Asked for cocktail sauce and received undiluted tomato soup! We approached the owner and asked why the Kraft Mac n cheese and he admitted that was what it was because they were catering to children and that's what the kids like. He did admit that they have had numerous complaints and MIGHT go back to real Mac n cheese. I reminded him still we were not kids and what kids order crab cakes, since they were potatoe pancakes.he just laughed. I told him to take a good look at us because we would NEVER be returning. He made no effort to apologize or correct the bill. PLEASE don't waste your hard earned money in this place!!!! read more

My husband and I visited this diner for the first time and it will definitely be our last. It is overpriced for the quality of food you get. My husband ordered a ceasar wrap which he said was disgusting. It was basically a wrap filled with mostly lettuce and overloaded with dressing so much so that it leaked everywhere and the wrap fell apart. I ordered a chicken panini which was horrible. The waitress was very nice and told us to order something else. We figured you can't mess up a burger right? WRONG! They served us with the cheapest frozen thin patties in an oversized bun. They should be ashamed of themselves to serve this kind of cheap meat and charge the amount of money you wouldn't mind paying if you were served with a juicy fresh ground meat burger. We were better off stopping at a McDonalds or Wendys and would have gotten better food. THIS IS BY FAR THE WORST DINER IN NJ! read more