Voted favorite spot by the whole family on vacation. Don't let the parking lot/shopping center deceive you, this place is great. Unassuming outside, clean and humble interior. Order at a register, pick a table and served from there. Workers were patient with a big order and timely with refills. Salads were fine but pizza was of course the star of the show. Everyone left satisfied and even with leftovers. Gluten free pizza was also fabulous. read more

See all

Super friendly and helpful staff! Fun decor and music is at a good volume. But the pizza...way better than expected! We wanted to try some of the named pizzas on the board, but decided to play it safe on our first visit and just got a large mushroom. You can tell it was made fresh; I can't say I've seen a pizza steaming like it was when we got it, mushrooms were very fresh, and just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and mushrooms. The crust had a good crisp on the bottom, but a really good chew. I usually prefer a very thin crust pizza being originally from the northeast, but this was amazing! The sauce wasn't my favorite, but nothing notably wrong with it. I was telling the guy who helped us that there are a few my son would like, and he said any pizza can be done by the slice, so we may be getting a "sampler" box soon read more

Moon River Pizza - Large mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Enjoyed the music while we waited on our food. We got a half cheese(for the kids) and half "the pizza" which was AMAZING! This really was some GOOD pizza! read more

Very good pizza Had the medium special with a full Greek salad. Service was fast despite filling someone's very large takeout order. It's a pizza joint so it was a proper setting, despite being in an older strip mall. Don't let the outside discourage you. It's well worth eating there or doing takeout. read more

Moon River Pizza - Medium "The Special ". - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Great pizza! The salad was small for the price, but it was yummy. The environment was a fun throw back type of feeling and comfortable

Still the best Pizza on Amelia Island! Maybe the best in the State of FL. Always visit whenever visiting Amelia. This is the Mother Ship; satellite in Jacksonville. Prices have gone up, but those are the sad times we Inhabit. Get a slice and a salad and think quality. read more

Moon River Pizza - Gorgonzola Salad and slice of "Special" pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

I ordered two large pizzas for carryout...excellent pizza. They are a bit expensive compared to major chains but sooo worth it. The pizzas have a lot of toppings and are very filling. The flavors are great, not salty like some pizzas and not sweet tasting sauce like some chains. Really great pizza! read more

Y'all remember when we had Beef O'Brady's, KFC, and Shoney's? You know who else was around back then? (I'm pretty sure) Moon River Pizza was. Now there are some good pizza options in the places formerly occupied by the 3 restaurants listed above, but Moon River is still doing their thing. The worst thing I can say about my experience is that I decided to share my calzone with my old lady, and we were HUNGRY. The food was delicious, the cashier/server was warm and friendly, and my favorite thing about the ambiance was the note on the tv's that said something along the lines of "please don't ask for the channel to be changed, just enjoy what's on". They had sports on 1 tv and Harry Potter on the other. If you aren't satisfied with one of those options, you're probably a hard person to please (and probably suck at Quidditch). read more

See all

Terrible service. Waited more than 25 minutes for a single slice of cheese pizza. Then they got slammed, and I couldn't speak to anybody. So I finally had to leave. When I called to explain the situation, I still got charged for it. read more

Just discovered MR Pizza, a hidden gem on Amelia Island! I enjoyed their pizza (TRex, White / Hawaii'n). Cool option is a 1/2 and 1/2 on one of the pies. Staff were all very friendly and cool. Environment is eclectic chill and music was a great mix. I enjoyed a Peroni on tap while I waited on my order and grabbed a couple cans of Stella with my to go order. I can't believe I was unaware of this place until now?! Well worth a try IMO read more

Delicious pizza.. slice is large. I always get the special. One slice of pizza can fill me up. Or get a whole large pizza that is a better price per slice.. see new menu read more

Moon River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

My service and food today (June 2, 2025) were extremely good. Always a good pie or slice of a pie if you're in the area and hungry. The facility was clean and organized. Only thing I saw, (never seen before) which I would have walked out if I saw it happen to my pie, the pizza maker decided to wipe his face with his hand, then wipe his mouth, then pulled a pie from the oven, lifted it up (with the same hand) and blew under it and then appeared to blow on it. I have never seen that technique before. Maybe a new method I'm not aware of, but not to sure it was sanitary. I love places I can see what they are doing and the majority of the time they (staff) are doing it right. read more

Good pizza and get it by the slice so everyone gets what they want. Also have good Greek salad. Not fancy but clean.

Easily the best calzone I've had anywhere in years. The pizza looked really good, too. The staff were super helpful and friendly, literally every person we talked to. We came in a bit closer to closing time than I like to do, having worked in the service industry myself, but you would have never guessed it the way everyone was so cool. Nice cold draft beer sure helped, and you can't beat the price for the amount and quality of the food you get. To top it all off, they were playing some really great 90s music, too! I would have never guessed a pizza place in a strip mall not on any of the main drags in town would be so amazing - great find!!!!! read more

I love this place for pizza. Just trying to figure out why they are charging $4.50 for a soft drink. That's got to be the worst price on the island. Pizza prices are fair but the drink prices are ridiculous. read more

Simply THE BEST Pizza EVER! The available variety just can't be beat. For me it's All Veggie all the time. read more

Love the story and following that Moon River has from the locals. We were directed here by the great people at A1A Cidery. We ordered the T-Rex and a Hawaiian calzone to enjoy in our hotel room after a busy day. Delicious! I will say it's cheese heavy but no complaints from the kids. The staff were friendly and we had a chance to check out the restaurant while waiting for the pizza. Cool little spot that has 'dive bar' vibes in the best way. If we're on the island again we're ordering from Moon River! read more

Moon River Pizza - Hawaiian Calzone - Cheesy!! - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Great ingredients and quality of pies. Nothing disappointing about the food quality or quantity.

My buddy recommended moon river to us when we were visiting Amelia Island. We called in the order to go and it was ready as soon as we got there. Pizza was huge and is a really good deal for the price. They also had some nice pizza combos you could get if you are wanting a smaller meal. The pizza was hot and full of toppings. It had a great flavor and we enjoyed the crust as well. I'd happily eat here again if I'm in the area. #bhamfoodguy read more

Moon River Pizza - T - rex #bhamfoodguy - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Terrible service. Sent my family there to pick up pizza and it took over 90 minutes to get the pizzas. Pizzas were overpriced and poor quality. Their website states that they do not take online or phone orders which would save a lot time and they should consider joining the rest of us in this century and offer call ahead service. They obviously do not respect anyone's time. Also not friendly. Will not return. Very disappointed. read more

Best Pizza! Great Service! Great place to sit and relax and have a drink ... I usually drink soda but they have beer and wine too. White pizza is my favorite although they make a mean pepperoni pizza as well. Servers are kind and friendly and it generally doesn't take long to get the pizza you order. read more

Best pizza in town! We always come when we visit! Staff is friendly and the ambiance inside is cool. Can't wait until our next trip!

BEST slice I've had in Florida and the best I've had in a looong time. Asked a bud for a good slice in Fernandina and he sent me here. He was right read more

These are some big pies! Hungry family of four ordered two large pizzas and didn't even finish half of either. The Hawaiian pizza and the T-Rex (all the meats) were both really good. Solid sauce and crispy crust. Well done, MRP. read more

Moon River Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Fri 8/24/19 - party of 2 We had calzone cravings and Yelp led us to Moon River. It's located in a sketchy strip with mostly empty stores. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you. There was quite a line so it took about 25 minutes to place our order. My teenager had Italian sausage and black olives in his calzone and I had veggies. Both were tasty but seemed to lack some seasoning. The marina sauce was really sweet and bland. Adding some Italian seasoning and garlic would have made these remarkable, instead of just a meal. Cute place with the walls covered in art for sale (with outlandish prices). It was really hot because of all the pizza ovens. I enjoyed the rocking music and the muted TV's. read more

Moon River Pizza - Calzones - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

This restaurant is housed in a random and somewhat run down strip plaza. Do not be fooled, the food is delicious. We ordered at the counter and then had a seat. Food arrived about 10 mins later. I had the white pizza per other Yelp recommendations. It was absolutely the best white pizza I've ever had. My family ordered a regular meat and veggie pizza. The crust is thin and crispy. We also had a greek salad. The dressing was delicious! I would definitely give this place a try if you are in town. Loved everything! read more

Several friends recommended this place so I'll start by saying it doesn't like inviting when you pull up. Dark tinted windows with crazy drawings on the storefront. Plenty of parking since several units next to it are closed. Huge menu on the wall as you enter and place your order and pay before seating. The decor inside could use a serious face lift. We ordered a small house salad that comes with Italian dressing. All the fixings on it with a pile of shaved mozzarella cheese on top. I enjoyed that very much. We ordered a large half and half. One side (The Pizza) and the other side (The Special) Both Pizza's were good but next time we will order by the slice. The pizza was very good and filling, but got kind of doughy after the second pizza. I would like to try a build it yourself pizza next time. read more

See all

One of the best pizzas on the island... a local favorite for sure. You can order by the slice or whole pizza . It's delicious!!! A little crisp on the bottom and tender topping... with tons of options. Kitchen is exposed to the dining area which has a cool feel. Very vibey kind of place . People serving are nice and helpful. read more

Food was amazing! Service was amazing! Atmosphere was great! 10 of 10 Awesome service, good food read more

A local pizza place in Fernandina Beach. Lots of " take outs" but there is spaced, seating inside too. The salads are not premiere salad but just iceberg, mushrooms, cheese and such, but they are fresh and crisp...just not fancy or creative. The pizza though is what we come for and the crust is great! We ordered a white pizza with bacon-the bacon was smoky! The menu on line is off a few dollars on almost everything. As an example on line menu showed medium white pizza was $17 but there it is $19-no big deal but just noting there is a difference. Inside has funky paintings for sale too read more

See all

Delicious pizza! Service was a little intimidating. The gentleman taking orders was yelling where to stand. Cute theme for the decor. One thing that was not great was how we smelled when we left there. Stunk up the hotel room pretty bad. Overall good food but maybe be better for takeout. read more

First time in yesterday afternoon. Staff was ok, not super welcoming but ok. You order first then they serve you. Pizza was Delicious! I certainly would be back! I brought home extra so heated in the air fryer this am, and it was definitely BOMB! Family and I will be back. read more

I am from NJ and it would not be fair ro just any of the places around here against the NY/NJ pizza, however, you might like this place. The flavor of the sauce/cheese/dough is good! It's a decent pizza- not my favorite- because I prefer a thinner, less doughy crust that either has the sauce and cheese coming close to the outer edge, or a crust that is crisp. I would try them out, you might like it. The people working there are very nice. The line can be long at lunchtime, so order ahead. It's a nice little restaurant/ bar too. read more

This pizza parlor was a great spot to stop. The pizza was so delicious, loved the sauce and service was great. The only thing I wish they had was outdoor dining because we'd love to go back with our dogs after going to the beach. We don't live close by. Definitely worth stopping here. read more

Will update in the future. Had the Special which was a meal in one slice. It has sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, cheese and great crust. Reason for updating is I will be trying other slices and this was good but I look forward to better. "Interesting art on the wall" read more

See all

Apparently this is the original spot for that great pizza and it is stated it is even better in this location than in JAX. I must say the pizzas are portioned larger. If you are alone or just two of you might consider ordering slices instead. Of course everything was fresh and hot and tons of cheese. Their was a line at the door all the time we were here so that says it all! Could use a slight remodel I think but its still has a nice family pizza vibe. read more

Moon River Pizza - Talk about a mediumportion - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

My wife and I have been looking for a great pizza place since we moved here a year ago. We've had a few good pies from a couple of different places but someone recommended Moon River. We were skeptical when we ordered as the previous pies were ok but not great. My wife ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and I ordered a calzone. We didn't eat there, rather we took it home. I have had many many calzones over the years but the one I ate from Moon River was far and away one of the best I've ever had! The cheeses, meatball and spinach made for a delicious meal!! My wife could not stop raving me on her pizza. She is very hard to please but she raved about it! I must give this place 4 Chef Hats ‍‍‍‍and a "See you soon!!" thumbs up!! read more

Very good pizza! We had "The Special" and it hit all the marks. Good crust. Flavorful toppings. And lots of cheese! I would definitely recommend this place. We picked it straight from the good reviews. It did not disappoint. read more

We drive about 40 minutes to come here, passing many other so-called pizzerias on the way. Why? Because this is the absolute best one around, period! The food is very consistent, and the service is excellent. One of the cooks even stopped spinning a dough to give it to a random kid that was watching in awe of the display of pizza preparation mastery! Who does that? These guys do. read more

Moon River Pizza - The best pizza around! - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

STOP. Because I shouldn't love a pizza place this much my doctor is going to hate me it's just so good I love the white pizza! And I love the pesto bread! Service is always great they've never once messed up an order and always so friendly. Ambiance is pretty unique very local/dive/surfer vibe which I love read more