This was a terrible experience. I would not recommend this place. They couldn't get my order right. I specifically ordered my sandwich with no meat, and it was made incorrectly. I also ordered sliced tomatoes, but they came chopped instead. The food was not what I ordered, and the mistakes were significant enough that I couldn't even eat it. Very disappointing. read more

I've been to a few mountain mikes, but my personal favorite is on Lakeville in Petaluma . The staff at the front counter is super friendly. The place is super clean too. It's definitely a guilty pleasure for me when I get pizza from this place, as one who loves eating all kinds of great pizza. If I need something quick especially for a larger crowd, that hits that spot, then I aim for mountain mikes mountain size . My personal favorite is doing have white sauce and half red sauce on the pizza. Game changer for your favorite toppings. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Custom made : anchovies, sausage, jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

This place is CLEAN! floors, tables, buffet all super clean which made this lady super happy. Service was top tier, very accommodating. We came for the lunch buffet and I don't eat pork but there were no "non" pork options as far as pizzas that were out and they quickly made me two options which were both delish. Food was great as well, fresh salad toppings, fresh lettuce. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Seating area - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

If you need to use the bathroom be sure to hold your breath. To me the condition of the bathroom tells you a lot about a business, especially a restaurant. ​With so many pizza options in your community I would consider other options. read more

Came in for a quick bite and was promptly greeted by KC and Prius. They both had a wonderful attitude and their people skills were great. Will definitely be visiting this location again. A+ read more

We popped in for a quick bite. The pizza place is more of a Domino/Pizza Hut type of restaurant. You order at the counter and then there is seating off to the side. The clerk that helped us was so incredibly nice. There were four of us, and we each ordered our own meal which was served quickly. We ordered mozzarella sticks that came out just lukewarm and the marinara sauce was ice cold straight out of the refrigerator. We asked our server to please take it back and warm it up which he did and reserved everything piping hot. Pizza was pretty good as we got the personal, which we could choose three toppings for. We also ordered the churro bites and they were delicious. For the food coming out Luke warm the server brought over a complementary cookie, which was so yummy. Overall good spot for a quick pizza, but don't expect Italian style. This is American style fare. read more

See all

Absolutely wonderful people who own and run this place. We have never had a bad order in our many years of ordering from them.

Clean restaurant, Courteous staff, delicious pizza and salad. Loved it! Ate the lunch pizza buffet on Labor Day holiday. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

Do the pepperonis come out of the employees paycheck? They used cover the pizza in pepperonis as advertised in their pictures. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Barely any pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

This location of Mountain Mikes is consistently delicious. My order is always correct and the service is always good.

We absolutely love this Mountain Mike's! Ever since my husband and I first came here, the place has been very clean, with outstanding personal service which always leads us to have a nice welcoming evening read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - The beautiful Everest - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

Best kept secret is their Half Dome sandwich with 3 toppings you pick and an order of the Garlic Knots (6). For one person it gives me 2 filling meals. Forget the pizza - this is the best! read more

On our way to Mountain Mike's we passed very crowded In and Out and McDonald's burgers. MM had a brisk business but wasn't too busy. We always have the salad bar and that's the focus of this review. The MM salad bar is the best. It offers lots of different salad add-ons that are kept stocked and fresh. The lettuce is so crisp and soooo fresh, based on Romaine lettuce rather than iceberg. If you're going for the full pizza buffet, the pizza selection is ample and well-stocked. The staff is very friendly and efficient. And lastly, the bathrooms are super clean. We actually look forward to a quick lunch at MM on our frequent trips between the valley and north coast. read more

Great pizza and customer service at this establishment highly recommend the new owners seem like good people

I ordered the large mushroom pizza. I did not care for the crust as was too thick and their sauce was just tomato paste with no taste of herbs like oregano. The mushrooms were plentiful but will not be buying another pizza here. read more

Lost my receipt so can't remember who helped us. That being said, after getting effed by airlines and deciding to drive home, we stopped here on a Sunday night so that we could have some road fuel. The staff was super nice and helpful. The food was delicious. Got us home on the 900 mile drive. read more

We have had many birthday parties here. They have a good size room where you can have 20 people comfortably. We've also got great discounts from the manager for the parties we have here. I would highly recommend them for your next celebration! read more

We've ordered pizza from Mountain Mike's a few times and each time has been a great experience. I customize my pizza to be thin crust with light cheese, extra sauce, and well done. They follow my annoying requests and the pizza comes out just the way I like it. My boyfriend always gets pepperoni and is never disappointed. The people who work there are also always friendly and welcoming. We walk away from picking up our pizza commenting on "how nice the person is" who grabs us our pizza. Mountain Mike's has been a consistent and quick dinner that hits the spot. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Small thin crust cheese pizza (requested well done) - so good! - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Mountain Mike's Pizza is amazing! Their Everest Pizza is our favorite. Absolutely huge and very delicious. They also make our pizza extra crispy by request, as we prefer it that way. read more

The pizza and service was amazing. We r visiting from Virginia and we will be back here before we head home.

This location is great! Amazing friendly, helpful staff. Super clean including bathroom smelled nice and was super clean. I got the bbq at the ranch pizza. Honestly I am 33 years old and this was one of the best pizzas I have ever had! read more

Food is always correct, staff, especially closing staff is friendly. Went to the mountain mikes in Rohnert park and didn't realize how exceptional this place is. read more

Soooo good! My first time getting mountain mikes and we got a Everest. I asked for crispy and added garlic. It was delicious!!! Crust was perfectly cooked and lots of toppings. We will be back! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Everest add garlic The Everest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

Not a bad spot for pizza ... Grabbed 3 large and I paid $50.. If I planned better I could have looked up better coupons.. I got 1 speciality combo and 2 Pepperoni.. It fed 16 people.. Flavor : it's nothing mind blowing or unusual.. Which is a good thing if you're looking for consistency.. service- mine is a take out.. But I was a bit disappointed when I asked for cheese and peppers I was only given enough for 6 people .. Or a box of pizza .. No offer of places or napkins.. I guess I have to ask instead of being asked. Counter lady was nice though. Will I come back? read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Take advantage of the coupons.. It's a bit steep for pizza.. - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

Pizza delivery is good.. Pizza arrived hot and fresh. Pizzas are pricey but worth it! Tons of toppings. A medium feeds 3 adults quite adequately. Hubby enjoys the veggiemore and the robbers roost. I find the cheese is perfect for what I want. Nice thick crust. Thin available but I prefer the standard crust. The seasoned wings are quite tasty. read more

Shout out to Charles for making my order easy and pleasant. Needed 4 pies delivered at the time they open so we called a couple days in advance to ask if that was possible and Charles said no problem. He came in early so we could have pizza for my daughter's 1st bday party. Very satisfied! Thanks Charles and MM team! read more

I am a head basketball coach of Amador High School and brought my whole program 50 people to Petaluma to play a game. The great people of Mountain Mikes were so hospitable and helped us have a great lunch as a program. They opened up a lunch buffet on a day where it wasn't the norm and created an environment that made us feel at home. Great people, great food, great experience = new team members Amador High school Basketball thanks mountain mikes read more

Plenty of service not "loitering"! Where's my pizza I'll take a sip of Stella Artois when bring me a menu I know I'll wait I've waited long enough for my goddamn pizza. I Veggie Pizzas read more

Awesome--every time! Our goto for pizza every month. Consistently delicious and the staff is always so friendly and helpful!

Wow this location has gone downhill! What a shame. Customer service is lacking, perhaps some more training would help. The young man working the phones on Labor Day could use a few more training days. I guess we'll be driving to novato mountain mikes from now on. Do better Petaluma MM :( read more

Awesome pizza and great experience. Everything you look for in a pizza! Will definitely order here again.

First thing I did when I enttered was use the bathroom to see if it was safe to eat at, I was blown away by how clean the bathroom Was, no etched glass, graffiti was covered/removed, and important to me, the water you use to wash your hands ran long eeNough for an employee to actually wash their hands before turning off. After that I asked for their least popular item, they said then I wanted the garlic Tuscan. 15 minutes later I was served a piping hot pizza with rich sausage and sundries tomato's. I finished my meal feeling full with food to spare. My meal was worth the price and worth the calories, I'd suggest trying it out if you're in the mood for pizza, even more so if you feel like trying savory sausage savory tomato's, fresh green onions, and bits of minced garlic. read more

I feel they should have a higher rating on yelp. Their pizzas taste amazing they clearly use really good ingredients read more

Don't order delivery. Great pepperoni pizza. Terrible delivery time. I don't think they could be on time, ever. Try being on time and not apologizing for being constantly late with your deliveries. read more

Mt Mikes food and customer service are great, no doubt about it! But last time we ordered pizza there, my son found what it seemed to be a small cockroach underneath the pepperoni slice on his pizza slice. He thought it was a cricket. We had guests that day and I was so embarrassed about the food that I have decided to not come back here anymore, even though the pizzas are great but I am not sure about the cleanliness of this place! read more

House sitting and decided to order some pizza for delivery. BEST MT MIKE's PIZZA EVER!!!!!! Thank you for making my first night in Petaluma so perfect!! read more

Got here at 1:00. Most tables are empty with garbage on them. The person in front of me is yelling into the back to get service. Ok. I got the pizza and salad bar. Wonder over after clearing a spot on a dirty table to find that most of the salad spots were empty or close to it. Then to find 2 what looked like hours old pizza. I asked when more salad and pizza would be put out and was told no more would be made because the lunch closed in 30 minutes. I asked for a refund and was told no because I had eaten some food already. looks like I should have read reviews before coming in. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

My dry cleaner is down the way, and when I go over lunch to pick up my dry cleaning, craving some pizza. I stop here. I usually get a small personal pizza, versus doing their buffet. Their buffet is okay, at a pretty good value for ~$8 (doesn't include soda fyi), but I rather pay ~$6 for a personal pizza to my liking. I usually have to wait 10 minutes for my pizza, but they are super nice and friendly bringing the pizza right to my table. The pizza lands in front of me, coming out fresh and pretty tasty. This place does not have amazing pizza (I am a foodie though, and have pizza around the world, so side note), but decent pizza. For the location, price, freshness of pizza and the friendliness of the staff, it is worth the trip. read more

This place needs a clean up!!! The pizza was fair but, eating in here was disappointing... I order a pizza and decided to eat there and as I walked towards the tables they had looked like they had not been wiped down...Super unsanitary!!!!!! read more

I want to thank Sunny Singh, owner of Mountain Mike's Pizza for allowing us to use their private guest room for our meeting tonight. With no notice another restaurant cancelled on us and we had to move our meeting. We contacted Sunny and he helped us out. AJ, the general manager, and his staff were very helpful. read more