Waiter was great!! Super kind. We ordered the shrimp bruschetta to start and it was delicious. I ordered the linguini with white clam sauce. The second that dish came out of the kitchen I could smell it. I took one bite and it tasted like the clams were bought 6 months ago. I explained this to the waiter. And was visibly sick. I asked for a different dish, because this was making me sick and he was happy to bring me one. We were still charged for the dish that made me sick. My boyfriend and I watched the waiter talk to the manager, pleading to take it off the bill, but she refused. Don't go here. The management does not care about your health. read more

Love the wait staff and the food. I've become a regular here because every time I come it's 10/10

My husband and I went to try out Mozzarella. Elmer was a very attentive waiter, all the staff appeared friendly. The food was delicious. We had mozzarella sticks of course they aren't your average size mozzarella stick the were large and we have the stuffed mushrooms as appetizers. I had the Philly Cheesesteak which was delicious and my husband had the salmon which was great. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

Get the Rhode Island calamari and the sticks. Love their salads. Pizzas were fine, but not memorable. Looking forward to trying their pastas. The pear chicken is a delicious thanksgiving-esqe meal that was very unique! Cute and small dining room, but we've never had to wait long for a table. read more

Came here on a Friday night. It was 5 of us and were sat right away outside. It was a nice chill night and the servers made sure he had two heat lamps to keep us warm. The layout of their outside is very homey and the service was top notch and quick. This place is byob (heavy liquor) and they have a store across the street very Convenient. We ordered the mozzarella sticks ( to die for and that cheese pull was crazy) and the wings and it was nice and crispy. For main entires we had pasta dishes and a pizza. The pizza was nice and soft with a crunch. Highly recommend this place. Good for date night or night out with friends. Will be coming back soon. read more

See all

My brother took my mother and I for an early Mother's Day lunch to this place. It's a small pizzeria with a seating area. The esthetic is pretty awesome. I would describe it as industrial and rustic. The tables are small, that I didn't like. They are screwed to the floor, interesting. The bathroom is the prettiest I've ever seen in a restaurant. The floor tile was beautiful and the toilet was awesome looking. Service was fine. I have this thing with a waiter or waitress constantly coming to the table, removing plates or asking if anything is needed. It was a bit annoying. I digress. We did wait a while for our food but we figured it made as ordered. I had the penne alla vodka with chicken parmesan which was good. My mother had the chicken fettuccine alfredo which was so delicious. I wish I had gotten that. My brother had the short rib mozzarella sticks which were ok. It wasn't filled much and was expensive. The green sauce with it was delicious. He also had the penne alla vodka. We also had calamari which was good. For desert I had the creme brulee which was delicious. Overall, everything was great. We will definitely return. I highly recommend it. Social distancing seemed to be enforced, we were the 1st of three tables there so we were apart. Hand sanitizer was available as you walked in and staff wore masks. read more

See all

Great food at reasonable prices. Everything tasted fresh. Only downside was that it took a while for our food to come out (note this was a Saturday night, and restaurants are understandably busy) Luckily it was worth the wait! read more

See all

Mozzarella sticks, Fried calamari, parmesan garlic wings. The entrees were huge you can definitely split between two people or have lunch for next day. Chicken parmigiana, fettuccine chicken Alfredo, shrimp scampi, all so yummy. Definitely a place to go to if you are hungry and looking for a great Italian meal. We will definitely try the pizza and salads our next visit. Everything was sooo good! read more

While we very much enjoyed the food and our server Trevor was very good I have one complaint. I don't like when restaurants try to "nickel and dime" you with hidden charges. My wife and I ordered two appetizers to start, an Arugula and Pear salad and a Parmesan risotto. We were asked if we wanted the salad split into two plates. We said yes. We also brought a bottle of wine with us as the restaurant has no liquor license. We both had pasta as our main courses and it was quite good. However when we got the check I discovered that we were charged $3 extra for splitting the salad onto two plates and we were charged a $5 "liquor fee", both in my opinion ridiculous. When you add the tax and tip onto those "up charges" we ended up paying $10 more for the meal than we should have. We were never informed in advance and if it is on their menu somewhere it was not evident since we had to scan a QR code to get the menu and read it on our phones. As much as I enjoyed the food I would find it difficult to go back because of their business practices. read more

Hands down, the pizza here has to be one of the best I've had in 2019! The place is spotless and beautifully decorated(on trend yet classic), the staff friendly and the food...so far so great! I look forward to coming back and bringing friends and trying more of the menu in the dining room, as well as future takeout. read more

Mozzarella - Extra cheese and pepperoni...delish! - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

Nice pizza options! Love the square grandma pizza, and like that they make smaller specialty pizzas like white pizza. If you're willing to pick it up, the prices on their website are considerably cheaper than Grubhub. Haven't eaten inside for some time (too long!), but last time we ate the menu was strong and the food delicious. read more

not too good and helping customer service guys, they kind rude, specially they treat uber, doordash and grubhub driver not in a good manner.

The food... Fantastic! Wild Mushroom Ravioli, absolutely delicious. I also had a Sweet Potato Corn Chowder with Jalepenos. Very good. The 3 stars stems from the the noisy atmosphere and cramped seating arrangement. The service is also suspect. A waitress brought our check and then the waiter who took our order asked if we would like to have dessert... I would go back for the food but it would be take out. read more

Mozzarella - Sweet Potato Corn Chowder with Jalapenos - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Place is definitely a spot where you wouldn't think the food would be so good but it is. Found this spot from a video online and ordered the mozzarella sticks which were definitely wayyy different from others I have but I'm a good way. The mussels were good and my dinner the penne with grilled chicken was super tasty and huge portions. read more

The food was exceptional. I had the nights special, a Sea Bream and mixed seafood medley with a mushroom base sauce over risotto. It was purely magical. read more

4 Stars for the great reviews and menu selections, but these prices are a bit high. $17.50 for a Cheesesteak??? Please tell me it's phenomenal and extremely worth it. read more

Food was great, service was great, ambiance was great; just a really nice spot in one my favorite villages. I wish they served alcohol but frankly it doesn't take away from the overall experience here. It's also BYOB so we just bought our own drinks from a spot next door. If you're in South Orange make sure you check this place out. read more

Mozzarella - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Bought honey garlic brussel sprouts. They were good. Declined other items because oddly pork was missing as an option but offered beef alternatives. ??? read more

A few of my friends and I walked in to be seated at a table and the waiter seated us.. soon after the waiter came back to take our order, we were still having a bit trouble deciding what we wanted and the WAITER was no help on helping us Decide, we also wanted to get to go boxes for our food while he was taking our order in the anticipation that we were going to leave a little sooner and he refused to do that and said " I cannot take your order at the table you would need to order at the front then" he refused to take our order at the table even after we told him we wanted to dine in. Really terrible experience . read more

Very good new home-neighbour family restaurant in the SO hood ... Has been improving in all four cardinal food aspects. Daily menus Chef Specials and great location. Easy walking parking and next door a good wine store. Owner. Chef and staff are friendly and improve a lot since opening Good for a party of 6 or more because have a modular tables and seating. Fun place for Milleniums looking for a good food and wine! C. read more

People who are making the food are wearing their masks below their noses. When I mentioned it they defended themselves saying they were wearing masks. Bad practice. Left and not going back. read more

First time trying the new Mozzarella on Valley Street in So. Orange. Everything was delicious from the House & Caesar salads to the abundant wings! One of us had the Rigatoni Bolognese and one had the Spaghetti with 3 Perfectly season & cooked meatballs! Their marinara sauce is mild and not real spicy or unusual! Next time we'll try their pizza. It looked very tasty on the next table over! read more

Best mozzarella sticks!! It's so good and definitely cheese pull worthy , you can definitely tell it's homemade!!

Decided to try a new local place for a birthday dinner. Did not disappoint! Everyone in our group loved their meals, from pizza to salads. We also had mozzarella sticks and cannolis - both were some of the best we've ever had! Our waiter was very friendly as were other staff members. Really great experience overall! read more

Mozzarella - Best mozzarella sticks ever! - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Fantastic meal tonight at Mozzarella. Food was great. Roasted beet, spinach & goat cheese salad, wild mushroom ravioli, shrimp and squid ink pasta special. Delicious. Staff wonderful, pleasant, and very attentive. Also love the vibe in the place, great look and feel. Great to have in MAPSO. read more

I decided to do take out and had passed Mozzarella a few times so I decided to check it out. I ordered the pesto pizza, the sea bass dinner and a side of risotto. First of all, they delivered sooner than estimated which was a huge plus. I had a slice of pizza as an appetizer, and it was so fresh and tasty. The sea bass was so delicious, as where the veggies. The portion was so large I had half one night and heated the leftovers for a second night. The fish and vegetables were so well seasoned and tasty. The risotto was also delicious and plentiful. I can't wait to try the salmon next time, 'cause I definitely will be ordering again! The cost was so reasonable, especially given the quality and amount of food. read more

I went here for my birthday on Sunday and I can not say enough good things about this place. My friends and I were seated right away. The waitress was very friendly and brought out some water and bread with marinara sauce which was delish. We ordered the eggplant parm sandwich, shrimp parm and chicken parm sandwich, the white pizza bianca and some mozzarella sticks. Everythinv was fresh and delicious. I have zero complaints and will most definitely be taking that hour drive to get that pizza again. It's definitely a must try read more

Was in the area looking for a quick lunch so I popped in. The place is spotless! Packed with high school kids (all well behaved). Bathroom, super clean! So why only 2 stars, I ordered a slice of margarita pizza and a bottle of water. Food came up very quick but as soon as I took a bite I realized why, it was ice cold!! I do not like to return food especially after taking a bite out of it and didn't want it to go to waste so I ate my ice cold pizza. Glad I don't live in the area cause I'd have to find a new pizza place. read more

DELICIOUS!!!!! DELICIOUS!!!! DELICIOUS!!!! I am very pleased with the food and service at Mozzarella. Everything was fresh and well seasoned. I will definitely be a returning customer and highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Honestly I can't believe the 5 star reviews for this place. Pizza would be the best ever if you lived in Utah but in Jersey? Please. Cramped space overcrowded on a Friday made for a miserable dining experience. Caprese salad has store mozzarella (ironic, huh?). Pizza was ok but in maplewood you have so many other choices read more

1st time here. Took hubby for his birthday. Went around 3pm on a Sunday. Empty which was perfect. Its tight in there as far as table set up. New York vibes with decor. Clean & bathroom clean also. Waiters were nice. Food delicious & fresh. Served fast. We ordered Vodka pizza with chicken & spinach, garlic knots super soft and fresh with olive oil and fresh garlic on top, mussels with tasty sauce & fresh garlic which were the softest, freshest I ever had!! Not tough or chewy at all !! Hubby also had chicken Alfredo. Nice size bowl and nice size large pizza, everything was hot!! Cucumber Water was nice. Affordable for 3 people. Thank you for hubby free red velvet birthday slice!! Good experience, would recommend. read more

See all

Literally the best pizza ever. My favorite pizza spot in Jersey. The Grandmas pizza is too good for words.

Ordered from here a few times online for takeout- sounds like that might be a better option than calling. I've only had their salad, pizza, and chicken balsamico wrap. I really like the wrap and the side salads have been really good & fresh. Pizza is also pretty good. read more

New facility. Excellent food! And Excellent service!!! This place is great. Restrooms are very clean and the servers are wat RNA's and grow friendly. Best place I e eaten at in this town! read more

The atmosphere was a fresh industrial look and feel and the food was much better than anticipated. The mozzarella stixs are a 10. Our table had a little of everything; pasta, fish and sandwiches and everything was great. Mozzarella is a welcome addition to South Orange. read more

Short version? This place rocks. Now for the details. My friends and I ate here on a Thursday night. Our server was Genese, and I felt like a guest eating in someone's home she took such good care of us. She was friendly, polite, and knowledgeable. Everything was delicious. My dinner companion, who eats a plant-based diet and is not on Yelp, gave me permission to quote her and says it best: "Please let folks know that the cauliflower pizza crust is so good it doesn't even make sense. It's completely illogical that it can taste like some of the best thin crust pizza I've ever had, but it's mainly made of cruciferous vegetables. Like, what? You could trick people. You could just not tell them it's cauliflower and they'd call you a liar when you finally revealed the truth. Mind boggling. Good pizza was one of the many things I've missed since cutting out wheat. They had it only as a special that day, but I'm praying they add it to their regular menu so I can run up in there and slam cauliflower crust pizza on the regular. Just cram it down my gullet after appropriately savoring it first. I'll probably go back there at some point and harangue them in person as well if it's not a permanent fixture." Enough said. read more

Needs to decide if it's a restaurant/takeout place or a slice place. Grandma pie was good but our table in front of the door that opened every minute was not. Pasta was okay. They don't take reservations but held a table for another group? Lots to choose from in Jersey, so..... read more

My husband decided to check out since we live in town, bad decision. We are still hungry leaving, how does that happen? We ordered mussels, their house meatballs, wings & their ginger calamari (didn't taste no ginger). We are foodies so we know good food. The service was fine, just the food was not up to par. We leave to go somewhere else (Village Trattoria) to eat. This restaurant is kid friendly which is a plus. We was wondering how come food was still on people's plates as usually people take doggie bags when leaving. read more

The hospitality is out of this world. The crew made sure we were satisfied with everything and I absolutely loved it. The service was quick too and their mozzarella sticks were 10/10!! The restaurant itself is beautiful. The only reason I give it 4 stars is because the alfredo fettuccine was a little low on salt but, granted, I like to over season my food. But I would still gladly recommend! read more

35 mins to get a chicken parmigiana sandwich to go during lunch when there are only 3 other customers in the store is simply not good enough. I had to eventually leave due to other commitments and comeback to get the get the cold sandwich later. Sandwich was small but tasty, side salad was in a container lines with wax paper which seemed strange. I hope this improves, as the manager and staff were nice and apologetic but that didn't fix the problem. read more