This place doesn't fit it's exterior! It looks like a regular pizza shop, but step inside, and it is anything but regular! From the first greeting, to the service (Chris), tons of beer on tap (so many local beers!), tasty pasta dishes, and the pizza is yum-azing! They even offer beautiful salads! The place is clean.. Even the restrooms. Not one complaint from us.. After repeated visits! read more

The pizza we ordered resembled a NY style pie with a wood-fried aesthetic but overall was bland from the crust all the way to the cheese the only salt on the whole pizza was in the pepperoni I think this is the only time in my life I have put salt on my pizza also froze my balls off in the section I was seated. read more

Tried calling in a take out order for Friday at 5:00. Answering machine said they were not taking orders due to the heavy volume. Pizza took 28 minutes from when the waitress left our table. Atm not working. Waitress never checked on us or even acknowledged the delay in service. Pizza was ok, lots of crust. Garlic sauce would be a good offering a la papa johns. Sly Fox cask on draft was a hit. Ceasar salad was only avg and skimpy. Really disappointed to only give two stars to an otherwise popular local establishment. read more

Wonderful casual place to relax and enjoy delicious pizza and craft beers with family and/or friends. Lots of menu choices but I love the pizza so much, I haven't tried anything else yet. There are 15 or so tables and a small bar. They have a big take out business. Wait staff very friendly. Cash only. An ATM is available. read more

I was very unimpressed with Mr. P's. I was excite to try this place after hearing the ads and reading the reviews. With that being said I was dissapointed. The pizza was okay. Nothing special and nothing I am looking forward to eating again. I would eat it again but I'm definitely not rushing to do so anytime. They do have a great beer selection, however you pay for.it $6 for a draft. Overall, was was a mediocre meal. Not bad but there are definitely better options for pizza in the area. read more

Waited 50 minutes for my small pizza which never came - even though the server kept saying it was on the way. By the time my husband finished his sandwich and fries I decided to leave without ever seeing my pizza. Unacceptable- especially since I ordered the special pizza thinking that would be quick- what a joke! read more

Let's start with the good things about Mr. P. They have a huge selection of local craft beers and will let you sample them before you buy. As a showcase for local beers, this place is awesome, and the beer is fantastic. The Natural Potato Chips ($2) are lightly seasoned with Old Bay and are both tasty and a great bargain. The Sweet Potato Fries ($5) are clearly machine cut and frozen, but are served in generous quantities and perfectly crisped. If you go to this place for beer and fries/appetizers, you can't go wrong. The chicken wings are also crispy and well executed. 5-stars for this part of the menu. The food is another matter entirely. When it comes to sandwiches, if you use good bread, it doesn't matter what you put on it, it will taste good. By the same token, start with stale or flavorless bread and there's nothing you can do to make the sandwich taste good. The same principle applies to pizzas. If the crust is good, it doesn't matter what you put on it, the pizza is going to be delicious. If the crust isn't good, there no way to make it taste good. The pizza crust at Mr. P is not good. The wood firing helps a little, but it's fundamentally an inferior crust. Consequently, the pizzas are not good. Some reviewers have complained about the marinara sauce used on the pizzas. I couldn't get my palate to consider this, because there's no point in looking beyond the crust (see above). Knowing that I didn't like the pizza, on a subsequent visit I ordered Pasta with Sausage ($13) and got a Greek salad to go with it. Now I can talk about the marinara: it was watery and bland, and the sausage lacked personality. A good Italian sausage is loaded with fennel seeds and bursting with flavor -- this was not that sausage. The salad was a salad, but the dressing just didn't taste good. I regretted dumping it on the salad before tasting it. The food at this place put in a solid 1-star performance, for an average of 3-stars. Come for the beer and enjoy a few appetizers, but avoid the pizza and pasta if you have a discerning palate. read more

Went tonight, first time trying. Service was spot on , we ordered two pies sauce was tasty and toppings we're good my one complaint is the dough was undercooked not crispy next time I'll ask for extra crispy . read more

We vacation in Lewes every year and have driven by Mr. P's and just never thought to stop in. A few locals highly recommended it, so we decided to give it a try- and saw their motto right on their website: "We chose Quality over quantity," First off, getting pizza from this place is somewhat of a quest. Last year we tried, we were told that they couldn't accept any more orders that night because they only have one wood-fired oven. We understood and for a year waited to give it a go, and we called on Friday night, ordered a pizza and calzone, and got a pick-up time that was two hours out. This was okay, and when I went to pick-up, it was ready and took it home. Once we got back to the house we flipped the box and quickly found disappointment. As you look at the pictures, it is difficult to tell the calzone was actually a calzone; it looked like they were running late and used a torch on the poor thing. The crust of the pizza was black. The kids were hungry, so we gave it a try, thinking this might just look worse than it tasted...but no, this stuff tasted like burnt toast. So I did what I think anyone would do, I called Mr. P to understand if this was up to "quality" standards. Well here's the rub --- they don't pick up when they are busy. Instead, you get a voicemail message from Mr. P telling you (at length) about their quality vs. the other guys, why it takes so long to make a pizza, rules of ordering etc. So when you have a legitimate question on the "quality" of the product they just sold you, they essentially ignore the phone. I told the friendly voicemail about the issue, and asked for a call, as I was not going to make the long drive back. Two days later, and NO call! So at his point I am working with the assumption that the "well-done, extra crispy" IS the norm at Mr. P's. The person working the oven that slid the burnt thing it in the box obviously thought it "quality." I have had wood-fired pizza at other restaurants, and you don't have to burn it just because you can. It is more difficult to cook the pizza than a traditional oven, but this is their specialty. I would expect after 17 years, they would have worked these types of kinks out. My sense is that they have built the business around them, and not the customer. If you have a problem when they are busy, you need to drive to Mr. P's. If you need to use a credit card, you will need to go find cash (they only accept cash.) You want to order a slice of pizza, you need to be in by 3:01. This just isn't a great customer experience at any level- they have made it all about them. My advice to those looking for pizza, go with someone that has a business model that revolves around the customer. That night Grottos came to our rescue, always consistent and prompt; there are many other quality pizza places in the area. We learned our lesson and will keep driving past Mr. P's next year; if this is what they mean by Quality pizza, we will chose quantity pizza every day of the week. read more

See all

Good pizza when they cook it long enough. Otherwise the crust is doughy and unappetizing. Interesting beers on tap but overpriced. These are mostly local craft brews and should not cost $6 and $7 each. And the cash only policy is very annoying. Try Vinnys in Millsboro. read more

Ever had narcotics? Eat this pizza and you will be begging for more before the pie is even over. Seriously, go here if you feel like gorging yourself with delicious golden brown crusts, fresh and sweet tomato sauce, and the best toppings you'll ever have for miles, because this is the place to do that kind of thing. The pizzas are available in a couple of different sizes starting with a small four slice pizza. Same type of place as Grotto Pizza if you ever eating there, but has a much less of a "chain-restaurant" feel to it. Find them on Facebook. read more

Some of the best wood-fired brick hearth pizza I've had, and I love my pizza! Their 'Pizza Alla Puttanesca with Goat Cheese', which included tomato sauce, shredded whole milk mozzarella, artichokes, capers, black olives, fresh garlic and goat cheese is as good as it gets. Some people refer to this as Greek pizza. Whatever you want to call it, it is definitely in my top 5 pizzas of all time! read more

OMG. The service, pizza, and beer were all great. Really enjoyed the relaxed atmosphere and the pizza was prepared and cooked in the wood fired over perfectly. May be back tomorrow to try the cheese steak subs. read more

Food is great but they can't handle being "busy". Went inside to place a carry out order. Even though there was hardly a crowd inside they said they wouldn't make the pizza for a few hours. This has happened before. Unfortunately I think I'm done trying to eat here. It's great but they don't answer the phones and I'm done showing up to be told they won't make pizza. Strange business model. Please get another oven! read more

Ended up here as a result of a billboard! When we arrived there was a sign that said " cash only, ATM inside". We left and went to the bank to get cash! So happy we returned! The pizza was amazing! We ordered a pepperoni and a shrimp and pesto pizza. Both were excellent! We also ordered a Caesar salad that came with shredded mozzarella cheese on top, I thought this was very strange but the dressing made up for the lack of Parmesan cheese! I would have never expected this little pizza joint to be so yummy, but we will certainly return! read more

Mr P's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

Nice stop at the end of civilization but the people of #LewesDE are so nice. I got two slices and a Coke, was going to use my company AMEX because I don't carry cash for work, nope cash only. Amber the hostess says, "What changes got?" I say, "$4 bucks!" She says "Done!" How cool is that! Come get your Woodford Pizza here at Mr. P's on your way to the Delaware beaches. read more

Their pizza oven is wood fired. Everything on the menu is amazing, including the salads. I have been going there for a few years now, the friendly staff knows me by name. read more

Terrific wood fired pizza, great selection of craft beers and friendly staff. One of our favorite spots! Cash only, atm on site. Worth checking out! read more

Husband and I ate here for the first time today. We've been looking for a great pizza place -- and we found it. The pizza crust has great flavor and the sauce and cheese profile is perfect!! Cooked in a 100% wood fire over. A must go to place in Lewes. read more

Pizza was great and with 19 craft beer s on tap, and friendly service, I'm coming back for more!

First thing to know is you need cash because that is all they accept! However they have an ATM machine inside the store. The pizza is good the serves is great and they cater to locals. You can also have a beer with your pizza too......I have not had anything other than pizza so I am not sure how the other Italian food is, hold that the calzone was good too! read more

Delicious pizza and very friendly service. A nice place to take the family to. It is a little dark inside but the place is very clean.

Delicious pizza, obviously wood fired, smoky, but not overwhelmingly so, tasty crust, fresh ingredients. Prices commensurate with the high quality. Beer prices reasonable too. The style of pie, despite the wood oven, is not the typical cracker thin crust and sparing toppings typically found, the pie seems halfway between gas oven Jersey and Neapolitan. Good stuff. Cash only policy sucks, but we'll return anyway. read more

Amazing Pizza! We got the Carnivores Dream and it was just that! You can taste every meat and ingredient almost individually! Nice crispy crust, perfect! Friendly atmosphere and great service staff! We WILL be back! I highly recommend Mr. P Pizza & Pasta when in this wonderful harbor town of Lewes, Delaware! read more

Delicious pizza, with incredible crust, wonderful craft beer selection and great service. We didn't wait long for our order and although you have to pay cash, they have an ATM so it's no big deal. We will be back when we visit Delaware beaches! I had to come and edit my review because of the incredible staff at Mr. P that solidified that not only would we be back, but we would tell everyone we knew about this great place! 24 hours after arriving back home in Philadelphia, I had realized I had left my purse in the restaurant. In my distress, I immediately called the restaurant to see if the purse was still there. As soon as Rick picked up the phone, he reassured me the purse was there and that he would next day mail the purse to us and save us the 6 hour drive there and back. I just received my purse, as promised 24 hours later. There are still good people in this world and Rick and the staff at Mr. Ps are among those! We are forever grateful for the service, extra mile and generosity this restaurant showed us. They saved us time, multiple headaches in replacing everything in my wallet, and stress over the situation. We are forever thankful and will most certainly come back! If you are in Lewes you must go to Mr. P Pizza! read more

fabulous atomsphere, great staff, generous wine pour, out-of-this-world pizza. Just love it!

Okay. So let me start off with the pizza is good.. but the service was TERRIBLE! I dont know if its because we was the only black people but the waiter NEVER checked on us and he never brought the check.. we had to go up and pay. Honestly im not supporting this place. read more

Delicious. Get it extra well done, nice and crispy. Get there early, otherwise the wait will be long. Long wait and crowded means it's worth the visit! Yum read more

Not a bad slice of pizza... dough was crisp and the cheese was good quality... inside is nice... went in on a off peak time but it looks like it can get packed... ambiance is typical of a family pizzeria... If you're hungry and on the ferry try holding off until you get here or grab a pie for the trip, it is 1000 times better than the ferry food... enjoy oh Cash only!!! but there an ATM.. read more

My wife and I retired to Lewes in 2011. Originally from North Jersey. We rescinded ourselves that we wouldn't find a local pizza to our liking. We were wrong. Mr. P's is one of several(?) places with a woodfired oven. The smoky taste coupled with the fresh ingredients keeps us coming back. read more

Great artisan pizza. They also have 17 micro brews on tap. We have never had a bad pizza here. Remember it is cash only!

Really great pizza! A little expensive but our pizza was wonderful! Waitress was super good! Will definitely be back!

Good pizza, good cheese, good sauce. The oven floor was not hot enough to get the real good crunchy bottom. Too skimpy on the fresh bazil. CASH ONLY PLACE... I usually get a little more smokey notes on wood fired pizza, not this one. read more

I live in Lewes and eat at most of the restaurants here and in Rehoboth regularly. Without doubt, Mr. P has the best pizza in the area. For one thing, the restaurant has an Italian, wood-fired oven -- by far the best way to make pizza. For another, the fellow who makes the pizzas has been there for as long as the place has been open -- almost ten years by now -- even though the restaurant itself has changed hands. I especially recommend the #2 pizza for pepperoni lovers. But really, *all* of the pizzas are outstanding. The house salad is large and very good as well. I don't recommend the pasta dishes particularly -- stick with the house specialty: the best pizza in the Lewes - Rehoboth area. Service is fine -- this place is the opposite of fancy. Prices are very reasonable -- but bring cash; they stopped taking cards recently. Hmmm, I might go there tonight! read more

Found this from an article in a Delawre Magazine while waiting for doctor's visit with my elderly mother.......great pizza. Small, informal pizza place with good firewood cooked pizza. Cash only business read more

Went to Mr p yesterday for lunch to get some good pizza. Not very impressed and kind of expensive. . I prefer a thin crunchy crust but what I got was kind of spongy. . Also strange that they do not take credit cards and also do not do call ahead. Wood burning stove was nice but very limited in capacity. . Could only handle two xl pizza at time. So if you are in vacation and feel like sitting and waiting for some spongy pizza you can go to Mr ps. Otherwise I would do to grotto. read more

Mr P's has very good pizza made in a real wood-fired oven. They don't take credit cards. Get over it. Bring cash. They're smarter than the rest of us. I wish I didn't tale cc's at my business. I just eat the pizza and very Sussex County maybe the best. Salads are good and fresh. Service is steady to excellent jo matter the season. read more

I don't ever write reviews on here but I was so upset after we left here I just had to. We are locals in Lewes and have been here many times. We love the food and it's a great local spot. However recently we had a bad experience that ruined it for us. We walked in with a baby on a busy night. Now I understand it's busy and we would have to wait for a seat. We were going to order take out but wanted to sit down and have an appetizer and beer while we waited for it. We told the guy and girl at the front and they said "yeah... but you have a baby". Oddly enough, we are aware we have a baby. As we turned around the young waitress gave us a rude smirk like why are we here with a baby. Needless to say we were treated very rudely by high school kids working because we had a baby. We emailed the owner but never heard back. Unfortunately we will probably not be back. This place got 2 stars because the food is good but they really need to train their staff better. read more

Good meal! When eating out with my family, it is hard to get a good all around meal. We have a food critic that has high expectations, a vegan and a gluten free eater all in the same party. Not to mention, I am from NY and spent a lot of time in Chicago, and consider myself a pizza snob. Everyone was very impressed. The dough is very unique. Similar to NY style but is also thicker and doughy, but has great texture. Decent sauce and toppings made for a good pie! My wife who is gluten free had the gluten free pizza and was also impressed. Gluten free pizza is generally an after thought a most who try it don't execute it very well. I even tried it and thought it was very good! All around good meal. I have found that most of the great food in Rehoboth Beach is closer to Lewes and the less commercialized popular tourist areas. A must try! read more

Great pizza, friendly staff. Cold micro beer on tap. Fun to watch them bake the pizzas in the wood oven. You can't call in an order when they are busy, but you can go there place an order and have a beer while you wait. Best pizza in the area in my opinion. read more