Best pizza I've ever had in my life, it was like a bite of heaven. I wish I could come back to CT just for this pizza.

I was in town and the group wanted something to eat and they decided on this little spot because it had great reviews. Since this place had a tie in with the movie Mystic Pizza, they had the movie running in the place which was really nice. However, I never saw the movie and neither of my group did either. Just to be fair in this review, My group had already had been seated and ordered by the time I came in. Parking is a bear. I found the atmosphere very comforting with families having a great time talking and enjoying meals. Their was a line for people to get in which is always a good sign. My table had ordered pizza, wings, drinks. Since I came late I ordered a Salad and a bowl of clam chowder. When the pizza came it was a good size pizza one was a meat lovers and the other was pepperoni. By the time I got my order they had almost killed the first pizza and the meat lovers was going down for the count. I was able to get two slices but I had to hit it quick. The pizza was a work of art. Rich thick flavor sauce that you can tell was freshly made with home ingredients that made me think they actually pick up the vegetables that very second to make this fresh hot pizza. The bite on the slice was juicy but not oily like some pizza. My only negative was that I could not get another slice to save my life. My salad was a Caesar Salad that was so big. I shared it with my wife and sister in law. They enjoyed it. that bowl it came it was almost as big as the table. We were having an issue because the pizza's and the other dishes we had ordered made space on the table very limited. My star of my meal was the Clam Chowder. OMG. This one was the best Chowder I have ever had outside of Fisherman's Warf in San Francisco. Rich and thick. Spot on. I only wish they served it in a bread bowl like on the docks in Frisco. I am a fan. Who ever make this I was taken away 10/10/ Summary. my family enjoyed the meal and the service was excellent and friendly. Recommended Yes Yes Yes. I live in Maryland and I would drive 6 more hours to have this again. Cheers!! read more

Mystic Pizza - Clam Chowder to die for. 10/10 - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

Mystic Pizza holds such a special place in my heart. This was one of the last places I visited with a group of my girlfriends during a weekend trip to Mystic, and it meant a lot to finally experience a spot tied to one of my favorite movies. We ordered onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and, of course, the pizza. Everything felt so nostalgic from start to finish--the atmosphere, the food, even getting a picture with the Julia Roberts poster upstairs. The staff was incredibly kind and welcoming, and seating us at the top of the restaurant made it feel even more memorable. Looking back, this visit is something I'll always carry with me, especially in memory of a dear friend who has since passed. It's a bittersweet feeling, and while I may not return because of that, I truly cherish the experience. The pizza itself was enjoyable--crispy with a buttery flavor and a nice layer of cheese. Some at the table thought it leaned a bit standard, but for me, it exceeded expectations and made the moment even more special. read more

See all

The ambiance is perfect! The original restaurant is still in tact from the movie AND they've added a bar upstairs just recently. It's welcoming, the staff is great, and it feels like home. Where else would I go for pizza in Connecticut! They have their own beer too. So, "fanboying" a bit here. I loved the movie, so keep that in mind when you read this. The pizza would have to be pretty bad to get less than 5 stars from me! Already love it! I ate the pizza, and: If there was a 6th star, they would get one here! The pizza was fantastic! I can't say enough about the hospitality! The owner stopped to say hi and talked for a bit! Great person. I will be planning a trip back to Mystic very soon! Wonderful place! read more

OBVIOUSLY we had to go to mystic pizza. As a ny'er im biased because i know we have the best pizza but that being said it was still fun to come here and the pizza and experience itself was really great. Our waitress melainey was wonderful, especially when my dad ended up experiencing low blood sugar. She zipped into action and speedily got him orange juice and was like, "I'm an emt if anything happens!" We got there at 11:30 and were sat upstairs outside right away but I'd imagine it gets packed. And being from long island I had to get the fire island cocktail which was delicious. I also loved that we could do half pepperoni on the small pizza which was perfect size to share! read more

Mystic Pizza - Fire island - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

No way this is still a family-owned and operated pizza joint. We stopped here on the ride home from the Vineyard, and it tastes like Chuck E. Cheese pizza. It's even served on the same type of pizza tray as Chuck E. Cheese. Take a photo of the sign and find somewhere better to eat. The movie was definitely better than the pizza. read more

Mystic Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

The food was mostly very good. The daily soup was amazing! The garlic knots chewy like reheated in microwave. The Mediterranean pizza was amazing crust on point. The service was good and helpful. The place still nostalgic vibe, mystic pizza great movie, first mention of my Portuguese people. Will be back! read more

See all

The pizza here was incredible. The crust was doughy, but crunchy. The toppings were fantastic. They had a lot of fun specifically pizzas to choose from, we had a hard time making a decision! I always love a pizza place where you can sit down and have an actual meal (I hail from the takeout pizza Mecca.) They have a full bar and a good cocktail menu. The service was slightly quirky, but everything else was so good we'll ignore that. read more

See all

We were in town for an event, and decided to try Mystic Pizza. Our expectations were not elevated because of the novelty and hype. The pizza was amazing! The pizza crust was baked a beautiful lightly brown color. It was delicate, tender and crispy all at once. We ordered the Margherita to share and just loved the freshly chopped garlic, tomatoes and fresh basil. It was so delicious and so much more than I expected. The staff is friendly and kind. Our waitress placed our order and was very attentive. The restaurant is decorated with the movie memorabilia as expected. It's adorable! They even had the movie playing as we had our lunch. It is charming! read more

Mystic Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

Came in for nostalgia and a slice. They had a walk up side that opened promptly at 10 and we had ourselves a slice of cheese. This was our first experience with New England style pizza. We enjoyed the crust and sweeter sauce. It was a great experience and one of the cheaper spots which we always appreciate. Customer service was friendly and fast. Highly recommend if you are in the area for some cheap and easy eats! read more

First off Rae at the counter is awesome! She denied us out after a long car drive! We all had a slice of breakfast pizza, which was actually really good! They have cold beer on draft, which is always awesome. All of the nostalgia from my childhood memories of the movie King flooding back to when we walked in. The decor is just what you would expect from a "famous "pizza joint . Their seasonal cocktails are also pretty awesome ! It gets busy even if they off-season so get there early! read more

See all

It was fine. The pizza was nothing special. Street parking. Cool place, celeb pics all over the place. Table service on one side and grab a slice on the other side. They do a beer and soda. I haven't seen the movie. read more

See all

Every time we visit mystic Connecticut we come by here so I'm surprised I haven't reviewed this place already, especially since we do love it here, but today was the best experience ever. We went at 9pm and there was no wait especially since they have lots of seating and an upstairs area too. There is a public parking right across if you can't find street parking and when you come from a city like Boston, the prices for parking are really cheap. Now one of the first things I look for at restaurants is if they bring water when you sit. Here they didn't, however when I order my soda I ask for no ice and most of the times whoever is serving us forgets, but our waiter didn't forget.. and not just that but when I asked one of the servers passing by for a refill and said no ice, they paid attention and I was sure they wouldn't because no place ever gets that right. So servers there are good. For food we ordered the Yiayias secret pizza, Buffalo wings and Cajun fries. They fries were better than at most places but not what stood out. I was really impressed with the wings which were some of the best wings I've had. Same goes for the pizza. Originally when the wings came and I was eating so many that I felt I wouldn't be able to finish the pizza and regretted that we had asked for the large. But when I tried the pizza I was happy we got the large as I would take the leftover pizza home. Always love stopping by there when we visit mystic Connecticut and now I have a new favorite pizza. Looking forward to our next visit. read more

See all

We visited the Coast Guard Academy for homecoming weekend and had to make a stop at the iconic Mystic Pizza. We were short on time and chose to order online & planned to eat it in the car, but thankfully it was slow at that hour and we were able to eat it in-house instead. I had wrongly expected it to be New Haven style with a charred thin crust, but instead it was doughy with a nice golden brown crust with plenty of cheese and fresh toppings. Overall, the pizza was fair and it was a fun visit, but we'd likely choose another location for our next pie. The pricing for their speciality pies seemed pretty excessive and we were glad we chose instead to made our own. read more

Mystic Pizza - Restaurant exterior - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

We were in Mystic while visiting different areas of CT... mostly watching the leaves change color. Saw the movie Mystic Pizza back in the 80's do how could we not stop in. The restaurant was cool and it felt nostalgic to be there. The pizza was very good but not great. I mean , Connecticut (New Haven) is practically the holy grail of pizza ... but this isn't New Haven style. Still, I did enjoy it ( I just love pizza) Service was good, staff was friendly, place was clean. If you're in town, it's def worth a go. read more

See all

Whether you come here for the nostalgia or for the fact that this place actually has great food, amazing ambiance and super friendly service, you will definitely not go wrong. We always stop by Mystic Pizza whenever we visit the town and nothing has really changed throughout the years. My only recommendation would be to start introducing vegan cheese and meats. read more

Mystic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

Mystic Pizza has the name recognition and the prime location, but the experience doesn't quite live up to the hype. The food itself is so‑so -- not terrible, not great, just fine. The staff felt subpar, a bit disengaged, which added to the overall underwhelming vibe. The biggest draw here is really the location, and that's what you end up paying for. Speaking of paying, having to shell out for parking on top of everything else doesn't help the experience. It's worth a stop if you're already in the area and want to say you've been, but it's not a place I'd go out of my way for. Cheers read more

I think most people know about this place because of that 1988 movie, Mystic Pizza. Personally, I haven't watched it yet lol. I still had to try the pizza and see what the hype was about. I've heard and read mixed reviews, but I like to judge places for myself. It's right in the heart of Mystic with a couple of tables outside. My family ordered a few slices. I had the pepperoni and cheese pizza. I really liked it! I'm a saucy person so I love extra sauce on my pizzas and that slice was definitely saucy. It's saucy, cheesy, and the pepperonis were perfectly crispy! I'm no pizza connoisseur but this pizza was 4.5 stars in my book. read more

Mystic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

I watched the movie when I was a little girl and I said that one day I would go there... today was the day! It was a unique experience and it was nostalgic to eat at a pizza place that still looks like the pizza places from the 80s and early 90s. Amazing customer service our waitress was so sweet. My son accidentally spilled his drink all over the table and she came right over help clean it up and didn't make a fuss about it. The garlic cheesy bread was probably my favorite item that I had today. The fried artichoke hearts were good as well. My Hawaiian pizza was OK. The pineapples on it taste different. It's not what I was used to, but the crust on the pizza was probably the best crust I've ever had. My son ordered a pizza burger and he was not a fan. My other son ordered a chicken sandwich and he loved it. My husband ordered the house Pizza and he liked it and he said the crust was amazing and he never eats crust. I'm so glad that we got there before the rush. We've driven past it before and we've seen lines outside and because I have a disability I prefer not to stand in lines for food so I was happy that I didn't have to stand in line. I also love that this place has a handicap bathroom separate from the men and women's bathroom, which is amazing. Overall it was a great experience and hopefully we can come back again on another day when it's not busy again. read more

See all

I finally got to this iconic pizza place in Mystic! I went on a summer Saturday so the place was packed but we were able to get a seat right away. The place is huge with two floors and an outdoor deck. We got a small House Special pizza and fried calamari (not pictured). The food arrived fairly quickly amid the crowd. The pizza was standard but the fried calamari was something else. It tastes fresh and fried well! -7/10 read more

Mystic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

So excited to be back at Mystic Pizza, over 20 years later! Cute place in the heart of Mystic. the service was friendly and helpful. We had the wings which were tangy and tasty, they could have been more crispy for our taste. We had heard from the locals that it wasn't the best pizza but still such an iconic place to visit so we had to go back! The pizza was actually quite good, thin foldable pizza, again could have been cooked longer for our taste but we really enjoyed the meatzza and margarita pizzas. Also, def. plan to come back with our gluten free friends to try the GF crust! read more

See all

LOVE Mystic Pizza and would highly recommend if you are in the area. Ambience is very hometown and vibey, service is friendly, and pizza is good. Sat down with my friend for just a slice after needing to pick up some music gear at a Guitar Center in the area- it was so good we ordered a whole pie for the road! Will definitely be back next time i'm in the area- Mystic is a very cool town in general, used to come here a lot as a kid! read more

Very nice little pizza spot, with plenty of other options as well. The server was kind, our pizza was amazing! read more

Mystic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

I got this to-go, because I needed a break from eating out during the week. And of course, the ONE time that I do not check my order before I leave, it's wrong. But I was already back at my hotel, so wasn't about to go back. I was excited to try the fried calamari, but unfortunately had a salad, instead. With Honey Mustard Dressing. WTF. lol I also was excited to try the "house" (I can't remember the name) pizza.. with some veggies and meatball on it. But I got just a plain cheese pizza with meatball. The salad was very basic. But I did like the pizza. It was VERY cheesy. And I would want to try it again whenever I'm in town. It felt like it was somewhere between a classic crust pizza and a "pan" pizza. I can't give them 3 stars, because it's my own fault for not checking the order. And despite it being wrong, the people inside were very nice! From the outside, it didn't look big enough to sit inside, but I think they might have had a little annex for more seating, if you did want to eat inside. Sorry for taking someone else's order, and for not bringing it back... read more

Mystic Pizza - To Go Order - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

I'm sure we've all heard of Mystic Pizza before. This nostalgic pizzeria rose to fame after inspiring the 1988 American romcom itself. We were on our way to Rhode Island and were passing through the area. It's always a hit or miss with hyped up places... and we're from an area that has easy access to NY style pizza. Sooooo we didn't want to get our hopes up too high... The pizzeria is located on the corner of Main Street. Parking can be difficult, but we were able to find a spot a few minutes away. We were greeted warmly as soon as we entered. The dining areas are decorated with memorabilia from the movie. They sell pizza by the pie (small or large) or by the slice (close to $4-$5 each). They have all of your classic toppings as well as specialty ones. In addition to pizza, there's also salads, appetizers, sandwiches, calzones, and burgers. Prices are steep - I'm guessing it's partially due to the large number of tourists. You pay for the name. Since we had dinner plans later on, we only ordered pepperoni & cheese slices. The pizza came out hot and super cheesy. The cheese was the best part - gooey and sweet. The sauce was lacking and I couldn't taste much of the seasoning. The crust was thicker and more on the doughy side - it reminded me of Pizza Hut or Domino's. I'm a thin crust kind of gal. Overall, the pizza was good, but not great. I wouldn't say it was a memorable slice. If you're in the area, it might be worth a try. It might float your boat. But I don't think it's worth going out of your way for. Overhyped, but tasty! read more

See all

Great pizza, great service, cool nostalgic vibe! Their fried artichoke hearts are excellent! Can't go wrong with this local eatery! read more

See all

was down Mystic and said hey it's been a while. Still a fantastic pie , amazing sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. They have expanded a lot but the OG part of the joint still rings nostalgia, read more

Went there around 11am on a Saturday and we managed to beat the rush I'd heard about. I've actually never seen the movie, but I still felt obligated to eat here while we stay in Mystic. I was pleasantly surprised by their pizza. The crust reminded me of my childhood, the cheese tasted very fresh, and the toppings were plentiful. We each ordered a small and it was just the right amount of food. read more

See all

Really good food and service. Decorated with old school movie decor. The fried artichoke hearts were the star of the show. Pepperoni pizza was great! read more

Mystic Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

Listen I live in Mystic. I've lived in this area my whole life. Mystic Pizza has, and always will be, a tourist trap. Which is fine! However, the pizza is just not good (the food in general, really). It's a fun place to take a picture when you're down here (which is funny because the movie wasn't even shot there - it was shot in Stonington), but I'd recommend eating elsewhere. read more

December 2025 Mystic, Connecticut I was not going to come here because I thought it would be a tourist trap. But after eating heavy seafood, the past three days I wanted something lighter. Sunday night at 5 o'clock, and the place is not busy. However, there is absolutely no place to park. We parked on the street four blocks away. Your waitress is extremely friendly and helpful. We ordered a small pizza one side with mushrooms and pineapple and the other side Hawaiian. The waitress explained that the large and the small both came with eight pieces. But the diameter is what makes the difference. We sat upstairs where there are maybe five booths and 10 tables. The booths are tight together and don't give you much room for your feet. Being two tall people, perhaps we should have sat at a table. There is a bar in the back of the dining room upstairs. Unfortunately, people have carved the tables and ours was dirty with food pieces when we sat. The walls are covered with poster, signs pictures, and of course the movie Mystic Pizza plays on the television. The pizza came quickly. The size of the pizza was perfect. But the pizza was not perfect. It lacks any sort of sauce. Tasted more like a cheese pizza with toppings. They put the toppings on the top of the cheese. So the ham had some burned spots. The mushrooms are fresh, which is a positive. And there was a lot of pineapple on the pizza, but there is no sauce. The pizza is more of a thick crust pizza. The dough had no flavor. And because there was no sauce on the pizza or there was lack of sauce, the pizza did not have any flavor to it. I think because the movie made this place famous, it is still in business. The pizza is not good. I really tried to find some positives, but because of the way the pizza tasted I struggled. I would give this pizza one and a half stars But I would give service five stars the waitress Audrey was very kind and attentive read more

See all

The service was fast, efficient and friendly. The pizza was Similar to Chuck E. Cheese pizza. I believe it's frozen pizzas that they bake in house, we went because of the movie and because we were in town. The town and location is adorable but if you're looking for good pizza this is not it. Their chicken strips and mozzarella sticks were very tasty. read more

Mystic Pizza - Inside sitting area - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

There's something oddly unpretentious about Mystic Pizza, despite the tourist trap nature of their business. Tucked away on a quintessential New England street, its iconic red and white sign proclaiming "A SLICE OF HEAVEN" hangs proudly against a white clapboard exterior, with a church steeple visible in the distance. This is small-town New England at its most picturesque. Inside, it's exactly what you want it to be - worn wooden booths with light blue vinyl padding, walls covered in memorabilia, and the warm, inviting aroma of pizza that's made this a local institution since 1973. This place has outlasted disco, the Cold War, and several economic downturns. The establishment leans into its fame without apology, playing the movie that put them on the map on a continuous loop in a room filled with artifacts from their brush with Hollywood. It's a strange cultural phenomenon - none of these servers were born when Julia Roberts, Lili Taylor, and Annabeth Gish were serving those pies on the silver screen. The movie, now 37 years old, has moved from zeitgeist to something approaching mythology now for the town. Today's teenagers coming in with their parents might nod politely at the significance, but they're here for the pizza, not a cinematic history lesson from 1988. The pizza arrives on a black pan, simple and straightforward. The crust is substantial enough to provide structure but airy and light, with a satisfying crisp edge. The sauce carries herbaceous notes without overwhelming, neither watery nor gloopy, hitting that perfect middle ground. And the cheese - there's a generous, almost defiant amount of it, melted to a not quite golden layer below the pepperoni that curl slightly at the edges, adding a little contrast to the pie. What's most surprising is that despite its obvious tourist-draw status, the restaurant maintains its pre-fame soul. Servers refill drinks without prompting, attentive without hovering. The prices remain reasonable, despite the perfect opportunity to cash in on their fame. In the booth next to yours, locals mix with tourists, a testament to the fact that beneath the souvenir t-shirts and the movie posters, Mystic Pizza still delivers exactly what it promised back in '73 - a little slice of heaven in idyllic Connecticut. read more

See all

Greeted promptly and seated upstairs. Lots of movie memorabilia. The movie was playing on TV while we dined. Food was delicious and servings ample. Restrooms and dining room clean. Our waitress was a delight. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I remember the movie when I was 18. I am here on a business trip and saw the town of Mystic and had to come by. I was not disappointed. The decor is reminiscent of the movie and they have memorabilia everywhere. And guess what, the pizza was delicious. I had the Mediterranean Pizza and it was cooked just like I like my pizza. The service was great. My waitress was attentive but not hovering. I recommend coming here. Brings back memories and has good food and cold beer. read more

See all

Great pizza, great flavors!! Fast service !!! The ambiance is great, friendly staff! I love recommending guests from other cities and states that are visiting to get some great authentic pizza!! read more

Stopped by here on a East Coast tour with family. We had the small House Special pizza and enjoyed our lunch. Great environment/ambiance with the movie playing on repeat and friendly staff. Line wasn't too long and we were seated pretty quickly. Pizza came out hot and a little crunchy. Interesting to see the toppings under the layer of cheese on top. They also have merchandise for anyone that wants to take home a momento. read more

Mystic Pizza - House special, small size, 8 slices - Pizza Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

Oh Mystic Pizza... how I want to love you. I'm a fan of good traditional pizza joints, and your mozzarella sticks remind me of my local restaurants when I was a kid. Your other appetizers are great, especially your garlic knots. Your servers are always friendly.... But then I get to your pizza. It's good, but it's not great. Luckily, you'll always be my favorite recommendations for out of towners looking for a brush with movie magic. read more

See all

Definitely a must try when visiting Mystic! It's right on the Main Street with all the other stores & restaurants! Our party of 7 were quickly seated on a busy summer Sunday and were very accommodating to the toddler & child with us! Highly recommend ordering their fried pickles & buffalo wings on top of their pizza! It was fairly busy but they had a lot of space with second floor seating and what seemed to be a rooftop outdoor seating area. read more

See all

Ordered from mystic pizza while in the area for an event. I've heard for years about this place and was excited to finally try it. The calzone and the salad were ok, could have done without the meatballs. Everything was ok, but that's about all I can say as most everything was bland or had a strange taste. Maybe I should have ordered the pizza and nothing else or maybe it is an unfair review because nothing compares to NY Italian food but based on the food I ordered and ate that night, I would never eat here again. The delivery driver called when they arrived ed and I tried to meet them to give them a tip but they dropped the food and ran. I called to try to leave a tip over the phone. So it was a bit unorganized since I was told I would be able to tip when he delivered. read more

See all