We've been to this place multiple times and always had a great time - tasty fresh food and friendly staff + generous portion sizes. Today I had baked tilapia stuffed with crab + mashed potatoes and broccoli with the crab sauce and it was probably my favorite meal out of everything I've tried there before (their steak, surf&turf and fries are also always amazing). I also got a half slice of strawberry shortcake to go and can't wait to enjoy it later - it looked fresh and delicious:) I've had their chocolate cake before and both times it was excellent. Their drinks also consistently deliver - we've tried both their cocktails and wine. Their wines are always reasonably priced and I've enjoyed them more than in some "fancier" spots in Durham. Love this spot and will be back many more times. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - baked tilapia stuffed with crab + mashed potatoes and broccoli with the crab sauce - delicious! - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

That strawberry shortcake is something else. 100/10. It's so fluffy and light and creamy. Amazing. However, the actual food... not the best. We got a lobster roll with fries. Not that great and the fries were more fried than potato. Maybe 2/5. I got a greek salad with chicken and it was oddly sweet? Like really sweet and the feta is a strange texture (i love feta this one tastes different almost like the vegan cheeses). Also, $24 for a greek salad with chicken...? Little too much. Chicken was good but not a great salad. Service was super quick, in and out in less than an hour and we take our time eating. Overall, wouldn't come back for food but would totally come back for the cake!! read more

See all

Good local restaurant with the best cake! We had dinner on Saturday night which is also cake night, but we were all so full we didn't end up getting any. Over the years they've changed cake night to just be half off (used to be free) if your entree is over a certain amount. I had the chicken kabob that comes with mixed veggies and her rice. Chicken was good. Veggies and rice were not super flavorful, but ok when I mixed the chicken in. Our server was very nice and service was fast. read more

See all

I got the whitefish sandwich and it was decent. The onion rings were recommended by my waitress and they were so good!! That batter is Service and ambiance were fine. I think next time I'll have to order another entree, though! read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Fish sandwich and onion rings - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

The food is always so fresh and tasty. Our waitress was so sweet and helpful. We sat outside. It was a beautiful day to eat outside read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Spinach Artichoke Dip and blueberry lemon drop - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

The service was amazing. The baked stuffed shrimp was stellar. I think I'd like their cake more if it were room temperature instead of cold. The food was so good, no one at our table captured photos. read more

Wonderful restaurant that is upscale casual with comfortable seating areas inside and out... Nantucket Grill has an extensive menu with great selections of seafood including New England specialties, salads, sandwiches and great entrees. The show stopper is their incredible cake selection which is available in restaurant and for takeout and catering! read more

The grill has a darker feel and doesn't necessarily look upscale. That's why no one would ever know from appearance that Nantucket bakes incredible cakes! I did not dine in on my visit, but got a cake slice to go. I have on many occasions stopped by Nantucket just to get dessert or buy a cake slice as a gift. They have never disappointed. The cashiers provide standard service when you just do a quick purchase and the restaurant is designed so you can go buy dessert and leave without disrupting the dining service or waiting too long. Overall, love visiting Nantucket to get dessert just as a end to a good evening out. The mint cake slice was delicious and not too sweet but so delicately balanced in flavor. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Mint Cake Slice - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Let me tell you. You can never go wrong with a piece of cake from Nantucket Grill. Oh my goodness, the cake is so dang on good...ALL OF THEM! Don't get me wrong, I have eaten various dishes from this restaurant but the cake has me in a choke hold. I always stop in and just grab a piece of cake and be on my way lol. So moist, so many layers, so good. My go-to cakes are the strawberry shortcake, the tirimisu and the chocolate peanut butter. Stop playing and go get some! read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Strawberry Shortcake - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

So I came to pick up an order for just some slices of cake and now I understand why everyone loves their bakery. I'm not originally from this area so I love trying a new local restaurant. The cake was delicious and so moist. I didn't eat inside the restaurant so I have to come back another day. The lemon cake, triple chocolate cake, cookie butter cake, and strawberry shortcake were absolutely amazing and I'll be back. read more

See all

Nantucket Grill in Durham serves up coastal New England charm in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, the vibe feels homey. The space is casual but thoughtfully decorated with nautical accents, light wood tones, and vintage photographs of lighthouses and sailboats that lean into the Cape Cod aesthetic without being too over-the-top. It's the kind of spot where locals gather for dependable seafood and generous portions, and service reflects that spirit, warm, attentive, and genuinely kind. We stopped in for dinner and left with mixed feelings. The food overall was solid, but many of the dishes could have used a bit more seasoning to bring out their full potential. We started with the Creamy Lobster Bisque, which had a nice, rich base with good flavor. The texture was velvety and comforting, but it was noticeably light on actual lobster meat. Still, for what it was, it made for a satisfying warm-up to the meal. Next came the Fresh Maine Lobster Roll, lobster chunks mixed with mayo and diced celery, served on a grilled New England-style roll. The bun had a good toast on it, and the lobster was fresh, but the flavor was very mellow. It could have used a little brightness or even a dash of lemon to lift it. Classic, but a little too safe. The Baked Stuffed Shrimp came out next, served over spinach risotto with a side of mixed vegetables. The jumbo shrimp were well-cooked, and the crab stuffing had nice texture. The risotto, however, leaned too soft for my taste and missed the slight bite of being cooked al dente. That said, the vegetable medley was a surprising highlight, vibrant, crisp, and perfectly cooked with just the right amount of seasoning. We finished with the Chocolate Bliss Cake, and it lived up to the name. Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake, whipped cream frosting, and a drizzle of chocolate syrup. This dessert was moist, rich, and had the perfect balance of sweetness and texture. Easily our favorite dish of the night. Nantucket Grill is a solid choice when you're craving classic seafood in a cozy, coastal-inspired setting. While some dishes could use a flavor boost, the service and dessert made the visit worthwhile. It's the kind of place you go for comfort food and casual conversation, not necessarily for bold flavors. read more

See all

Stuffed tilapia dish was amazing. The lobster cream sauce topped perfectly. The mashed potatoes were creamy and flavorful and the broccoli roasted perfectly. I also had the crab dip but it was not the best but it is the first time I've had crab dip so maybe it's just me. It tasted like tuna blended down so wasn't impressive. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Stuffed Tilapia broccoli and mashed potatoes. - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

nver ate any food here but the desserts? The CAKE ? Amazing. Never had anything like it

Rating based on: consistency, cleanliness, quality, taste, and presentation FAM , LET ME PUT Y'ALL ONTO THIS SPOT I STUMBLED UPON WHILE CRUISING FOR A DRINK - TYPE HUNGRY VIBES, AND MY SIS STRAIGHT UP BASED RECOMMENDED IT! , wasn't expecting much from this Irish pub American flavor joint FYI it's not a Irish pub!!! but it's giving dope hardy real food energy without all that cheugy processed junk gaslighting your taste buds with 150k ingredients! If you're simping over Burger King or some mid fast food, just ratio that thought - kick in a few extra bucks here and you're getting fire quality with portions bigger than your gains after leg day! The service? Straight impeccable, treating you like kings and queens - vibe check passed HARD! Now let it cook on the menu: That GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH with FRENCH FRIES extra fried hard? Came out crispy, hot, and fast AF - 10x better and fresher than Chick-fil-A, no glazing! The BURGER? Nice and fat, juicy without being too much, with onions and lettuce so fresh you'd think they chopped 'em right there! This place stays packed like peanuts at the ball game, keeping everything bussin' and fresh - I've hit it up 10+ times, and the Chapel Hill location is rad with outdoor seating for that view while you chow down! The SALAD? On point and ate harder than any fast food slop! But here's the kicker, kings - bring your ride-or-die shorty for the specialty CAKE! We're talking 6-7-10 layer deliciousness that countries fought wars over (do your history, bro). I'm not even a sweet tooth simp, hate processed sugar, but this uses real sugar and it's not too sweet - portion sizes huge and worth every penny! Don't eat seafood so can't speak on that, but the SOUPS are fire and giving home-cooked meal realness at decent prices! Menu's vast with cake flavors and burgers galore, but it stays consistent without changing - that's based, cause consistency breeds excellence, FR FR! If you're sleeping on this for that processed cringe, you're taking an L + ratio - pull up fast, feast like a boss, and thank me later! This spot is straight fire! 6 7 read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Custom chocolate strawberry shortcake - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

I'm always in Durham but never been to this jewel. First time here but not my last. The food was amazing. The ambiance was cute. The service by Manuel was awesome. Wanted something good with a variety and this was the place. Everything was good. And the bakery. They have grey bakes cakes and cupcakes and pies. They go fast so I suggest getting them before dinner like I did. lol.... read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Overall Experience: I recently visited Nantucket Grill and had a good experience. Service: The service was good. Our waitress was very nice. She gave us her recommendations and even gave us extra time to figure what we wanted from the menu. Food: Crab dip: 9/10 I really enjoyed the crab dip! It was tasty and I loved that it was served with pita bread. Baked Stuffed Shrimp: 8/10 I enjoyed this dish. I never had stuffed shrimp before but I was pleasantly surprised. The portion was great. I think the dish could have used a little extra seasoning but otherwise it was really yummy! Atmosphere: The atmosphere was nice. It was a family friendly environment. Price: The prices were reasonable for the quality and experience. I would definitely go back! It seems very consistent like one of those restaurants that never fail you ! read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Stuffed Shrimp - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

One of my favorite places to go. The restaurant is really big, but clean and the staff are awesome. I have never had anything bad off the menu. The cake is the best and worth the money. Highly recommend. read more

Wonderful location to unwind and relax. Great food and beer options. Check the specials, some days have really good offers. Staff is great and personable. Zack at the bar is the best! read more

Portions are good, and waitress was attentive and kind. Hostess rubbed me the wrong way with attitude and then not following instructions (created a 10-top instead of 8-top as requested). Later, the same hostess was reading a book at the front. We went on a Sunday night partially because of the free kids meals. Unfortunately, that only applies with an $18 entree, and almost all of the burgers/sandwiches are below that threshold. There are only 2 total vegetarian options on the entire menu, and the portabello mushroom sandwich (less than $18) looked better than the Penne Primavera, so we had to forego a free kid's meal. Our party was 4 adults and 4 kids, so they charged us automatic 20% gratuity. I'm not a fan of automatic gratuity for a specific party size. They offered to-go boxes, but they were made of styrofoam, and I would have preferred compostable or recycled paper boxes. read more

This was our first visit. We will definitely be back. The prime rib and filet were phenomenal. Service was excellent (Brad). We will definitely be back with the fam. Would absolutely recommend them anytime. read more

We live in Charlotte but anytime my husband's work takes him remotely close to here, he knows I want that Blueberry Bread Pudding brought home read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Blueberry white chocolate bread pudding - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

We eat at Nantucket Grill 2-3 times a month. The fried shrimp, scallops and cod are excellent. You cannot go wrong trying any of the three. Fridays are extra good and tasty I order the 2 lobster tail chef special. Nantucket Grill has a pretty good cocktail menu and beer menu. I am not a beer drinker so my preference would not mean much to a serious beer drinker. Always worthwhile to try the cocktail if the day. read more

My lunch buddy and I had a wonderful meal today at the Nantucket Grill. He ordered the 1/2 pound burger with fries. I had the Greek salad with chicken. Everything was delicious. My buddy finished everything on his plate - and it was a big plate. My salad was similarly large. I really enjoyed the dressing and the marinated chicken. We ate inside this time because it was so hot but the outdoor seating looked very inviting. Maybe next time we'll sit outside. The service was a bit slow but I could overlook it because they were so busy. I'd definitely return! And next time I'll stay for cake! read more

A tender and flavorful Prime Rib with au jus and veggies. So delicious! The holiday cake & cherry cheesecake were divine as well. read more

See all

Summary: reliable eatery with over-the-top desserts and a nice outdoor seating area Details: If this seems like a New England style restaurant, it should -- that's what the owners are going for. Clam chowdah, lobstah rolls, and strip steaks are all on the menu. Summary of 4 or 5 visits: Bacon Cheeseburger: comes with jack and decent amount of bacon. We've had it both with fries and apple coleslaw. Both are quite good -- maybe a tad too much mayo in the slaw. If you're gf, you can order it bunless. Steak Burger: Grilled pieces of marinated steak, mushrooms, onions and melted pepper jack on ciabatta. Didn't work for me. Meat was a little too chewy and the bun tasted a little stale. The only thing I've ever ordered that I didn't like. Blackened Salmon Salad: a solid choice with a large salad and a generous amount of salmon. No skimping on the ingredients. BBQ Chicken Sandwich: eh. It's fine. Not great but not bad. Grilled Salmon: comes with a generous portion of mashed potatoes and asparagus. Default version is grilled but they will give a blackened version if you ask. Always been nicely cooked, not overdone and not too rare. There's a full bar with a decent selection of draft beers. The wait staff have always been helpful and patient when one diner isn't sure what to order. One word review: reliable read more

See all

Amazing food! Great service, and desserts to die for. I have been there a number of times and have never had a bad meal! I am from Michigan and I winter down here and this place has always been my go-to when we want a great meal! read more

YELP! Today's visit to #NantucketGrill in Durham left much to be desired. I ordered the lobster bisque soup, hoping for a flavorful experience, but the soup was extremely bland-offering no seasoning. When I voiced my concern, the waiter informed me that it couldn't be removed from my bill. I felt dismissed. I hadn't mentioned anything about removing the soup from my bill. Instead, I was offered to speak with the manager. While I looked over the menu for other options, I was surprised by the small appetizer portion as well, but more surprisingly, the manager dismissed my concerns to reassure me that I was the first to complain after so many have raved about this soup.?. Had the manager not vocalized in such an animated way to dismiss my subtle concern, I may have considered dining longer to enjoy, perhaps a dessert. But when nearby tables began looking up and turning heads, I knew it was time to exist. At this establishment, the manager reiterated the restaurant's policy against refunds and pointed out that this policy is written at the bottom of their menus. In addition, when attempting to select other options (seafood), the manager shared that these items, too, may not suit my liking as they are seasoned with little to no seasonings as well. After some back and forth, the manager offered to charge me half for the soup and ultimately decided to remove it this time. After all that. Although I appreciate this lesson, I left feeling a tad embarrassed over the encounter and for using my voice to speak against something that just did not suit my taste. In total, I spent $18.07 (plus tip) for an appetizer (1/2 priced) and side salad, and left hungry. With over an hour's drive home, I stopped off to purchase more food (fries and an ice cream cone) to hold me until dinner. We never know what a person is going through. I had just finished an outpatient procedure and was definitely up for a great lunch. I just hope whatever it is, that we can just #BeKind to one another. #NantucketGrill read more

Went here for a business lunch. Food was delicious, the server was friendly, nice patio area. Will definitely be back.

Usual grill food with good service. Decided to get a slice of cake to take back to the hotel and BAM-- now that's a slice of cake. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Good place to grab food, drink, and of course their famous CAKES! Most recently I visited with my mother for an early dinner. This location is situated in a shopping center with other businesses. There is parking all throughout the area. We were sat and greeted quickly. My mom ordered the full rack of ribs with a baked sweet potato and I ordered the Seafood Scallop Kabob. Both were very good! I'm not a big fan of ribs, but I did try one of my mom's and it was tender and flavorful. My scallops were delicious! They were cooked perfectly! It's hard to get scallops just right because they can easily burn or become rubbery, but these were so tender and well-cooked. They were also some of the biggest scallops I've seen. Although I did not get a slice of cake this visit, I have had their cakes and this is what Nantucket is known for...and for good reason. When you walk in the baked goods are on display and very tempting. You can also order speciality cakes as well. I recommend coming here if you're in the area. There's also a location in Raleigh and Chapel Hill as well. Make sure to leave room for cake or get a slice to go! read more

See all

Sorry, not sorry, but I have to bring my review back up to 5 stars. Ever since I started doing pick up and adding extra cranberry, my experience went back to 5 stars lol. I wish they would add more to the actual cranberry bog sandwich, but it is easily remedied by adding cranberry to the order. Service remains top notch! I have no idea how the staff always remain so nice when the place is always packed!! But service definitely rocks. read more

See all

Came here for dinner the other night and it did not disappoint! Inside ambiance is very homey and buzzing. There is a huge dessert counter in the front of the restaurant, where you can see all their amazing cakes being displayed. We were seated quickly. Our waiter (Miguel) was very kind and constantly checked on us and made sure we had a great dining experience. I ordered the blackened salmon salad. It came with a perfectly cooked filet of blackened salmon on a big bed of greens with a delicious raspberry vinaigrette. I love the little bits and pieces of nuts and cranberries in the salad. The dressing paired with the greens very well, although it was a little too much dressing. Another thing I noticed was that the cheese used in the salad was not feta as described on the menu, which was a little disappointing. My friend, and I also ordered the crab dip that came with pita wedges. The dip came out, hot and bubbly, and it was absolutely delicious, appropriately cheesy with chunks of crab in it.. For dessert we ended up ordering a strawberry cream shortcake. The cake was absolutely delicious, not too sweet, the berries were super fresh, and the cream was light and airy and cake portion was nice and spongy without being too dense. I can see why their cakes are so popular now. I think this is a solid place to grab food, even better for dessert. If you find yourself in the area, please come here and check them out! read more

See all

Nantucket was grill was yummy! I loved my baked scallops and crab dish. It was rich, delicious and well made. The service was pretty good here too. My chocolate cake looked better than it tasted but I've heard other flavors are fantastic. I would definitely come back read more

The last two times my wife and I went they got her steak wrong. Specifically told the waiter this time it was rare last time and it's to be medium well. Again she got medium rare with blood running out as soon as she cut it. It ruined her appetite and we left without her eating. I went for prime rib, which is advertised as all day Sundays and they didn't have any. Staff was friendly and the place is clean yet the experience soured us on Nantucket Grill. We will not be returning and we were going twice a week at least before this. Disappointed that the last two experiences ruined a place we enjoyed eating at before. Need to get cooks in the kitchen that know how to cook steaks. read more

Ribs were not tender and needed a fork and knife to be eaten. Taste was uneven and meat was tough read more

As a Durhamite, I can honestly say both the Durham and Chapel Hill locations feel nostalgic in the best way. Great for family dinners or when you're just craving something classic and comforting. Local vibes and their cakes are the bestttt! read more

I came in about 20 minutes before close as I had been at an event earlier. I usually think the food isn't as great at night that late, but Nantucket nailed it! The shrimp and crab dip were so good. It was pretty busy, but not loud. They had run out of nearly every dessert (Valentine's Day win for them!) and the staff all seemed really happy. I had a great experience. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Crab Dip - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

I went to have a drink at this place with a friend, once i was there I decided to get something to eat, i got a ribeye steak sandwich it was good but not the best sandwich ever it was a big portion though. Also i had a drink and it was good, i think it's a little overpriced (this is just my personal opinion) but the service was good. The bartender was very attentive and friendly. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Ribeye sandwich - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

I was an instant fan just by the name alone, since I'm a native of New England. I was visiting the area for work and this place was within a few miles of my hotel. It was a Sunday evening around 7pm when I visited. Great location, although it was a bit of a puzzle working through the parking lot from the main road. I was seated right away, which was probably best since the dessert case was staring at me the whole time and if I had waited a minute longer I likely would've started off by ordering dessert first. :-) I ordered a ceasar salad to start with, and then the grilled kabob (2 meat - beef and chicken) with a substitute of the risotto instead of the rice. The kabobs were grilled to perfection. Really good flavor. I'm not sure I was a huge fan of the homemade teriyaki sauce as for me it was a bit too overpowering. The grilled vegetables and the risotto were really good. Kudos to the cooks! I filled myself up on the salad and entre but I couldn't help but to order a dessert to go. I went with the "half" slice of carrot cake since I still had a pretty clear memory of how ginormous the cakes looked in the dessert case. It took me all of about 5 minutes after returning to my hotel room to devour, and I mean devour, that carrot cake. It was quite possibly the best one that I've had. I'm sad that I won't just be able to order takeout from my home state of Florida. If ever I'm back in the Durham area, this will be top of list to return. Great dining experience, great staff, and amazing food! read more

See all

I love love love the lobster tail, special with the sautéed spinach. This is also one of the fews restaurants with a bar that has rums other than Bardi. read more

Nantucket Grill - Durham - Lobster tail special with sautéed spinach - American Near Me - Durham, North Carolina