I did not have high expectations based on previous reviews but pizza was quick and so yummy. Two whole pizzas fed 4 people plus leftovers, with 4 drinks 35$. Definitely recommend read more

Fit the bill for a quick meal. Pizzas were done in about 10 minutes. I really enjoyed my salad - seasoned perfectly with salt & pepper. Service was great! read more

See all

Great little pizza spot on the Omni Amelia Resort property. Service and pizza was good for a quick late night snack.

Pizza is very average but it's convenient and kid friendly if you're at the Omni. They have fro yo too but when we went the vanilla/chocolate was broke leading to many disappointed kids. A few arcade games but they are mostly claw games that cost $1 so bring your quarters. read more

Ordered 2 pizzas and garlic bread. The food tasted good! Nothing out of this world but no issues either! There is a frozen yogurt shop inside as well! The kids loved that and enjoyed the frozen yogurt! read more

We've been coming to Amelia Island every year and we ALWAYS stop and eat here. It's a tradition at this point! The servers are SO friendly and they've memorized our names and faces (Hi Hailey)! It's always so fun to eat here and the pizzas come out very fast and yummy! They make sure to take care of everyone. We love you guys! read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Salty Pig pizza & Endless Summer pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Gross. Disgusting. 4 slides and a coke. $32. Do not go. Couldn't even eat parts burned so bad. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Nasty slice - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Thank you Jesus, they were open on Christmas night! It was convenient because the team stayed at the Omni resort. My husband is vegan so we appreciated their salad offerings. I loved the crust on the pizza. We ordered a custom pizza- spinach & red onions. I wished they had roasted garlic but the pizza was still "ono"! It was too cold to try the frozen yogurt but they offered a variety of flavors. Thank you for working on Christmas! read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Closest pizza to Omni Hotel/ Villas. Good pizza, reasonably priced, got order of 8 pizzas done quickly/ ready for pickup at the time I was told. read more

Sauce on the pizza was done well. Really liked the texture on the vegetable pizza. Only problem was the crust. Might've been a little overcooked and dark. Ambiance was really nice. Liked the chill environment and were taken care of nicely. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

YUM!!! Quick service pizza, definitely reminds me of NY style, We had sausage and pepperoni and were not disappointed!! read more

Natural Slice Pizza - pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

This was a good place for both pizza or frozen yogurt while at Amelia island. We stayed on the resort, but you can also visit this location without staying at the Omni resort. We went in January, so it was not crowded and we had quick attentive help. The only concern is they have limited hours and when we first tried to go they were closed. It has a fun beachy atmosphere with surf board tables and a jutebox read more

I really like that there is a pizza restaurant here. However, I didn't really like it! It took a suspiciously long time for the slices to be ready, and I thought they were too cheesy. read more

See all

We enjoyed the Endless summer pizza. The crust was good. The weather was gorgeous so we sat outside. They bought the pizza out in a timely manner. The cashier/waitress was sweet and kind. She answered all our questions. They brought the pizza outside where we were sitting. We parked our car at the restaurant and there were enough parking spots. We were too full to try their frozen yogurt. But maybe next time. read more

Good knots, HORRIBLE pizza. No flavor, being from the northeast, didn't expect much and we weren't disappointed. Would not recommend pizza, only game in town near Omni resort​ read more

VERY pleasant staff + Prompt service + Delivery! You can't ask for more in this remote corner of our world aka "Mayberry by the Sea". We're a "slice" of life and so grateful to have yummy pizza at my back door. read more

This is the only place around here that you can eat on a budget. First impression was weird cause right when you walk in, the place was filled was smoke. There weren't a lot of people here but it took such a long time for our one pie. I guess it's a lot of online or over the phone orders? Our pie came out 40+ mins later and it was steaming hot. The first bite into my ham and pineapple pizza would be the most important, however, it did mot leave such a good impression because it was just so salty lol. You would think the pineapple would offset any saltiness but it didn't. The pizza was thin to my liking but the ingredients didn't taste fresh -- the cheese, the sauce, the dough.. everything tasted like a replica of Dominos. Sorry, I'm really critical of pizza since i'm from the Tri State but I would've been easier on this pace overall if it had not been so dang salty. read more

See all

They failed twice to add pepperoni on our pizza. We finally just ate what they brought us. In addition, the sauce has big chunks of tomatoes which is not my thing. Not recommended read more

Natural slice is a surf-themed pizza restaurant at the Omni resort. We were very impressed with the pizza here and ate here a few times during the week (they also deliver to Omni hotel guests). The crust is made with local saltwater, and the cheese is a nice blend of mozzarella and parmesan. The cheese is slightly on the abundant side, so you may want to request less if you like light cheese. Overall, it has great flavor. They do pizza by the slice, but at $4 per cheese slice, it's not a good value. The whole pie is only $12 or so, and a much better purchase. They also sell some other items like salads, and they have ice cream and popsicles as well. I liked the surf theme as well, and they have video games and a jukebox. They even sell surfwear (though very expensive). We were there during the school year, so it was basically empty in there. But I imagine it would get packed during the summer. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Mushroom and black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Good atmosphere, decent service. Wildly overpriced, god-awful pizza. I ordered two slices, was charged for a whole pie for some reason. Decided to just roll with it and save the rest for leftovers. Pizza had almost no sauce on it! I lifted up the cheese to see what the heck was going on, and there was the feintest pinkness like they brushed the dough with marinara-water. The rest of the ingredients were almost completely flavorless. I struggled to get even one slice down, then just threw the rest away. Unbelievable waste of money. read more

Stuck here once last year, really didn't enjoy it. David, another shot the night of my daughter's birthday we ordered a simple pepperoni pie, and a pepperoni with jalapeños and pineapple. The crust was fantastic, the texture was great. I reviewed this the first time I probably wouldn't have given it but 2 1/2 or three stars, but it was much improved! read more

Had some salad and a mushroom and pepperoni pizza at this joint and wasn't all that impressed. The salad wasn't much to speak of and the roasted tomato dressing was pretty lame. When the pizza got to the table it needed anvil filter for as much oil that was on the surface and below the crust. Then they wanted $4.00 for a fountain soda. Are y'all serious???? I had water. Find a different spot for pizza when your in Fernandina. The best part was the atmosphere. You can tell by my Pics read more

See all

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, and I have never had so little pepperoni on my pizza ever. Each piece of pepperoni was 2 or 3 inches away from the next one. The average amount was two pieces per (largej slice. Laughable. I liked how cheesy it was and the thin crust was good. read more

It was decent pizza. Biggest annoyance was sitting in restaurant waiting to take pizza to Go and did not get told ready. read more

This is a great restaurant for a family with kids. Our tweens loved it. They played air hockey while we waited for our yummy pizza. A little shopping at the surf shop. Delicious salad. We'll be back. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Air hockey - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Humm pizza and surfing. Fun shopping for beautiful clothing and gifts while you await your pizza being made fresh. You will not be disappointed in your pizza pie! Delicious! Family friendly, spacious and yummy! read more

See all

Not bad, but not great. The thinness of the crust is great, but the cheese and pepperoni are so greasy that grease drips all over and you may have a stomach ache from all the grease. Good location, fast cook speed, maybe plain cheese would've been a better read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

I'm local. Pretty much all you need to know is this place is inside the Omni Resort. Local people don't eat at hotels. $5 soft drinks are kinda the indicator. They definitely have a little bit of a local spin with local salt from the Atlantic in the crust, but they could very well be using any salt and no one would know. I don't know, nor can I find, any artisanal salt producers locally, but I would love to learn a little bit more about this industry. Still, if you're staying at the Omni and want a less expensive place to eat, this seems to be the least expensive place. However, if you're local and you want pizza, this pizza is no better than gas station pizza. I will say that the people working were not teenagers, and were friendly and professional. For a resort, I think the cleanliness of this place was subpar. It could have been just some things that caught my attention, like the very large window ledge near the men's bathroom had all kinds of dust and cardboard debris all over it like it hadn't been cleaned in months. I truly wanted to give this place a one-star review because it's seriously not worth going to unless you're captive at the Omni, but the counter service was good and the food was edible. As far as places that we love, I would just trust y'all band follow those reviews. Honestly, we tend to go to Mellow Mushroom and a Blaze Pizza, neither of which are considered local. read more

Quiet, and laid back. Hardly anyone there, but not a bad place for a slice if you just need a little something. The service was fine, the pizza was ok, but nothing to write home about. Honestly, I was expecting something a little more chi-chi or "artesenal" from a resort pizzeria... read more

Natural Slice is a great option especially for folks staying on the Omni Amelia Island property. The pizza was quick and tasty and there are outdoor seating options available nearby. Everything was affordable, too, especially for food on a resort property. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Remarkably terrible pizza. Worst I've ever had! Soggy, greasy, meal - how did the do that? Cardboard. Yuck.

Some of the pizza we have ever had. Great food and friendly service. If we make it back to Amelia island, we definitely be eating here again. read more

If you're staying in the Omni Plantation property or close by, it's a perfect spot for basic but good pizza. It's not gourmet, but it doesn't proclaim to be. It's convenient and tasty. read more

The pizza was not that good. The cost did not match the prices from any source we could locate. The delivery to our room only took twenty minutes. The pizza was warm when delivered. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Ordred a straight cheese pizza, excellent crust, sauce, and cheese. Service was great and they have reasonable prices.

Fast and friendly service. Pizza was delicious! We ordered the Point Break and Endless Summer by the slice. Yum!

Pizza was pretty good. Service was quick.......the teens working were friendly and helpful.

Average pizza, nothing special. They brought out our pizza after 20 minutes or so and it was wrong. We ordered half sausage and half chicken (hubby doesn't eat pork). It had sausage on the whole pizza. We asked if it was pork sausage and the guy said yes so they took it back to make a new one. Five or ten minutes later he comes back out and says the sausage is beef not pork. Not sure why. There was a bit of a language barrier. Another 15 minutes go by and finally the correct pizza arrives. While we waited we drank some really sweet tea. read more

See all

Since we were staying at the Omni resort we ordered from Natural Slice. We got the cheese pizza and cinnamon bread bites. There was nothing that blew me away. Other than the pizza being greasy the food was fine. The menu includes salads, bread, pizza, and alcoholic beverages. The food items were pretty basic. I would recommend getting it fresh rather than delivered. read more

Natural Slice Pizza - Cinnamon bread! - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

very good pizza. Kids love the decor. very clean.. They seem to use very good ingredients. In the spas at the Amelia Island Plantation. we also love Marche Burette for Breakfast or lunch, also in the same village shopping area. read more