100% Tourist Trap!!!! Waiters are horrible food is 3x overpriced. $75 dollar bottle of wine is served in plastic cups. You can hear everyone around us complaining about the service too. They don't care if you ever come back again because for some reason everyone has to go here when they visit Montauk DO NOT DO IT! DONT SUPPORT THIS PLACE! No specials and very little sea food options for dinner. I got the $35 fried chicken dish. read more

Beautiful location on the beach with a fiery sunset as a backdrop. We shared starters: calamari, edamame and pan fried peppers. All was overly salty and while good, nothing marked them out as unique in flavour/taste. Mains we mainly opted for the tile fish in red curry, Dad had seared scallops and mum the lobster bake of course! The red curry wasn't authentic Thai curry, bud didn't pretend to be. The curry sauce portion was a drizzle and we had to order more. Ideal for someone who fancies an exotic flavour without the chilli. The sushi rice though was almost crunchy. Not sure what happened but wasn't good at all! This could have been an amazing dish but didn't quite make it. Lobster bake was a good portion with a whole lobster, and a mix of clams and prawns. Seared scallops was almost like a paella and was gobbled up fast! These 2 dishes were successes! The parmigiana fries were morish (I want more!) so forget the calories when you dive in! The chocolate mousse dessert was excellent, not too rich with white chocolate in the middle. Great setting, great wine choices and an easy choice for dining. read more

See all

Beautiful location on the beach, fantastic decor, service issues. I was so impressed by the outdoor dining area, with comfy lounge chairs, stylish decor, and the cushions on the beach. I imagine if it wasn't foggy and rainy, it would be an amazing sunset cocktail place. What a cool place!! I tried the tilefish in red curry. It was tasty. My fish was not fully cooked, however, it was quite raw (raw, not rare) in some sections. The portion was a very thick cut of fish, which is tricky to cook. I ate around it rather than sending it back - simply because service was so slow, and I didn't have to time to wait; but that was my choice. I came on a foggy weeknight evening, and the place was empty. There were three cars in the parking lot, and yet I was forced to do valet parking. Why can't I park my own car? I can see the need for valet on busy weekend nights, but this was not a busy weekend night. I walked up to the hostess (why is the hostess all the way in the back by the bathrooms, past the bar?) and asked for a specific window seat in the bar area, overlooking the patio. She gave me a hard time. The place was practically empty, and she was giving me a hard time about my selection of dining tables. She finally agreed it actually made the most sense, and seated me. My waiter did not appear for quite some time after that. After my meal, I waited 20 minutes for the bill. Finally, I was fed up, and walked over to the hostess and paid my bill at the hostess stand. Despite my problems with the place (raw fish, slow service, rude hostess), do you know annoyed me most about Navy Beach? The speed bumps on the street in front of the condos right before the restaurant! I know there is nothing the restaurant can do about that. The speed bumps are entirely too high, and too many of them; bottoming out your car going very, very slowly over them. I suppose the condos installed these to get back at the loud bar with its loud drunks screeching past their once peaceful waterfont heaven. I really don't need to be bumping over these things with my Audi, and truthfully, as petty as this sounds, I would seriously consider not returning for this reason! My meal came to $53 with wine, tax, and tip. If the service and cooking issues could be resolved, this could be a spectacular dining place. read more

Navy Beach - Tilefish - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Great place to grab a drink and watch the sunset! Amazing staff were incredible and very frIendly. They didn't charge us for a fresh OJ for our 2 year old son which was really sweet and not necessary! We had a lovely evening watching people skip rocks and enjoying the sunset. read more

Navy Beach - Enjoying sunset with the family - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Literally the worst service and food ever ! Waited 55 minutes for meals manager never came over to see if everything was oaky . Iv been waitressing for 10 Plus years and would never let such unprofessional people work in my restaurant. Zero stars from me ! We were unhappy with our drink and server response was " get somthing else it won't be any better " .. you guys should sell to someone who knows how to run a business ! read more

Great for a cocktail, food ok, the staff has an attitude and lacks customer service. Noise! read more

Navy Beach - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

Really nice sunset but most of the dishes we ordered tasted awful. The fish stew was really bland and the jumbo shrimp did not taste fresh. The tile fish was okay. The curry paste in the sause was to thick. The papedelle pasta was bland and tasteless. The kale salad lacked seSoning too. The tuna appetizer sauce was just off the mark too. The highlights were the French fries and the rock shrimp. Two stars for ambience and drinks. Also there are 5-6 hostesses at the front that play games with everyone's reservation. I saw them on several occasions tell people that there was a 2.5 hour wait outside for the reservation they made just so they would sit inside. They told me this too and then sat my group in 15 minutes as a walk in no reservation. read more

1 year later: In honor of our anniversary I just want to say Navy Beach is still THE WORST experience I have ever had at a restaurant. read more

I have had the worst service in the world here. Making a reservation is impossible. The person talking to me didn't even know the date and was convinced we were in august when it was July. They never sent me a confirmation email to place my order. They repeatedly hung up on me when I asked about what happened. I wouldn't go here if you value your time. read more

Food very good, wait staff robotic and unfriendly. The " they're doing me a favor" mentality. Some of the prices head scratching ( $32 fried chicken) No bread, had to ask twice. Great sunset view. Not a fan of plastic cup with my wine and other cocktails. Fish dishes were tremendous. Mandatory valet on a slow night. read more

Horrible service, lot's of attitude and mediocre food is what you get when you come to this spot.

Went for my birthday, we had 6 people. Mentioned an allergy (cause we would go elsewhere if it was a problem) they said no problem and brought the food back with the allergy. When they revamped the dish, it was horrible- no flavor, just thrown together poorly. Service was horrible. Our waiter was rude, talking back to my 65yo mother and threw the bill on the table almost hitting my mother. Extremely disappointed. read more

Regardless about what people feel towards the food, staff, crowds etc. one thing that cannot be denied is the amazing sunsets here (you should come here for this alone). The sunsets here are absolutely breathtaking. You can order drinks at the bar and have seats outside on the benches or if you are lucky can snag one of the bed / couches. If you do decide to catch the sunset here, be sure to get here early for a seat or good spot on the beach (this place fills up fast, especially during warm summer days). As for the service/food, I recommend going elsewhere unless you can manage to get a seat along the windows. The food is good (not great) but priced a bit high for what you get. read more

Not really a restaurant. They kind of abandoned the food & service aspects of what a restaurant is supposed to be. They've pretty much resigned themselves to a place that offers drinks in a pristine setting, with a mix of somewhat attractive waitstaff. If your food is terrible or takes too long they tell you to get lost. They have adapted the Times Sq mentality that another wave of tourists will be here next week for us to screw over. Strictly for drinks ( preferably bottled beer or wine),& a great sunset. read more

Navy Beach - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

To start, Navy Beach is a beautiful setting on the Long Island sound. As a long time resident, I was thrilled to see an upscale place serving cocktails and delicious seeming food. Unfortunately, our dreams of a bar with gustatory excitement fell flat. A hippie friend of mine once postulated that calamari was made of pigs anus, and until I had the calamari at Navy Beach, I had poo poo'ed this idea. The calamari was the blandest excuse for a seafood dish I have ever experienced. The fish was lukewarm at best and accompanied by a large frisée salad dressed exclusively with jarred sweet chili sauce. When our cocktails arrived I hoped for respite. They were mixer heavy but tasty and who can complain about that on a warm July day? Our second dish was the Tuna poke-like dish. While the tuna seemed fresh, it was basically shredded flesh. It was topped with a yummy cucumber salad and ripe avocado but the compliments ended with the stale crispy rice atop. Unfortunately the starters were too dismal to encourage an entree, but maybe next time we're in for a fruity drink and pig parts we will find our way back. read more

Location is unbeatable, but the food is mediocre at best. Most dishes lacked flavor and needed salt or some acidity......and the fried chicken and fish special were so over fried they were completely dried out, the side of rice totally mushy. Come for a drink, leave for dinner time. read more

Navy Beach - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

HELP WAS HAMMERED. Literally. hammered. There were multiple things I can say about my experience but i'll keep it to the major ones. To start our waitress missed three dishes. After commenting on a missing appetizer she told us it would be right out... it never came and wasn't even on the check. I asked for my drink not once not twice but three times... each time after asking our drunken waitress replied with a smile and "right away". One time she even came back with drinks we never even mentioned. We also asked for our check three times. The last time our waitress approached the table and said "can i get you anything else"... she had already said this twice. To top it off the check had to be sent back to be revised because we were being charged for things we didn't get all. Despite the awful service the food was delicious. read more

Came here for my birthday dinner. Was basically rushed out while eating. To the point they put new silverware out and took my plate WHILE I was finishing up my food. If we were there 30 minutes that was a lot. And not for nothing, the food is so overpriced for dive bar quality. Never again. read more

The beach itself is beautiful for sunset but the staff is rude. Typical entitled hostess and management who belittles guests because we asked for outdoor seating. Great sunset views and food was good but sometimes the staff just ruins things you know? Waitress was fine but the front desk people are just entitled and rude. read more

What makes this place great is the beach setting, laid back decor, views and...that's where it ends. We arrived at 11:55 for our 12:00 lunch reservation. The hostess said they weren't ready but meanwhile took larger parties that arrived after us. 10-15 min later she seated us! We were the only ones to sit inside. We ordered and shared 2 small dishes-- the fish tacos and the ribs and 2 iced coffees. The big feature on the dessert menu-- the peanut butter bomb-- they were out of apparently since last night. Our bill with tip came to $50. The food was just ok but the setting was delightful. I can see how it would be fun for drinks and large crowds on a weekend night but it is not worth it for an out of the way lunch. read more

Third best sunset view among Montauk restaurants. Excellent food and attentive service. Can enjoy a drink or sit for full meal. Parking can be an issue, but that's Montauk. read more

Navy Beach - Sunset June 2014 - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

The view is great, the service was good. Clam chowder was good and mussels were ok. Main courses were expensive and over cooked.

Got to the restaurant on time and were seated in an empty ballroom. The waiter was snide and kept trying to rush us along. Food was completely indifferent, expensive for what we got and served as though they wanted us out of there before we even started. We were a group of ten and we got the impression we were doing the restaurant a favor. read more

I don't know where to begin. Pulled up to meet friends visiting from Miami and were told we couldn't get out of the car or enter the restaurant. Aggressive and mean at valet stand. Tried to explain we were meeting friends who were visiting. With our 2 kids and we are locals. Treated like crap. We left and drove our car down the road to call our friends who we couldn't enter the restaurant to meet and someone from the restaurant attacked us and told us to leave. Have never experienced anything so rude ever. Don't attend. Pretentious. Not the Hamptons read more

Navy Beach made the decompression from inland life to beach life possible. My Belvedere Vodka, Lime and Ginger Beer Cocktail known as the Ferretti just what the doctor ordered. A bevy of small plates of tuna tartar, salmon ceviche and edamame started the evening off perfectly. Catch of Day was a whole fried Black Bass in Mustard with tomatoes and grapefruit - Superb! Truffle Mac, and Mary's Papadelle rounded out the night. After dinner a beautiful sunset posed for pictures as we lounged on the bean bags tossed along the shoreline - hard to get up and leave. Support the Navy Seals eat at Navy Beach. read more

This place had an overload of awesome restaurant potential but unfortunately failed to deliver it all. Let me expand - the Navy Beach restaurant is situated in the middle of nowhere, basically, down a small road that is truly off the beaten path of Montauk. When you get there, you struggle to find a parking spot and, in the process of doing so, nearly run over about three people. Extremely cramped parking situation they've got going on here. Once we got into the restaurant, I was significantly impressed by the ambiance they had going on. The bar area is gorgeous, a lounge-y feel with big mirrors and bottle-themed stained glass. The sound system pumps out progressive house music and for a moment I felt I was back home in some trendy LES bar in Manhattan. We had a few minutes to spare in there, and were then seated as per our reservation (which I'll touch on later). Menu is small but extremely diverse. Lobster ceviche for appetizer and fried chicken for dinner? Hell yeah, sign me up. On that note, the ceviches are freakin' awesome. Truly an expensive indulgence but one worth it nevertheless. After realizing they were out of the fried chicken (aww) I ordered standard Montauk linguini and red clam sauce, spiced up with some chorizo and large chunks of juicy tomatoes. It was delicious but nothing special, as I totally thought it would be. The menu really looks like everything is going to modern and "new" spins on everything, but in reality, it didn't really feel that way. By this time, it was after 8:00, the sunset came out. OMFG. I have never seen a sunset like that, ever. If you have a window table, you are in for the one of the craziest experiences of your beachgoing life. People immediately gravitate towards the outdoor patio (which is just a hang-out spot, no tables) to take photos. Desserts were nothing special, I had a key-lime tart (my absolute favorite) and was largely unimpressed. Overall, this was an interesting dining experience and the sunset is awesome, but you can experience pretty much the same thing on another location on the beach without eating at the restaurant. It is a very expensive restaurant and I didn't feel I really got my money's worth, I could've easily ate just as delicious food somewhere else in Montauk. I wouldn't come out of my way to eat here again. Note on reservations - this is an insanely popular place now, and they do not take reservations more than a week in advance. That being said, if you want to go, call exactly 7 days before your desired date or you will probably find yourself out of luck. read more

I made reservations at Navy Beach two weeks in advance and snagged (what I thought was) the last table. I anticipated sitting on the water, but when we arrived (albeit a half hour early) I was disappointed that we were seated inside. Part of me wonders if we would have been outside, had we shown up at our designated time. Anyway, I digress. The views, even from inside, are breathtaking. For dinner, I ordered the salmon, which was SO FRESH (perks of ordering seafood in Montauk) and my date ordered the burger. Both of us left with clean plates and full bellies; would definitely return. read more

Navy Beach - VERY fresh salmon, but could have used a more substantial side dish IMO. - Seafood Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Sun and being stress-free definitely puts me in a good (reviewing) mood. So my opinion about this place might be rather biased since I was able to lounge around at this chic eatery cleverly disguised as a beach, and tucked away in a little corner of Montauk and that's light years away from all the clamor and bustle of the city. The bar has fabulously priced drinks all around ~$5 for a draft and ~$8 for a cocktail. Try the strawberry mojito, great of quenching thirst out in the hot sun. Outdoor seating is a must for all you sun-lovers and you can take a quick dip in the ocean while you wait for your food. Be cautious that this beach is rather rocky and not a place for you to run amok without your flip-flops on. Service is pretty slow, not sure if our blonde waitress was giving us the eye-roll underneath her Ray-Bans but our order took about 45 minutes to be released from the kitchen and water refills were scarce. Blondie was nowhere to be seen when we wanted an extra fork or bottle of Heinz. The food however was surprisingly delicious and the menu included a variety of seafood: from tuna tartare salad (tiny portion) to scallops on a bed of greens, to a rather expensive $37 lobster roll. There was limited non-seafood and veggie options: only their signature burger for those that eschew fish and the truffle mac-n-cheese for our cow-friendly friends. I definitely recommend the truffle mac-n-cheese, mexican corn, calamari and tuna tartare. Stay away from the fihs-n-chips, it's a fried, artery-clogging mess. All the menu items are a tad on the expensive side but by the time our $600+ bill came (we had a party of 10), we were all so imbibed with rum that we happily forked the money over. Come for the scenery and the experience! read more

It was generally good. The only reason I am writing this review is to tell you not to order the fried chicken. $32 three pieces and not very tasty. Want chicken? Go to Herbs Market in town. Whole fried chicken $14 and is the greasiest, saltiest, tastiest chicken you'll ever have. read more

Horrible Horrible experience. Arrived at Navy Beach restaurant around 4pm with my brothers, nieces and nephews. There was 13 of us. We tried to get an reservation but was told all the tables were reserved. At that point of time there was a considerable amount of empty tables. We were hungry so we ordered food and drinks at the bar. Two hours later the same tables sat empty. I asked to speak to a manager. I asked her how for the past 2 hours tables sat empty and how the restaurant had poor management skills. She claimed I was screaming at her - but it was loud and I did not think I was screaming. Within 10 minutes my family was surrounded by walkie talkies and security asking us to leave. It was bizarre and in my opinion very disturbing. This restaurant does not deserve to stay open - we did nothing wrong. read more

What a cute place. This is both romantic and breathtaking. Definitely go for the outside seating for the great view of the Fort Pond Bay. They have cute seating and amazing food with great views.I had the lobster roll special with fries. It was so fresh with great texture and powerful flavors. The music was on point which was an added touch. A perfect option for lunch at Montauk. A must for for sure! read more

An exquisite dining experience . Hostess can be a bit snobbish once you arrive after that the experience it all yours. Make a reservation in advance if you want outside get there at 5:15 check in and wait for the table at 5:30 once they open . Food is incredible they have small kids menu child friendly although some patrons may not like it the restaurant allows it . Food : apps : crab-cake , tuna , ceviche all fantastic Fritters not so great Dinner ; fried chicken awesome crust and batter but heavy entree Scallops : awesome brown butter sauce and pan seared . Salmon: fresh standard good decent size can't go wrong . Parmesan fries awesome Dessert : peanut butter pie crazy good and moist . Remember we bring your camera awesome sunset . read more

We showed up here Friday night for a late dinner. We got there a little after 10 and the kitchen was closing at 10:30, so we made our food and drink decisions pretty quick. We didn't have the option to sit outside, since it was so late, but it was also crazy foggy so I'm sure we would not of had a good view anyway. We got a bottle of Rose, and went with something from Long Island's Northfork. I forget the name of it, but it was good and decently priced. Then we split a couple small plates and got 3 entrees to share between the four of us. We got the mussels and crispy rock shrimp to begin with. Both were good! The sauce with the shrimp had a good kick, and the shrimp were good, not too greasy for being fried. The sauce with the mussels was really good, and they gave us a bunch of bread to dip in it. For our mains we got the pasta dish, scallops and the burger. All of it was great, and plenty of food, we couldn't even eat all of it! The pasta was pretty light actually and served with veggies. The scallops were cooked perfectly! The burger was also really good. It had a bacon-onion marmalade on top, soo good! The fries were nice and crispy, but it was too much food and a lot of them got left behind unfortunately. We skipped dessert, since we were so stuffed, but decided to stick around for one more bottle of wine before heading out. I felt a tiny bit bad a one point when I realized we were the only people there and probably holding them up from leaving, but they didn't say anything or make us feel awkward about it. We finished up the wine and left with the rest of the staff. Overall food was really good! I think it's supposed to have a really nice view, so it would have been nice if we were there on a better night and could actually see. The way we split the food it was plenty and wasn't even too expensive. Would definitely go back, if I'm in Montauk, and hopefully earlier so I could enjoy the view. read more

See all

Sunset! This review is not for food, only a drink on the beach to enjoy the sunset. Great set up, adirondack chairs and couches on the beach. Service was subpar, but we got our drinks and were able to enjoy a beautiful sunset. Its worth the trip for that!! read more

Overpriced and overrated!!!!!! Everything was decent enough but I definitely felt like I spent an eff ton of money on dinner and left hungry (not a fan). read more

Despite some of the reviews I've read here, tried navy beach anyway. Just couldn't resist the location. It is a bit off the beaten path to find, but you do find it, it's worth the trouble. Stopped in for a late lunch around 3ish. The food was very good we had the mussels, fish tacos, and Calimari. All very good and enjoyable. Service was very attentive but not over bearing. One negative, to some not me, is when eating outside it can get quite hot as your sitting in the sun. The day I stopped in it was breezy so they didn't want to open the umbrellas, understandably. The service was on point though as they immediately brought a pitcher of water. I would recommend this place and visit again when in the area. read more

If it weren't for the sunset, there would be no reason to come here. Used to be a hot spot, trendy and a draw. Now it's just a few annoying ditsy barely dressed hostesses seating their friends and telling you it's an hour wait when you have a reservation. They rush out out in an hour and won't let you order unless every single person at the table is ready to order their entire meal from appetizers to entree. Little kids will be running circles around you the entire time a muck while you try to enjoy dinner on the shore. Everyone seems to have learned - hang out here for a cocktail at sunset, enjoy the colors and then head out to dinner. read more

Ambiance and view? 5 stars. As far as the service and food, it was the worst dining experience I have had out here. A girlfriend and I had dinner and we thought it was strange that literally as soon as we placed our order-the food came out 3 minutes later (crab cake/fried chicken/side of cauliflower/side of parm fries). But whatever-maybe they were just on it in the kitchen. food was okay-nothing spectacular and nothing was really hot. Our server never checked in seeing if we needed anything (the sauce for the fries) and the busboy pretty much took care of us which was sweet. The next time she did come over (while we were still eating) she said "you're fine, right?" and we were like ummm yeah we are fine-meaning we didn't need anything at the time. (bus boy had already brought the sauce) then she comes over and drops the check while we were eating! and proceeds to tell us we need to pay because they have other reservations coming in. I was dumbfounded. I have never been told that we had to leave. So i expressed that and she said we have been there for an hour and forty five minutes. I honestly thought this was a joke because we had made a reservation for 7:15 and it was 8:02 at this point and we weren't even sat right away so there was no way that was true, and if she took the time to check with the hostess stand she would have known that. I asked to speak to a manager because i was just appalled and at this point we felt so rushed to eat our food and go, so then she proceeded to explain herself over and over (because it was clear at this point she didn't want to get in trouble and bring a manager over). She then said "you can stay" and shockingly we were thinking, "okay thanks for letting us stay at the restaurant we are paying $35 for overpriced cold fried chicken". So i asked again for her to bring a manager over. A manager comes over and has a totally different story for us. She said she understood there had been a miscommunication with the server. (which was not the case obviously) and that the server thought we had been there for a while and that they had a lot more reservations which the manger mentioned they don't in fact have anyone waiting so we could stay. Not once did the manager apologize and just kept saying over and over that we could stay. unbelievable. the server then came over ten minutes later and dropped the check. awful experience. go for a drink if anything just for sunset and save your money to eat somewhere worth it. read more

Came here with low low expectations based on the reviews and ordered accordingly. We came on a weekday afternoon, so the place was relatively empty and the waiter was super friendly and easy. We ended up trying the ceviche, which was pretty darn good considering my hesitation. Not Peru level ceviche, but certainly no complaints. I'd come back for it. Wife had the caesar salad, since it is hard to screw that up, and they didn't. Both are overpriced, but you're paying for the decor and convenience. I had the Painkiller, which was really good and the S.O. had a santgria rosa, which she found slightly disappointing, but i don't remember why. They've got a bocci ball court right there and if you're with kids, the beach can serve as your baby sitter while you relax with a drink. read more

Came for a drink & apps for sunset. Great glass of wine & cool ambiance. The fried calamari salad was delicious. Shrimp corn fritters had no taste. Basically just fried dough. Mussels were ok, but nothing great. There are better sunsets at the Montauket, but the bean bag chairs & vibe of this place are really gorgeous. read more