Many of my family members have talked about how much they enjoy New Hope Mills & I was excited to try it yesterday for the first time! The staff were attentive & friendly. The atmosphere was comfortable & casual. The food was very good & served freshly made. I went with a sandwich this time but for my next visit I will certainly be trying their pancakes. Again- genuinely looking forward to our next visit. read more

See all

The food and the service were very good. The seating was a bit cramped, and arriving on a busy Saturday in February turned out to result in a significant wait for a table. There were some samples to try while we waited, however, so that was nice. Essentially, this is like a local version of a Cracker Barrel complete with a shop of interesting things. The breakfast skillet was tasty and I really enjoyed their toast. The burger was seared well for flavor, but still juicy and the fries had good flavor and crispiness. I enjoyed the semi campy vibe of the restaurant and store in a way that a corporate place would not accomplish. read more

New Hope Mills - Mills burger with house cut fries. - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

See all

Gluten free pancakes and waffles were right on point. Staff were attentive and helpful.

The food was great and our server was even better! You won't be disappointed. Breakfast and lunch served all day.

Delicious breakfast served in a homey atmosphere. I really enjoyed my blueberry pancake. They serve real maple syrup as well. The service was fast and friendly. Love the pancake mixes which are available for purchase along with many other things. read more

This place is so cozy. The wait is always a little crazy on the weekends and they seem a little short staffed. But the food is solid and the coffee is great. Nice brunch spot with lovely ambiance. read more

See all

service was good, only waited 10-15min but we looked around the shop and got a few things, pancakes were really good! but they are definitely HUGE read more

New Hope Mills - chocolate chip - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

See all

I was looking for a place to meet a friend and this popped up. I was unaware of their flours, so the cafe was new to me. Good food and service. Big portions! A place I look forward to visiting again! read more

New hope mills has excellent mixes. Their pumpkin and buttermilk mix is excellent, especially if you substitute buttermilk for water. We were excited to have breakfast here. The service was great. Unfortunately the pancakes were terrible. A real disservice to the brand. They had no color, looked like they were cooked in no butter. Very dry and crumby. A tip - a hot griddle pan with some butter. read more

Finally made it here! Love the pancake and waffle mixes always wanted to eat here. Early Saturday morning made the 45 minute drive to check it off my to go list. Greeted warm and friendly hostess said about 30 minute wait. Not much seating so we decided to browse the small store area next to the eating area. maybe 15 minutes later our tracker vibrated and we were graciously seated. A few minutes later our waitress came to take drink orders. There was an iced dark chocolate with milk, whipped cream and crumbles sounded great but it was cold out and I was looking for something hot. The waitress said she would figure out a way and it would be hot. We had browsed the menu and ordered. I chose waffle over pancake with blueberry for my base and crumb topping added on an egg and home fries with onions. My co-eater chose 3 eggs over easy bacon ham and home fries adding a pancake and a birch beer soda. The waffle was light with a perfect crisp outside flakey blueberry inside and a brown sugary crunch topping. Egg medium cooked just right. Home fries are actually deep fried premade home fries but good and crispy and onions pan fried just enough to lightly carmelize. The 3 eggs were ordered over easy came out very medium. Pancake was banana caramel light and fluffy a little shy on flavors but good. That hot chocolate was to die for and I would go back just for that honestly. Overall came to $30 and change plus tip. Service was beyond excellent and our waitress was a lot of fun. Good value nice breakfast great service. Small dining area so expect to wait or go early for breakfast. They also have lunch. read more

New Hope Mills - View from our seat - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

See all

Awesome food !!! Highly recommended. Shop around the little store after eating. So many nice local things to buy.

I have not found a place in all of Central New York that has more delicious soups. I come here frequently enough, that Connie the chef, whom I considered to be the queen of soups, stops by our table to say hello. Extremely friendly and relaxed environment with great pricing. We stopped in last week and I had what I call the soup smorgasbord. Ordered three different soups all for myself :-) I only order soup when I go, but my husband can vouch for the other items on the menu! read more

New Hope Mills - minestrone soup, chili, and lovely French tomato soup - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

Casual eating at its best. Staff helped by checking in but not rushing decisions. Food was excellent and arrived in a short amount of time. Food was hot and done well. Not too sweet or too salty. Decorations were charming and relaxed. read more

Cute brunch cafe! I stumbled upon this place, and the interior is absolutely beautiful! Very rustic and homey vibes. They also sell their famous pancake mixes of every flavor you can think of from classic buttermilk to apple cinnamon to birthday cake to pumpkin spice. They also have jams, jellies, brownie and cookie mixes, soup ingredients, honey, kitchenware and souvenirs, and so much more. I ordered a single Apple Cinnamon Pancake and their Breakfast tacos. The pancakes were a bit underwhelming to be honest. They were fluffy and soft, but not much Apple or cinnamon flavor. It was nice with the salted butter and maple syrup, but I had expected more of an Apple cinnamon profile. The breakfast tacos consisted of 2 giant buttermilk pancake with scrambled eggs, peppers, sausage, and cheese. It was extremely filling, and the sausage had good flavor and meshed well with cheese and seasoned eggs. It was good overall, but not extraordinary and probably wouldn't get again. They also have samples around the store, and the Honey roasted peanut butter was the best peanut butter I've ever had. It had the perfect savory, nutty balance with the sweet roasted honey flavors. It was amazing with crackers too. Their Brownies were incredibly chocolately and had a lovely cakey, texture that simply melted in my mouth. Their giant chocolate cookie was also pretty good--crispy exterior and soft interior. I would have liked it to be a bit softer and chewier but still decent nonetheless. Overall, it's a cute brunch spot, and the staff were all very welcoming, attentive, and friendly. I would recommend stopping by, and definitely try their honey roasted peanut butter and brownies! read more

New Hope Mills - Apple cinnamon pancake and Breakfast Tacos - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

Lovely little place. Definitely recommend. Great restaurant, good food, menu has a wide variety of selections to suit anyone. The best! read more

See all

Love the the warm feeling you get when you walk in. We found this place while out on a Doctor appointment for my Great Niece who is having twin boys! Service was a bit wonky. Nice but a little slow and I did not know for sure who was waiting on us. There is a bit of a wait. I ordered a waffle and my niece had pancakes and eggs. It looked so good. The berries I had where fresh but had no juice or sugary syrups, that was disappointing. Mine was no hot at all not sure if hers was. I ate it and sent halfe home with her. They have a shop to buy food items and home made goods. We did pick up a few cookies for her little ines at home. I did enjoy it non the less. It was different and made you feel you were not home anymore. Like on a vacation. read more

See all

We went out to New Hope Mills to experience this great atmosphere of a place. When entering the parking lot be careful there are a bit of pot holes. The inside is great warm welcome. Great shop to find little things. Don't forget to pick up your favorite pancake mix. We sat down about 15 minute wait. The waitress was amazing. I ordered pancakes Carmel banana, bacon, home fries, and toast. The toast was amazing and pancakes as well. The only thing is home fries are regular deep fried type not homemade. The pancakes had a lot of flavor definitely tasted banana. Overall was a great time. read more

One of my favorite places. Huge menu variety, huge portions, and the food is always good. I especially like the atmosphere - fells like a log cabin, and the music is soft so you can actually talk with people. It's fun to look around the store; I didn't know pancakes have so many possible flavors! read more

Delicious and worth the wait! This was my wife's return trip to this restaurant in my first experience. My daughter had recommended the chicken and waffle with Sriracha to me and it sounded too good to pass up. My wife had the maple bacon waffle with eggs on the side. Neither of us were disappointed and we will definitely return again in the future! read more

See all

Very delicious had an omelet coffee was great atmosphere was warm and homey table available right away ty

Stopped in for breakfast and was not disappointed. Between my husband and I we had an omelette, home fries, bacon, scrambled eggs, pancakes, and toast. Everything was fresh and delicious. Even the toast tasted amazing, which certainly isn't the case everywhere. Plus they have real maple syrup! It was very busy but everyone was attentive and made sure each table was taken care of. We were in and out fairly quickly. This will be a regular stop for us whenever we're in the area. read more

Tried to get lunch here today. After waiting a few minutes at the hostess station a waitress tried to seat the couple standing behind me first, until I spoke up. Once seated, waited 10 minutes for someone to take my order. 3 waitress walked by, one was even refilling coffee cups on her way by. I left at this point, the place was not busy, there was no excuse for being treated this way. I will not be going back! read more

Love it here. The pancakes are delicious and they have lots of gluten free options. They make the best gluten free pancake mix. Unfortunately they have limited seating, so you may have to wait...if the weathers nice they have a nice porch to wait on. The cafe store is nice and sells their mixes. The servers are always friendly. read more

New Hope Mills - Chocolate Chip Pancakes - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

Great food, amazing people. Loved every Minute of it. Will definitely come again with my family read more

Connie was beautiful And very good Food was terrific!!! Definitely will be back everyday for the next 5-7 years read more

In the middle of rural New York, New Hope Mills is a gem! I visited my family for a week and they raved about this place every day and how wonderful it is! Thankfully I got to experience this myself as well! This restaurant is tucked alongside the road in what looks like a barn. There is any expansive parking lot that can handle more cars than the restaurant can seat. There is both inside and outside seating. The weather is beautiful so take advantage of the fresh air if there's a table available. On the inside there is both a restaurant and a shopping area. It reminded me of going into Cracker Barrel and I love me some Cracker Barrel. This shop is full of food items as well as household goodies. I was amazed at all the delicious smelling candles, 10+ types of pancake mix including gluten free options and well as all the dips/jams. The menu is expansive-there is both a breakfast and lunch menu. I chose the shredded chicken tacos off of the breakfast menu and they were delicious. Sadly they didn't come with the corn jalapeño pancakes as described on the menu which took away from the overall flavor. This is a cute place to eat with family and friends! read more

New Hope Mills - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

My family loves going to New Hope Mills. Their Banana Caramel French toast is my usual go to, but occasionally I'll try their monthly specials! read more

New Hope Mills - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

I struggled with whether this should be 3 or 4 stars. The menu options were good and so was the food, but nothing about it was great. I try to look at things through the lens of current events and ask if any thing is simply due to the limitations of the pandemic. In this case I think it would still be a 3. Everything was good, but nothing was great. I had a BLT with French Onion Soup. The BLT was good, adequate amount of bacon but not a lot. The soup was very good. The service was slow; we were the only ones there and it was still slow. All in all, it's worth going to once for the novelty if you are a fan of New Hope Mills products, and I wouldn't avoid the place, however I wouldn't go out of my way to go back. read more

See all

While staying at one of the local hotels, we asked for a good local spot. The two employees at the hotel both said you must eat at New Hope Mills. It's a local favorite that guests always love too. They were right. So happy we asked! Always ask a local. They know best. My husband absolutely loves breakfast. I knew we had to try it. So happy that we did! He loves pancakes and theirs were huge. He could only eat two. I'm really glad I tried them. They were so light and fluffy. I'm obsessed with corned beef hash. Theirs was the perfect amount and very good. We also got a chocolate milkshake to mix it up. It was creamy and delicious. When checking out, a local told us we must try a chocolate chip cookie. So glad we did! They were so moist and delicious as a snack when traveling. We loved their gift shop and got so many goodies. I wish they were closer. We made their biscuits at home. At first, we were a little intimidated because we had never done it before but it was pretty easy and they were so worth it. Unreal! My husband also loves the grits they bought. My mother in law loved the chocolate chip cookie mix we bought her. My mom absolutely loves the orange marmalade. Everything is so reasonably priced. Wish we lived closer. Can't wait to go again when we're back up in the Finger Lakes! Definitely go check it them out. Everything is great. read more

I bought some cookie mix from here and while I was making them with my husband, we found a Bible verse on the package of the mix! That verse really spoke to me and I really think it was meant to be there! The atmosphere was cozy and the service was incredible! It was a little busy but worth the wait! "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God" Ephesians 2:8 My husband and I went here for breakfast and the food was amazing! I really recommend this place! Will definitely be back to try lunch read more

New Hope Mills - Cookie mix - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

Lunch at the New Hope Mills Cafe made it a well worthwhile trip to Auburn, NY. Auburn is well known as the site of one of NY's maximum security prisons, but the architecture of the old mansions in the residential area are a senic triumph for the visitor to relish. Speaking of relish, there was none on my plate, but the thick bacon BLT I enjoyed for lunch was perfection. Meg's roast beef sandwich with mac & cheese, and our guest's enormous cheesburger were reportedly delicious. Portions were filling, and the ladies had to carry the leftovers home to enjoy later. We were seated immediately, and our server was not only delightful, but efficient, leaving us wanting nothing. The store. Ah, the store. We shopped among the various flours they produce at the actual mill, and found some other objects to buy as well. The ladies ended up with pancake, and corn bread mixes. I found chocolste covered peanut clusters and a couple of huge cookies to carry out. There's tons of neat stuff to select from, so be sure to peruse the shelves. In a word, our lunch experience here was...perfect. I highly recommend stopping here for breakfast or lunch. Why not both, if you're enjoying time in this part of the Finger Lakes Region? read more

See all

I saw this place on GPS on my phone. I Saw the reviews and knew I had to come here for breakfast. WOW! This place is amazing. The BEST breakfast I've ever had. Try the key lime pancakes. Huge servings! Love this place. We are from Pennsylvania but would come back here just for this place. It's THAT good! read more

took awhile to get seated and short staffed in the kitchen, but worth the waitlist . Shopping was awesome

Terrific brunch while we caught up with old friends. Fun atmosphere, friendly staff, great food. Highly recommend and hope to visit again! read more

New Hope Mills - Fresh fruit, Chicken & waffle, brunch scramble, biscuit, and fresh, hot coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

High quality food. Friendly service. Great prices. Hometown feeling. Pleasant atmosphere

absolutely spectacular!.serve was great and food was very good. Highly recommend!!!

The service is great. The food is great and the atmosphere is perfect! What more could you ask for?

We stopped here on the way to Aurora, NY. It's about 30 minutes from there. I'm glad we did! It was an interesting place, and store! They have samples of jam and crackers too right as you enter. I tried the pumpkin spice jam - it was so perfect! I knew after trying that I would enjoy the food here. Their mask rules are pretty lax, and to waitresses didn't wear any either. It didn't bother me too much. We had pretty quick service here which was perfect. There were a bunch of people still here for lunch around 1:30 PM! I ordered the eggs your way and my husband ordered a breakfast bowl. The egg whites with veggies (inside and American cheese) were delightful! Not too heavy! Their potatoes tasted exactly like a French fry which I didn't object to. The toast - I put strawberry jam on it which was amazing. All in all a great experience and I know my husband enjoyed his food. Honestly the only reason this is rated a 4 is because I wanted a soup and they didn't have any non-beef/non-meat options! It's important to have some veggie options imo. Quick service, great food, a big thumbs up from me! read more

New Hope Mills - Breakfast bowl (or something like that) - Bakeries Near Me - Auburn, New York

See all

This was a gem of a place! Unusual, quaint, clean and the food was great and the service excellent. My friends and I had brunch like items; waffle hamburger, crepes, and corn jalapeño pancake tacos. Each of us was satisfied with the portion size and quality. Coffee was good too. And the bonus brownie at the end was delicious. The shopping inside was awesome. So many things to purchase. If it weren't for Yelp reviews we honestly would have driven on, don't be deceived by the area and outside. This was one of our favorite stops of our Finger Lakes weekend. read more

Food is always wonderful! Service is not always great. The main server, Carmen, can be moody & rude. We only go there when we're visiting family, because we enjoy the food. The store itself is quaint & pleasant. Mirroring a mini Cracker Barrel. read more