Still the best bagels in San Diego! Go early because they are the best and may sell out. I've read other reviews and it's just not fair to dock stars because they are out when you get there! It's because they are so good! Don't expect them to lose money making bagels to keep them sitting in stock for the random afternoon one person may show up. These are freshly baked! They are best freshly eaten! I have to always tear into one as soon as I get them. Where else can I devour an entire everything bagel with no spread! They are that delicious! No butter necessary. Just full of flavor! Don't pay any attention to the low star ratings. Absolute self-centered rubbish. The employees work so hard making these bagels early every morning! Just be a good bagel and get there early (before 9:30) and enjoy! They also make a darn good caramel macchiato. read more

I love tuna sandwiches, so why not have a tuna bagel? Came in on a Saturday afternoon with a craving for a tuna bagel. I got the tuna with an onion bagel and it was delicious! The guys that helped me were super nice and attentive. Lots of space to eat. Got my food at the perfect time, before the rush! I can't wait to come in more and try their other specialities. read more

New York Bagels - Tuna with onion bagel - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

Great lottle bagel, tea, and panini shop. Stopped by for a quick bite and ordered a Reuben and chait tea latte. Service was awesome, very nice and friendly. The panini was perfectly toasted and lots of flavor. The chai tea was ok. It had lots of ice and milk and some chai. read more

See all

Very easily some of the best bagels in north county, possibly all of San Diego. I recommend going when they first open or close to it to have the most options. Every time I've come here the staff is always great. The store is always clean and the bagels are delicious! read more

Bagels: 4.5 Coffee: 3.1 Customer service: 4.2 Visiting family so we usually stay at the RB Courtyard down the street, but wife needed to eat before she goes shopping with her BF. So instead of going to McD's, I decided on bagels. I'm so glad that I did, even on a Saturday morning there was a steady flow of customers so there was a line to order. We order: an Everything and an Asiago cheddar bagel both with cream cheese and a house coffee and a Carmel macchiato. The bagels are cooked right front of you: fresh, OMG soft, and tasty!!! We ate the majority of our food before taking a pic. Their house coffee is from Seattle Best but the selection of flavors were just okay. And my wife said her Carmel macchiato was okay, but she rarely gives a review on her food / drink. There are other food items on the menu board so we'll need to return to try those next time in town. Just be aware that if you order a bagel, $2.75 then add cream cheese the price jumps to $5.25. read more

New York Bagels - Asiago Cheddar Bagel w/cream cheese. There's plenty of cream cheese on one bagel to share. - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

I want to like this place, but I also like bagels, and they always seem to be out of everything every time I come here! I walked in and saw there was 1 blueberry bagel. Great! Nobody else was in the shop, so I figured I was in luck. There was 1 guy working behind the counter. No greeting, no "I'll be with you in a second". He was just straight up grinding, handling online orders or something. Then he grabs that last blueberry bagel and throws it into a bag. Okay... I guess I'll go for a different flavor, how about Everything bagel. Nope, apparently online orders also snagged the last of those, too. I had to wait around 10 minutes before the guy asked me what I wanted. By that point, my backup choices were gone and I had to go to one of those 3rd rate bagels that nobody eats (who even orders a Munster Cheese bagel?) At least there was seating. In fact, I was the only person dining in. Any other people coming were just doing pick up orders. It was just a bit disheartening that the customers actively in the restaurant had to wait, but online orders were done immediately, especially when I saw that the first online order pickup person came about 20 minutes later. It feels like they could have just taken an inventory for their online orders, and then handled the people who were there first, so we wouldn't have to wait so long. The bagels themselves are good, if you can get the flavor you want. The place is named "New York" bagel, which it isn't exactly a New York bagel, but the flavor is fine. I wish they either had more people helping out, or had a higher inventory of their popular flavors. As it is, I don't know if this place is worth going to unless you go earlier in the morning. Maybe next time I'll just order online so I don't have to wait 10 minutes to talk to someone. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

The bagels are the BEST I'm the area. I ordered a baker's dozen. I had six different kinds of bagels. All exceeded my expectations. Delicious! read more

We ordered a surprise bag from Too Good Too Go for pick up before 2:30pm. We got two bags stuffed with bagels (14 in total I believe for $7). There were a few cranberry (which are always my favorite), a few wheat and mainly plain bagels. They we light and fluffy on the inside and a bit chewy on the outside and were all tasty. The bagels were great on their own toasted with butter but they also made great sandwiches. We have been here a few time before and the bagels and food never disappoint. The staff is always great and the store is easy to get to with plenty of parking. There is also a decent amount of seating inside or you can take your bagel and schmear to go and sit at the near by Webb Lake. Great place, food, and people. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

Bought a variety of breakfast bagels for the family. Everything was great would recommend and return.

Standard bagel shop in the neighborhood. Has been around forever. Small interior and parking lot but good to grab a quick bite or a dozen to go read more

The staff were so sweet and it was my first time coming here and trying it out! Just so happened I pass this place all the time from my dad's work. I got an albacore tuna on an everything bagel and a pesto chicken on a jalapeno cheddar for my friend. once I took a bite in my car I couldn't stop eating. Evrything tasted so fresh and every bite was good. A well put together bagel and definitely coming back! read more

See all

This small bagel shop has great, hot bagels and great breakfast sandwiches. You can pickup up or dine in. read more

New York Bagels - Delicious bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

I crave their bagels all the time. Every Tuesday I will get either a plain bagel with jalapeño cream cheese or a blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese. I prefer it not toasted just for the bite and texture, but toasted is great too. Lots of selection and they have more than just bagel as well so a great place for breakfast and a coffee. Service was fast but friendly. read more

Had a order good to go and cancelled it while i was already there. He should at least to it much earlier..

A cute place in a small plaza, be careful of the parking lot! Spaces are really small. Order at the counter and pay once you get your food type of vibe, with lots of sandwich options!! read more

Wow... stopped off at New Bagel and Cafe with my 3 Daughters and Mom from Tucson,AZ... I had the Mew Bagel with Bacon,Egg, cheese EVERYTHING bagel.. .. Not only with it Amazing the bagel had seasoning on both sides.. My mom had the Oatmeal.. she said it was Amazing... my Daughters had the plains bagel with cream cheese.. They also said it was Amazing c. The owner was really nice and was really informative on how they make their bagels and cream cheese in house. I would totally recommend this place to start your morning off.. read more

See all

Hidden gem in a small shopping mall with bagels that truly taste like what I remember in New York! They are fabulous, with soft inside and a soft crunch on the outside and light cornmeal on the bottom. Ordered a jalapeño cheddar bagel, lightly toasted with their house chive cream cheese. So delicious! And a garden veggie sandwich. As I was waiting this morning I could see them baking the bagels, which was really cool! Nice little chairs inside you can sit and enjoy your food. Service was very fast and helpful! Highly recommend stop if you are in the area! read more

See all

I popped in here for breakfast because Robeks was closed. This was a mistake. I ordered the classic bagel sandwich with turkey. When I tell you that this thing was flavorless it is an understatement. I ended up just throwing it out. The coffee was ok, but wasn't really fresh. They were polite and quick and that is why I am still giving three stars. read more

We are so lucky to have NY Bagels! Lovely people that truly know authentic New York bagels. I'm from the East Coast and have been co.ing here for the real thing for years. Brought my New Jersey bative friend today, and he was like a man finding water in the desert. How do you do it, NY Bagels?!?? Please never stop because there's nowhere else in California to get real bagels read more

Can't believe I'm just hearing about this place now. Been driving by for years and finally stopped in to buy some bagels. I was impressed with the chewiness and softness -- definitely a standout among bagel shops in San Diego. It's prob as close as you can get to a real NY bagel. Also: a BIG plus -- they have rainbow bagels! I used to drive to OC just for this but it's cool they have them here, and you can get rainbow bagels for your bagel sandwiches! read more

I hate doing bad reviews but I need to. I love this place so much my bf who's from NY loves this place. But my order today was burnt with barely any cream cheese and it tasted like burnt bread no flavor unfortunately. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

There's nothing more heavenly than a hot fresh egg bagel from this place! I swear if I could choose one food to eat for the rest of my life it would be an egg bagel with cream cheese and lox from this place'! My son said not to leave this review because we should " gate keep" these egg bagels like they are our little secret. They are so "fire". Yum!! read more

I'd rather go across the street to get bagels. I feel these bagels are more bready with a hole in the center. The people here obviously work long hours, but they kind of always give a bit of a hard sell, " anything else ? " " any cream cheese? ". No, thanks. It could've been better. read more

The bagel was delicious! They had a fresh batch just as I arrived and the bagels look just as good as they taste! read more

New York Bagels - Everything bagel with egg & cheese - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

The parking lot gets hectic but the bagels here are good! Service is usually quick and friendly, especially if you're just grabbing a bagel and cream cheese. I highly recommend their bagel sandwiches though. They are amazing and hit the spot every time. They also make their own cream cheese and have good flavors to choose from! read more

Just have to say these are simply the best bagels I've ever had. Super fresh, still oven warm even coming from Uber Eats. Place is phenomenal read more

Surprisingly great bagels. As a native New Yorker I have no expectations at all of eating good bagels on the west coast. I've been dissapointed so many times, I just don't seek out good bagels out west. Of course, bagels on the east coast are better, but the bagels I received from this shop were pretty great. I confirmed that no one at the shop is actually from New York, but the bagel recipe comes directly from New York. I got a dozen bagels for my family (sesame, everything, cinnamon raisin, a plain and a sun dried tomato -- all great). I also ordered a really nice oatmilk latte. The service here was top notch as well. Everyone was so nice and I even got some bagels fresh out of the oven at around 9am. There is some seating here and I saw a couple families enjoying their breakfast in the medium sized shop, but I wasn't here for the ambience, just a dozen bagels to go. read more

Came to this spot on a Saturday during lunch because its local corporate competitors were sold out. Parking lot was a little tight but plenty of spots available. What sets this place apart from other places was as soon as I walked in, I was instantly greeted by the kind staff with a smile. They had plenty of bagel flavors available. Ordered bacon egg and cheese on plain bagel and bagel and lox and both were so delicious. The bagel had a nice crunchy crust and was soft on the inside. Happy to say I'll be coming here more often. read more

New York Bagels - New York Smoked Salmon-Lox - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

We saw the sign and ended up changing our breakfast plans. I've never heard of the shop before so we were taking a chance and we ended up really enjoying it. We both got jalapeño cheddar bagels. One with chive cream cheese and the other with garden veggie. Both were really good and the jalapeño was actually a little bit spicy which I wasn't expecting. Service is friendly and I really like that you could see them making the bagels - something I've never seen before. We were surprised how popular the place was too read more

Best bagels in San Diego County imo. Always fresh and often still warm with a lot variety to choose from. We always order ahead to grab and go. read more

Ummmm well let me just say that I had high expectations from a business that was named New York Bagel. The staff were very friendly and the restaurant was nice and clean. The orange juice was good... but the bagels... ummmmmm. read more

See all

Such a great bagel experience! We are from upstate NY so we know a good bagel! Toasty fresh sandwiches - definitely recommend. Plus the owner was there and he was a great guy. Very customer oriented and helpful. read more

Service was amazing, super friendly staff, and well maintained seating area. All of the bagels were fresh, cream cheese selections were great, and the perfect combinations with bagel selections of your choice can be out of this world. Definitely will return to this place!! Great job, thank you. read more

See all

Bagels aren't always on my top of the list when a snack or meal is on my agenda, but that may have just changed. I've been working around RB for over a decade, and I've only eaten their bagels when a coworker randomly brings bagels from here. I've always enjoyed them every time. Very recently, I figured it was my turn to bring the bagels, and so after many years, I stepped foot here first thing in the morning and ordered a dozen bagels for my team at work. I ordered a variety of bagels from wheat, plain, blueberry, cheese, everything, and cinnamon sugar. There were no leftovers, so it was safe to say everyone enjoyed them. I bought smoked salmon, honey walnut, and plain cream cheese. All of which I've had previously and had again and rest assured...all are delicious. The cinnamon sugar bagel paired the best with the honey walnut cream cheese though (pro-tip and you're welcome). I also tried their Crispy Bacon breakfast bagel and they were able to hollow-out the bagel at my request. Solid breakfast bagel. The staff are really friendly and committed to helping you out despite being indecisive. Of the many bagel spots around, I may just stick to this place...even for when I go on my own whim and not only when I have it randomly at work thru a generous coworker:) read more

New York Bagels - Cripsy Bacon on hollowed out Wheat Bagel - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

BEST BAGELS EVER! we were just driving by one morning and stopped for a quick breakfast and so happy we did. The bagels are soft and tasty! Definitely will be coming here when in the area! read more

They're bagels but not as good as real New York bagels. They're proud of their prices.

Best bagels in San Diego and amazingly hard working and pleasant tenured staff. I always look forward to visiting this place for a toasted everything bagel with plain cream cheese and a fresh large coffee. This place has the freshest home made bagels, cream cheese and cleanest tasting coffee around. 100% approval rating for this place! read more

I'm sad because I TRULY think this place has potential for me... it was my first time today and it's awesome because as soon as you walk in you see them baking the bagels so you know it's legit & fresh! They do have a variety of bagel flavors, we got 3 breakfast bagel sandwhiches and 1 rainbow bagel with strawberry cream cheese & I spent $40 total... a little pricey but this is the norm in San Diego lol Anyway I'm only leaving a 2 star review because the bagels legit tasted like sink water every single one of them! I'm not sure if it's the machines they are using aren't cleaned properly or the water is heavily chlorinated tap water when boiling idk guys just assumptions on what it could be but it HAS potential! I Just cannot go back for this exact reason unless that's just how their bagels taste it was a Metallicy, sink water after taste and that's never happened to me before and I LOVE bagels so was definitely sad to write this but felt necessary. Other than that everyone was nice and place looked busy after we arrive there was a line stacking up read more

great place for bagels and sandwiches, super happy that they make chocolate chip bagels since a lot of bagel shops don't make those! read more

New York Bagels - rainbow bagel with lite herb & garlic cream cheese, turkey california sandwich on sourdough bread - Bagels Near Me - San Diego, California

Contender for worst Bacon Egg and Cheese on a bagel I've ever had. Egg was so overcooked the yolk was actually gray. Cheese was missing from half the bagel. The everything bagel might've been good on its own but I'll never know because I'll never go here again. read more