I tried the mozzarella sticks fresh out of the fryer, but they were a bit of a letdown. They looked homemade, but not in the best way--more like someone tried but didn't quite get there. They weren't stretchy at all, which kind of defeats the whole point of mozzarella sticks, though the flavor wasn't terrible. A little "yummy" in taste, but poorly done overall. I'd call them homemade, just not good enough to brag about it. read more

New York City Pizza - Cheese sticks - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

One of the best NY/NJ style pizzas in the Low Country. Prior to this visit every other pizza shop has been below standard. Pie was thin, foldable with a crispness and crust actually tasted like real NJ pizza. read more

New York City Pizza - Plain slice, nice size and texture. - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

Hidden gem in the Kroger shopping Center. Nothing fancy just good casual food. Service was great! Pizza, was as traditional as NY style should Be, crispy crust. Good sauce... Bonus Fried Zucchini stick are made from scratch! They do a lot of take out.. cant wait to Go back! read more

New York City Pizza - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

11-22-24 Friday night 7:30 pm Was in the area and I had this bookmarked to come here. Hubby goes what's their Yelp rating? I say but neighbors say it is good. The service and atmosphere were outstanding I would give them a five star rating. We were acknowledged the second we walked through the door to have seat we wanted. Our server immediately asked us what we wanted to drink. She was so fast I had to get my bearings quickly to see what they offered and decided on a Michelob Ultra hubby got a Budweiser both in bottles. We got a Zucchini Sticks as an appetizer. The zucchini itself was very large and fresh. With dipping sauce on the side. Also a large veggie pizza with sausage added. The pizza was ok. The only thing it is not NY pizza. But I give them this it is edible and better than Savannah Pizza. read more

See all

Poor side Caesar salad fir $8.72 dressing, very salty and yellow and color. Sicilian pie is very thin. read more

New York City Pizza - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

Sorry to say this but the pizza was overdone. Crust was hard. Toppings were not fresh. Had the Hawaiian pizza. Couldn't even cut it into slices. When I did, couldn't enjoy it due to bad taste and hard like dry wall crust! We need a good pizza place in Bluffton!! read more

The pizza and the service were great...the best pizza we've had since moving here from NJ...but it was a bit pricey for a 14" pizza with sausage and mushroom almost $30.00! read more

The staff was friendly. The basic pizza was thin and tasty, like NY style. But, we ordered pizza with peppers and onions. They were put on raw, and the pizza then heated in the oven, so they were still raw. We asked the waitress, she admitted it wasn't the right way to do it but that they were planning on changing that soon. They also charged us for the p & o's, even though they saw we didn't eat them. Not good for business. I ordered Italian wedding soup. Broth with chicken & veggies was great, but instead of mini meatballs, like it said on the menu, and like it's supposed to be, it was chunks of sausage. They are going to have a lot of trouble with return business. All I can say is whatever you are selling, do it right! read more

Great pizza, fun vibe, and good service with covered outdoor seating for those sunny days. read more

New York City Pizza - Inside Seating - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

Excellent pizza. Good char, good sauce/ cheese balance. Ordered online and food was ready before expected time. Knocked off a star for the price. Probably the most I've ever paid for pizza . read more

Don't waste your time and money on pizza or food, stay away from this place, don't go there and then say I should have listened to the reviews. Even the managers are nasty. read more

We were excited to try this place. As a native New Yorker I know a good NYC pizza. This did fit the bill Great sauce and crust. Tasty. We didn't have to wait to long for it either Will Order again read more

They have a CAPRESE that is magnificent.... Great Service.... Good Food... Amazing ambiance...

I hope there's better pizza in Bluffton. We started with a chopped salad. It was all lettuce with scant vegetables. I did enjoy the house vinegrette. We got a NYC special pie. The toppings were generous, but the crust was soggy in the middle. Even on the outside, it just wasn't crispy. If I come back, I'll ask for a well done pie. That said, I do hope to find better pizza. read more

Had friends in town and wanted to have a great pizza during football games. I ordered online - which looked like it was how their business executes delivery orders themselves. You are actually ordering from Doordash. One 16" 2 topping bacon & onion pizza with a 2 litre drink was over $50 with tip. $7+ delivery fee then they do their tip percentage after adding the $7. Pizza showed up before the 45 minute delivery window but was not even luke warm. Honestly looked like it was leftover from night before. After warming the pizza it was still so bland. read more

Ok I tried NY pizza at Buckwalter and it was better. I think their pizza is tasty and crust was good The staff is very nice and attentive even though busy place. read more

I'm standing at the end of the bar, waiting for my food to be prepared. I noticed that the cooks do not wear gloves when handling the food. The cook got offended and had an attitude because I said something to him about it......I'm like, really? but you are handling my food? I thought the manager would have been apologetic to the situation, and they did take something off, but it's the principal of doing what is right. When you know better, you do better. read more

Terrible customer service. Ordered pizza took more than 2 hours to be delivered and the customer service told me to just deal with it. Turns out after being told 3 times my order was in route, it was never made. 3 hours and still no pizza. I would not recommend this place to anyone. read more

The best food . The best service. And the best price.we always order food from NYC PIZZA for many years now...

NYC pizza is the only place that I'll eat pizza. it's almost as good as home. get it welll done!! that's the trick. Now, delivery is thru Uber eats. what a disappointment. I've ordered twice & both times the food was ICE Cold!!! so disappointing. Bring back your own delivery people. I don't want to start a new pizza search. read more

restaurant looks nice, but the food lacks flavor. My chicken parm was missing an ingredient, i don't know what it was. It was very bland. Same can be said about the pizza and meatballs. Also, I ordered on Grubhub, but when I went to the restaurant, but manager said there was no order from me. Then he told me that "they cancelled Grubhub but grubhub doesn't want to cancel them". This is absurd. It's your restaurant, you know it's on grubhub and that people are ordering food and not getting them. Isn't this a problem you should fix? I would not go back to this place. read more

We ordered a simple order or 3 pizzas and breadsticks and were told it would be ready in 35 minutes. I arrived 35 minutes later, and two of the pizzas were done, the other they told me would be done in 10 minutes. 20 minutes later, they said it will be done any minute. 30 minutes later, I said just give it to me in whatever state it's in. It was in their warming oven, the rude staff didn't even bother to look. Of the original 2 pies, both were cold, and one was over cooked. The third was fresh, and decent, but not worth returning for. Rude staff, bad food, high prices. A trifecta. read more

Not too bad. Got delivery after a day at the beach and was happy with the ease of ordering and quickness of delivery. Pizza arrived more warm than hot but was ok. Got a margarita pizza for my wife and I and a plain cheese pizza for the kids. The cheese pizza was good--nothing unique about it, but was tasty and in the NY style as promised. Margarita pizza was just ok...very skimpy on the toppings and the sauce was average at best, but again...tasty and not bad. I can't say it was good but I can say it wasn't bad. On the better side of average I guess. I'd eat the pizza again (the cheese, but probably not the more expensive "speciality" margarita). But almost $50 for two average pizzas, tip and delivery? Eh.... read more

NYC Pizza, Towne Drive location. Since moving to SC four years ago, this is the closest we have come to the pizza we enjoyed back in NY. Even better than some places there. We ordered a large pie half meatball and half eggplant. We were a bit disappointed with the skimpy portions of meatball, but more so with the small strips of eggplant. So small, you could barely taste it. We could reason that the ingredients cost a lot more for restaurants these days, and they have to make up for it. But this is not the way to keep loyal customers. Charge me a little more, but give me a nice hearty slice of pizza. Otherwise, the service here is super friendly and courteous. Our server, Cara G. was excellent! read more

So I call to order a pizza. And this is the response I get.... "Hello, thanks this is NY City Pizza. Happy LBTGQ+ Month, can I put you on hold? Five minutes later I hang up and call back. This time I get " hello, this is NY City Pizza can I take your order?" Place the order and my wife picks up. 8 slices with a s$6ty sauce and $29 dollars. For $29 dollars I won't be going back. I will make the trip to go to Mama G's for a $29 pizza. There's a pizza you can barely fit into the oven and has great sauce. read more

New York City Pizza - a slice of pizza - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

If you happen to be visiting Hilton Head South Carolina and you're looking for a great pizza stop by this place for a epic experience their food is delicious it's fresh and you get a lot of bang for the buck read more

My hubby & I have tried a lot of different pizza places around here and we have decided that this place has our favorite pizza. The crust is just right... nice texture & not too thick or too thin. The sauce is good, although I would like a little more. Amount of cheese is just right. We have never ate in, each time we have taken it home. read more

Has gone way down hill! Had been one of the better pizza joints in the past but now it is very very BAD! Pizza had little sauce and the cheese was a poor quality mix that had little or no mozzarella! Our eggplant parm hero was equally poor quality. Taste like a frozen prepared patty from Sysco or other and Hero bread was barely cooked. THIS IS NOT ANYTHING CLOSE TO NEW YORK CITY! read more

It was very good, we have recommended it to anyone we know going to Charleston being from NJ we were surprised how good it was

Just ate at this restaurant in Bluffton, South Carolina with my wife for the first time since we just moved into our new house here. I have the meatballs with extra marinara sauce. My wife had already got a pizza. Both a very good I would recommend this. read more

Clean, authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and great service. Came in for an impromptu lunch and I was severely impressed with the menu options and was not at all mad at the recommendation of the pasta bolognese. Highly recommend read more

I can't speak for all locations- but the Belfair location in Bluffton SC SUCKS. If you call to place a delivery order, they will put you on hold every time you call and tell you they are no longer delivering. Secondly- if they do take your call- you'll be put on hold three times during the call- and the store manager won't let you get two words in when you raise an issue about how many times you've been put on hold. I called the Buckwalter Bluffton location to order afterward. They took my order, processed my payment, then they called the Belfair location - the one I had an issue with, to get them to make and deliver my pizza!! REALLY??!! The driver arrived, came beating on my door after I asked for no contact delivery. She wasn't wearing a mask either. Her demeanor Was very confrontational, I asked her through the door to leave the pizza on my patio table. I walked out to get it, and to give her the cash tip I forgot to leave outside on the table- and she was FLIPPING ME OFF WITH HER MIDDLE FINGER FROM HER CAR IN FRONT OF MY DOORWAY, SCREAMING TO THE TOP OF HER LUNGS "DONT COME BACK, DONT CALL BACK !! Needless to say - she didn't get the tip! MY UPSTAIRS NEIGHBOR GOT THE WHOLE SCENE SHE WAS MAKING RECORDED AND ON VIDEO. I opened the pizza box- and there was slimy saliva all over my pizza where someone SPIT ALL OVER MY PIZZA The manager at Bluffton Belfair- Dina, kept cutting me off, would not let me get a word in to resolve the issue. It was bizarre. They were all a bunch of whiny baby whackadoodles. I was just trying to place a damn pizza order for God's sake'! They don't understand customer service. You will certainly get CUSTOMER NO SERVICE and a spit covered pizza if you object to being put on hold 20 times when you're trying to order a pizza. I paid 65.00 for a spit covered pizza and wings. Thanks NYCP. YOU SUCK. I will be sure to let everyone I know what I experienced and show them pictures of my expensive saliva covered pizza. read more

Staff is extremely friendly, and the food is okay, but it's nothing special. Pasta sauce is the most bland sauce I've ever had, but the rest of the food is decent. Wouldn't recommend the garlic bread either, but the pizza gets the job done. read more

I wanted pizza for lunch and decided to give them a try. I loved the crust which is thin and generous amount of toppings. I was able to order 2 slices of pizza( large slices) each different for my husband and myself. They were terrific. We will be back. About a 7 minute wait and you can call in an order if you choose to. Great pizza at a reasonable price. They were still hot by the time I drove home . read more

I have never been so shocked by a restaurant in my entire life. I walk in and it seems fine at first. My family is seated at a table and we get TOSSED torn up menus. I randomly got tossed a beer menu which was baffling to me. Then the server asks what we want for drinks. She comes out with the straws open and hands us our drinks. The side of my glass had a massive lipstick stain on it. Which is just plain disgusting. Then we got plates for our appetizers and my mom got a dirty plate. Later on after ordering I realize there is a pregnant lady who is working there that had a skimpy white tank top on. I could see her belly button and nipples and it made everyone incredibly uncomfortabl. You would think that there would be some type of dress code?? Then the food comes and it's fine nothing fancy. But I then smell a very strong smell of smoke. I look out the window and see a man smoking a massive cigarette. Which caused my asthma coughing to kick in. Then he took the rest of the cigarette, walked into the store. Threw it away in the open trash, whipped his hands on his pants and went and just started making pizza?! I was wildly concerned because he hadn't washed his hands and he just started making people food! That night I had terrible stomach pains and the next day I had food poisoning. Shocker as to why??? So save yourself food poisoning and a very strange experience and DO NOT GO. There should be some health code person to go and look at this place because seriously it isn't healthy or safe. read more

Omg such attitude! Cant stand the woman. Can it be better professionalism. You should be a lot more cheerful to have a job in these tough times. read more

New York style pizza place, pizza is not bad and the atmosphere is overall warm and inviting. We had 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 pineapple well done. read more

New York City Pizza - Italian Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

New York City Pizza participates in our community's 'Hungry Hearts' program which supports all of the local Food & Beverage employees and provides free meals to those who have lost their jobs to COVID-19. It was difficult for me to swallow my pride and accept the charity, but I couldn't be more grateful. The meal I had today was better than I had hoped for. I expected maybe a couple slices of pizza, but instead we were given multiple options to choose from. I got the philly cheesesteak, and it was perfect! Fresh baked bread and all. Delicious! Thank you so very much for looking out for your fellow foodservice workers, we appreciate you so much!! read more

Went to New York City Pizza Belfair location today. Defined the best pizza around, just like back home. I'll be sending all my friends there

Not sure it's the lack of inconsistency, bad QC, or they don't know how to make pizza. It was good five years ago. But now a English Muffin w ketchup and cheddar cheese beats it. So now I check out Sunset Pizza on 170. I honestly feel sorry for people who never tasted the North End in Boston or Mulberry Street in NYC. The crust tasted like Bisquick, the cheeses was dog shi$ domestic and the sauce was too sweet. They need to close. Never will I go back. read more