I've lived in Redlands for over a decade and never stopped in. My mistake. Cute little place. Friendly and fast service, cheap pints, and maybe the best crust I've ever had. read more

This was my first time ordering New York pizzeria pizza from DoorDash. I ordered a 14 inch pepperoni pizza with black olives on it. What I received was a cheese pizza black olive 14 inch I went back and looked at my receipt. Apparently it showed that I had put in a cheese pizza with black olives, but the picture above the cheese pizza with black olives that I ordered showed a pepperoni pizza so they folded me about the picture on DoorDash. I also ordered their potato wedges, even though they have seasoning on them they were tasteless. They were stale tried adding some salt that still didn't make them taste. Good I ordered extra ranch dressing because I thought this pizza place probably has the good ranch. No taste just like hidden Valley Ranch, which I don't like the pizza was OK, but it should've come a pepperoni definitely never ordering those potato wedges again I didn't say for the cheese pizza at least it's better than Domino's or Pizza Hut! read more

We had this delivered for dinner. Large pepperoni pizza with an order of potato wedges and an order of wings. They gave us a ton of ranch which was the best because some places are stingy. The food was delicious! I am sometimes picky on pizza but this was so good. I only wish the slices were bigger so that you could fold the pizza when dipping and eating it. The potato wedges and wings were good as well! I was worried the wings would be too hot but they weren't - I felt it was perfect. I would absolutely order from here again!! Yum! read more

Sauce that came with the delicious calzone was so good that I wanted to drink it. Best pizza and service. I will be a regular here and it's not even near my neck of the woods. read more

New York Pizzaria is predominately a takeout place, but still has quick service. Since they are located on the street side of the building, parking on the street is the most efficient, but there is parking in the rear. You can see inside pics, but keep in mind it's a place. You can see my pic of the menu and see the limited selection, yet it has a diverse representation of Italian food. Also note that cash is welcomed here - there is a 3.75% surcharge for non-cash payments. We were offered water, and you can see what we received. Nowhere else in town does one get their own pitcher of water - great for us! We started with the antipasto salad - it was straight-forward. It had all the main ingredients, see pic. The Italian salad dressing was okay. The greens were fresh. The processed meats and artichoke heart were somewhat bland. We split a 4 slice (individual) pepperoni and sausage pizza. It has a thin crust, which holds up quite well. The exposed crust around the edge was quite flavorful and crunchy without being over cooked. The sauce was tangy and rich. The pepperoni and sausage were a bit flavorless. read more

See all

Best pizza in Redlands! Try the Sicilian or calzone. They are always consistent with amazing ingredients.

Pizza was decent 4 out of 5 , delivery was fast, pricing was average... would like to try it again but sit in the pizza parlor and try it there. read more

I called in an order this morning for two pizzas and two salad salads. They were ready on time. They help me carry them out to the car due to my recent surgery. I donated them to a a fundraising group for their lunch, and they all raved about how good everything was. Some of them had never heard of this place, but I hope I was able to steer some traffic there way read more

Pepperoni pizza was delicious Mozzarella sticks were ok and the salad had too much mushroom not enough lettuce Service was fast! I wish they had music playing or something it was way too quiet but besides that this place is worth a try!! PS we just placed our mozz sticks next to the pizza read more

See all

I'm from the OC and originally from Chicago and know what an authentic deep dish pizza should taste like! The deep dish pizza was like eating some semi ok toppings (tasteless) on very very dry bread for $45!! We literally threw it away This owner should go to Tony's Little Italy in Placentia and taste a real deep dish pizza and then do all he can to duplicate it. I'll never order from here again unless he does. Most of the restaurants in Banning/Beaumont area are not worth going to. That's why everyone that lives here goes to PS or Redlands to dine out. Take my advice...go to Tony's...change your pizza and watch the crowds appear. You COULD become the ONLY good pizza place in town! read more

I ordered takeout from here through Grubhub. It arrived quickly and hot. The potatoes were packaged well so they stayed hot. This pizza was thin and delicious! The sauce was great and the cook on the pizza was just right. I'll definitely order again! read more

New York Pizzaria - Large pizza with pepperoni and jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Great pizza, great toppings, great pizza place. I'd highly recommend you try their pizza!

Great service and a great cheese pizza. repeat customer. won't let you down. consistent.

Consistently the best pizza in the area! The crust is especially superior to any other pizza purveyor in town. Don't waste your time ordering from a chain. There is a time and a place for some of the other places in Redlands, but for delicious pizza, friendly ownership, and consistently delicious food and good service from a family owned small business, this is the place every single time. read more

Place smells like insect repellent, bathroom is out of order, my small pizza was 16.99 even though advertised as 13.99. There's a fee to use debit cards and credit cards. Owner and cook seem checked out. What a depressing experience. The Tuscan pizza itself is advertised as a "creamy Alfredo sauce topped with chicken, artichoke hearts, mushrooms and sun dried tomatoes." But the cheese sauce is over my minimal toppings. Presentation was that of a cheese pizza. Pizza was a tasty rip off. Needs to highlight the toppings on the advert. Tried to start a friendly conversation but owner didn't seem interested in having any kind of hospitality for his only patron, and gave his attention to his movie. Should've ordered takeout. read more

See all

Another amazing and delicious meal at NY Pizzaria! Had large pepperoni pizza, large Tuscan pizza, jalapeno poppers, and spaghetti with meatballs. The highlights I must say were the classic pepperoni pizza and spaghetti with meatballs. Omg the spaghetti sauce made me feel as if I was in an authentic Italian household getting spoiled with the marinara sauce... mMmMMm!! Highly recommended spot! They're also allowing dine in with limited capacity. Next time I'll try their meat lasagna... can't wait! read more

See all

My husband and I are on a mission to find our favorite pizza place in Redlands and decided to try this place since we always see it when we get a sandwich from Saverinos. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza which was around $18 and a calzone to go. Not worth the price and the pizza reminded me of a lunchable pizza flavor. My husband said he felt like he can taste what their fridge smells like and it ruined it for him. The calzone was okay. Definitely not like NY pizza and neither of us liked it so we won't be going back but at least we got to try it. Uncle Howies is still our #1 pizza place in Redlands but we still have a few more places to try. read more

The food, in my opinion, is very delicious and at a good price. New York Pizzaria has been around for many years. I would bring my sons here back on the 90's. Pizza, drinks, tv and a few arcade games was the scene then. You can get other foods like some sandwiches or spaghetti and meatballs too. The owners are great and friendly and give great service. read more

We had a ham and cheese calzone and a sausage, pepperoni and cheese calzone both were delicious

Ordered a XL cheese pizza over the phone. Had to call back to tell them how delicious their pizza was!

Ok - sadly a 3 star review. I got all pumped up about "New York" pizza. I'm not an expert, but to me New York should be large slices, cheese galore, bubbly melty chewy cheesy goodness that covers your hand easily. These pizzas looked good - but the taste can only be described as basic. A specialty XL pizza was $25 for a meat lovers - and my take? Not enough meat. The pepperoni? Super basic - no distinguishing characteristics at all. More flavor from major chains and way less cost. Long story short - 2 XL pizza and one Medium for just under $75 (+ their charge for using a card.....) - not worth it at all. Load the toppings - generosity always wins the day. read more

I could've bought a frozen pizza!!! I order 3 toppings and barely got the 3rd one I counted two. Very dead inside. Don't get me wrong the flavor wasn't bad but it was just equivalent of School pizza. The guy behind the counter was nice. I don't like eating off a Styrofoam because the heat singes the plate. But that's what they serve you on Styrofoam plates. I think if you were broke and you need some thing this is the place but this is not the place you would go to for New York pizzeria or for any gourmet pizza. This is just not it. I think I would've been better off with a hot and ready. read more

New York Pizzaria - Can you see any ham. I paid for ham. - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

They make sure food it's fresh always great service family owned excellent food go and enjoy you will love it

Ordered 2 pizzas and a salad, Not worth the money at all. The pizza's were not good, such thin crust, barely any cheese and wheres the toppings on a supreme and meat lovers? I don't write reviews but after 3 months of no pizza I was excited and this was not it read more

Can't say enough about New York Pizzeria in Redlands California. The have lunch specials to that are very affordable. Yes I would recommend this restaurant to a friend, family member. read more

See all

We ordered pizza from here that we go and pick up. It's only a couple of Blocks from my house. It's my opinion that this is the best Pizza in Redlands. that is, for mainstream pizza. read more

Small mom & pop place. Ordered the 14 inch sausage, peppers & pineapple. The pizza was very good!! Will definitely return.

Their pizza is fine but I like my pizza crust a little thicker. Hadn't been there in a while. The last time we were there, the Family Meal was $39.99 for 2 lg pizzas, a salad, and a liter of soda. Now, $34.99, you only get one pizza, potatoes, salad, and soda. The new total was $62.00 to add another pizza. A little expensive for what you get but so is everything these days. read more

The service was bad and the pizza sucked big time I should've just went to Little Caesars better service and better price had no cheese practically had no air-conditioning inside the facility and took forever to get the food. The tiramisu was overpriced dessert and it was grainy and it was the worst tiramisu I ever had read more

Delicious food. One of my dad's favorite places. If you want great quality pizza go here!!! The owner is always happy to help you decide what is best for you. It's a cute small place like most places but the smell sets the tone. Delicious and you gotta try it. The cheese ravioli, lasagna and spaghetti are amazing. I have yet to try a calzone but I know it's going to be awesome!!!!! EAT HERE OR TAKE HOME!! You won't be disappointed I promise. Oh the pizza is New York style however it is not as greasy as I remember the pizza in New York. The taste is all still there though!!!!! I think I'll go tomorrow. read more

I ordered just a large pepperoni to go and it was delicious. The crust was nice and crispy and perfectly cooked. It was ready quickly and service was fast and friendly. The restaurant itself was empty(I picked up about 20 minutes before close) but seemed clean and neat. read more

Came here to update my review- man when I'm craving a nice, cheat day greasy pie this is the BEST hands down. Tonight didn't disappoint. We mowed through that pizza in about 10 minutes. My only regret is we got a medium instead of a large. It's okay, people make mistakes lol. Give NY Pizzaria a try, it's been excellent each time we visit. Shop small!!! read more

See all

Good Pizza and customer service. Small dining area. The place is kind of hidden. You can miss it if you drive by too fast.

Let me begin by saying that we have only had take out from New York Pizzeria so I can't review ambiance or atmosphere. For more than a year now we have gotten our pizza from NYP for one distinct reason and that is abundant, flavorful pizza. They don't skimp on the ingredients. We get the "New Yorker" which is a supreme pizza full of fresh meat and veggies topped with extra cheese. It takes time to prepare so call ahead, it is worth the wait. In the new year we plan to try more menu items and test their taste, and I'll let you know how it goes. read more

I've been to New York Pizzaria several times now and they never disappoint. Thin crust, cheesy and good size pies. I recently ordered a family combo, 2 large pizzas, potato wedges, salad and a 2-liter of soda all for under $40. The staff is friendly and fast. Seating inside is limited as is parking out front on State Street. read more

Really good pizza for a really good price. I usually just order a pepperoni pizza with two ranch dressings.

This spot is extremely family friendly. Came here with my 4 kids and husband. I was recommended to order ahead before arriving and it was the best advice ever! They communicate so warmly and saved our dinner family night. We agreed on a arrival time and parked literally right in front of the shop. We were greeted, given drinks immediately and within less than 5 mins we had all our food (2 mediums, 1 small, wings and wedges) we were checked on numerous times and felt extremely comfortable here. This spot is mostly known for take out but I love it for dine in.Don't skip out on the wedges!!! read more

New York Pizzaria - Fire and extremely family friendly - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

I ordered a meat lovers pizza yesterday. If you look at my pizza I don't know if it had any meat in it. There is supposed to be like 3-4 different meats. It's cheap and way overpriced for basically a frozen pizza. If you read the menu it states you charge by the topping. Why was I charged for 4-5 toppings when you didn't put them on my pizza? Go to Strongman Pizza for delivery or fast pick up pizza. All the reviews on here are very old and if you don't have the toppings you still don't get to charge people the same price. I was charged $20 for a large cheese pizza..... read more

New York Pizzaria - Where's the Meat in the meat lovers lol - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Great pizza! We've been here twice and it satisified my family's craving for great New York style pizza

Tasty food. Loved the crust. Everything we ordered was delicious. Order was ready for pick up on time