Love this place!! What a lifesaver in every single way. I was in a local hotel traveling on…read morebusiness. Hungry is an understatement! It was a sweltering 93 degree day, and I walked to order a simple lunch here. Oh and I needed caffeine. As I walked in I found it so quaint. I went up to the counter and found a beautiful soul. I spoke to her letting her know about my food allergies. I asked her about the bread ingredients and she so sweet and very patient. I grabbed a coffee, bottles of water and soda / pop. She knew I was at the local hotel, she asked if I was going to walk back and I said yes. She said no you are not. I have to go get gas, I'll take you. I said no, not to worry. I grabbed the heavy bag and remembered the heat. I said, I'll pay you. She wasn't having it. She drove me back to the hotel. I learned that she is the owner! This is what I say is the best, most beautiful thing a restaurant could ever do for her customers. The ham and cheese were excellent. The coffee was so good. Barbara THANK YOU!!!! I hope my followers will continue to bless your business beyond measure. You made such an impact and turned my day around to the better.

Great service and our order ready numerous times for 5:30 AM…read more We start a work crew near Pierce Street Bagels on Saturday and Sundays and we need 35 sandwiches by 5:30 AM and they always meet that goal even though they don't even open at 5:30 AM

Excellent bagels. Fabulous selection. Craving! It gets busy! Fast service. Easy parking.read more

Ordered delivery and tried a few things from Kettleman's Bagels and overall it was a decent…read moreexperience. The Chicken Salad Sandwich was really good, fresh, flavorful, made exactly to order, and probably the standout here. Also grabbed 1/4 lb each of the egg salad, tuna salad, and chicken salad, and all three were tasty. I think the Egg Salad was probably the best one and reminds me of a deviled egg. The Steak Breakfast Burrito was just ok, but it was definitely heavy on the potatoes and pretty light on the steak which was like shaved steak meat in Philly sandwiches instead of chunks of steak. I think at least half the burrito are potatoes. Still flavorful overall, just not quite balanced the way I expected.

Great bagels!! Loved my interaction with the staff. Inside was organized and easy to get in and out…read moreof. I would definitely recommend if you are in the New Brunswick area!

Went to Bagel Nosh on March 16, 2026 for breakfast. The overall place gives you that classic deli…read morevibe, which I liked. There was a large assortment of bagels to choose from, so you've got plenty of options. I went with my go-to -- a BLT on a plain bagel. The total came out to $7.90 with tax, which honestly isn't bad at all for today's prices. They were generous with the bacon, and overall the sandwich was really good. One thing to keep in mind is parking. You won't really find parking right in front since there are signs posted, but I was able to find a spot around the corner without too much trouble. Overall, if you're looking for a quick bite at a decent price, this is a solid choice.

This place is a stone's throw from my in-laws, and we finally stopped in to grab some breakfast…read morebefore heading home to Boston. There were lots of orders and it seemed as though we might need to wait a while, but it turns out that the service is ultra fast, so we got our bagels within a few minutes. I got a plain bagel with veggie cream cheese and it was delicious. My sister in law got a bagel with lox and she said it was a bit too salty, but otherwise decent. Fast service and tasty bagels... we will be back next time!

We love going here. Honestly, these are the hardest working people. We came in the morning of a…read moresnowstorm and they were ready to assist us. Super nice and friends. I always get the BEC and my bf gets the cheese steak on a roll. We recently tried their french toast and it's absolutely BOMB. They are very generous with the syrup and butter. Love this place, def recommend.

Had high hopes for this place as you can't have enough great bagel shops. The facility is decent…read moreand makes it easy to eat in if you want. What threw me off is there barely any bagels on display. Usually when you go into a bagel shop they have a large glass case displaying all their types of bagels. I had ordered 3 breakfast sandwiches. Asked for 1 Taylor Ham, Egg & cheese and 2 bacon, egg 8 cheese on hard rolls. Super standard for central/north Jersey. The gentleman taking my order looked at me confused. I had to make clear what Taylor ham was - I said oh yeah pork roll. Then he tells me they don't have any rolls and bagels only. Very odd. You would think they would have rolls for sandwiches. I ordered the sandwiches ok plain bagels. Took about 15mins which seemed long since there was only one person in front of me. The sandwiches weren't great - barely any meat in them and the bacon was soggy/fatty. Should've been cooked more. The pork roll was ok but it was only one slice. Wish this place and hope they do well but not sure if I will go back with bagel supreme right around the corner.

Wasn't really impressed. I had ham and Swiss on a bagel. Bagel was good but the lack of meat was…read moredisappointing. My son hated the bacon egg and cheese, too much cheese and they put ketchup when I specifically said none.

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Literally, they have the most amazing…read morebagels. Coming from NY, this is it. There's what seems like endless options of bagel flavors. We've tried a few, and I love the Asiago cheese. The service is great, staff is friendly. There might be a bit of a wait, but I promise it's worth it. There is some seating, so don't fret. Give them a try, and don't forget to try the coffee!

I came here on my way to work to grab a lox spread bagel on an everything bagel. The bagel was so…read morefluffy and huge and they layered on the lox spread thick just the way I like it. The staff was also pretty friendly and got my bagel out quickly First thing I noticed was that this bagel spot also gives back to the community through regular donation opportunities throughout the year! I love a local spot that supports their community. I got my bagel to go but I noticed that the interior is so cute and has a couple of tables if you do want to enjoy your bagels inside.

Rahway Bagel has the best bagels in town -- always fresh, soft, and made daily. You can really…read moretaste the quality in every bite. It's my go-to spot every Sunday after church and such a nice little treat to look forward to. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, even when it's busy. I also like that everything is made fresh early in the day, so you know you're getting something good. They do close early around 3pm, so it's definitely a morning and early afternoon spot -- but it's worth it every time. Highly recommend Rahway Bagel if you want fresh, delicious bagels done right!

Bacon scrambled eggs, butter and pepper...delicious huge sandwich!! The bagels are always fresh and…read morewarm and delicious

I was looking for a traditional bagel store and bumped into this gem and I must say they have so…read moremany options in the staff is so friendly. I will definitely be back. I just got a bacon egg and cheese on a roll and I have to add that the coffee was absolutely amazing. I can't wait to try some more of the deliciousness of this menu.

I take back what I said about the French toast. Hubby surprised me with breakfast today and came…read moreback with French toast that was far from mid. I very much enjoyed my platter, though the bacon is still overly salty. I limited myself to one piece while my dog had the rest