Overpriced for the quality and presentation. We reluctantly paid over $30 for fish and chips that looked like something you could have gotten at a ball game. The fries tasted like they were frozen and then just heated up. The portion size of fish was small. I also had the crispy duck confit. It a very small piece of duck on the bone with a fruity salad. The salad was ok and the duck was crispy but the near $40 price tag left much to be desired in flavor and portion size. The raw oysters were tasty but small $3.50 each. For a bill over $100 (no alcohol or apps) we were disappointed with the mediocre food that came out. We've gotten better meals for half the price. *Staff was friendly and accommodating! No complaints there. read more

Noah's - Duck confit - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

The service is amazing here! Plus, it's dog friendly if it's warm enough for outside seating! The food was outstanding! Get the frito mixto it had the perfect spice to it and squeeze lemon on it and you will be more than pleased with this as a starter. I had the lobster roll as my main; it was good. I think I would definitely go back for the drinks and for the appetizers! I would like to try some of the other items on the menu since so many sounded amazing. read more

Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

This is a really nice spot in downtown Greenport New York. The food was spot on last Friday night. The waitress gave us great suggestions including the wine pairings with the appetizers and entrees. She was also attentive and stopped by frequently to see if we needed anything. The place was busy and a bit noisy, the interior has high ceilings so the sound carries. You can also sit outside. When on the North Fork, you need to get seafood. It's always fresh out here. I went with an order of Blue Point Oysters which were delicious. My wife and I split a watermelon feta salad. Again, delicious. We also got an order of grilled squid. It was cooked perfectly. The crab topped deviled eggs were also a hit. For dinner I had the seared tuna over a mix of bok choi and other veggies. It was cooked to perfection. I don't remember what my son got and I think my dad had the beet salad along with an order of oysters. He seemed to be happy with it. The only ding is the parking. They took the spots away in front and expanded the outdoor dining. You can park in the public lot around back but, if you have someone who is handicapped, it could be problematic dropping them off in front. Main Street is narrow to begin with so just keep that in mind if you venture here on a Friday or Saturday night for dinner. read more

See all

This place is just fantastic. The service is top notch and the food is delicious. It's my go to for a wonderful meal.

Great place, glad we could get in. It was Monday, off season, and still full. The food, service, and atmosphere were superb.

Food was delicious the waitress was great. I really loved the cauliflower and broccoli small plate, it was baked and full of flavor. The cocktails were also very good as well. The only thing I was disappointed about was the red crab tacos which everyone was ranting and raving about and I found them to be fishy. Maybe it was a bad day but I would not get them again. read more

Noah's - Lunch time - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

We had our hopes high as this has been on our must try for years. Save your money and eat anywhere else. Honestly, the food quality was fine but all of it was way marked up. The duck liver mousse was bland, the octopus was good, the shrimp and grits were fine, the fish and chips were dying for some salt and vinegar. Everything was just meh and for what we spent it needed to be much more than meh. We won't be back. read more

See all

Let's start with pros - Ambiance and decor - 5 stars, very elegant, tables spaced far enough away, and nice decor. It's a white table cloth establishment, but also has a homey casual feel so you get the best of both worlds. Food - lobster roll, although I'd say a little heavy on the mayo the lobster was cooked incredibly well and it was very delicious. Crab Tacos - for not a taco place, these tacos were superb. Would definitely recommend. Very small portion, but big flavor. Ribeye - Nice, but some of the other options were better. Oysters and muscles we as expected, very satisfied but nothing crazy. Crab Cake - a bit over charred, nice flavor. Cons- Respect as a patron - there is an older woman that mans the door and she might be the most unpleasant person we met in all of Greenport. She had a general lack of respect for people and made the experience a bit trained. The restaurant was mostly empty, we showed up 10 minutes for our reservation and she scowled and said they were not ready and we had to go to the bar. This makes me confused because if you have reservations coming in and no one is there, why aren't you preparing the tables? Also, they did look ready, so why didn't she seat us? Also, why be rude? General experience - I felt uncomfortable after being seated, the server offered free champagne because she could tell we were all so taken aback. (We were appreciative.) The staff seemed nervous and timid, like they couldn't actually be themselves or have a personality. We tried to connect with our waitress, but she just wasn't having it. It was just weird and hard to explain, but it did make things more awkward than they should have been. She was foreign, so maybe it was just sarcasm she didn't understand. At one point my friend asked for a plastic to go bag, the lady again scowled and said they didn't have plastic bags and turned away. My friend lingered and said, do you have paper? She gave a heavy sigh and reluctantly gave her a paper bag. Again, just so unnecessary. I think given the positive experience at other places, I would not return here when visiting Greenport next time. Wrote a review for Bruce & Sons - you must go there! read more

Noah's - Plenty of space on a Saturday night. Nice ambiance. - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

My husband and I had a vey good lunch at Noah's this week. We decided for small plates, tapas, and white wine. We had a nicely presented Peel and eat Jumbo Shrimp ( just cooked and served with very tasty aioli on a crushed ice base), tuna tartar, green fried tomatoes and warm endive salad. Good portions, fresh and satisfying. Staff is friendly and attentive. Beautiful place! read more

Noah's - Fried green tomatoes with pesto - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

This was our second time at Noah's and we were equally pleased. Lobster roll is great, the oysters sweet and fresh, the frito misto delicious and the atmosphere relaxing. Enjoy! read more

Coming in with a large bachelorette group and the only vegan I made sure to scope out the menu before hand. They have really great vegetable options and even a tofu one. There were no vegan friendly mains but the sides were enough and tasty. I had the tofu skewer, the local mushroom side and the stuffed autumn squash. The mushrooms were truly amazing and a shining 10/10. The tofu and squash were a little sweet for my palate but that's really just me being picky. The waitress was also super helpful in double checking to make sure there was no dairy/eggs in any of the dishes. Paired with a great ambiance I highly recommend. read more

Noah's - Tofu skewer, roasted mushrooms and stuffed squash (all vegan) - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

I went to Noah's during restaurant week. I had the salad with apples, walnuts and cheese, one of the best salads I had recently. My main course was Swordfish with ratatouille. The fish was cooked just right and the ratatouille was delicious with the bread. For dessert I had the hazelnut apple which was also amazing. The service was great and they didn't rush us since we were there enjoying the company of our friends. read more

We had dinner here last Monday. We.brought our dog and was able to get a seat outside. It took a second for our waiter to come out, but that was OK. The weather was beautiful and we were in no rush. We ordered cocktails that were really nice. We had the tacos and corn as an appetizer. They were both really yummy. We had the corn risotto and tuna with bok choy for our entrees. They were also super yummy. Dare I say, the best tuna I have had in a very long time!!!! This was our first visit and we will definitely be back. read more

See all

Came here for appetizers and drinks however, was so disappointed by our cocktails and service that we left without eating. I ordered a dirty martini made with tanqueray and what i received was a glass of olive juice with lemon. The martini was so salty it tasted like a cold cup of the long island sound after a storm. I was truly taken aback so i asked the bartender what happened and they insisted that i asked for lemon in it which was odd. It was completely opaque super salty and oddly sour with the lemon. Just a really odd experience overall. The ambiance was lovely though and i'll definitely update this if i ever go back because their menu does sound good and i would like to try it! read more

Noah's is always great. Great food and service, and Im always at home there. A great place near the inn . Walkable . The guests love it too

Amazing restaurant and cannot say enough! From the service, to the ambience, to the delicious food and cocktails, this restaurant is a dream. We were here for our anniversary and they greeted us with complementary glasses of champagne. However, that was not the most amazing part. Our waitress went above and beyond to ensure that we had an amazing experience and delicious meal. read more

We LOVED Noah's! We did several small plates and they were all delicious; Deviled Eggs, Tempura squash blossoms, Crab tacos and the Korean Short Rib. If I had to pick one, I'd say you must get the Crab Tacos! Also, Jason was a lovely server, attentive and kind. read more

This is our go-to whenever in Greenport. Best food in the area with the most amazing ambiance and staff. Not your "loud scene vibe" as found way too much all across long island. The oysters! AMAZING!!! Love that they're local - but usually NOT Blue Points (sorry, i've had way too many of these over the years - and there are MUCH better ones out there) Great location too! If you haven't been, you should definitely give Noahs a try :) read more

Top drawer meal from start to finish at Noah's! Lovely restaurant, attentive staff and...the food!! The yellowfin tuna tartare with avo, jalapeño and soy vinaigrette was outstanding. I love yellow fin tuna in all its guises and this really hit the mark. Perfectly balanced to respect the quality of the fish. We followed up with the lump crab cakes, perfectly cooked filet mignon sliders, and an outstanding duck confit. I finished with an affogato - simple but well done ending to a great dining experience. I also loved the wine selection - some fantastic local wines from Bedell, Lieb and Kontokosta among others, as well as a selection from further afield. I would recommend trying local pairings - I was surprised by the quality but shouldn't have been; I guess these places were only a secret to me! Noah's clearly takes patrons' health and safety seriously - we felt very comfortable throughout and really enjoyed the experience which is important in these difficult times. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Don't really understand what all the hype is about this restaurant. It's fine but no where near extraordinary. We started off with the Calamari frito... I have to say that was the best part of the meal... it was a melange of fried squid, rock shrimp, string beans and squash all perfectly fried. I had the warm lobster roll... it was ok but nothing amazing and certainly not rising to the position of being something considered one of their signature dishes. My daughter had one of their specials of the night... tuna poke bowl. We actually had a second reservation for later in the week because of the hype around this restaurant and promptly cancelled it while still there. read more

Noah's - Tuna poke bowl - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Friendly staff, very accommodating, excellent menu recommendations. Craft cocktails were very good, house wine was local wine which is OK. Went with the small plates, inventive, tasty, interesting. Especially enjoyed the small plate filet mignon slider perfectly cooked open faced mini sandwich. Fabulous crabcake small plate over a corn relish. Good finish with Keylime pie.... read more

Noah's - Happy hour at Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

Top quality and nice atmosphere. Full inventive menu and they were very nice helping me surprise the gf with a bday dessert. Gets busy in summer. $$$ more accurate re prices. read more

It had Top notch food and cocktails. Highly recommend fritters and duck with cheese grits. read more

Noah's - Deviled egg with crabmeat - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Last night my dinner party included my son-in-law and his family from Spain. He gallantly translates from English to Spanish and back again menus to his parents so that they can enjoy the meal. However last night the server did not appreciate that he was translating and that the order may take longer to take as he was translating. The server had no time for that and curtly answered legitimate questions with a shrug. My son in law asked if he could share three dishes, two from small plates and on dish from the large plates menu and was told he could. Then the plates arrived they, received no plates for sharing. At no time did the server ask if everything was all right nor welcome us. While the dishes arrived on time they were served with little politeness. We split the bill and my son-in-law gave a small tip and the server came to ask him did he make a mistake in the tip. He said no. and we left. I do not recommend this place to people whose first language is not English. read more

We stumbled upon this cute little place while in Greenport over the weekend. The interior of Noah's is just as amazing as their food! From the appetizer to dinner to dessert- everything was great! I'm a huge fan of connecticut style lobster rolls- warm with hot butter. Noahs NAILED it! It was super tasty and paired with a great wine. Definitely should check this place out if you're in Greenport! read more

Noah's - Warm Lobster Roll - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Ate here on July 11,2024.....service good, drinks ok, my $50 ribeye cooked beyond oblivion!

Excellent service and decor. Bar not operating which is strange. The food was exceptional. We had the risotto and the duck confit. Both were amazing. We shared a special appetizer of stuffed squash blossoms. They were delicious. The beignets for dessert were ridiculously good. read more

See all

Noah's is a very good restaurant on Front Street in Greenport. A little bit hipsterish if that's a word but the food & drinks are very good. It's also good to know that they don't frown on sharing so mixing up some small plates before your entree is a good idea, especially for groups of 3 or more. In the last few years a lot of restaurants have popped up in the area, price wise this is upper side of middle of the road. In closing the Kobe burger is one of the best I've had so stop there for that if you can't decide. Happy dining. read more

See all

To finish off a culinary Thanksgiving weekend in NY, we returned to our Greenport favorite, Noah's. This is our third visit, and Noah's never disappoints. For one, the service is consistently great. All the servers, be they male or female, are model material and incredibly professional without being stiff or overbearing. And then there is the food! We really enjoy the tapas style menu, so we can order a variety. Today we picked a variety. The crab deviled eggs were as good as ever. Jack's favorite was the tuna tartare which was presented seared, chopped, mixed with avocado, spices, topped with a seaweed salad, served with baguette sliced croutons. Although the bread added a pleasant crunch, the dish could be more appreciated without the crunch. Both flavors and textures were better presented by tasting the tartare solo. My favorite were the crab tacos. A delicious crab salad served in a small crispy corn tortilla. Yum-O! The lamb meatballs with hummus were also fantastic. Flavors reminiscent of Morocco! The chef is really a master of flavors. We will keep coming back on our trips to the North Fork. read more

See all

Had a delicious meal at this place while visiting from NYC. Ordered a raspberry Cosmo, and it was great because I tend to enjoy sweet cocktails and this was perfect. My fiancé ordered a jalapeño cocktail which he loved as well. The food was excellent- I highly recommend getting a few of the smaller plates. For my entree I had the steak sliders and the heirloom salad which was amazing and my fiancé enjoyed his lobster roll. My only complaint is that we waited forever to get water and had to ask several times, and after spending the day on the water it was really needed. read more

See all

Once you walk in you cant miss the smell of fish. We were served in 45 min food was sub par service was terrible. They take plates faster than they come out. Apps not great, escargot has a weird taste although fresh, main courses tiny and lack flavor. read more

Delicious food and close to Menhaden boutique hotel. Menu is varied and wine list is varied.

We were very disappointed with the Kobe beef burger that we had the other night. Especially since Noah's is our favorite restaurant on the North Fork with, I feel, delicious and consistently good food. First, the burger wasn't hot (or charred enough), the cold slab of tomato on top cooled the temperature even more and the bun wasn't warm let alone toasted. All this made for a non-pleasurable experience. The fries were industrial so we couldn't even enjoy them. Really, Shake Shack burgers are better! I do remember having had a decent burger at Noah's a few years ago. It seems the kitchen staff should be retrained to turn out burgers the way they should be done. read more

Noah's was one of my favorite restaurants in Greenport. Today my family and I were discriminated by the hostess, Yasmin. When we arrived at around 4:30, the restaurant was empty with the exception of a few people at the bar. In front of us were a white family whom were given a priority of which table to sit at by the windows. When I personally asked, Yasmin stated that she could not sit us by the window because she had to "extend" those tables later. When I asked why that family was allowed to sit there, she stated, "I'm the hostess!" When I asked her name she rolled her eyes and said "Yasmin." She the walked away. My family and I felt that were treated unfairly because we were a latino family. Ironically, I believe she was also. We decided to leave and stated to her That her attitude and customer service was disgusting. She stated, "I really don't care what you think!" My brother stated to her that we would write a negative review. She stated that our review wouldn't have an impact and again stated, "I really don't care what you do!" We went to American Beech where we got amazing service! I highly recommend! If you are a someone of color, beware of Yasmin, she'll put you all the way in back in an empty restaurant. read more

Right on the Main Street in Greenport is a culinary treasure. I would call the decor "minimalist", but I don't dine for decor.... I wanted seafood, I came to the right place! I had the clam chowder. BEST I have ever had. Not too creamy, lots of clams. 10 out of 10! I followed it with the Seafood Stew. OMG! Good eats! The broth base was amazing with tons (figuratively, not literally) of shellfish, fish bites throughout the entire bowl of yuminess. Go there... go there now. (Make sure they are open though). read more

Great breakfast! Been here a few times. In season it gets very crowded but always worth the wait!

Great quaint place for a nice meal. The inside has a great calming feel. We started with the Kale salad, calamari, and pulled duck BBQ over polenta. The polenta came out cold but the other two dishes were great. Also side note but the bread is very yummy!! Kale salad is garnished with pine nuts which was a nice addition. Despite the polenta being cold the BBQ pulled duck was actually really tasty. For entrees, we tried the spring veggie Risotto and paella. The dishes were just ok. The risotto was not a great consistent and lacking in flavor. The paella was good overall but was not cooked evenly throughout. I wouldn't recommend either. For desert, we tried the raspberry sorbet and flourless chocolate cake which were great. Ambiance: 5/5 Food: 3/5 Staff: 4/5 Overall: 3.5/5 read more

Noah's - New American Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

I was disappointed when the paella had no saffron at all and the rice was soggy. When I mentioned this to the waiter, he pretended he did not hear me. No need to return to Noah's. read more

Our family has been coming to Noah's for at least 10 years years. It's our go-to spot on the north fork. It's fancy, with upscale food and decor, while still being down to earth and very kid friendly. Not cheap but outstanding value. Their protocols during COVID were as sensible and user-friendly as any restaurant we've visited, which was quite welcome. Noah's is everything you could ask for in a family restaurant. read more

We were on a wine tour and had two hours in Greenport so decided to stop by Noah's for a late lunch. Best choice we could have made. Every bite of food was exceptional from the crab tacos to the filet mignon sliders to the best shrimp and grits I've ever had. Do yourself a favor and skip the fish fry joints. Service was as excellent as the food. They are attentive without being pretentious, and our server Leslie provided top notch recommendations. Wheelchair access: as good as it gets! Flat entry from the street, plenty of room between tables, and a spacious accessible bathroom where I could even see myself in the mirror. read more