I drive by this place all the time and never thought anything of it. Well I googled best pizza and this place came up. Went for pickup and the lot had a lot of cars also picking up. There was like 6 people working there. It must get busy. The girl who was taking phone orders was super sweet. I watched her take an order and she was even smiling The pizza was delicious. Their regular slice really good and their pepperoni "chips" so good and only like $.80 cents. I also agree it's their sauce. Also garlic knots are super seasoned in a good way. My new go to place now read more

See all

I came here based on a recommendation from a guy named Pino we met in a Massapequa coffee shop So thank you Pino if you read these posts. Easily, Best pizza this side of the Atlantic. Crispy crust. best sauce and cheese. Friendly service. And I'll be back for a deep Fried Calzone, an almost impossible to find favorite. My new favorite!!!! read more

I've been looking for THE pizza place near me and although nunzio's is a little out of the way it's worth the drive because dangggg their pizza is fire !! I think it's the sauce that makes it. I ordered a plain pie (really the only way to judge a pizzeria) and was blown away. Top notch. The place itself is a little on the run down side if you ask me but i picked up and could care less about what their dining area was like when the food was so good. Parking was difficult - I accidentally pulled into the storefront next door because it's right off a major road and at night was a little hard to distinguish where the entrance was. My only complain is about the parking lot so yeah I'd say this was a home run! Pizza over everything. I'm curious about their specialty slices so I think I'll try one next time but it's hard not to get just a big ole pie when it is so good read more

Chicken Francese was amazing. I would definitely recommend it. Great Tasting and very generous portions.

This is a great local pizzeria. You can sit down at tables and order other Italian foods, but their pizza is excellent. Crispy thin crust and good cheese and sauce. I've never been disappointed. Conveniently located on 109 with a decent sized parking lot. Good place to stop when you're on the go. Friendly service too. read more

Been going to this old style Italian Resturant for a few years now. Never have I had a bad meal. The owner Nunzio comes out and says hi to everyone like your familia. I would get a bottle of wine makes the meal perfect. He will also make special dishes as a surprise and they are amazing. Give it a try you will thank me for it. Ira. say hi from me. read more

Great food .....great service from great people. Brooklyn style Fried calzones remind me of my mother's cooking

We called Nunzio's because they were recommended by a local funeral home. We came in from all over the country to a graveside service and looked forward to a visit with all the folks who came in for the funeral. They said they would accommodate us but it turned out that they were closed on Sunday. Didn't eat there, can't comment on the food, but this should have been obvious. read more

Their pizza is phenomenal. I also ordered a meatball sub and for the first time I was disappointed. The meatball was seasoned perfectly, however too much salt was added. Had to have been a mistake. read more

Excellent. Unexpectedly full bodied flavor in the crust and cheese. This is my new spot.

Excellent food they will make you anything you want. Excellent service old style Italian restaurant 5 *****b

Best Pizza around. Truly a hidden Gem! Nunzio (the owner) greets and smiles at all his guests. Highly recommend the regular pizza... read more

I go there aii the time either the front for pizza or a canzone or the back for a full meal never had a problem food is great

The reviews seemed good so I stopped in for a couple slices. The margarita pizza was epic. The undercarriage was super crispy and tasted amazing! It's the only NY pizza I have ever had but I can't imagine anything any better. I will be back here again over and over. 8.0 read more

See all

To die for. Forget the chain stores. This is REAL New York pizza Best cheese and sauce! read more

Pizza town is by far my favorite pizza of all time. I have been a customer my entire life literally. I would walk to their restaurant when I was little to get Italian ices and now get pizza weekly for my daughter and husband. This is just a great family owned pizza place with great employees that have been their longer than I am alive and hands down the best pizza on Long Island read more

In my search of really good pizza on Long Island I somehow overlooked Nunzios. I've reviewed over a hundred pizzerias in the past 4 months and I live in West Babylon and have not found the best local place. This is it. I'm a well done pizza guy, thin and crispy and great taste. They check all 3 of these boxes. Even their deep dish was somehow crisp and firm on the bottom and the end had this really great chewy texture. Old school pizzeria vibe inside, basic, no fan fair. Everyone there are helpful and friendly. On the barstool scale I would give it an 8.2 which means you make the extra drive to get something you like. read more

People are always talking up New York Pizza, and we chose Nunzio's Pizza Town to start. We came in pretty late, so I get that they are exhausted from a whole day's work. However, complaining should be behind closed doors, not within earshot of the customers. As soon as the food was done, we rushed out so they can get cleaned up and head home. Once home, the whole pizza shifted and a lot was off to the side on the cardboard. I figured it was just because it was really hot, so I wait a sec and let it cool down. But regardless it was so messy that I'm wasn't able to pick a slice up. Couldn't fold it, couldn't use a fork and knife, couldn't even scoop it with two hands. Mind you, it was delicious, but it was too annoying to eat. After a few bites I didn't even care anymore. I think maybe at earlier times of the day, it's probably fantastic, but it really lacks later in the day even during open hours. Give it a shot anyway, I say. Like I said, still very delicious, but check them out earlier. read more

See all

Wish they had zero stars !! I placed a order there and got a confirmation and text saying my order will arrive between 9:42- 9:57 they never showed and they were closed when i tried calling at 10:15 they took the money out of my account and everything. I checked my bank account the next day and they returned it read more

With the sale of my former favorite pizza joint and its subsequent drop off of quality, Nunzio's has become my go to place. A bit expensive, you do get what you pay for. read more

Pizza wa good. I came here on the recommendation of a friend and perhaps he set my expectations a bit to high. The service was quick but the ambience was not to my expectations. The place looks like it's been there for a long time and it show. That is why I deducted one star from my review. read more

The food is good the staff are very friendly plus the restaurant inside food is also good and very clean place

Very solid pizza and fried calzone.......yep fried not baked. read more

Nunzio's Pizza Town - Calzone, fried Calzone, trust me.....it'll make ya smack your Grandma. - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

We were visiting from NJ and we were looking for great Italian food- this was def the place we were looking for! The owner Nunzio came out to make sure everything was to our liking - we enjoyed the garlic bread with moz cheese- so much yummy garlic! We had the Chicken Milanese and Chicken Parm and they were both fabulous. The pasta and sauce with the chicken parm were perfection. Simple and elegant and delicious - exactly what we were looking for! Our waitress TerryAnn was so sweet and very quick to take our orders and circle back if we needed anything! Her smile will  light up your day! If we are back in town again we will absolutely be back! read more

I like to believe I'm fair when it comes to Yelp Reviews. I just ask for three main things; atmosphere, friendly staff, and good food. That alone and you will get four stars from me. But if you can't meet my criteria on at least one, than in my opinion you're a sinking ship. I came to "Nunzio's Pizza Town" because of the convenience. I found a spot quick in the mini parking lot because there weren't many cars around. Heading inside I can see the place was a bit dated. They played no music and the lighting was low. They had nice seating in the back, but I wasn't looking to stay long. When I approach the counter I felt the staff was at defcon three. They weren't pleasant and only seem to be about work. I looked over their specialty slices and got two. I like blue cheese with my buffalo slice and asked for some. The guy at the counter said "I have to charge a dollar." Nice! No welcome first, just about money. I reluctantly paid my dollar and got my two slices. My full experience so far put me off, but how was the food? Another big let down sorry to report. The buffalo slice didn't taste like buffalo. It almost tasted like marinara. Maybe they ran out of buffalo sauce and substituted. I can definitely say it wasn't what I was expecting. When it comes to surprises however, I saved the best for last. I got a meat stuffed! That's right, I slice stuffed with cheese and meat. A slice no man can live without.....unless it was this particular one. It was thick but deceptive. You see the dough was thick, making the slice look big, but the cheese and meat was applied to the top only. Sort of like a regular slice. I wasn't happy about that. I ate my two slices and left. I made the effort not to look back, not because I had fear of turning to stone, it was more like, I only wanted to see this restaurant once because I'm pretty sure I'm never going again. read more

See all

great old school Long Island pizza. Thin crispy crust, nice sauce. They had a hot cherry pepper slice. Freaking awesome !!

I've been ordering their shrimp parm every week for a few weeks now. Never disappoints! read more

Nunzio's Pizza Town - Shrimp parm - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Great food doesn't have to be born of interstellar components. Basic good food always wins. I recently touched on this favorite spot from my youth. This made me feel young again. Thank you for maintaining a fountain of youth. They don't miss read more

Love PizzaTown! Food is always great and the service is spectacular! TerriAnn is the best!!

Nunzio's Pizzatown. Has got to be one of the best slices in Long Island. Keep on rocking Pizzatown read more

See all

I stopped here while working for lunch on the advise of a colleague. I'm glad I did. I ordered a regular slice of and a slice of their pepper pie. Both were great. The crust was crispy from start to finish and the cheese was (ready for this) real cheese with plenty of stretch. The way God intended. The pepper slice was just as crispy and the sweet bell pepper (marinated overnight with crushed red pepper and OO) was delicious. Just the right amount of "heat". Can't wait to come back to try their calzone which I'm told is deep fried. The way I remember it from Italian feasts in Brooklyn. Again. Good eats ---- update 2/27/19 -- Again this place was awsome. I had the same two slices as last time and it was just as good. However, this time I left with a bag of hot Zeppoles. OMG, I thought I was at the Feast of our Lady of Mt Carmel in Brooklyn. I swear next time I'm going to try the Calzone. I haven't found a better Pizza joint in Suffolk County. read more

Love the food here for years!!! They have catered for us many times and it's always been special. Can't miss

Went here for a big family dinner and sat in the back restaurant part. We walked in the front entrance, looked around at the pizza counter and booths. This area is not very clean looking or inviting, and has a slight dingy feel to it. The floors were filthy and the ladies room was out of order, so we had to use the men's room which hadn't been cleaned in quite some time. From the reviews I see on here, this looks like it would be a better experience if I just ordered a slice of pizza (to go). The back end of the place looks more updated in decor and has a more restaurant feel to it. Wait staff was friendly and service was good. My only complaint is that they took plates from some people before they were finished eating and seemed to be rushing us. Huge pet peeve of mine in any place I dine in. As for the food in the back restaurant, the appetizers were tasty- had baked clams, very salty but still good enough to eat. We were also served fried calamari, muscles (which were my favorite) and garlic bread, all served family style. The entrees however were EXTREMELY SALTY. I only had a quarter of my chicken Parmesan, which was very tough. I wouldn't come here again to dine in. May possibly try the pizza next time I'm in the area. read more

Our family went for lunch following the burial of one of our own. It was a somber day for us all. The staff was not only efficient and friendly but also kind and compassionate. These ladies were remarkably helpful. Nunzio himself was there as he knows many of us personally. He is a superlative human being and still going strong at age ??? (maybe 115 LOL). The food was excellent and portions plentiful. It was a wonderful ending to a very difficult day. Thank you, all of you. read more

True story...this place was once owned by a midget who drove a red corvette, just like in the Prince song. He was the original little Ceasar. Nunzio's was actually better than expected. There is a nice dining room hiding in the back that lacks the grease and bustle of the front counter. The service back there was good, but not as good as the delicious ham and cheese calzone. It arrived with a crispy, deep-fried crust and a soft, creamy, cheesy interior. Just order one already! The pizza was fresh and tasty, hotter than a June bug on Georgia asphalt. Get enough to bring a few slices home to feed to your pet Llama. Or eat it all yourself and let the Llama fend for itself in the cupboard. Either way, Grumpy will be back around again. read more

The staff was friendly, and the pizza was good. They have a good variety of pizza by the slice. When I commented jokingly about the sign that states the "pizza slices were for display only," the man behind the counter jokingly noted that they were all for sale, and that if I could eat all of them the meal would be on the house. I had the spicy pepper pizza (which was really nice and spice), and the chicken bacon blue cheese pizza. They were both very good, but not the best but I have ever had. To be fair, that is a high standard (I love my pizza and take it very seriously), so I would go to this place again. The crust on both was nice and crispy, but the chicken seemed to be highly processed. One note about the atmosphere and environment, it may have just been the day I was there, but it was chilly in the restaurant. I left my jacket on while I ate my meal. read more

Nunzio's Pizza Town - Very spicy pepper slice and chicken bacon blue cheese slice with lemon tea. - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Pizza Town was founded 3 yrs before I was born - and I'm sorry I was late! As a kid, I can remember my father driving past 150 pizza places to get to "Pizza Town" and every time I'm back in town I still do. For me, Tony and his team serve the best home-cooked Italian food on Long Island, Nunzio's is a very special place for me. As long as the Minnisale's keep the doors open I'll keep going back... maybe for another 53 yrs; this Siciliano will hope anyway. Salut e Cent'an, con amore e rispetto, see you again soon Tony! read more

Nunzio's Pizza Town - I've eaten here so many times, it's like my family dining room! Try it once and you'll be back, like all of us! - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

We had a party of about 15 people and I must say. This place is probably the best priced with some of the best Italian food I have had. I cannot say enough good things about Nunzios Pizza Town. I will say if you are looking to book someplace to go after a communion, christening or really anything and you have less than 30 people. This place is hands down the best price per person. You will leave full and still have money left over. We will be definitely using them again in the future. Also the owner Nunzio is super nice and the wait staff is courteous and attentive. I just wish they would fix the awning because this place deserves everyone's business! read more

I do not even know where to start! This place has the best everything; pizza, calzones, dinners, zepoles and the list goes on. It's been my #1 go to for Italian everything for well over 20 years and will continue to be. Not to mention Anthony, Frank and the rest of the staff make you feel welcomed, like you walked into your friends kitchen to have a bit of homemade Italian everything! read more

So when you walk in the door and all the staff and customers stare at you with that "what you doing here" or "how'd you find this place" look and don't say " hi how may we help you" or something customer service-ey I knew we were in trouble. If it were not for the simple fact that my Hubby loves there damned zeppole and that they actually tasted good we'd have made a huge U-TURN. read more