Drinks were good and strong. My Blt and sweet potato fries were delicious. Would definitely go back here again great little dive bar with food. read more

I've eaten both lunch in a booth, and had drinks at the bar. The bar sits low with comfy chairs on wheels. The service is always friendly. My favorite thing not on the menu is the Rachel, a grilled turkey and coleslaw sandwich on rye, served with chips. They also have sweet potato fries available as a side. The parking lot isn't huge, but there is street parking on the side street. read more

O'Reilly's Pub - Turkey Sub - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Been here several times with my sister and her wife and was never disappointed. Food is delicious, generous and the staff is wonderful. We are looking forward to our next trip. read more

Super love this place!! Seriously best place in Columbus!! Staff is awesome. Place is like a dive bar but so friendly. Food all looks good that came out of the kitchen (sat right by window). AMAZING just go!! I'd definitely go again and again. Literally would only come to Columbus to come to this bar!! Has free parking!!! read more

O'Reilly's Pub - Drink & entrance - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Best Irish Pub in Columbus. Near campus but feels more like neighborhood place. THE BEST BURGERS in town. Try the black pepper burger. Friendly. read more

Disappointing meal. Service was great and we had high hopes on Sunday at 1pm. Fried food came out dark brown! Oil needs replaced, or temp lowered. Fish and chips were so dark. The breading was so thick and rock hard. The chips were almost inedible. Family's fries were just as dark brown, even the bun was extra krispie. Husband said the Reuben was just ok. read more

See all

Five stars. Five reasons. Review based on lunch / daytime visits... 1. O'Reilly's is a cool boozy hangout that caters to an older locals crowd. It's a certified dive wirh an Irish theme that's got that Thurman's, India Oak Grill, Mama's Pasta and Brew kind of vibe. 2. Bartenders? Jill is the fun one. She'll say almost anything with a salty sassiness that really lights the place up. I've also met another bartender who's also super nice but she has a little more down to earth, down to business way of doing things. 3. They've got a pretty impressive menu with wallet friendly prices. There's all kinds of burgers, subs, sandwiches with a big selection of the usual deep fried bar food you'd expect. 4. Their daily specials are pretty sweet too and they are a big hit with all the locals that come in. Look for it by the kitchen door. 5. The jukebox. Im guessing it was last updated around 1998 or so. That's not a bad thing as it's a cool eclectic mix of retro music that just fits the place. ***Please note my personal thank you to the staff and management for not having it cranked up to 11. Go there if you like good hearty food in an authentic dive... And I Have To Give You My Thoughts On Some Of The Food I've Tried... Rachel: Aka Turkey Reuben. It's a freaking awesome sandwich with just the right amount of savory goodness. Get the fries with it. Fish and Chips: It's a solid meal. It's a big portion that tastes great and it will fill you up for a reasonable amount of USDs. Veggie Sub: As good as anyone elses. I'm happy their's come with chips and a pickle spear at no extra charge. Wings: They come breaded and sauced. No joke, these are seriously the biggest wings I've ever seen! Celery and ranch/bleu cheese are an upcharge. Chili: Mark K got this and had nothing but good things to say about it. Ruben: Pat E's choice for a great lunch! ***Thanks to Pat E. for introducing me to this place! I'm looking forward to another meet up. SOON! read more

See all

Food and ambiance is great. Might have to wait a little for your food but definitely worth it. Get a beer and hang out for a bit

Everything you want from a neighborhood bar. Menu full of simple classics done well. Very local and friendly feel with quick service

This place is a hidden gem. Although it's super small, it is cozy, and the staff is great. It's a lively Irish pub in the evening with great food. Try the Reuben. You won't regret it! read more

I hate leaving 5 star reviews. It seems dishonest and lazy. This place is a dive bar feel that is probably a popular local spot. The service is not super speedy, and there was one person service the entire place - bar and all, but she was so friendly and fun. I'm amazed at how she keeps this place in order by herself. Additionally, she made the experience so fun! I was looking for a good burger and landed on O'Reilly's. I ordered a side of onion rings and also a pepper burger with fries , while my girlfriend went with the jerk burger. There was no discussion on how i wanted it cooked, but toppings were asked. My burger was so intensely good that this might be the best burger I've had yet in Columbus. The onion rings were perfectly cooked. Everything about our burgers was fresh and just delicious. I have a new favorite burger spot. This is a perfect dive bar feel with an outstanding kitchen and truly amazing and friendly staff. This is an example of what makes Columbus dining so great! This is a hidden GEM! read more

O'Reilly's Pub - Cheetah on tap. - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I do not want to leave a positive review because I don't want you to come to this place and mess it up. I stop here weekly and I love it. Seriously, if you are in a frat, looking to get hammered on Jaeger, trying to hook up with a hottie, or just bought a new Tesla and you want to look cool because you aren't "one of those Tesla owners" or whatever, just stay away. If you like cold beer, a laid back atmosphere, classic rock on the juke box, and hanging with your friends at an amazing neighborhood pub, then by all means this is your place. O'Reilly's Pub makes some of the best burgers in Columbus. On a quality-of-burger-per-dollar scale they exceed Chapman's Eat Market. Don't believe me? Fine, I don't care, I said it and I believe it. I particularly love the pepper burger, but you better love black pepper. Just order something else though, and you will be fine. The food is solid pub fare top to bottom. The hoagies are good too. Damn, now I want a hoagie and a PBR. Beyond the atmosphere and food, the service is always friendly. Don't come in a rush, be prepared to take your time and enjoy life a little. They are not slow, but usually there is a little crowd that keeps the servers busy. You won't hear a bad word from the staff about it though, they are glad you came (unlike me). Seriously, be cool. And try the burger. Just kidding about the Tesla, kinda. read more

I have seen this place on a list of best burgers, and friends have recommended it, and I finally got here. It's a fairly nondescript building on High, decent parking out front. It's pretty small inside, and the floors are weird. Step up to get in, and then the ceiling feels kind of low, and the bar is actually lower than the rest of the room. That might be more efficient for them? Feels a little awkward but not awful. Pretty big menu, lots of interesting bar type food. I was here for what everyone recommended, the pepper burger and the sweet potato fries. Both of which were excellent. Among the best in town, and the best I've ever had, of each. The burger was thick and juicy and meaty. I like pepper, but I was afraid it would be over the top. It was not. A perfect complement to the meat. A little bit of a zing on your tongue afterwards, but not overdone. Fresh toppings, piled high, good bun. All melding into a beautiful whole. The sweet potato fries are perfectly cooked, and came with a zesty ranch-southwestern type dipping sauce. Coke as my drink. All that for $12. 12! For a good, big burger, and a ton of good sweet potato fries, and a pop. I think it was a lunch deal, or they just liked me. Good service, although they seemed a little short staffed so it was pretty curt. But when they did have a chance to stop and talk they were super friendly and laid-back. Seem to be a lot of regulars here. It's definitely worth coming back. I wish I'd been hungry enough to try the wings. read more

The staff is amazing and the atmosphere is so cozy. Try the fish and chips! The steak fries and regular cut fries are both delicious. Next time I'll pass on the chicken tenders because the fish is where it's at. My parter had the mushroom burger and barely talked because he was so busy eating it all! This is a hidden gem and a great local spot. Dive bar vibes. I will be back again!! read more

Friendly locals place. Burgers looked really good and my draft Guinness was on point. They have a dinner special Every night and tonight we're quesadillas? In an Irish bar? read more

I've heard my brother talking about this place and "The Pepper Burger" for years. We met up today for lunch there. What a great little place, decorated with a mix of Columbus sports memorabilia and other odds and ends. Our waitress was great, asked us for our order right away, two pepper burgers, an ice tea and a PBR. It took awhile for our burgers to come out, no big deal, we bullshitted and the wait was worth it. The burger was cooked perfectly, it is covered with cracked pepper corns, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles. That's all sitting on a fresh bun. It came with a side of potato chips and a dill spear. I will definitely have this burger again. I have to try the Rueben though, I overheard someone saying it's the best they've ever had. read more

O'Reilly's Pub - Menu - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I just...love it here. I love that it hasn't been updated in forever. It's charming and absolutely perfect. The burgers are huge and the French fries are freshly cut. The drinks are made well and it's affordable. Bartenders are nice. Mixed crowd. It's a no-frills kind of pub and they don't need to change a thing. read more

No frills place for simple solid food and drinks. In the best way possible this is an old school Irish pub don't expect it to be anything more. Service is great, bartenders/waitresses are quick to help but won't hover over you. Great menu for whatever you're in the mood for. All the burgers are huge and well cooked. Get the onion rings, trust me. read more

Last few times I've been here the food has been mediocre. The pepper burger which I used to like has been dry and the wings soggy. Maybe they've hired a different cook? Whatever the case, I am no longer ordering food when I come here. read more

Great little local spot for good basic fare and drinks. Very popular place and definitely recommend it!

O'Reilly's is a Clintonville hole-in-the-wall serving up drafts and pub fare in a shabby bar. There's a small and sunken bar, with a handful of tables decked out in Irish regalia. I had the classic cheeseburger with sweet potato fries, and let me tell you, it was one of the best burgers I've ever had. The beef was fresh, the bun was perfectly toasted and the cheese and vegetables were delicious. The sweet potato fries were also among the best I've ever had. Prices are reasonable and the service was fast and friendly. read more

Came here for the first time and had a great experience! It's everything you could want from a dive bar: great service, great good, reasonable prices. The club sandwich was perfectly toasted and even better with a side of honey mustard, the wings were huge and meaty with great sauce options if you like them on the hotter side. Would recommend the Scott's sauce over the wild though. They have both smithwicks and Guinness on tap for the Irish beer lovers as well read more

See all

AM and Bethie are the best barmaids in CBus! I had the mushroom and onion burger with provolone. It was outstanding!

Gastropub with gourmet buckeye OMG feeling totally spoiled. I was told by locals that there isn't one like in anywhere! The 1/2 lb burger here is one of the best burgers I've had and I am super picky with my burgers!! This place is easy to miss and doesn't look modern nor gastro at all but don't judge 'book by its cover'. If you are ever in Columbus, Ohio don't miss this hole read more

See all

This place is epitome of Irish pubs in my opinion! It has a dark entrance, long bar, and booth seating throughout. The decorations are awesome and the staff was super friendly when we walked in. This stop was recommended by another Elite friend of mine who said I needed to try the chicken wings here. I was not disappointed, probably the top 5 wings in Columbus in my opinion. They were coated, crispy, and perfectly sauced. I got the mild wings since we had a few more stops to the evening and they were delicious. Adrienne ended up getting the pepper burger based off the recommendation from the server and it was really good as well. The onion rings were some of my favorite additions on the meal as they were cooked perfectly as well. The drink prices are standard around Columbus and the pours were definitely heavy. Check this place out for some great pub food and a great atmosphere! read more

See all

This place is a hidden burger gem for sure. I almost don't want to write about it and tell you of the awesomeness I encountered during my visit here. I happened upon this after looking up the best burgers in central Ohio. After doing various cross-checks and references, this place was one of the establishments that stood out to me. Be mindful that this is the quintessential hole in the wall; it just has a lot of windows that brighten the place up, yet it still has a tinge of darkness. It's long and narrow. I like to sit at the booths by the window; those are the best seats. The service is pretty speedy here, so be ready to look at the menu and get your order ready when you come in. When I did my burger search, the burger that popped up everywhere was the peppercorn burger. Reading the plentiful amount of rave reviews, I was afraid that I would get my hopes up and be let down like a Cleveland Browns fan; I was pleasantly mistaken. I took a bite into this burger, and it was the juiciest and tender burger with a charred outside that I have ever tasted. The burger's flavor hits you upside the head out of nowhere if you are not expecting it. It's pretty savory and is reminiscent of Worcestershire sauce. read more

It's a neighborhood pub, so set your expectations accordingly. That said, it's a great place to go. Very attentive and friendly staff. Good selection of beers and, of course, Irish whiskeys. Food is pretty dang good as well. Want a few drinks? Grab a bite? Just want to hang out? This looks like a great place to do it at. read more

Usually this place is pretty good. Today's visit was not good at all. My husband knew what he wanted, I said I'd need more time. She never came back to take my order. I understand it's a busy bar, but we were paying customers just like everyone else in there. My husband went to the bar to tell her what I wanted. It finally came out, after my husband was done eating, so we asked for it to go. Noticed right away it was COVERED in jalapenos, so much so as to render it inedible. If she had actually come back to take my order, I would've told her to hold them. Paid for garbage and bad service. read more

O'Reilly's is the best Irish bar in Columbus. It's located far enough from the campus crap you're able to enjoy it. The bartenders may not be the friendliest but they know how to make a good whiskey and cola. An Irish whiskey and you won't go wrong here. They also have food but not too many people we come with have ordered it. If you're in an Irish bar you know what you need to get. It's recommended you get something with Jameson or Tullamore Dew but as long as it's Irish, it's good. The happy hour specials are okay. It's still cheap no matter what the time is. This bar is far enough from campus you're actually able to enjoy your drink, unless it's St. Patrick's Day when the idiot college students look for the nearest Irish bar. If you're here almost any other day of year it's fine. The college kids are too busy with the meat market scene to bother with it. I recommend O'Reilly's to any Irish bar fan. If not ordering an Irish whiskey then what the fuck. Take it up and be Irish until the early morning. read more

O'Reilly's Pub - Vegetable Sub - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great service and get the peppercorn burger! Full of flavor. The hand cut fries were also excellent!

Bang for your buck: 8.5/10 Quality: 10/10 Service: 10/10 Ambiance/Location: 9/10 Overall: 9.5/10 Okay, these burgers are a real hidden gem in Cbus. Our waitress was just the absolute sweetest. She gave us the tip of ordering the burger with 1/2 the pepper, and that was great advice! It's definitely a dive both inside and out, so don't go thinking you're going to some super fancy spot. But if you're looking for a great burger, a cold beer, and some super friendly and efficient service, this is it! read more

Here is the updated 5-star review for O'Reilly's pub in Clintonville, Columbus:"O'Reilly's Pub in Clintonville is an absolute gem! The staff here are simply unbelievable - they are friendly, attentive, and go above and beyond to ensure you have an amazing experience. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warm smiles and a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The standout staff includes Anne Marie, Adria, Chelsea, Beth, and my boys - they really make this place special. But the real standout is the food. O'Reilly's menu is simply exceptional, with a wide variety of delicious rotating options throughout the year. However, the staples like the everyday pepper burger and the Friday-only meatloaf are always a hit. I had the shepherd's pie, and it was out of this world - the perfect balance of savory flavors and tender, slow-cooked meat. My dining companions raved about the fish and chips and the corned beef and cabbage as well.In my opinion, O'Reilly's Pub has some of the best food and the most attentive, friendly staff that Columbus has to offer. Whether you're looking for a lively night out or a relaxing meal, this place is an absolute must-visit. I can't recommend it highly enough - five stars all the way! read more

This place is good. Nice "dive bar" interior and ambience but certainly not dirty. Plenty of parking when I was there, 2 pm on a weekday. The lady tending the bar kept my iced tea full. They had all kinds of alcoholic beverages but since I'm totally square now and don't drink at all I wasn't paying attention. I had the pepper burger. God damn it was good. The portion size of the onion rings was small but it's okay since I was stuffed anyway. It came with "crack sauce" which is hot sauce and mayo. The bartender grumbled about how "crack sauce" gets people's attention whereas "hot sauce and mayo mixture" doesn't. Maybe the crack sauce would be better if it had real crack straight from Colombia. read more

O'Reilly's Pub - These are some beers. - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The diviest of dive bars, in the best way. Bartenders are always great and remember your name after one visit. The chairs are comfy and the women's bathroom is even nicer than my waspy grandma's. Some bars don't make women feel safe upon entering but this is definitely not one of them. I see people of all ages and backgrounds in there and even people studying. The food is always solid as well. read more

Chill neighborhood divey bar. Great place for a quick beer and some snacks or some chili dogs if you're there on Saturday or Sunday. read more

See all

Perfectly dive-y. Great service friendly patrons good prices. Didn't try the food but looked like good pub stuff

Some of Columbus wings finest. Currently holds a spot in my top 3 for fried chicky wings. Great dive on High, smaller spot with limited staff and service. It adds to the experience, just be prepared to be here for awhile. Onion rings are great pairing. Can be a little loud with the jukebox playing and occasionally has some awkward silence of between songs. read more

See all

This was my first time here with a group of friend and we were motivated by the 5 stars. But gotta be honest, though the service was nice, the food took way too long to come out (Friday night, but for the size of the building, the wait was intense.) Then when the food comes out, it's over cooked, fairly bland and some items tasted a bit past their expiration dates. Pricing was fine, but we all agree: Not coming back: read more

Hole in the wall with great food at great prices. Love the vibe and atmosphere here. Food is definitely bar food, but done well and cheap. Italian sub and apps were good, pepper burger was amazing. Have never had peppercorns like that in a burger, but it works. Great spot for some beer and bar food. Lots of charm. read more

Used to be great food, great service. Then I had several overdone burgers. I was told to come back on Friday to get a replacement meal then was made to pay again and another bad burger. Customer service has taken a hit. Also does not have Coke or Pepsi, some generic soda. read more