Rosario's is my jam! Just a few issues. The individual slices never seem to be as good as the full pizzas, for some odd reason. The slices are firmer and thicker, with a little too much cheese and a bit too little sauce, which i personally dislike. I usually come here with a few friends anyway, though, so we get a full pie. That's where it's at. Crispy, cheesy, saucy, even the crust is great! Great bang for your buck, too. If you're looking for a great family meal without putting a dent in your wallet, get some rosario's! The restaurant itself is pretty alright. It could use a little more... anything, to be honest. the place feels a bit empty. That said, it's rare that i even sit down and eat there anyway. The service is good. Nothing of note. They're polite, quick, and friendly. Can't ask for much more read more

First: EVERYTHING SAUCE (for wings/dipping) is a MUST! The pizza crust is AMAZING (I haven't had crust like this in ages). Second: I ordered a FULL size sandwich (for the extra cost it was worth it). And for half I got 2 meals out of it.... this is the remainder of that other half. Highly recommend just getting a full. It was delicious! Lastly: We Stayed to eat there. Overall service was great. It's definitely the "to-go" vibes but very much sit down friendly. I can't wait to go back. -First timer to the restaurant- read more

Rosarios Pizzeria - Half of the Eggplant Parm. Sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Service and food was amazing! We ordered the chicken parm sub and buffalo chicken wraps! The pizza on display looked so good too we had a hard time deciding. We were just passing through and found this by chance but will definitely be back! The employees were very friendly! Restaurant was cute and quaint and above all very clean! Recommend anyone try this place! read more

Rosarios Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

I ordered a Eggplant Parm&it was Burnt&it tasted OLD.. the Service was good until I told the girl about my Sandwich.."then RUDE"

Was passing through town on the way back to Drum from NYC. Other places were closed, thankfully. This place is great. Chicken riggies off the chart. The burgers are also fantastic, a definite hidden gem. Quick service and a nice place to sit. Definitely a pleasant dining experience for road weary travelers. read more

Rosarios Pizzeria - a sandwich with a pickle on top - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

This review is based on one slice of pizza I had here. It was an upside down slice with sweet sausage. The sauce was nice. The sausage was crumbly and good. The slice had a nice crunch to it just how I like it. I went at lunchtime and it was busy so the locals must love it here. Place was clean and didn't raise any red flags. Worth a shot if you are in this part of Utica. read more

I honestly just took a covid test because this pizza had zero flavor at all!!! Yes, the test came back negative. So incredibly disappointing. Why did parkway pizza have to close? read more

Amazing food and service! Clean and fast service. Our go to pizza spot in utica. Definitely recommend!

This pizzeria deserves 0 stars. I placed an order for delivery and the pizza never came despite the app indicating that the order was received and the food was on its way. Then when I called the restaurant well before closing time I could hear a man in the background say "tell them to call tomorrow to get their fucking refund." Totally unprofessional and downright disgusting. Pass on this place. read more

I haven't had this pizza since high school. I used to order the single slices and they were pretty good back then. Now I order two specialty pizzas; rosario's supreme and buffalo chicken. I called and asked if the specialty pizza was brick oven; the girl over the phone said yes. When I got the pizza they were NOT. It was cooked on a conventional oven, and not even crispy. I was pretty disappointed and wasted $51 on two pizza. The pizza taste was okay, nothing special about the "specialty pizza." Only thing is that it cost more and has different toppings. The overall rating is a solid 2. read more

Best pizza you can get. This and Franco's are the regulars for us. Nice place to sit down inside.

I love the food that they have there the people are very nice and the friendly too I love going there to eat

Very nice and clean place. Their wings are great and the pizza good. Subs are good. Can't go wrong with this place. Very friendly workers. read more

Wow, That Dishwasher, David Cooley, is a great man I wish I was as cool as Dave. *All-League for football BTW*

The place is very clean and they have a few eat inside tables. Their prices are reasonable and food is very good submarines are big and fresh. Pizza and wings very good. Definitely going back kmv read more

The best of everything , pizza good , pasta fagoli Best Ever i had , chicken riggies excellent , lasagna very very glad s , New England clam was great , anti pasta great , this is our staple for very 3 years visit , I just die when. I go here , don't change a thing , you would could knock any Italian business out of bizness ,! i am the hardest to please and u guys excel at it !! My first 5 star read more

This may not be the most famous of the Utica tomato pie places, but it's a good one. Nice marinara on a medium crust with shaked basil, oregano, and grated parm. The crust is excellent too. The pasta dishes (which I dont normally get) are good too..I usually get the hats and sauce or greens. If you are over by Mohawk Valley Community College it's a great stop and @ the Parkway Drug you next door you can pick up Guiseppie's pusties. The star off was for a tomato pie that had sausage in it...delicious but it's happened a couple of times. read more

Table service is great but it's so much better when the service actually comes to the table. Having said that, once our waitress came to the table she was quite friendly. Christmas music made the wait for our pizza tolerable. So did the clean table (I had to ask for a wipe down). Real plates not paper and napkins provided (unlike Parkway next door). Now. The pizza. Good sauce and cheese. Crust sucked. Go to Slice. read more

Rosarios Pizzeria - Big ups to Akex - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Ordered the chicken riggies to go. Sauce was very watery. 1 piece of chicken there was only green peppers in it. The garlic bread was very good. All I can taste in the sauce was hot pepper flakes. Maybe I just got the bottom of a batch. The lady who answered the phone was quite pleasant. All the hearty things that belong in the riggies was missing. Hey at least they got the pasta right! Lol read more

Pizza was so greasy, i had to use tons of napkins and try to get the grease off but it was already soaked into the crust and bottom. Made me feel disgusted after eating the first slice, really a waste of my money. read more

Every time I order here they ALWAYS mess up my order. The only thing I ever want is a Buffalo chicken sub. One time I got it with MAYO it. Once it didn't even have Buffalo sauce on it. How hard is it to make a Buffalo chicken sub? When it's right it's amazing. But I've never once ordered here and got what I wanted. Idk if it's because it's a bunch of teenagers working that can't read but it's pretty ridiculous. read more

Great service when the waitress came.Free news adds in front of the pizzeria also free wifi a great place to sit and listen to holiday music also our waitress was in the holiday spirit great pizza!!!!!!! THANKS ALEX read more

Rosarios Pizzeria - A BIT CLOSE ALSO PAPER TOWEL RACK RIGHT ABOVE TOILET!! - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

I ordered a 12" tomato pie. What I got was a cheese pizza that was a greasy mess and not even cooked all the way through. For a utica restaurant, they should know what a Tomato pie is. Extremely disappointed when I opened the box read more

Haven't been there in years. But, it was one of the cheesiest and best pizza's in Utica. I think that there are only 5 I can say that about. And this is one of them. Plan to visit soon. read more

Buyer Beware. We just called in an order of pizza and wings from Rosario's. We ordered the "large pizza and 25 wings special" but did not realize we had an old menu. The person taking our order DID NOT EXPLAIN that the special no longer existed and just made our order whatever they felt like and charged us $18 more dollars than we were expecting. When we got to Rosario's to pick up the order, the person cashing us out was rude and told us that he was charging us for a large pizza and 30 wings, and that our menu was out of date. They basically just made up an order for us regardless of what we actually ordered. No attempt was made to correct the situation and we were stuck paying $40 instead the $22 we were expecting. TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! If you change your menu, let the person on the phone know when they order so they can adjust it or at least know what they are going to pay. Probably my last trip to this place. This is not how you keep customers. read more

My *second* favorite pizza in the world, next to the great Tony's of Utica! Rosario's Welsh Bush Rd. location was a fabulous, inexpensive piece of pizza that offered a respite from the miserable MVCC food I had during my unfortunate stay at Proctor On The Hill. The location is sunny, clean, and quiet, the food is terrific, and the staff is quite polite and helpful! All in all, a great little pizzeria that makes the fringes of East Utica feel a little less lonely; this part of town can feel rather deserted compared to other parts of the city, commerce-wise. So yeah, definite thumbs-up for Rosario's! Thanks for making my stay at MVCC a little less hellish! read more

The BEST place to get Utica's famous Tomato Pie.

Great pizza, quality ingredients. If I'm in the area for lunch I'm definitely stopping in to grab a chicken wing slice.

I got the riggies and they are the worse chicken riggies EVER, they are literally soaked in oil not sauce, the chicken is way too dry, its like you had chicken lay out for a week and them decided to cut it and fry it. the only good part was the garlic bread... which was my lunch due to the huge disappointment in the Chicken Riggies! read more

Called at 6:55 pm on a Friday night for two fish meals to go. Response, "Actually we are all done with fish for the night." WOW! This is why people in Utica get very upset. I travel around the 50 states - never got this type of response. Very sad - the food is good here - but the young folks need some interpersonal skills training!! read more

Pizza is always fresh, workers are always helpful, and it's the best pie in Utica. Owner is friendly and helpful and they treat their customers with respect. read more

Decent pizza by the slice and garden salad. Good for a quick lunch.